Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Anger and sadness at this interaction with homeless person

361 replies

BlueCupOrangeCup · 09/01/2024 23:35

Tonight, a polite homeless man named Kevin told me he secured a spot in a 12-week program at St Mungo's after a year of homelessness. He needed £7.50 urgently to go there tonight and had been trying all day. Skeptical, I regretfully declined, later realizing he might have been genuine.

I'm replaying the whole conversation in my head and now I think I recall him almost bursting into tears as he asked if there was any way at all I could help him.

This one might have been genuine and I'm so disgusted with myself.

I could have helped. I had a £5 note in my purse....and I am fortunate enough that I wouldn't miss it or notice it gone.

And at the same time I'm also so angry at scammers of this thing. If someone stood in front of you asking begging for a small amount of money to help them and you knew it was genuine OF COURSE all of us would help! But genuine people don't get the help they need because scammers make people have attitudes like mine tonight.

There is no way to phone st Mungo's now to 'pre pay' for Kevin should he turn up tonight....meanwhile I'm going home to sleep in my warm bed and work my lovely job tomorrow.

Poor Kevin, I'm sorry I didn't help you.

OP posts:
CormorantStrikesBack · 10/01/2024 07:54

I see the same people frequently outside the train station asking for money for a train fare because they have lost their card/fallen on hard times/ off to a refuge. The same people.

LodiDodi · 10/01/2024 07:53

It's a difficult call to make as there are many genuine homeless desperate people which is why there needs to be proper organised help that is able to provide for the complex issue of getting people off the street which takes time and a lot of money.
I have noticed since the cost of living became worse, begging people are acting more desperately. Presumably because people aren't able to give as much.
I heard that animal charities receive an rye watering amount of money whereas charities which support human needs don't receive a lot. Think of the people living in misery next time you donate towards a chipmunk with a sore toe.

MorningSunshineSparkles · 10/01/2024 07:51

I’m sorry but if someone burst into tears in front of me and asked for help you can bet your arse I would. You’d have to be entirely cold and callous not to.

bruffin · 10/01/2024 07:49

OhBumBags · 09/01/2024 23:49

Just to add if 'enabling' a homeless person's lifestyle means giving them a couple of quid when I know they're going to drink it, I'm happy with that.

God knows how many addicts are on the street, but even if every single one of them decided to get help tomorrow, the NHS and other charities couldn't cope at all.

The government would rather keep the addicts on the streets, being 'enabled' by passers by, rather than government money.

You are enabling their drugvdealer though. Buy a hot drink but no cash.
Team was out the other night offering rooms for the night and out of 16 approached only 2 accepted.
Where i work , they know all the regulars and their back stories, its not as simple as offering them somewhere to live.
Anyone say they need money for a hostel is lying. Hostels are free

NeverDropYourMooncup · 10/01/2024 07:47

LambriniBobinIsleworth · 10/01/2024 07:40

My policy with this stuff if that if it's an amount of money I wouldn't miss- I've spent more than £7.50 on a coffee and a cake- it doesn't matter what is for. I would have given him the £7.50: what's the worst case scenario if you had? That he'd had a small amount of money off of you to spend on booze/drugs. Hardly matters does it. I always give to homeless people, it's a basic human kindness.

That they die as a direct result of your money?

I wouldn't give an actively suicidal person money that would be used to buy a blade either.

Sadza · 10/01/2024 07:47

Yes it might have been a scam, and probably was. But if there was a slim chance it might have helped someone, I would have given it and moved on. Nobody on here knows if it was genuine or not.

teddycoat · 10/01/2024 07:46

I'm answering this post based on what you've written, not on the various moral arguments about giving homeless people money.

Ring St Mungos and ask them if they charge £7.50. If they do, and it was bothering me so much I'd go back to where I saw Kevin last and give it to him. If they don't charge then I'd just chalk it up to a sad experience that someone has to lie like that and let it go.

Fantaandcola · 10/01/2024 07:46

YankSplaining · 10/01/2024 03:02

I never give money to people begging for it on the street. They tend to ask women specifically because they think we’re an easy target - basically, they’re banking on the fact that a lot of women have a hard time saying no or disappointing people.

When I was in school, there was a man who always stood by a nearby street with a sign reading WILL WORK FOR FOOD. Some of the older girls I knew went shopping one day and bought him a whole big box filled with non-perishable food. When they tried to give it to him, he stared at them for a few seconds and then just ignored them.

