Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To remove the fence

170 replies

NoTreadingHere · 10/01/2024 05:20

We have a fence that sits about 7cm from the neighbour's wall. It's a huge wall covering the entire length of their property. They never see into our side.

Our relations have been amicable but I've been keen to entirely remove the fence. It's rotting and decrepit, but the issue is that they demand the existing fence replaced (at shared cost) by a new and very expensive new fence to protect their precious 7cm.

They're now moving and are in the process of selling the property. They're not living in the property and I'm keen to have a helper come in and quietly pull out and remove the fencing. DH is totally absolutely against it, mainly because he's timid and conflict averse. I'm fuming as neither the existing owners or new owners would ever know about the fence removal and this is a golden opportunity to solve the fence problem forever. The new owners are unlikely to be any more forgiving (it's that kind of area).

Basically I'm raging that the solution can't be implemented

OP posts:
LumiB · 11/01/2024 11:32

RhiWrites · 11/01/2024 11:30

Why not wait until the house is sold and then pull out the fence?

Because you cannot just take peoples land which is what OP is clearly showing she wants to do. Its not about the fence for OP otherwise she would just take the advice of take the fence down and mark the boundary if she is responsible for it. If she isn't and takes the fence down and she isn't the owner of it then the new owners can legally ask her to pay to replace the entire fence as what she did is illegal.

RhiWrites · 11/01/2024 11:30

Why not wait until the house is sold and then pull out the fence?

LumiB · 11/01/2024 11:28

LaurieStrode · 11/01/2024 11:27

Well, why is it OP's job to mark the boundary? Shouldn't the owners be doing so, as they are the interested party?

It depends on who is responsible for the boundary and therefore the fence.

If OP is responsible for the boundary and therefore the fence then she can take the fence down and mark the boundary how she chooses.

If she is not then she cannot take the fence down.

Neighbours have suggested sharing the cost OP doesn't want to pay.

OP hasn't despite others asking confirmed who is the responsible owner.

However regardless of the fence the land is still the neighbours land.

LaurieStrode · 11/01/2024 11:27

Well, why is it OP's job to mark the boundary? Shouldn't the owners be doing so, as they are the interested party?

LumiB · 11/01/2024 11:25

Ktime · 11/01/2024 11:17

I don’t think it’s stealing. It’s not like OP is building anything there.

Its stealing if she doesn't mark the boundary and then just takes it anyway, which OP has clearly made obvious is what she will do. As her last post oh well who will care about 7cm.

Its not her's to take and yes that is stealing in the eyes of the law. It's illegal to possess land that you know is not your land. She is fully aware that 7cm is not her land. There is a difference if you never knew who the land belonged to and then started using it then you can claim adverse possession. But she is fully aware its not her land

Ktime · 11/01/2024 11:17

Sureaseggs44 · 11/01/2024 10:45

If they steal the land and it goes to court and they lose they would have to pay costs . I would not try and steal the strip of land .

I don’t think it’s stealing. It’s not like OP is building anything there.

NoTreadingHere · 11/01/2024 11:14

LaurieStrode · 11/01/2024 11:04

What is the height of the stone wall??

Varies between 10 to 15 feet or so.

If the roles were reversed, I wouldn't care a bit for a tiny nugget of land I could never ordinarily see or benefit from. I definitely wouldn't buy several ladders purely for spying purposes and obsessively monitor the fence and 7cm 🙄

OP posts:
Mittemucci · 11/01/2024 11:06

Pull it down.

if anyone asks tell them you found termites.

when challenged play dumb. Oh it must have been a ladybug. Terribly sorry.

LumiB · 11/01/2024 11:05

Let me ask you OP if the situation was reversed would you just let it happen?

LaurieStrode · 11/01/2024 11:04

What is the height of the stone wall??

LumiB · 11/01/2024 11:03

NoTreadingHere · 11/01/2024 11:00

Yes, once the garden grows and memories fade, the 7cm is an rounding error lost to time. Seems worth a punt.

There is also evidence of where the boundary is in terms of pictures. I took plenty of pictures and videos before I put my fence up next to my neighbours (whose fence was the boundary)

So I had enough evidence to prove where the boundary was after they decided to try it on like you are.

