Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder if anyone else struggles to know what to do with their child in the house?

232 replies

Notreallylookingforadvice · 10/01/2024 08:28

As the username suggests I’m not exactly looking for advice on this but I really struggle, always have. Ds is now 3 and I don’t know how to play with him at all. Whenever he’s in the house the TV is inevitably on for him.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
NoCloudsAllowed · 11/01/2024 10:16

What does he actually watch on TV, OP? There are some active things like cosmic kids, go noodle, loads of other stuff that are basically exercise videos for kids.

The problem with TV is it buys you some time but then backfires because once you turn it off, all the energy they haven't been using is right there and they go a bit hyper and hard to handle. Which makes you just want to put the TV back on.

I also have a disco light thing, quite cheap but you can turn lights off, close curtains and toddler dances the energy off while baby coos at the lights. In an ideal world!

ShoePalaver · 10/01/2024 22:24

I think when you have a young baby isn't the time to be worrying too much about this.
You are out a lot which is great for the 3 year old.
Anything else is a bonus.

ShoePalaver · 10/01/2024 22:15

Notreallylookingforadvice · 10/01/2024 19:56

I can’t answer for @Jellycats4life but I always think the danger with my own Ds is that ‘something to do’ is something naughty or (I can imagine with older kids) falling out.

If they do something they shouldn't then I intervene. Mostly they do what they want as long as no damage to property or physical violence. Hasn't resulted in any major disasters so far.

JennyWren87 · 10/01/2024 20:34

My son is three and has been home for three weeks from nursery. On any given day his two year old sister, him and me will do any or all of the following.

Puzzle
Books
Crayons
Play Doh
Watch Disney+
Go in the yard
"Clean" the house together
Song sings
Play tag
"Cook" together
Build stuff

Somethingsnappy · 10/01/2024 20:27

I totally hear you op! I feel the same. I often berate myself because I feel guilty that I'm not playing with my 3 year old more, or doing crafts etc. To try to avoid the self-criticism, I remind myself of the things I am good at, and like you, I'm good at getting him out the house most days. Because I know I'm not the best when we're at home, I concentrate on outside entertainment. When I factor in that, dropping and picking up the other children from school, and mealtimes etc, it doesn't leave masses of time, I don't think, and having the TV on in between times helps him to wind down. Plus, he doesn't watch constantly. He plays with his toys or follows me around doing jobs, and goes back to the TV now and then.

Also, go easy on yourself... You have a baby too! And soon enough, they'll be playmates. My 4 children are a good source of entertainment for one another.

Geraldneedsasecondclassstamp · 10/01/2024 20:26

@ShoePalaver

It is a bit of effort and mess. Which is why I do it once a fortnight max. I don't do stuff like that too often because

a) I simply cannot be bothered
And
b) I don't like it to lose the novelty value

He gets plenty of that stuff on nursery days. Similar to the fact that he eats better at nursery than he does at home. I don't stress I see it as a positive that he's getting all these things and it doesn't all have to fall to me!

@VenhamousSnake

I found schemas helpful for me as I struggle to think of different nice things we can do. Schema ideas just help me extend certain types of play and make a bit more out of them.

Fortunately my son plays very well on his own and isn't the needy type for my constantly playing with him. But he's only good like that for an afternoon as long as we've been out all morning.

Cannot state enough how just getting them out and about anywhere is the best thing above all! Run the legs off them!

VenhamousSnake · 10/01/2024 20:13

I found "play schema" type ideas off instagram to be a load of shite.

Set up carefully planned activity. Child does it for about 5 mins, does nowhere near half the stuff the trendy website claims they will do to "extend" the play, makes a giant mess, and it creates a lot of rubbish that goes in the bin and isn't reusable.