This part. They target certain demographics based on perceived generosity. Gender and race and age is taken into account.

I didn’t realise this was a thing until I’d spoken to a few others including homeless people but apparently many target POC/ black women in particular because they see them as being left wing , social justice minded and out to fight for the little man etc. it does explain a lot of my experiences growing up as the only POC in an area with a lot of drug addicted people on the street.

I find this massively problematic for several reasons one of them being women POC are often the least likely to be offered help and most likely to be discriminated against which then impacts their economic success (See gender and racial pay gap) so no we shouldn’t be expected to be front of the line giving out money to anyone.

Agree with most posters on this thread including the person who said it should be stopped and homelessness and addiction tackled properly. Many women have had unpleasant encounters with men asking for money late at night and feeling intimidated. I also know both men and women who have suffered verbal abuse including racial abuse for refusing to give money.

A lot of the people who don’t mind the practice are those who want to feel good about giving a fiver to the guy on the street while not actually doing the hard of work of supporting organisations and politicians to tackle the root of the problem.

Op don’t feel bad, you did the right thing and you can use that money towards supporting a homeless charity which is what they advise anyway as per the guardian article someone posted earlier. Or buy a tea and hot sandwich for the next homeless person you encounter.

Those who don’t mind the high risk of funding drug and alcohol habits or trafficking rings by giving indiscriminately to people on the street well crack on as each to their own and all that, but I’m not going to feel bad about donating to homeless charities and (in the past ) volunteering at soup kitchens instead.

Nopenoway · 10/01/2024 07:43

Illegal in most cities?? Eh??

LakieLady · 10/01/2024 07:42

Beautiful3 · 10/01/2024 07:16

There's a genuine homeless man sleeping rough in our area. Lots of people give him money/drink and food. Then someone posted a picture of him at his tent, there were stacks of beers behind him, inside the tent. He said he's on the street because he's addicted to alcohol. But he's clearly still drinking. It really annoys me when I see people give him.money now, because he spends people's money on booze.

Someone who's addicted to alcohol can't just stop, not safely, anyway, it can be fatal. That's why people who are able to get treatment have a managed detox in hospital, followed by a long spell in rehab.

LambriniBobinIsleworth · 10/01/2024 07:40

My policy with this stuff if that if it's an amount of money I wouldn't miss- I've spent more than £7.50 on a coffee and a cake- it doesn't matter what is for. I would have given him the £7.50: what's the worst case scenario if you had? That he'd had a small amount of money off of you to spend on booze/drugs. Hardly matters does it. I always give to homeless people, it's a basic human kindness.

DezRez88 · 10/01/2024 07:37

It's a common scam in London unfortunately.

There are beggars that get onto trains and walk up and down the carriages with a pre rehearsed speech about how they need X amount to get into a hostel that night, every day.

As a regular commuter you tend to see the same ones all of the time with the same story.

I'm much more cynical these days and often say no. If I see somebody who is obviously homeless IE dishevelled and sleeping outside with their belongings I will absolutely buy food, drink or put a few quid in their cup, but people approaching me to ask. No.

LakieLady · 10/01/2024 07:37

i think homelessness needs to be properly tackled and as part of that, begging random people in the street should be completely banned.

Begging in the street has been illegal for nearly 200 years, under the Vagrancy Act.

I worked in homelessness prevention and resettlement for 10 years. The project started in 2009 with a decent budget and 110 staff. We could work with people for 2 years, to get them resettled and help them develop the skills they needed to maintain a tenancy. The project still exists, but funds have been cut so much that there are now fewer than 30 staff, and the longest they can work with a client is 12 weeks. That's not enough time for them to achieve anything meaningful.

Tackling homelessness "properly" is complex and costly. I like to think that a change of government might lead to more funding, but I'm not holding my breath. And I think things may well get worse if more BTL landlords decide to jack it in, and rents keep rising the way they have over the last couple of years.

Tiredoutoday · 10/01/2024 07:35

That £7.50 could make a huge difference in the wrong direction. You harden as you get so many in your path begging, spinning a story true or not. The best way is to donate directly to shelter or whatever charity you can if and when you can.

babyproblems · 10/01/2024 07:30

I think you should give it even if you aren’t certain they are genuine… it’s £7.50.
If it gets spent on crap then it’s gone. If it’s genuine, you’ve made a huge difference to someone. If you won’t miss it, it’s worth giving it away. I hope you’ll spend that £5 wisely.