You are the worst type of neighbour. Why are you so bothered by the 7cm? Why don't you just take the fence down which is the problem right and stick up a wire or whatever to prove the boundary? Why are insisting on taking the land?

If the neighbours are already part way through a sale the new buyers will have bought knowing there was a fence their.

NoTreadingHere · 11/01/2024 11:00

KaiserChefs · 11/01/2024 10:48

If there's a wall that close to a boundary then legally the wall is taken as the boundary. So most of the advice on this thread is wrong.

Also the land registry doesn't record the boundary accurately enough to know whose that 7cm is. It sounds like they're trying to do a land grab.

A garden wall is a party wall if it's on the boundary.
https://www.gov.uk/party-walls-building-works

Yes, once the garden grows and memories fade, the 7cm is an rounding error lost to time. Seems worth a punt.

OP posts:
LumiB · 11/01/2024 10:57

KaiserChefs · 11/01/2024 10:48

If there's a wall that close to a boundary then legally the wall is taken as the boundary. So most of the advice on this thread is wrong.

Also the land registry doesn't record the boundary accurately enough to know whose that 7cm is. It sounds like they're trying to do a land grab.

A garden wall is a party wall if it's on the boundary.
https://www.gov.uk/party-walls-building-works

I think you will find you are wrong. A boundary is already clearly marked the land still belongs to the owner even if the wall is there with a 7cm gap. The wall is not automatically the new boundary.

OP made it clear the fence is the boundary not the wall.

Whatever reason for the wall it will have had to leave a gap from the boundary due to foundations etc. But this does not mean the wall becomes the boundary.

AlbatrosStrike · 11/01/2024 10:54

KaiserChefs · 11/01/2024 10:48

If there's a wall that close to a boundary then legally the wall is taken as the boundary. So most of the advice on this thread is wrong.

Also the land registry doesn't record the boundary accurately enough to know whose that 7cm is. It sounds like they're trying to do a land grab.

A garden wall is a party wall if it's on the boundary.
https://www.gov.uk/party-walls-building-works

This is wrong. The wall on the neighbour’s land is NOT a party wall, it’s the neighbour’s wall. The fence marks the boundary and the fact that the neighbour has built a wall on their land does not change the boundary.

KaiserChefs · 11/01/2024 10:48

If there's a wall that close to a boundary then legally the wall is taken as the boundary. So most of the advice on this thread is wrong.

Also the land registry doesn't record the boundary accurately enough to know whose that 7cm is. It sounds like they're trying to do a land grab.

A garden wall is a party wall if it's on the boundary.
https://www.gov.uk/party-walls-building-works

Party walls and building work

When and how to tell neighbours about building works on party walls, what to do if you've been notified of works, how to come to an agreement

https://www.gov.uk/party-walls-building-works

Sureaseggs44 · 11/01/2024 10:45

Ktime · 11/01/2024 10:42

Would you be amused at the cost? You must be rich!

If they steal the land and it goes to court and they lose they would have to pay costs . I would not try and steal the strip of land .

Ktime · 11/01/2024 10:42

AlbatrosStrike · 11/01/2024 10:33

If I was your neighbour I’d watch you do all this in amused silence and then serve you with a lawyer’s letter to hire a surveyor to reinstate the boundary.

Edited

Would you be amused at the cost? You must be rich!

LumiB · 11/01/2024 10:37

NoTreadingHere · 11/01/2024 10:11

The fence is the boundary line. It predates both of our occupancy so there's no known history as to why their wall and house don't go all the way to the property line.

I'm NOT stealing anything. The garden will just grow over the boundary line into the 7cm (especially once I insist that DH accidentally and thoroughly fertilize it).

Well it might grow over but it doesn't make it then your land. That is the point everyone is making to you. You come across as you're like well the garden will grow over and it'll just be part of our garden. NO! It is not nor will ever be part of your garden. You've been told countless times that you need to mark the boundary. Ok if grass or the plants hang over its their problem if they want to cut it back. You still have to mark the boundary line!