Honestly nothing occupied my kids like good old duplo or brio.

verabarbleen · 10/01/2024 20:10

I'm quite similar and I find playing hard but I play for a about a minute , sort of set them up with an idea and a scenario ( cars are being naughty so the police car keeps capturing one and putting it in jail. Then the naughty car shouts "get me out of here etc etc" I do that with them and then say "oh mummy has to get on with dinner/work/cleaning now , you carry on "
And then they sort of have an avenue to go down.
I call it play and runaway 😂

VenhamousSnake · 10/01/2024 20:10

3 is a tricky age.

I found we needed a mix of being out and about (duck pond, park, swimming, cafes etc) with time at home.

Some toys are less destructible and better suited to open ended independent play.

The best things with my kids:

  • toy kitchen/shop with food,
  • till with buttons/scanner.
  • duplo. So much duplo
  • brio/wooden track. Worth the investment to buy a load- look 2nd hand.
  • crayons/paper

Spread a large blanket or sheet on floor qhen playing duplo or brio. To tidy up just tip all pieces from sheèt into a kallax box or similar

Re the mess - at this age whats hard is you pretty much have to be involved a lot. You need to help them tidy up at the end of each toy/game, they won't contribute a lot but they need to do it with you and learn/make it habit

ShoePalaver · 10/01/2024 20:06

Geraldneedsasecondclassstamp · 10/01/2024 19:10

With eg colouring, you sit at the table with him. Don't let him get down and wander around.

Why? What benefit is there to forcing him to colour in? He's 3. OP should be led by his interests.

Look at the things he enjoys OP and expand on them. My son is 2 and enjoys scooping and tipping with diggers. So I put a tuff tray out some days with various things he can scoop and tip. He has his diggers but I also give him lots of kitchen utensils, cups, jugs, ladles, etc etc that he can play with. Some days it's something messy like sand, but other days it might be big fluffy pom poms. Another day pasta or rice and lentils. I put toilet or kitchen roll tubes in and he tips them down the tubes. It all sweeps up/hoovers up easily enough. We don't do it every day, maybe once a fortnight.

You can find easy charts online along the lines of "my child likes X, try..."

So "transporting objects" might be giving them an assortment of bags and purses and interesting things to put in them. Kids love putting things in bags to cart about the house. Scooping and tipping, as above: tuff tray or flisat table with something fun to scoop. If they like things that spin you could get a water wheel to play with in the bath or at the kitchen sink, or a treasure basket of different fidget spinners.

Google "play schemas" for more ideas.

All this sounds great but it's a lot of mess and effort and I think there's also huge value in just letting children entertain themselves. Basically have a few toys out or a box of cars, a few teddies, cushions etc, some floor space, turn off the TV, ignore the moaning, busy yourself with some jobs so that you aren't available and see what happens after an hour.

If you get into a habit of TV for an hour or 2 in the afternoon each day that gives you chance for a sit down and break while it's on. Go out in the morning for an hour or 2. Spend 10 minutes per day doing a child led activity with your child. The rest of the time child does their own thing. You can be on the periphery accepting pretend cups of tea or admiring their tower etc while you feed the baby but no need to get too involved. Half an hour tidy up time at some point and it keeps the mess contained.

I mostly leave the messy stuff for nursery or playgroups, I think it's not really worth it for one child. They can get their fill at the beach or sandpit in summer or the bath in winter.

Notreallylookingforadvice · 10/01/2024 19:56

I can’t answer for @Jellycats4life but I always think the danger with my own Ds is that ‘something to do’ is something naughty or (I can imagine with older kids) falling out.

OP posts:
ShoePalaver · 10/01/2024 19:51

Jellycats4life · 10/01/2024 15:59

They look at me like I’ve made the most ridiculous and unreasonable request ever. They huff and flail and refuse every single thing I suggest - from the general (“your room is full of things - pick something”) to the specific (“why don’t you play with one of those logic games that you like, or read your magazine?”).

Like I said, my kids are autistic and extremely demand avoidant. To be both extremely bored and in complete opposition to every suggestion I make is hardwired into their brains. I know it isn’t normal 😅 But it’s been my reality for over ten years.

