Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To tell 10 year old daughter the truth?

218 replies

TheGhostsOfMeAndYou · 10/01/2024 08:22

My daughter's 10, she's due to start secondary school next year.

We haven't told her Father Christmas isn't real yet.

I think she knows really but she hasn't addressed it aloud to us.

I want to tell her as I don't want her going to secondary school and being picked on, or finding out from another child.

But how do I do it?

I feel so sad that another part of her childhood is over and I also worry that Christmas will loose that magical feeling.

OP posts:
cannaecookrisotto · 10/01/2024 11:04

She most likely already knows. I think my 7 year old goes along with it for my sake 😂.

We've always went down the road of "the parents buy the stuff and Santa consolidates then delivers" so:

A) Santa doesn't get all the credit for her gifts
B) She understands that Xmas isn't unlimited funds-wise and not all children get the same, so don't go in school bragging that Santa brought you a Meta Quest when your friends might have asked and their parents couldn't stretch to it. To be mindful.

InTheRainOnATrain · 10/01/2024 11:03

PillowRest · 10/01/2024 10:54

Believing in something doesn't indicate additional needs, there are still lots of children who believe in God because they're told enough times that it's real despite other people telling them its not.

If anything there's more proof with santa as there's a physical sign that he's real with the presents.

I meant more that kids are going to notice logical stuff like the fact that the Santa at Lapland UK looked totally different to the one at the garden centre. Or that their friend at school gets all their presents from Santa, the kid next door thinks Santa is just the delivery man but in their house they’ve been told that Santa brings stockings. Or all the stories that bang out about him coming down the chimney but they live in a flat without a fireplace. Etc etc.

Religion is totally different I think as there’s a level of consistency eg the bible is the same in any christian church and there’s not someone different dressing up as god everywhere you go! So if you’re from a religious family there are far less inconsistencies to question.

Souvenir81 · 10/01/2024 11:02

Don’t tell her; she will figure it out or may be pretending. I told DD in year 9; not sure whether she believed it or not at that stage. I asked her the other day how she found out and she said well you told me: You don’t believe in Santa? Do you? So what do you want for Christmas? I asked her if she believed by then, she was a bit vague. I think they sort of know but like to keep the game, pretend is real, something like that

Sausage1989 · 10/01/2024 11:00

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

hotpotlover · 10/01/2024 10:59

I never tell my kids about Santa and Father Christmas. I always say "mommy and daddy got you presents for Christmas".

They are 3 1/2, almost 2 and 3 weeks (well, baby doesn't count yet)

Anyone else?

Reading all these threads on mumsnet makes me think I might be doing something wrong 😂

CleansUpButWouldPreferNotTo · 10/01/2024 10:58

https://www.amazon.co.uk/Jacqueline-Wilson-Christmas-Cracker/dp/0440871204

This one says FC, EB, tooth fairy et al aren't real

PillowRest · 10/01/2024 10:54

InTheRainOnATrain · 10/01/2024 10:35

Unless there are additional needs then she almost certainly knows! She’s just humouring you, loves the rituals, thinks certain traditions like stockings are conditional on believing (like receiving a stocking, especially if adults in your house don’t get them), maybe even playing along for younger siblings if there are any etc. etc.

Just drop some hints if you’re not sure like say you’re buying the wrapping paper for next year now while it’s reduced in the sales and see what her reaction is?

Believing in something doesn't indicate additional needs, there are still lots of children who believe in God because they're told enough times that it's real despite other people telling them its not.

If anything there's more proof with santa as there's a physical sign that he's real with the presents.

MuddledMadge · 10/01/2024 10:53

Clarice Bean Think Like an Elf by Lauren Child has some questioning of whether FC is real. It doesn't actually say outright that he isn't but it is a really lovely, gentle, sweet book and would be a great way to bring the subject up and have a discussion about it.

IbizaToTheNorfolkBroads · 10/01/2024 10:51

Age 6 DD told her 9 year old brother !

Caththegreat · 10/01/2024 10:48

I knew he was a bit weird/perve but then I was the kind of kid who's been around before

TempleOfBloom · 10/01/2024 10:47

StaunchMomma · 10/01/2024 10:43

My DS is going up this year, too. He told me they had been covering St Nicholas at school so I took the opportunity to talk about how the story of St Nick developed into the story of Santa.

I sold it as Santa is real, but that he isn't a person, he's a tradition, because every grown up IS Santa for little ones and now he's old enough to be Santa too, for younger friends/family.

He'd been poking holes in santa/easter bunny/tooth fairy for a couple of years and I've been batting questions off with 'if you don't believe, you don't receive!' but it was definitely time.

He wasn't bothered at all, until Xmas Eve when he realised he wasn't going to get a little Santa sack left out in the morning (we've always done Santa presents early then family presents after lunch), so we started a new tradition of a stocking on his bed with a few things in, which he loved.

We've done well to get ours to 10, I think.

