Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Anger and sadness at this interaction with homeless person

361 replies

BlueCupOrangeCup · 09/01/2024 23:35

Tonight, a polite homeless man named Kevin told me he secured a spot in a 12-week program at St Mungo's after a year of homelessness. He needed £7.50 urgently to go there tonight and had been trying all day. Skeptical, I regretfully declined, later realizing he might have been genuine.

I'm replaying the whole conversation in my head and now I think I recall him almost bursting into tears as he asked if there was any way at all I could help him.

This one might have been genuine and I'm so disgusted with myself.

I could have helped. I had a £5 note in my purse....and I am fortunate enough that I wouldn't miss it or notice it gone.

And at the same time I'm also so angry at scammers of this thing. If someone stood in front of you asking begging for a small amount of money to help them and you knew it was genuine OF COURSE all of us would help! But genuine people don't get the help they need because scammers make people have attitudes like mine tonight.

There is no way to phone st Mungo's now to 'pre pay' for Kevin should he turn up tonight....meanwhile I'm going home to sleep in my warm bed and work my lovely job tomorrow.

Poor Kevin, I'm sorry I didn't help you.

OP posts:
Brefugee · 10/01/2024 09:02

KinS24 · 10/01/2024 08:33

Interesting that despite all the homelessness experts here agreeing that beggars shouldn’t be given cash there are still some holier than thou types who are berating anyone who doesn’t do just this.
I keep seeing this on here. People being attacked for being pragmatic and not just acting on emotion.
I don’t give to beggars. I am still a good person. So are you OP.

I'm reading a different thread i think? There is no "berating" going on. There are people saying what they do when confronted with this kind of thing.

But i see why there are so many threads about how horrible MNetters are, if people explaining what they do when they see a homeless person is described as "berating".

FWIW - i don't donate to homeless charities (or many charities) tbh. Mostly because i do think a lot of them spend too much on admin and not enough on the target of the charity. I do give clothes directly to a friend of one of my DC who works in a homeless shelter. They tell me now and again what they're looking for in terms of support (often it is large sized underwear for women) and i rootle round and see what i have. Or blankets. Or winter coats, scarves, hats and gloves at the moment.
We donated an old trolley-type suitcase to one chap who carried his things in 2 plastic bags but he has back problems. He's very happy with that. etc etc

Everyone should be able to decide for themselves what they do, if anything. And should we feel bad about homelessness? Sure. I do. It is one of the things i ask our local councillors about when elections are coming.

Flickersy · 10/01/2024 08:59

St Mungo's Recovery Colleges (which sounds like what he was referring to) are free. There is no charge.

There is also no charge to stay in their hostels.

It may be he was asking for money for the transport there, but only OP would know if that's a realistic possibility.

On balance, it sounds like this man was probably a chancer.

People do tend to equate begging and homelessness, which is a mistake.

The majority of homeless people don't beg. A shockingly high percentage of homeless people have jobs (the fact they're not paid enough to be able to secure housing is a national scandal IMO) and most homeless people are not sleeping on the streets - they are sofa surfing or otherwise going from one place to another.

Beggars are, in the main, a different group. A few are homeless, more are trafficked by gangs, and many are addicted. The latter two groups will often resort to tall tales to extort money from others.

They are not undeserving of help but it's best not to part with money on the street.

If you feel guilty OP, I would make a donation of whatever you can afford to your local shelter / St Mungo's.

hydriotaphia · 10/01/2024 08:59

This was obviously a lie. As if St Mungo's turns homeless people away because they can't pay a tiny nominal sum that obviously can't cover a fraction of the charity's costs. It's just very clearly not true.

Wheresthebeach · 10/01/2024 08:56

Donate to a homeless charity if you want to help

Pratchettt · 10/01/2024 08:55

Beautiful3 · 10/01/2024 07:16

There's a genuine homeless man sleeping rough in our area. Lots of people give him money/drink and food. Then someone posted a picture of him at his tent, there were stacks of beers behind him, inside the tent. He said he's on the street because he's addicted to alcohol. But he's clearly still drinking. It really annoys me when I see people give him.money now, because he spends people's money on booze.

Whoever took and shared that photo is an absolute wanker.

