Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you forgive your child if they went no contact?

135 replies

mrsxox · 10/01/2024 09:46

Ds was living at home with his father and I and 2 younger siblings, we were a loving family and all close.
He had a gf who would regularly come over and often stay over.
One day he announced he was moving out, had found a place with gf and would text the address when they had settled in.
We never got that text as instead he blocked us and we were left wondering what we'd done wrong for nearly 5 years.
He recently got back in touch with us, apologised for the long time no hear and explained that we hadn't actually done anything wrong but ex gf hadn't really liked our family so didn't want us in their lives but that they'd split up now.
Ds is now in regular contact with us and we meet up often as he's living close by.
He didn't see his siblings who live at home in the 5 years he went no contact and he hasn't mentioned anything other than it was what ex gf wanted and hadn't been his decision.

AIBU to think ex gf didn't do this he did, he had a choice and decided to cut us all out of his life at the wishes of ex gf but he still chose to do that and would never have seen us again if he was still in that relationship.
I love him dearly and I'm grateful to have him in our lives again, especially as we didn't expect to see him again but I feel like he's shown me his true colours and I can't unsee them.
Or maybe I should just accept he stood by his relationship and now that's not worked I get to have a son after all.
And if they get back together will we be cast aside again?

OP posts:
NonPlayerCharacter · 11/01/2024 08:56

IMO his mother, who is in poor health, would forgive him tomorrow, but the father, who is a truly lovely bloke, has said he never can or will forgive him for causing so much appalling heartache to his wife.

If his wife would forgive the son and have him back, then he would be hurting her still more by refusing to do the same. Sounds like he'd be using his wife's heartache as a way of valorising his own desire not to forgive.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 11/01/2024 08:54

I know a formerly happy and very close family where a DiL was clearly determined from the word go to hate her dh’s family. There has been zero contact with their son for some years now. To me it would seem that he’s doing exactly as he’s told, for the sake of a quiet life.

IMO his mother, who is in poor health, would forgive him tomorrow, but the father, who is a truly lovely bloke, has said he never can or will forgive him for causing so much appalling heartache to his wife.

2jacqi · 11/01/2024 08:46

@mrsxox I think I would really struggle to forgive that behaviour! sorry if that differs to everyone else's belief!

ButterBastardBeans · 11/01/2024 08:44

I think whether I could forgive this or not would depend on his personality and how vulnerable he is.

My husbands sonefrom his previous marriage met a woman exactly as you describe and married her. All his family could see that she was systematically cutting him off from his family and that included us. We haven't spoken to him since 2016. We have no idea if he is touch with the rest of his family.

Nothing would get us to speak to him again. He knew full well his treatment of us would break his father's heart, he just didn't care enough to stand up to his foul wife.

MumblesParty · 11/01/2024 08:34

icelolly12 · 11/01/2024 08:27

Also suspect there's more to this. So you waited for a text that never arrived and that was that? You weren't contacting the police or his work to check if he was dead or alive? You weren't going round his girlfriends parents to ask what they knew of the situation? You just sat back and "wondered" for 5 years. Riiight.

Yes that’s what I wondered.
I’d have done all those things, then hired a private detective.
Very strange story (if true…..)

NonPlayerCharacter · 11/01/2024 08:33

Enterthewolves · 11/01/2024 08:21

I’m concerned that the OP isn’t reflecting on why her child might have been open to being told to cut his family off or where his desperate need to have a partner/please a partner comes from but is instead positing all of this as internal to her child.

Yeah. I'm not accusing OP of anything but I have definitely seen a lot of families where things were going very badly wrong in certain ways externally, but it was all put down to "well it's because this child is mentally ill/insane/an arsehole".

icelolly12 · 11/01/2024 08:27

Also suspect there's more to this. So you waited for a text that never arrived and that was that? You weren't contacting the police or his work to check if he was dead or alive? You weren't going round his girlfriends parents to ask what they knew of the situation? You just sat back and "wondered" for 5 years. Riiight.

Enterthewolves · 11/01/2024 08:21

I’m concerned that the OP isn’t reflecting on why her child might have been open to being told to cut his family off or where his desperate need to have a partner/please a partner comes from but is instead positing all of this as internal to her child.