It doesn't even matter why the wall is there anything anyone does inside their property boundary is of no concern to anyone. Build a wall, a fence whatever the boundary is still the boundary unless it is legally changed.

AlbatrosStrike · 11/01/2024 10:33

NoTreadingHere · 11/01/2024 10:11

The fence is the boundary line. It predates both of our occupancy so there's no known history as to why their wall and house don't go all the way to the property line.

I'm NOT stealing anything. The garden will just grow over the boundary line into the 7cm (especially once I insist that DH accidentally and thoroughly fertilize it).

If I was your neighbour I’d watch you do all this in amused silence and then serve you with a lawyer’s letter to hire a surveyor to reinstate the boundary.

randomchap · 11/01/2024 10:33

You have no right to that strip of land.

You may have the right to remove the fence, check your deeds.

If you go ahead and take over that land then you're very likely to have legal troubles in the future.

Frankly you seem to be greedy, grasping, and ignorant.

LaurieStrode · 11/01/2024 10:33

So is your intention to use the 7cm?

How high is their wall?

What outcome are you seeking vis the boundary line?

StonliaKyle · 11/01/2024 10:32

You cannot grow anything up their wall, attach anything to it or do anything to damage it in any way that does include damage from plants.

We own our garden wall but there is still a gap I can walk behind to trim back tree and shrub branches as the cost of a fence is expensive, think how much building a wall costs.

The reason they didn't build all the way to the boundary line especially if part of it was an extension and then the wall a continuation is because it is best practise to leave a 50mm gap as a minimum. That way if you ever wanted to extend too you would also not build up to the boundary wall. Also allows the bricks to dry out from wind and the occasional sun we get in the UK.

You seem to think that you are not stealing land by allowing your planting to grow in that direction, yes you are intending to steal using plants. I hope they see this thread and take photos and videos of the fence being where it is in relation to their wall.

The other thing I will caution you on is never assume that your new neighbours won't be batshit crazy and make their life's mission to make your life hell. Have a wander over to the Garden Law forum especially the boundaries or fences sections. No they can't sue your plants but they can cut them back to the boundary line.

Check your deeds and see what the situation is re the boundary and whether you have to keep a fence in place. My deeds specifically state that all walls and fences must be kept in good repair so I can't allow a fence to fall down and not repair it.

BusyMummyWrites01 · 11/01/2024 10:27

You need to look at your deeds and establish whose responsibility the fence/boundary maintenance is. If it is yours, you can take it down and chose not to replace it; if it is theirs, they can chose to remove it/erect another fence or you can request they take it down and hope they agree, but the cost for doing so is their liability. It will be in your conveyancing documents (deeds/covenants).

If you take it down and it is not your boundary/responsibility, a future owner can take legal proceedings. They may be referenced on the new buyer’s survey report, so don’t assume no-one will notice.

In our street, on our side of the road, we are all responsible for the right hand sided fences, per the deeds & covenants. I wanted to dog proof our garden and replace ugly/rusted/low/broken 30-40yo wire fences and industrial iron posts. We were not legally entitled to change the ones on the left hand side, but our lovely neighbours happily agreed to allow us to do so as we offered to pay for it in full and consulted on the style of 5ft wire fencing and associated hedging. They did, actually offer to give us something towards it all, but it’s our dogs we’re safeguarding, so we were happy to decline.

NoTreadingHere · 11/01/2024 10:11

rainbowstardrops · 11/01/2024 10:03

I'm confused (it doesn't take much at the moment!)
So is the fence along the actual boundary? Why did they build a wall? Is it a low wall?

Are you saying you want to remove the old fence and subsequently you intend to keep quiet and effectively acquire an extra 7cm x the length of the garden? You can't do that!

The fence is the boundary line. It predates both of our occupancy so there's no known history as to why their wall and house don't go all the way to the property line.

I'm NOT stealing anything. The garden will just grow over the boundary line into the 7cm (especially once I insist that DH accidentally and thoroughly fertilize it).

OP posts:
Clarinet1 · 11/01/2024 10:07

Anjea · 10/01/2024 17:31

Don't sit on the fence, say what you mean

😂 Sit on the fence! Did no one else laugh?