Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Anger and sadness at this interaction with homeless person

361 replies

BlueCupOrangeCup · 09/01/2024 23:35

Tonight, a polite homeless man named Kevin told me he secured a spot in a 12-week program at St Mungo's after a year of homelessness. He needed £7.50 urgently to go there tonight and had been trying all day. Skeptical, I regretfully declined, later realizing he might have been genuine.

I'm replaying the whole conversation in my head and now I think I recall him almost bursting into tears as he asked if there was any way at all I could help him.

This one might have been genuine and I'm so disgusted with myself.

I could have helped. I had a £5 note in my purse....and I am fortunate enough that I wouldn't miss it or notice it gone.

And at the same time I'm also so angry at scammers of this thing. If someone stood in front of you asking begging for a small amount of money to help them and you knew it was genuine OF COURSE all of us would help! But genuine people don't get the help they need because scammers make people have attitudes like mine tonight.

There is no way to phone st Mungo's now to 'pre pay' for Kevin should he turn up tonight....meanwhile I'm going home to sleep in my warm bed and work my lovely job tomorrow.

Poor Kevin, I'm sorry I didn't help you.

OP posts:
TheIncredibleBookEatingManchot · 10/01/2024 09:57

A few people have said on this thread that they're happy for someone to buy drugs or alcohol with money they've given them.

Out of interest, if someone were to approach you and say, "Excuse me, I'm sorry to bother you, but I'm homeless and a heroin addict and I need money for my next hit." Would you still give them money or do you need the illusion that it might be for food, shelter or transport, and if so why is that, when you say you don't mind people buying drugs with money you give them?

Lifeomars · 10/01/2024 09:51

Boomboom22 · 09/01/2024 23:43

Def a scam, most are not homeless anyway. Often live in a squat or part of an organised gang.
Plus it's illegal in most cities to give money directly to beggars.

Which cities are these?

How is it enforced?
What happens to the people involved, the person who gives the money and the person who receives it?

How can individual cities make their own laws?

CarterBeatsTheDevil · 10/01/2024 09:51

I've never been abused or threatened by a homeless person - genuinely - and I think it's because I am always polite and apologetic if I'm saying no. I do sometimes give money to homeless people - mostly in my home town, where there are relatively few and they're all well-known in the community (each has some level of mental illness and has not been able to get on with accommodation, their names and histories are well known, and they are accepted and looked after pretty well for the most part although sadly they also sometimes get abuse).

I do care about how someone uses money I give them, because I don't want anyone to die with a needle in their arm that I paid for, or to die of exposure clutching a whisky bottle that I funded. When people say "I'd want a fix too if I were homeless" I understand that it's meant well but I also think there's an assumption underlying it that homeless people must have such shit lives that it doesn't matter if they end. I don't think that's true, personally.

Manyandyoucanwalkover · 10/01/2024 09:50

Brefugee · 10/01/2024 09:02

I'm reading a different thread i think? There is no "berating" going on. There are people saying what they do when confronted with this kind of thing.

But i see why there are so many threads about how horrible MNetters are, if people explaining what they do when they see a homeless person is described as "berating".

FWIW - i don't donate to homeless charities (or many charities) tbh. Mostly because i do think a lot of them spend too much on admin and not enough on the target of the charity. I do give clothes directly to a friend of one of my DC who works in a homeless shelter. They tell me now and again what they're looking for in terms of support (often it is large sized underwear for women) and i rootle round and see what i have. Or blankets. Or winter coats, scarves, hats and gloves at the moment.
We donated an old trolley-type suitcase to one chap who carried his things in 2 plastic bags but he has back problems. He's very happy with that. etc etc

Everyone should be able to decide for themselves what they do, if anything. And should we feel bad about homelessness? Sure. I do. It is one of the things i ask our local councillors about when elections are coming.

I think you’re conveniently overlooking some of the comments. Everyone should of course decide what to do but informing yourself doesn’t go amiss. @KinS24 is correct in saying that those working in that sector, say you shouldn’t give money.

On my very first day of working in that sector, as part of our induction, we had a talk about how giving money only makes the entire situation worse. It might make you feel better, that you’re helping a homeless person but the reality is the very opposite.

Burlee · 10/01/2024 09:49

Fluffywhitecloudsinthesky · 10/01/2024 08:50

@Burlee why are you laughing? If you google St Mungo's, the very first thing is it tells you how to donate.

If it turned out this thread was a giant marking exercise, good on them, it was quite creative! I needed to donate to a shelter anyway and this prompted me to do so.

Do you immediately donate to every charity you’ve just heard of? Or only when you can boast about it on here?