He’s on the street because he’s addicted to alcohol, it’s crazy that it annoys you that’s he’s still drinking. If he has had zero support to stop drinking then of course he’s still drinking. Alcohol will also help numb the god awful reality of living on the street.

The judgement is hideous.

passiveaggressivenonsense · 10/01/2024 08:53

Does it matter what he uses the money for ? If he has addiction or mental health problems withholding generosity isn't going to make his life any better. Kind words and a bit of cash could.

underneaththeash · 10/01/2024 08:52

Foolosophy · 10/01/2024 08:46

St Mungo’s is a real place?? I’m shocked and would certainly not have given him anything as up until now I’ve only heard of St Mungo’s hospital for magical maladies! I would have thought he was taking the piss! Perhaps I would have given a few pounds for the (imagined) cheek of it, come to think of it.
In my defence I’m foreign and don’t live in the uk. Consider me flabbergasted and a bit more educated.

It is a homeless shelter in London

There is some info about the programme here - it's free.
https://www.mungos.org/clients/

In London, there are many people who are trafficked here to beg on the streets, they're the ones kneeling with the cardboard signs usually around Marylebone High Street or Green Park. They're abused and tightly controlled, you can often see the "facilitator" wandering around and checking on them.

I have no idea why the police don't address the issue. Please don't give them money.

Clients | St Mungo's

Clients If you are a client of St Mungo’s, please read on to find out more about the services available to you and how you can get in touch and get

https://www.mungos.org/clients

MaisyAndTallulah · 10/01/2024 08:51

I work with people experiencing homelessness. Sometimes I also give to people living rough, sometimes I don't.

My point us, do what you can when you can, and that's OK. You can't save everyone but you can contribute to making someone's day or the long goal of making a better world.

I don't care what a person spends their money on, especially a rough sleeper. Of course many will be experiencing substance use disorder and need to feed that. And who am I to judge? Homelessness is appalling for everyone experiencing it and as a reflection on us all. God knows every homeless person needs their vices to survive the hell that is their reality.

Fluffywhitecloudsinthesky · 10/01/2024 08:50

@Burlee why are you laughing? If you google St Mungo's, the very first thing is it tells you how to donate.

If it turned out this thread was a giant marking exercise, good on them, it was quite creative! I needed to donate to a shelter anyway and this prompted me to do so.

EasternEcho · 10/01/2024 08:49

In most cases I usually give if I can afford it and won't miss it. I know myself to know I won't lose sleep over it if I helped, but I would if I didn't. To me, it's a bit like the judicial "It is better that ten guilty persons escape than that one innocent suffer." As long as I can afford it, and is not a familar face I've helped before.

RaisingAnOnlyChild · 10/01/2024 08:49

There are organisations that help the homeless and if it was genuine they would have helped him. Always better to give to a charity or support organisation as they can assist the homeless person in seeking all the help they need

Foolosophy · 10/01/2024 08:46

St Mungo’s is a real place?? I’m shocked and would certainly not have given him anything as up until now I’ve only heard of St Mungo’s hospital for magical maladies! I would have thought he was taking the piss! Perhaps I would have given a few pounds for the (imagined) cheek of it, come to think of it.
In my defence I’m foreign and don’t live in the uk. Consider me flabbergasted and a bit more educated.

Burlee · 10/01/2024 08:46

Fluffywhitecloudsinthesky · 10/01/2024 08:40

Thanks, OP. I've just donated to St Mungo's. I suggest you do the same. Don't spend time trying to work out how to fix the past, it's gone! Think if there's anything you'd like to do today to change things and then do that.

😂

Knitgoodwoman · 10/01/2024 08:43

Did he mean to pay for the transport to get there? Are you £7.50s worth of transport away from St Mungo's? Otherwise I agree no homeless charity would ask for money.

Fluffywhitecloudsinthesky · 10/01/2024 08:40

Thanks, OP. I've just donated to St Mungo's. I suggest you do the same. Don't spend time trying to work out how to fix the past, it's gone! Think if there's anything you'd like to do today to change things and then do that.

teddycoat · 10/01/2024 08:38

KinS24 · 10/01/2024 08:33

Interesting that despite all the homelessness experts here agreeing that beggars shouldn’t be given cash there are still some holier than thou types who are berating anyone who doesn’t do just this.
I keep seeing this on here. People being attacked for being pragmatic and not just acting on emotion.
I don’t give to beggars. I am still a good person. So are you OP.

