Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want to cut as many ties with SIL

119 replies

alltheteainchina · 10/01/2024 08:58

NC for this.

Over the past few years my relationship with SIL has soured.

The relationship began to sour when she made some very inappropriate comments to me. I was so shocked at the time that I didn't call her out on it, but DH agreed that what she had said was inappropriate. From then on, I decided I would be nice to SIL but after those comments I've always been a bit guarded with her.

Against my better wishes, DH asked if SIL could come and stay for a few days last summer as she's been having a difficult time (her EXH essentially asked for a divorce 4+ years ago and she hasn't been able to move on). I was a little reluctant given how she can be me with me on a 1:1. I feel like I have to walk on eggshells with her. Unfortunately I didn't have the hindsight to say that if the visit went ahead DH would need to be home. He wasn't. It was all left to me. She took offence at everything - she asked me what our plans were for late summer and I said we had a family wedding and because it was a gay family wedding, she got very angry with me for talking about gay relationships in front of her 11 year old daughter.

She sent me a very rude birthday card about ugly people, which DH laughed off but I felt this wasn't sent in humour. Most recently at Christmas, every time I walked into a room, she would walk out. Every time I spoke she would roll her eyes. MIL said she doesn't understand me and doesn't know how to properly communicate with me. Yesterday we received a card in the post address to DH and DD with a letter from SIL saying how lovely it had been to spend Christmas with the 2 of them etc. No mention of me. When we were at her house, she made a point of offering everybody else a drink, except me - I appreciate some of this sounds childish!

SIL triggers me. I find her rude. I find the family use her depression as a green light for being able to say what she wants to people. I stopped messaging her ages ago, but I know I have to have a relationship for the sake of DH.

DH said talking about SIL is "off topic" as it opens up a huge can of worms. She wants to come and stay again in the summer, but I can't have her here but I feel by saying that I am putting DH in the position of having to choose.

I've already stopped all communicating via text, we don't speak to each other on the phone, but can I really go the whole distance and refuse to have her in my home?

OP posts:
TeaGinandFags · 10/01/2024 13:45

If SIL is off topic for discussion, then how tf can she stay under your roof?

Give DH a flat no.

While no is a complete sentence, remind him how she behaved last time. Explain that he was conspicuous by his absence and if she's not right in the head that you're not a psychiatrist.

If he invites her regardless there is a lovely little company called lastminute.com where you and the kids can go. Leave a text when you hit the airport.

purplehotdogs · 10/01/2024 13:42

No. Tell your DH to strap on a pair and stop enabling her dreadful behaviour towards you. If she wants to be a bitch, she can do it on her own time in her own house. There's no way she'd be doing it on my time in my own home.

SerafinasGoose · 10/01/2024 13:41

I know I have to have a relationship for the sake of DH.

No, you don't. Especially if he's shrugging off and minimising her extremely unpleasant, caustic behaviour.

He can have a relationship with her if he so wishes. You are not compelled to do the same. You certainly don't have to accept someone so hostile staying under your roof, and are well entitled to protect your own mental wellbeing by distancing yourself from people like this.

Some years ago I was in your position and took the same decision. I've never regretted it.

whatsitcalledwhen · 10/01/2024 13:37

@alltheteainchina

The way it will be approached is D niece needs a holiday.

You're a woman her mum bullies, not Butlins.

Not your responsibility!

whatsitcalledwhen · 10/01/2024 13:36

@Getthethrowonthesofa

Well the op is a grown up, she can be away when she’s there. The op doesn’t get final say, if he wants to invite her and have a relationship with his sister, then he can, the op can go stay with mates or family or something when she’s there and the husband can limit it to one or two nights.

So she doesn't get the final say... but her husband does?

Imagine telling someone to leave their home to facilitate a visit from someone who has been actively nasty and spiteful to them in front of the whole family.

It's madness.

Nanny0gg · 10/01/2024 13:28

MaryDroppings · 10/01/2024 13:13

It isn't JUST her home though, that's the problem. It's his home too. I know the default on MN is to assume men should have no say in their own homes but this is the real world unfortunately...

I'd say the same on either situation

MassageForLife · 10/01/2024 13:25

alltheteainchina · 10/01/2024 12:11

The way it will be approached is D niece needs a holiday. She's a lovely kid and I have no qualms about her coming, but if she comes the SIL comes too. That's her it will be got around so I think th ebest thing to do is to start looking at a long spa break of a long weekend somewhere!

This, absolutely.

And make sure your DH knows that, while you are ok with SIL and DN coming to visit, that you will be taking no part in it, and he will have full responsibility for hosting them.

Go somewhere lovely and enjoy it, and don't even concern yourself with what is happening with them. They are adults, they can sort themselves out.

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 10/01/2024 13:21

She's bullying you

LakeTiticaca · 10/01/2024 13:19

I wouldn't be having this woman in my house and if my DH behaved like this he would be getting his divorce papers

MaryDroppings · 10/01/2024 13:13

Nanny0gg · 10/01/2024 09:45

Yes she can!

He wants to see his sister he can visit her or go and stay somewhere with her.