Getthethrowonthesofa · 10/01/2024 09:45

How far was st mungos? Was it transport costs?

on a side note I always find the “i buy food and water” thing a bit virtue signalling, I’ve sadly come across loads of homeless folks and never are they sitting there looking well fed or with a load of food. And based on the amount of folks that say it, they would be.

mumsytoon · 10/01/2024 09:43

This is what I do op. When I'm confronted in such a situation, if it's nothing to me to lose 5 pounds I would give it. Does it matter how it is spent? If it's on drugs or a home for the night, it's still 5 pounds that's gone. The difference is if you're right then you have a clear conscience, if you're wrong then you still have a clear conscience because your intentions were still good.

Nanny0gg · 10/01/2024 09:41

MayThe4th · 10/01/2024 09:19

It astounds me how many people on here are happy to endorse and support the drugs trade and everything that stands for.

Because by stating that “it doesn’t matter what they spend it on, it’s not for me to judge” that’s exactly what you’re doing. You’re supporting the people who stand at your children’s school gates enticing them into drugs.
You’re supporting the people who will lure your children or their friends into dealing.
You’re supporting human trafficking, prostitution, county lines….

No, maybe the drug dealer on the street isn’t involved in all those things, but he’s a pawn in the bigger picture.

So by standing there and saying that it doesn’t matter if someone spends your fiver on a hit (which might well be their last), you’re lining the pockets of the organisations who represent all that.

Hey but if virtue signalling that you don’t judge makes you feel better, who cares who else suffers because of it.

If I'm going to condemn anybody for that (and I'm happy to) it won't be the poor bugger who's sleeping outside in this weather. It'll be the middle-class professional who thinks a line or two rounds off a nice dinner party or needs it to 'relax' after a tricky week at the coalface centrally heated comfy office

MaisyAndTallulah · 10/01/2024 09:39

Crikey I've only read a handful of posts but the sanctimony on display is grim.

It is no-one's place to dictate who each of us choose to give our money to. Or to judge people living with addiction.

90 percent of us are just 2 disasters away from homelessness. Please try to find a little kindness and compassion for people living with the hell that is homelessness. They are people like you and me.

CherryBlossoms88 · 10/01/2024 09:38

I’ve given money to what I thought was a homeless beggar! As soon as he took my £5, his iphone started ringing and it looked like a newer version than mine! Fool me once……

however just go with your gut, you don’t owe them anything in the first place. If you want to give great and if you don’t then there is no need to feel bad about it.

Pratchettt · 10/01/2024 09:37

Isittoolatetosayhappynewyear · 10/01/2024 09:34

I once bought a lady formula milk and nappies when she approached me at a supermarket telling me she can't feed her baby (who wasn't actually there). I just couldn't have that on my conscience. I then did my shop went back to the car park and there she was asking help from others (must have given the things I bought her to someone in her group). Was a strange one as she wasn't asking for money and maybe did need those items but I felt a bit deflated and that I'd been scammed when I saw her approaching people straight after.

Don’t feel deflated. Even if it was a scam, you bought those items out of the good of your heart. You could have ignored and moved on and if she were genuine then you would have ignored a vulnerable, desperate person. Don’t let a scam make you feel bad about your good actions.

Nanny0gg · 10/01/2024 09:37

Testina · 10/01/2024 00:03

Nothing on St Mungo’s website about a charge. Various links to Thames Reach charity reminding people that night hostel access in London is free at point of access. I’m in London - I usually hear that the cash is needed to get to the hostel, as it’s a more believable tale.

Leaving aside the scammers though… or at least, scamming with a lie, but not as part of a ganging, begging for themselves for good reason.

It is hard - I look at people on the streets and think, who am I to judge if in the moment you want £7.50 towards drugs? I’d want to lose myself too. But… it really does do more harm than good, because it stops people accessing services. Or kills them.

You can easily donate to a number of charities online right now.

It was to get there, not a charge!

MayThe4th · 10/01/2024 09:35

MorningSunshineSparkles · 10/01/2024 09:20

@MayThe4th im not sure what crappy kind of area you live in but no one stands at my DC school peddling drugs Hmm

Maybe not outside, but don’t kid yourself that your kids couldn’t easily get hold of drugs if they’re secondary age.

Nanny0gg · 10/01/2024 09:35

porridgecrumble · 09/01/2024 23:44

I don't think St Mungo's charge individuals up front. Why not phone them and ask? You could make a donation to them directly.

It was to get there (allegedly)

Nanny0gg · 10/01/2024 09:34

misssunshine4040 · 09/01/2024 23:45

Enough!! She was NOT bang of order to refuse him money end of.
And yes, he was probably going to piss it up the wall and she would be enabling his lifestyle.

Some 'lifestyle'...

Isittoolatetosayhappynewyear · 10/01/2024 09:34

I once bought a lady formula milk and nappies when she approached me at a supermarket telling me she can't feed her baby (who wasn't actually there). I just couldn't have that on my conscience. I then did my shop went back to the car park and there she was asking help from others (must have given the things I bought her to someone in her group). Was a strange one as she wasn't asking for money and maybe did need those items but I felt a bit deflated and that I'd been scammed when I saw her approaching people straight after.

peppermintcrisp · 10/01/2024 09:33

I'm sure the people who think you're bang out of order don't live in an area where begging has reached the point that people can't use certain areas because the antisocial behaviour associated with begging and those who do it.