Yep- and all the people saying it's cold and heartless not to give- what exactly are they doing for the homeless?- my guess is absolutely nothing except berating others online and feeling superior because they once gave a homeless person a fiver in 2004.

Savoury · 10/01/2024 08:38

It’s too hard to pick out the genuine from the scammers so I don’t give now to beggars. In Mayfair there used to be a van that dropped off a number of beggars from a certain minority which collected them in the evening. They had a coffee in Pret before starting. I saw this several times with my own eyes.

I have only recently gave on the street. About 2 years ago so still during Covid, there was a guy on a bench near me with a new looking backpack who didn’t ask for a thing but petted my dog. We got talking - he was sober and seemed sad, and I bought him a hot dinner. He planned to sleep rough that night and seemed to be most likely a newly released prisoner.

HashtagShitShop · 10/01/2024 08:36

If you'd taken your purse out there's a high chance he could have grabbed for it or stolen it or more. That's also why I'm very unlikely to give someone the time if out and about and not wearing my watch as there's been a run on people asking the time then grabbing phones when people have looked at them to give the time where I live.

Sadly it's safer to take the attitude of not trusting people here and not helping given the majority of people asking either the time or for cash are young, male and quite clearly on something here.

piemania · 10/01/2024 08:36

Even if it was a 'scam' why didn't you just give it to him? You said you could afford to and would have if the story had been more believable

You've decided who and who isn't worthy of your measly £5 note, based on how good their story telling skills are or how much you believe this person is in need

He's begging on the street, he's already much more in need of everything we take for granted than you are

There by the grace of god

KinS24 · 10/01/2024 08:33

Interesting that despite all the homelessness experts here agreeing that beggars shouldn’t be given cash there are still some holier than thou types who are berating anyone who doesn’t do just this.
I keep seeing this on here. People being attacked for being pragmatic and not just acting on emotion.
I don’t give to beggars. I am still a good person. So are you OP.

laclochette · 10/01/2024 08:32

St Mungo's don't charge. He may have been referring to a bus or train fare to get to the shelter. He may have been lying. That doesn't mean he isn't also desperate and desperately miserable. That's what is so hard in these situations. People can lie and tell you fake sob stories, but also and at the same time be desperately in need.

Personally, I would make a decent donation to St Mungo's and even a regular one, if you can afford it. These feelings you're having are natural but they can only be useful if channeled.

HaggisPakora · 10/01/2024 08:32

CurlewKate · 10/01/2024 03:13

I act on the principle that if I can afford it, I give. If it's a scam, so what? If it isn't, then the person's life is a bit easier.

Because by giving, you are perpetuating the whole scamming industry. From the people who beg on the streets through to the people who call you up and say they're from Amazon, the people who post on here with a sob story, the romance scammers who target your granny. They know that there are people out there who like to virtue signal how "good" they are, and turn a blind eye to being scammed.

xILikeJamx · 10/01/2024 08:31

I worked with homeless people at a local council for a few years and he was almost certainly not telling the truth. Don't beat yourself up about it.

He has access to government services and various charities will have outreach programmes that he could take advantage of. It's all too easy to ignore people asking for spare change or "20p for the bus" etc, so he's maybe figured out that asking for quite a lot more, but not too much for most people, works out better overall.

In my area at least there's no way any homeless services would charge an individual - they get money from public sector grants. I spent many a weekend pounding the streets at night talking to rough sleepers and trying to get them to engage with services and into accommodation for the night and the majority refused (or if they did give it a try, would vanish after a few days and appear on the streets again.)

19percentineedmycharger · 10/01/2024 08:30

If I ever have cash on me I'll give it if someone asks. I don't think anyone actually would choose to live a life begging on public transport whether it be for alcohol, drugs or somewhere to sleep for the night.

Lokkii · 10/01/2024 08:29

Never give cash.

Donate to a charity instead.

I gave money once to a homeless man who had a heartbreaking story. I was a student at the time working two poorly paid, zero hour contract jobs and barely money enough for food that week but I gave him the £20 I'd got from the ATM for food shopping.

Found out later he was a scammer.

I'm a good judge of character and have a good gut instinct on these things usually, I'm quite a skeptic, but he fooled me! They're experts at lying.