Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To tell 10 year old daughter the truth?

218 replies

TheGhostsOfMeAndYou · 10/01/2024 08:22

My daughter's 10, she's due to start secondary school next year.

We haven't told her Father Christmas isn't real yet.

I think she knows really but she hasn't addressed it aloud to us.

I want to tell her as I don't want her going to secondary school and being picked on, or finding out from another child.

But how do I do it?

I feel so sad that another part of her childhood is over and I also worry that Christmas will loose that magical feeling.

OP posts:
Blondeshavemorefun · 11/01/2024 16:49

@Peachandwatermelon this book

To tell 10 year old daughter the truth?
Mumof2NDers · 11/01/2024 16:47

Mine are 16 and 23 and are still humouring me 😂

Allofaflutter · 11/01/2024 16:42

Still magical.

Allofaflutter · 11/01/2024 16:41

I never told my kids, I’m assuming as most of them are in their 20’s that they have twigged by now lol. Seriously it was obvious by about 8/9 they were doing the Santa stuff to humour me, in fact they still do!

NoThanksymm · 11/01/2024 16:39

…. Provided she’s nurotypical she will be smart enough to keep her mouth shut or play it off as sarcasm.

chill mama, chill!

and keep getting those Santa presents

LolaSmiles · 11/01/2024 15:34

Your Christmas sounds lovely Deckchairs.

The gradual realisation in an age appropriate way makes the most sense I my opinion. There's not need in my opinion to create a big deal when they're younger and then panic each time they might find out the truth.

Harperhan · 11/01/2024 15:00

She will already know have an inkling and don’t spoil it if she doesn’t. I have never had a conversation with any of my children about it and we still have the same conversation on Christmas Eve about if Father Christmas might come etc. Only now there is a wink, wink nudge, nudge with it. Just because she is at secondary school doesn’t mean he won’t come. My eldest is 17, middle one 15 and youngest 11 and Father Christmas still comes for them every year.

Kaybee50 · 11/01/2024 13:27

I had similar concerns about my daughter who started secondary school last September. It turns out she had known for two years that he didn’t exist! (Apparently a yr 5 teacher told the class) She was still very excited at Christmas.

RatatouillePie · 11/01/2024 11:47

YABU. Lots of Y7 pupils still believe in Father Christmas.

We had a supply teacher who told a Y7 class that it was your parents who put the presents in the stocking. We then had 5 complaints from parents when their child came home upset about this as they had no idea! (The supply teacher was never used again!)

If she has her own ideas then she'll figure it out in her own time and is hardly going to announce out loud to the who class that the big man is real?!

I still keep up the pretence with my Y11 classes and asked them all if Father Christmas got them anything nice. They usually play along.

LBFseBrom · 11/01/2024 11:39

Very sensible, Doone. I brought mine up with the same attitude and Christmas was still exciting and magical.

Doone22 · 11/01/2024 11:21

I always told my kids from the start that FC was not a real person but he symbolised the spirit of Christmas. They still have stocking every year, as do all the adults and anyone in my house on Christmas Eve.

But yes you do need to make sure she knows now instead of being utterly humiliated at a later date.

Peachandwatermelon · 11/01/2024 10:55

theduchessofspork · 10/01/2024 08:26

I think there’s a Jacqueline Wilson book that will do the job for you - someone was asking a few days ago.

She’ll still enjoy Christmas, but she is now a tween ie going to adolescence (whether it shows or not yet) it’s naturally going to be different. But in between the drama the teen years are magical in their own way.

Shit which one? I didn't know this. I have a younger dd who has read a lot of these books.

Deckchairs · 11/01/2024 10:52

I have 12 year old twins, I’m not sure when they found out tbh as it was a gradual realisation in line with their increasing maturity. Honestly it wasn’t a big deal and Christmas is still lovely, with all the same traditions. We ham it up a lot with the kids, lots of pretend “mistakes” and “slip ups” (eg “I - I mean Santa - saw that and knew you’d love it”: “Santa” (big inverted commas) would love you to leave out a gin and tonic this year” 🤣). I think they enjoy being in on it and they still get all the presents, so all good. Tbh, it’s less stressful than worrying about them waking up and being caught in the act. Please try not to worry and see it as another phase/ transition that will happen in due course… I agree summer time likely a good idea, when Christmas seems AGES away.

beenwhereyouare · 11/01/2024 09:15

Please be very careful how you handle this. For basically the same reason as you, I told, and it really hurt my daughter. She later said that at the time she felt very disillusioned and almost betrayed because we had been "lying" to her to begin with.

I was trying to protect her from ridicule and instead ended up making the next Christmas miserable for her. If I'd thought it through, I'd have left her alone and let her find out gradually the way most kids do. Her sister is 2 years older and most likely would've told her soon anyway. I so wish I'd have handled this differently- she's 40 now and I still regret it.

Getthethrowonthesofa · 11/01/2024 08:09

BoredPangolins · 11/01/2024 07:29

Don't tell her! Honestly she already knows and won't be picked on at school because she won't say anything. But clearly wants to keep the magic alive. Allow her that; she'll tell you she doesn't believe when she's ready to tell you.
My 15 year old only told me this year that he doesn't believe, but I've known since he was 9 or 10 that he didn't. My 13 and 11 year olds still claim to believe. My 13 year old definitely doesn't but most of my 11 year olds class still seemed to this year.