Mine worked it out by 4 or 5. But we still did Santa Sacks… still do now they are at Uni. They enjoyed pretending / imagining and leaving the mince pie etc until they were about 9 or 10.

It’s fun, it’s the Christmas Tradition.

I never did ‘don’t believe, don’t receive’.

IbizaToTheNorfolkBroads · 10/01/2024 10:47

Lots of good advice, but do do it! A friend of mine didn't specifically tell her DD - she was 13 when her friends told her!

Caththegreat · 10/01/2024 10:46

Absolutely.i knew from age 5 when I was v uncomfortable sitting on Santa's knees.i knew it was a racket but that was a long time ago

TempleOfBloom · 10/01/2024 10:44

They know, but they go along with playing as if it’s real because it’s fun and the Christmas tradition.

Leaving primary and starting secondary is a big milestone, but they are still your kids and new lovely things emerge as they grow. You have to let her be her and develop.

WhatanEmbarrasment · 10/01/2024 10:43

I’m amazed children get to 10 and 11 and haven’t worked it out? How? Mine knew from 4/5

StaunchMomma · 10/01/2024 10:43

My DS is going up this year, too. He told me they had been covering St Nicholas at school so I took the opportunity to talk about how the story of St Nick developed into the story of Santa.

I sold it as Santa is real, but that he isn't a person, he's a tradition, because every grown up IS Santa for little ones and now he's old enough to be Santa too, for younger friends/family.

He'd been poking holes in santa/easter bunny/tooth fairy for a couple of years and I've been batting questions off with 'if you don't believe, you don't receive!' but it was definitely time.

He wasn't bothered at all, until Xmas Eve when he realised he wasn't going to get a little Santa sack left out in the morning (we've always done Santa presents early then family presents after lunch), so we started a new tradition of a stocking on his bed with a few things in, which he loved.

We've done well to get ours to 10, I think.

Gastropod · 10/01/2024 10:43

I just told mine that Santa will keep coming as long as you "believe" in him, with a big wink. They started suspecting around age 9-10 and this was always my stock answer!

LittleGreenDragons · 10/01/2024 10:40

I think she knows really but she hasn't addressed it aloud to us.

I still haven't had any discussions with my 29yr and 25yr old. My 29yr old still insists Santa is real but that's probably because I made the mistake of when she was five that if she didn't believe in Santa then she wouldn't get any presents from him. She's a mercenary little begger 😂 if you think she knows then leave it. See how she is nearer Christmas as her friends might discuss it between them before then.

EDIT - We have Santa presents as well as family presents. I suppose if Santa brings them all then that's different. If Santa only brings a couple then leave it.

kittensinthekitchen · 10/01/2024 10:35

I'm another who told my kids in the summer before they moved to secondary school, so they were both just after turning 12.

They both knew but still needed it confirmed. We still talk about Santa and do the same traditions we did when they were younger. This past Christmas is the first year we haven't left a mince pie and carrot out, or read The Night before Christmas before bed, they're nearly 19 and 16.

The idea of telling them in summer was that it's unlikely anyone else is talking about Christmas so the 'news' was unlikely to be shared with anybody who wanted to keep it going for longer I.e. any younger friends or friends siblings etc

InTheRainOnATrain · 10/01/2024 10:35

Unless there are additional needs then she almost certainly knows! She’s just humouring you, loves the rituals, thinks certain traditions like stockings are conditional on believing (like receiving a stocking, especially if adults in your house don’t get them), maybe even playing along for younger siblings if there are any etc. etc.

Just drop some hints if you’re not sure like say you’re buying the wrapping paper for next year now while it’s reduced in the sales and see what her reaction is?

ChinUpChestOut · 10/01/2024 10:33

I had to make sure DS knew before he went to boarding school at age 10 - we were worried that he might still actually believe. In the end we got DSS who was 14 to do it - and DS did still kind of believe, just hadn't put it all together yet.

We live overseas where children are kids for a bit longer than in the UK, so it's as well that we did check. Now DS and DSS are 24 and 28, they still get Xmas stockings and they still excitedly tell us what Santa brought them - we joke that they have to behave themselves or Santa won't come, they joke back that they never buy undies or socks in the run up to Christmas as they hope that they'll be getting some in their stocking. DS always gets a small Lego box, DSS always gets some small gadget, and they both get chocolate coins. They love it.

chocolatemademefat · 10/01/2024 10:32

I think you’re kidding yourself. She knows.

JustEatTheOneInTheBallPit · 10/01/2024 10:30

Does anyone know the name of this Jacky Wilson book?

Hullabaloo31 · 10/01/2024 10:28

Notmyhair · 10/01/2024 09:25

I can't remember anything about finding out or not and never had this discussion with my son. Does it need to be a thing?

This! My 12yo son knows but it's never been said out loud. He plays along for his little sister and because he wants to!

IggyAce · 10/01/2024 10:11

I’d do nothing my dd is nearly 18 and I’ve never had the conversation with her, but she happily played along for her younger sibling.