Edited

But after they've finished huffing and puffing what happens? Or do you eventually give in and put TV on? Or do they continue to follow you round all afternoon? My kids are younger and I don't think they are autistic, so doubtless easier, but I ignore the whingeing and crying about tv and they will eventually find something to do.

Notreallylookingforadvice · 10/01/2024 19:47

Most people have been really nice and supportive tbf

OP posts:
Jellycats4life · 10/01/2024 19:46

I’m so disappointed with the vicious and otherwise empathy-free responses to this thread.

Are they from a genuine place of concern for the OP’s child, or are they to bolster their own egos?

I’m glad the early years of parenthood went so perfectly for you guys.

Forcing an uninterested three year old to do colouring, FFS 🤣

Geraldneedsasecondclassstamp · 10/01/2024 19:26

Notreallylookingforadvice · 10/01/2024 19:13

No, but then you take the crayons away. A 3yo can understand 'we only colour at the table'. Yes but then if you want to colour with them, you’re not, are you?

Plus, colouring in with him is hard with a baby who as I said above won’t be put down at the moment. It’s a phase.

Ds is compliant enough but doesn’t tidy away very well. It ends up being very stressful.

your poor dc the only response to that ends with off.

Honestly OP, we can all give advice based on how we are as parents and the type of children we have. But we're not you.

Go with what works for you and your child. If playing at home is too stressful, just don't. Fill his bucket and get all his energy out by getting outdoors. He'll be getting plenty of the messy sensory stuff at nursery.

I do not enjoy playing anything that doesn't have a "purpose". So I'll set up a train track with my son, or build a castle with magnatiles, or bake a cake, or sit and do puzzles with him.

But anything imaginative is just dire. I hate it. As they get older they learn that you can't give them everything. You're a separate human being and you have your own personality. He'll be at school in a couple of years getting all of that stuff from his friends. He'll even learn that some friends are fun for certain kinds of play and other friends are not. Even my two year old knows this. He plays in different ways with different children. And he doesn't need to get everything from me all the bloody time. I can't possibly give him everything he needs all the time!

I get him out as much as I can because it saves me from playing with trucks all day. He's happy outdoors and it tires him out. Get to the park, the pond to feed the ducks, the woods for a walk, museums, local farm parks etc, or just a wander around town to help with the shopping or to find a new toy in a charity shop.

We arrange play dates and they scoot about on balance bikes together or play in the sandpit at the park. I provide what I can at home and I know he gets everything else that I can't give him on his nursery days.

Don't stress about it. Try to expand a little on what you do enjoy doing with him and bugger the rest. All that matters is you're giving him your time and love. Fucking flisat tables, sensory tuff trays, baking and gender neutral toy recommendations are irrelevant at the end of the day. It's all just fluff.

Do the things you enjoy doing with him and fuck the rest.

Notreallylookingforadvice · 10/01/2024 19:13

No, but then you take the crayons away. A 3yo can understand 'we only colour at the table'. Yes but then if you want to colour with them, you’re not, are you?

Plus, colouring in with him is hard with a baby who as I said above won’t be put down at the moment. It’s a phase.

Ds is compliant enough but doesn’t tidy away very well. It ends up being very stressful.

your poor dc the only response to that ends with off.

OP posts:
Geraldneedsasecondclassstamp · 10/01/2024 19:11

Ah I see you mean implement a "crayons at the table only rule"

Yes 100% agree. Some things are only allowed in certain places.

Mamabear2424 · 10/01/2024 19:10

make art and craft things, bake cakes , play some games , read a story ?

Fernsfernsferns · 10/01/2024 19:10

Springbaby2023 · 10/01/2024 16:28

@Fernsfernsferns this is quite reassuring to read. I really want to cut back on tv for my eldest DC but I’m in the middle of sleep deprivation hell with his younger brother, so maybe I should cut myself some slack and reset instead when I’m less tired!