Oh cmon now. No kid wants to pretend to be younger than they are. If the pretend to believe it’s to keep the parents happy. She needs to take the pressure off her and have the convo.

BoredPangolins · 11/01/2024 07:29

Don't tell her! Honestly she already knows and won't be picked on at school because she won't say anything. But clearly wants to keep the magic alive. Allow her that; she'll tell you she doesn't believe when she's ready to tell you.
My 15 year old only told me this year that he doesn't believe, but I've known since he was 9 or 10 that he didn't. My 13 and 11 year olds still claim to believe. My 13 year old definitely doesn't but most of my 11 year olds class still seemed to this year.

mathanxiety · 10/01/2024 23:53

AlltheFs · 10/01/2024 15:45

I believe in fairies, magic, Father Christmas, the Easter Bunny and Hogwarts. I’m 45.
Stop being such a fun sponge. It’s lovely to live inside your own imagination- the real world is shite.

It won't be so much fun when the rest of the kids find out.

What is to be gained by keeping a child in the dark here? Whose benefit is this for?

Parents need to let their children know it's OK to grow up and leave childhood behind. It doesn't have to be done abruptly. But a child needs to know her parents are willing and able to cherish her as she grows and sees herself and the world differently just as much as they did when she was a tot, and they're not holding her back because change is outside of their comfort zone.

Perfectlystill · 10/01/2024 23:04

Tell her before she starts secondary school

SpicyMoth · 10/01/2024 22:52

theduchessofspork · 10/01/2024 08:26

I think there’s a Jacqueline Wilson book that will do the job for you - someone was asking a few days ago.

She’ll still enjoy Christmas, but she is now a tween ie going to adolescence (whether it shows or not yet) it’s naturally going to be different. But in between the drama the teen years are magical in their own way.

THAT EXACT BOOK RUINED IT FOR ME IN CASETTE FORM!!

I've never heard/seen anyone else mentioning it ever before - Was it "girls under pressure" maybe?
All I remember was it also mentioned Doctor Who, and to lessen the pain of Father Christmas my mum then introduced me to the Christopher Eccleston Revamp!

LolaSmiles · 10/01/2024 21:58

I have never had this conversation with my parents and I’m 45.
I still had a stocking until I moved out of home-I wasn’t under any delusion it was Father Christmas when I was 18.

There’s really no need to actually say it surely?!
I think it depends on the family.

In a chilled out family where Santa has always been low key, a bit of a story, we put some fun treats out, he brings a stocking but presents are from family, you probably don't need to have the conversation. They'll realise naturally as they gain critical thinking and maturity, and it becomes a unspoken thing.

In the (ridiculous imo) families who go out of their way to convince their children from a young age that Santa is a literal human, who take their children here there and everywhere to do Santa things, to fake letters from Santa to their children, have Santa cams and other stuff to add to the 'proof' he's real, where the parents are devastated that their 6 year old asks questions or has doubts, and they're posting on Mumsnet overwhelmed that the magic of Christmas will be ruined unless they can find a way to stage things to shut down a 7 year old's questions, yeah they probably will have to have the conversation. These are the parents who seem to think that their 11 year old sincerely believing in Santa gets them some parenting of the year award. They can usually be spotted saying how sad and upsetting it is that a 5 year old realises reindeer can't fly and Santa can't get round over 6 billion homes in one night.

Edit to add, obviously there's shades of grey between the two.

Wakemeuuuup · 10/01/2024 21:49

I told my 2 the August before starting secondary.

My youngest said "yeah I know, the tooth fairy isn't real either"

My eldest was absolutely gutted, he only just turned 11 before starting secondary. He said he suspected but really wanted to believe. After Christmas he told me was was really pleased we told him as another kid in the year still believed and was bullied because of it

Branwells77 · 10/01/2024 21:32

I told mine (twins) in the August before they started secondary one of my DS laughed and said I’ve known for years it was you and Dad the other DS was devastated still fully believed in Santa and it did break my heart a little bit and Christmas hasn’t been the same since but it’s all part of then growing up Good luck OP

Ludovik · 10/01/2024 19:49

AlltheFs · 10/01/2024 15:45

I believe in fairies, magic, Father Christmas, the Easter Bunny and Hogwarts. I’m 45.
Stop being such a fun sponge. It’s lovely to live inside your own imagination- the real world is shite.

For something to be part of your imagination you have to know it isn’t real.

Kids believing in Father Christmas aren’t enjoying their imagination, they are just believing in something as a fact because their parents have told them it’s real.

Tiredalwaystired · 10/01/2024 19:33

Pusheen467 · 10/01/2024 14:02

It's honestly embarrassing how long some people let this go on for.

Really sorry that I’ve embarrassed you because my 40 year old cousin with Down’s Syndrome still believes.

I’m going to tell him the truth immediately because it will make you feel less embarrassed and we can all agree the world is a better place.

LBFseBrom · 10/01/2024 18:11

I'd be more than surprised if your daughter, at the age of ten, believed in Father Christmas. It's likely she has known the truth for a very long time but doesn't say anything to that effect in order to spare your feelings. You have already expressed feeling upset at the very thought.

The myth often means more to parents than children.