It's the OP's home and she shouldn't be disrespected in it or in front of her daughter

It isn't JUST her home though, that's the problem. It's his home too. I know the default on MN is to assume men should have no say in their own homes but this is the real world unfortunately...

TTCMama88 · 10/01/2024 13:11

I would go away when she's there. She gets gets to visit and have her brother all to herself. You get a break and don't have to deal with her. DH can feel all smug for helping his sister out.

Jl2014 · 10/01/2024 13:06

If my SIL behaved like that towards me she would never be allowed to step foot on my home. Of course you shouldn’t have her to stay and I don’t think you need to maintain any relationship with her just for DHs sake.

eish · 10/01/2024 12:49

I would make sure DH knows that you will not be left with her at any point. His sister, his problem.

pinkyredrose · 10/01/2024 12:48

Definitely say no to her staying. You need to stand up for yourself, you obviously can't rely on your husband. Wtf is wrong with him, why would he want her in the house when she treats you like crap?

Mikkismum · 10/01/2024 12:42

Louieloves · 10/01/2024 09:09

What a nightmare! Refusing to have her in your home may give her more 'ammunition' against you. You could play it as concern for her - 'I don't think Lucy would be comfortable staying here as she's obviously not happy when I am around. It's best you go to visit her'. If it ended up with her coming to stay, I would find a reason to go away for a few days with my DD. 'It's great that you and Lucy can spend some time together over the summer. Me and DD will go to visit Jane for a few days, as I know Lucy is uncomfortable when I am around'.

Perfect response

Beautiful3 · 10/01/2024 12:35

No I wouldn't have her over again. Husband can visit them whenever he wants to. If you were rude to people, they wouldn't ever invite you again, so why do you accept her bad behaviour?

Brefugee · 10/01/2024 12:30

OP do you have a friend that your DH can't stand to be around? Invite them for 5 days.

MzHz · 10/01/2024 12:28

alltheteainchina · 10/01/2024 12:11

The way it will be approached is D niece needs a holiday. She's a lovely kid and I have no qualms about her coming, but if she comes the SIL comes too. That's her it will be got around so I think th ebest thing to do is to start looking at a long spa break of a long weekend somewhere!

@alltheteainchina people like your sil USE their kids as the battering ram to get what they want, it's just manipulation.

No to the niece, no to the SIL. DH can arrange to go and visit.

DO NOT ALLOW THIS BULLSHIT INTO YOUR HOMES/LIVES. Your SIL needs to learn that she has to respect people to get invited. She knows damned well what she is doing and YES, there is little doubt why her H divorced her.

MzHz · 10/01/2024 12:25

Cuppachuchu · 10/01/2024 11:15

This.

Why are you afraid of calling her out on her behaviour? As long as you don't, she will carry on. I would give her a row, then ban her from my house.

Damned right!

LookItsMeAgain · 10/01/2024 12:23

If your niece needs a break why is it up to you to provide it? You're not a holiday let or a travel agent. Let them pick somewhere in your area (if they really have to) and base themselves there. They can do whatever activities they want but out of that base, not your home.
Then DH can go to visit them and you don't have to leave your home.

This idea of being an open door to waifs and strays and anyone else who happens along should have gone out with the dark ages. You are not running a B&B here and if you were, you could evict them during their stay for whatever reason as the management reserves the right to refuse admission! 😆

MeMyBooksAndMyCats · 10/01/2024 12:16

No wonder her husband divorced her Grin

I would tell your husband if he wants to see her he can go to hers. She's not welcome to your home

notlucreziaborgia · 10/01/2024 12:15

alltheteainchina · 10/01/2024 12:11

The way it will be approached is D niece needs a holiday. She's a lovely kid and I have no qualms about her coming, but if she comes the SIL comes too. That's her it will be got around so I think th ebest thing to do is to start looking at a long spa break of a long weekend somewhere!

Ask why it’s considered your responsibility to provide it, and/or suggest that SIL look online for package deals. You don’t have to bow to emotional blackmail.

You know she’ll keep coming if you don’t take a stand. You’ll be expected to suck it up for years to come. You’re not doing yourself any favors by giving in.

alltheteainchina · 10/01/2024 12:11

The way it will be approached is D niece needs a holiday. She's a lovely kid and I have no qualms about her coming, but if she comes the SIL comes too. That's her it will be got around so I think th ebest thing to do is to start looking at a long spa break of a long weekend somewhere!

OP posts:
notlucreziaborgia · 10/01/2024 12:03

Getthethrowonthesofa · 10/01/2024 10:38

Well the op is a grown up, she can be away when she’s there. The op doesn’t get final say, if he wants to invite her and have a relationship with his sister, then he can, the op can go stay with mates or family or something when she’s there and the husband can limit it to one or two nights.

Or OP can stay home and he can fuck off elsewhere. He doesn’t get ‘final say’ either.

sweetgingercat · 10/01/2024 12:03

If your DH wants to support his sister it should not be at your expense. He should take her out fit the weekend or go and stay with her instead. And if he says no that then you should not have any problem to saying no to having her in the house.