Definitely

you too@Notreallylookingforadvice

when on mat leave with the second I let the amount TV slide for a good few months.

no child ever died from watching a lot of TV

The hard phases pass, your babies will be able to sit up and play from
6 months - ish

you can reset on the amount of TV watched then, when you are feeling more on top of things

meantime the only things that matters is finding a moment of connection with your eldest most days. Which COULD Be an outing or activity you do together, you reading them a story. But could also be sitting with them watching their favourite thing.

we also spent about a year acting out Bluey episodes when we did turn the TV off which was fun 🤩

Geraldneedsasecondclassstamp · 10/01/2024 19:10

With eg colouring, you sit at the table with him. Don't let him get down and wander around.

Why? What benefit is there to forcing him to colour in? He's 3. OP should be led by his interests.

Look at the things he enjoys OP and expand on them. My son is 2 and enjoys scooping and tipping with diggers. So I put a tuff tray out some days with various things he can scoop and tip. He has his diggers but I also give him lots of kitchen utensils, cups, jugs, ladles, etc etc that he can play with. Some days it's something messy like sand, but other days it might be big fluffy pom poms. Another day pasta or rice and lentils. I put toilet or kitchen roll tubes in and he tips them down the tubes. It all sweeps up/hoovers up easily enough. We don't do it every day, maybe once a fortnight.

You can find easy charts online along the lines of "my child likes X, try..."

So "transporting objects" might be giving them an assortment of bags and purses and interesting things to put in them. Kids love putting things in bags to cart about the house. Scooping and tipping, as above: tuff tray or flisat table with something fun to scoop. If they like things that spin you could get a water wheel to play with in the bath or at the kitchen sink, or a treasure basket of different fidget spinners.

Google "play schemas" for more ideas.

hellsBells246 · 10/01/2024 19:07

Springbaby2023 · 10/01/2024 18:59

@hellsBells246 out of interest, and I’m genuinely interested not being patronising! How do you make them sit at a table and colour? If my DS wants to get down I can’t stop him

No, but then you take the crayons away. A 3yo can understand 'we only colour at the table'.

Of course, some Dc will be happy to sit at a table and colour for ages. Some won't. I'm just saying that things like scribbling on the walls can be avoided. You just have to have some rules and be eagle-eyed at this age.

Whatdotheyknow · 10/01/2024 19:05

Oh also meant to say. Please don’t beat yourself up about it. Mum guilt is awful and it just seems to get me whatever I do and it has never helped me be a better mum - it just makes me irritable.

I reckon a happy mum and a full day of TV is much better than a stroppy mum trying to engineer ‘fun’ while stressing about how messy the house is!

Whatdotheyknow · 10/01/2024 19:00

Hm, I have always struggled a bit with playing with my children, especially imaginative play. I think they get a lot of that from nursery. Also not all screens are equal - different cbeebies programmes for example will give lots of different information/ spark imagination etc compared to back to back paw patrol.

I remember one of my older friends saying she couldn’t remember her Mum playing with her as a child at all. They had a fantastic relationship as adults. She also used to say that it’s quite a modern thing for mums to play with their children - they didn’t have time when housework was more manual/ time consuming that it is now.

I think if your child knows they are loved that’s the main thing. Play might be nice, but you can’t pretend to be someone you aren’t with your children - you see them too much!!!

Springbaby2023 · 10/01/2024 18:59

@hellsBells246 out of interest, and I’m genuinely interested not being patronising! How do you make them sit at a table and colour? If my DS wants to get down I can’t stop him

hellsBells246 · 10/01/2024 18:39

With eg colouring, you sit at the table with him. Don't let him get down and wander around.

Brio train tracks are a great toy, impossible to break. Great for imaginative play.

Your outside activities are great, but you do need to up your game inside. Your poor dc.

Choose a song to be your tidying-up song, and play it twice a day. You both tidy up during the song.

But yes, there is a lot of tidying involved when you have young Dc. That's just part of parenting.

Swipe left for the next trending thread