PriOn1 · 11/01/2024 08:20

If my son cut contact, I’d be moving heaven and Earth to find out why. If it was simply coercive control, I’d expect him to return with his tail between his legs, very unhappy and needing comfort.

Is there back story you haven’t told us, OP? Were there problems in your household when your son was growing up?

My son cut contact with me and ex-DH for a while and I know exactly why it happened and it was partly my fault as I enabled ex-DH for too many years and stayed in an abusive relationship when I should have prioritised my son.

I don’t think anyone with a normal relationship with their parents would go NC to that extent without it being an incredibly painful experience, which would probably become clear on their return. This is not s normal family dynamic, OP and if you honestly don’t know why, then I think there might be some soul searching to do on your own part.

DreamItDoIt · 11/01/2024 08:20

So many on here jumping to the conclusion, with no facts, that he was in a controlling relationship and was vulnerable.

Of course I would welcome my child back however I would want to know what happened. I would also expect them to listen to and understand the trauma this had caused me and the family. Seeing the bigger picture, recognising the consequences and owning your actions are very important. Unconditional love does not equate to 'treat me how you like'. What's to say that he won't do the same next time he gets a partner!

Ewoklady · 11/01/2024 08:13

five years is a long long time
my parents had genuine reason for me to go low contact (my mother tried to break up my marriage and had severe depression / jealously type traits) but i didn’t let the low contact go on for long

your son was cruel to not have a reason other than a girlfriend to not contact you. I don’t think I could heal from that

Sunflwer · 11/01/2024 08:07

CarrieMoonbeams · 11/01/2024 08:00

@allaboardthestation , my childhood and early adulthood were probably quite similar to yours, so firstly I wanted to say that I hope you - like me - have a genuinely happy and contented life now.

I wish the same for PP who have been in controlling relationships too.

For those who haven't been in that situation, you have to understand that the thing with a coercive relationship is that it happens so slowly and quietly at first. Look at how many threads on here are written by women who are enduring the silent treatment, or their partner walked out hours ago and the woman is frantic with worry. She usually asks "What can I do to make this right?" or "What did I do wrong for him to punish me like this?" So although you say that your son did cut contact as soon as they moved in together @mrsxox , this drip, drip, drip of coercion could well have been going on in the background for a while beforehand.

Anyway, to answer your initial question, yes of course I would forgive him. I'd definitely look into some counseling for him, and I'd also have several conversations about what to do if he feels like he's getting into a relationship like that again.

All the best, I hope it works out well for you all.

Edited

This is all true but there is another side to it - those of us who have been accused of being the driving force behind choices our partners made when it had nothing to do with us and everything to do with our partner. Sometimes it's easier to blame the other person.

I can't imagine not letting my child back but I think it is quite fair for OP to have feelings and apprehensions about it. She's been terribly hurt and the son's place in the family, even if only in the eyes of the siblings for who five years is a long time, might need to develop again over time. I think it's important that OP is validated for maybe having her own feelings about it, whatever they are, rather than sweeping everything under the rug.

reflecting2023 · 11/01/2024 08:06

How old was he when he left ?

CarrieMoonbeams · 11/01/2024 08:00

@allaboardthestation , my childhood and early adulthood were probably quite similar to yours, so firstly I wanted to say that I hope you - like me - have a genuinely happy and contented life now.

I wish the same for PP who have been in controlling relationships too.

For those who haven't been in that situation, you have to understand that the thing with a coercive relationship is that it happens so slowly and quietly at first. Look at how many threads on here are written by women who are enduring the silent treatment, or their partner walked out hours ago and the woman is frantic with worry. She usually asks "What can I do to make this right?" or "What did I do wrong for him to punish me like this?" So although you say that your son did cut contact as soon as they moved in together @mrsxox , this drip, drip, drip of coercion could well have been going on in the background for a while beforehand.

Anyway, to answer your initial question, yes of course I would forgive him. I'd definitely look into some counseling for him, and I'd also have several conversations about what to do if he feels like he's getting into a relationship like that again.