FluffyFanny · 10/01/2024 07:28

No-one should be made to feel guilty about not giving to beggars.

violetcuriosity · 10/01/2024 07:20

I think she means he needed £7.50 to get there.

OP- it's not just on you to carry this, lots of other people also felt the same way. You've reflected and maybe next time you'd do something differently, maybe you won't. Don't beat yourself up about it, pay it forward tomorrow.

Beautiful3 · 10/01/2024 07:16

There's a genuine homeless man sleeping rough in our area. Lots of people give him money/drink and food. Then someone posted a picture of him at his tent, there were stacks of beers behind him, inside the tent. He said he's on the street because he's addicted to alcohol. But he's clearly still drinking. It really annoys me when I see people give him.money now, because he spends people's money on booze.

ZenNudist · 10/01/2024 07:15

Guavafish1 · 09/01/2024 23:55

he is not telling the truth

This

Was stopped 3 times with similar tales in reading city centre. Scary place. I gave money direct to a local homeless charity instead.

They all claimed to have sick wives with them nearby. I think they think I'd be more likely to help a woman . The cynicism is awful.

malovitt · 10/01/2024 07:14

There are three men (different but look related to each other) who have been begging in the Camden area of London for the past seven years They sit with identical "I'm hungry" cardboard signs in front of them, usually outside a supermarket (with a cashpoint outside) or bakery - I know it has been seven years as I started to notice these particular men whilst on a nursery school run and the child I was dropping off to nursery is now in Year 6. I also have seen these same men being dropped off/collected by a Mercedes people carrier. You never see them overnight; I wonder why? In contrast, I have noticed others in sleeping bags in the Poundstretcher doorway who have obviously been out all night. After the recent torrential rain, I asked what I could do to help and the guy politely asked for some dry socks and a hot drink which I bought for him. There are many genuine homeless people out there but plenty of scammers.

Alcyoneus · 10/01/2024 07:14

sawnotseen · 10/01/2024 06:55

This thread has really upset me, where is the love? Where is community? Empathy? What are you teaching your children?

Sounds like something you read on the back of seat on a bus.

MoominMamma15 · 10/01/2024 07:14

You can call or e-mail them if you’d like more info

Anger and sadness at this interaction with homeless person
HangingOver · 10/01/2024 07:14

I would never give free handout to anyone; well, at least not so far. No one has managed to convince me that they are worth it.

Lovely.

I donate to shelter but do give cash sometimes. Doesn't help in the long run i expect but I'm an ex addict and I know how bloody awful it is when you're sick from it.

Alcyoneus · 10/01/2024 07:13

The naivety of people on this thread she is why begging has become a profession.

DistressedDamson · 10/01/2024 07:12

FeliciousM · 10/01/2024 05:51

Oh dear. You lot really have no idea do you? I do. I know. I was on the streets at 17. Human trafficking is greatly exaggerated for a start. Greatly. As is the kind of fraud you are excusing your own lack of empathy with. Even when people beg to fund an addiction, you really think their life is better than yours? That they are luckier than you? I don't know what to tell you OP....but I'm disgusted by what I see in these comments. Echo chambers are real. The fake bourgeois left is real....and they lack empathy to an extraordinary extent.

Hear hear. I too spent time on the streets and I used to beg for money as it was usually a safer bet than the alternative option (as a woman) to earn quick money. Yes, I was addicted to drugs but i was at my absolute lowest and begging was a safer way to get money than selling myself.
i do agree that, if people want to help but don’t want to give money directly to beggars, they should give money to charities (st mungos, shelter, CGL, etc) but all this nonsense about beggars living the high life with their plush flats and designer clothes makes me seeth. Once you get to the point where asking strangers on the street for money (or worse, see above) is a viable option, things have got pretty desperate. It was some of the charities mentioned above which helped me turn things around (not to mention my own desire to sort my life out and not die like so many of my contemporaries) so please donate to them if you don’t want to give direct. One thing I would say as well, is if you don’t want to give, at least acknowledging the person begging “sorry, can’t help but good luck” means a lot (well, it did to me anyway).

Swipe left for the next trending thread