My DD used to attend a regular club in a city. I would wait outside in my car. Drug deals at 11am, deficating on the street, hostile, aggressive behaviour outside cash machines and intimidation in stairwells of carparks, violence. It is not good to enable this crime/ addiction with handing over money. I have offered to buy food and drinks and been to told to fuck off.

I have been told to fuck off bitch in a deserted stairwell of a carpark with my young DD when I declined to give over cash. I thought he was going to attack us.

Police are also going a round the area removing these people as a lot are not genuine homeless people.

I know we are told to talk and make contact but how do we know who will be aggressive towards us as a woman I feel too vulnerable to do this but will donate to homeless charities.

Brefugee · 10/01/2024 09:26

Yep it is a dilemma, i want the authorities to win the war on drugs. I know that this is a "war" nobody is going to win any time soon.

Homelessness is a hugely complex issue, which is why i prefer to donate food to the person, or clothes to my daughter's friend's place. But sometimes i will give money. I try not to beat myself up about the decisions i make.

Edited for spelling

MorningSunshineSparkles · 10/01/2024 09:20

@MayThe4th im not sure what crappy kind of area you live in but no one stands at my DC school peddling drugs Hmm

MayThe4th · 10/01/2024 09:19

It astounds me how many people on here are happy to endorse and support the drugs trade and everything that stands for.

Because by stating that “it doesn’t matter what they spend it on, it’s not for me to judge” that’s exactly what you’re doing. You’re supporting the people who stand at your children’s school gates enticing them into drugs.
You’re supporting the people who will lure your children or their friends into dealing.
You’re supporting human trafficking, prostitution, county lines….

No, maybe the drug dealer on the street isn’t involved in all those things, but he’s a pawn in the bigger picture.

So by standing there and saying that it doesn’t matter if someone spends your fiver on a hit (which might well be their last), you’re lining the pockets of the organisations who represent all that.

Hey but if virtue signalling that you don’t judge makes you feel better, who cares who else suffers because of it.

lockbox · 10/01/2024 09:17

Its really difficult, yes perhaps he needed the money for a bed, alternatively he may have used the money to buy the drugs that would kill him, or would profit human traffickers. I think most experts suggest buying food for the homeless and then donating to charities that help them. If you want to help then donate that £5 to a charity that helps local homeless people.

Avacardo2023 · 10/01/2024 09:16

If anyone is still in any doubt that this is a scam, ask yourself how "Kevin" found out that he had won this coveted place on the life changing (fictitious) scheme? Did St Mungo's phone him? In which case why didn't he say thanks so much but I don't have the means to get there, what shall I do? And they would send a volunteer to collect him. Or he could use his phone to work out how to get there (walking to somewhere with free WiFi).

Did they write to him? In which case he's not strictly homeless and does have access to an address and certain services.

I'm not saying everyone is a scammer but this is a well known scam, and the people commenting about kindness obviously haven't been regularly exposed to it.

hydriotaphia · 10/01/2024 09:11

Also the specific sum, the time pressure and high stakes (needing exactly £7.50, RIGHT NOW, otherwise I will lose a place at a 12 week programme after 1 year of homelessness) are all classic marks of a scam aimed at putting psychological pressure on someone. It's a similar thing with online scams. I've been on the receiving end of a scam whereby I received an email apparently from a friend (in reality from a scammer who hacked her email) saying they she needed a specific sum of money in her venmo because she was stuck at x and had her bag stolen and needed to get a taxi to her airport otherwise she was going to miss her flight back home and be struck in a foreign land.... The time pressure/high stakes/very specific request are a classic tactic.

Kevin may well genuinely have been going through a lot, but he wasn't being honest.

Dotjones · 10/01/2024 09:10

You should never give money to homeless people directly, it just encourages scammers and professional beggars. The money you give doesn't even go to the person themselves to spend on drink or drugs in many cases, it goes to fund terrorism and organised crime.

If you want to help people who are genuinely homeless then give money to charities and organisations that are set up specifically to help them.

I think I've mentioned this before but my council used to run an ad campaign in the centre of town with the message "spare change doesn't make change" - giving a few quid to individuals just leads to more begging and more homelessness.

Silverfoxette · 10/01/2024 09:09

I went in to a church the other day and a lady approached me to ask if i knew of any food banks in the town. Unfortunately im not from that area so wasn’t able to help. She told me she was homeless but didn’t want any money, just to know if there was somewhere she might get a bite as her social welfare hadn’t come through the day before. I tried to give her a fiver, she refused to take it.

she said she had been offered a job and accommodation but didn’t know how she would pay it as she had not received her payment. She would not accept a penny from me but asked me to pray for her.

on my way out I met a local anc asked them to advise her where to go for a meal.

they’re not all fake!

Swipe left for the next trending thread