All the best, I hope it works out well for you all.

PumpkinsAndCoconuts · 11/01/2024 07:56

mrsxox · 10/01/2024 13:49

He's always wanted a girlfriend and while all his friends dated in their youth he was not so lucky and this has meant he's willing to do anything girls ask to make them like him.
He struggles with woman and if a girl likes him he'll do whatever it takes to keep her happy and with him.

And some women are so desperate for love that they accept unacceptable behaviour and abuse from their boyfriends / husbands.

I usually don’t like the „if this was a woman“ argument. But I wonder if it might make sense in this case. How would you feel, OP, if this was your daughter (niece etc.)?

If your DD was a vulnerable young adult / teen who fell in love with a man who turned out to be abusive? If your daughter was a victim of coercive control and lost contact to you do to an abusive boyfriend / husband?

it sounds to me as if your son is extremely vulnerable. Summing his behaviour up as >>wanting to please his girlfriend because he was unlucky in his youth<< doesn’t seem appropriate to me. There has been a lot of really good advice on this thread and I hope you take it on board.

Epidote · 11/01/2024 07:40

I agree with PP your son could be in an abusive relationship. That doesn't automatically made up for the long NC but you know him best.
Could be different separate things the abuse and him trying to impress, being brainwashed etc. In any case he is an adult and I agree with you. I wouldn't cut contact with my family to please a partner. So I think there is more that just a simple explanation here.

WhatNoRaisins · 11/01/2024 07:27

I think it's possible to forgive a person whilst still being very wary about what they might do in the future. I'd never reject a child in this situation but at least on the inside I wouldn't be able to just pick up the relationship as normal.

It's normal to be hurt by his behaviour and to wish for some closure. I think you should welcome him back into your life practically but when it comes to your feelings I'd take your time OP.

NonPlayerCharacter · 11/01/2024 07:26

Everyone advocating for a sit down discussion to explain how OP felt: fine, but OP also needs to be prepared to listen to him and how he felt too. Really listen, not just listen in order to throw it back and tell him why he's wrong.

OP claims not to have the slightest idea why he did this. She could find out.

Beautiful3 · 11/01/2024 07:24

I think I'd sit down and talk with him. Explain that we really missed him and were hurt to have not seen him for 5 years, and the siblings were really affected by it. I'd ask him, if a future girlfriend asked him to do the same, would he do it again? Because it wouldn't be fair to the rest of us, it would make us feel used when ever he doesn't have a girlfriend. That way he knows that he can't do it again because it affected the whole family. If he does do it again, I'd be civil but keep him at arms length, to stop my heart being broken again.

NonPlayerCharacter · 11/01/2024 07:10

I really, really want to hear the other side of this. The fact that you're considering not forgiving your own son while he was clearly in a controlling relationship or for some reason keen not to be in touch with you, and you're thinking only of the effect on you, suggests to me that there's a lot more going on here.

But yes, of course you should forgive him. He's your child and that relationship isn't transactional.

Ladyj84 · 11/01/2024 07:10

Since the son hasn't actually done anything criminal then I would have no reason whatsoever to stop contact with him. If this was one of our kids they are always welcome back if there were no underlying issues because love is unconditional

Kwam31 · 11/01/2024 07:07

@LadyMacbethssweetArabianhand
If you know where he lives, could you send a letter?

Nicole1111 · 11/01/2024 07:02

Forgive him but support him to reflect on his behaviour in the form of a discussion about what a healthy relationship is and share how his actions impacted his family.

Beezknees · 11/01/2024 06:58

Absolutely, I would welcome him back with open arms. I would never want my son out of my life.

Having been in a controlling relationship myself I know what it's like.

MaisyAndTallulah · 11/01/2024 06:55

DeeLusional · 11/01/2024 06:35

It takes a while to establish coercive control. This young man blanked his family as soon as he moved in with the gf so I don't believe that coercive control was the reason. I think he is shallow and selfish and is only back in touch with his family because it suits him now.

It always makes me giggle when a poster can make a judgement with such certainty based on a few paragraphs. We all know that people don't cut their families off without reason.