Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Anger and sadness at this interaction with homeless person

361 replies

BlueCupOrangeCup · 09/01/2024 23:35

Tonight, a polite homeless man named Kevin told me he secured a spot in a 12-week program at St Mungo's after a year of homelessness. He needed £7.50 urgently to go there tonight and had been trying all day. Skeptical, I regretfully declined, later realizing he might have been genuine.

I'm replaying the whole conversation in my head and now I think I recall him almost bursting into tears as he asked if there was any way at all I could help him.

This one might have been genuine and I'm so disgusted with myself.

I could have helped. I had a £5 note in my purse....and I am fortunate enough that I wouldn't miss it or notice it gone.

And at the same time I'm also so angry at scammers of this thing. If someone stood in front of you asking begging for a small amount of money to help them and you knew it was genuine OF COURSE all of us would help! But genuine people don't get the help they need because scammers make people have attitudes like mine tonight.

There is no way to phone st Mungo's now to 'pre pay' for Kevin should he turn up tonight....meanwhile I'm going home to sleep in my warm bed and work my lovely job tomorrow.

Poor Kevin, I'm sorry I didn't help you.

OP posts:
Justfacts · 12/01/2024 10:15

I always give out and no I’m no schmuck either. Their lives are crap one way or another. So what if they use it for other purposes. Human trafficking involves a lot more than begging on the street. If they are? Maybe they need to amass the money to escape. If you can, always give.

Darlingx · 12/01/2024 10:04

There is a girl I have seen at various affluent locations with glasses on in her sleeping bag . She accepts hot drinks food but on one occasion she didn’t and said she was not well and I looked further on under a shop front watching us was a man with a nasty presence so now I know she is enslaved to bringing money in to line his pockets and that he wants is cash coming in not her well being. I then would see well meaning people giving her money without knowing its being funnelled to that man but there is nothing I can prove but its like lifting a curtain as he saw me notice him and he knew I knew. I have seen a similar scenario a man watching with another young girl who was once sat on cardboard in the pouring rain crying out to everyone saying I am so cold. Crying in the pouring rain . It’s literally human misery to envoke hard cash and its not going into the hands of the victim for the longterm. Its also just a lot of the money funding cycles of drug addiction I can’t afford to fund drug dealers for personal use or strangers and I don’t want my money in their hands to continue human misery. I have had some heartbreaking exchanges because I will chat offer to buy food and its something I am very aware could happen to me. I can’t really afford to donate much but I think of all the hobbies we spend money on and apparently we could end homelessness if this became our priority

Brutalass · 12/01/2024 09:27

If it makes you feel better there was a homeless man that used to sit by the parking machine at the hospital where I regularly had to go with my son. I felt so sorry for him. People regularly gave him their change, but I never feel quite right giving homeless money.

The next time I was there, I took him a lightweight rucksack with some essentials inside; tissues, deodorant, thick socks, a long sleeved T-shirt, healthy snacks, a bottle of water, toothbrush and toothpaste, wet wipes, lip balm, plasters, a note book, a pen and other bits and pieces that I thought would be more useful. He took it off me, didn't say 'Thank you' he rummaged through the bag and then threw it back at me and said 'I don't want this shit - I want money!' I was absolutely gobsmacked. I actually went into the hospital with tears in my eyes. I actually couldn't believe it.

Another time, I saw a young woman and a dog sat on a street corner whilst I was waiting in my car for a friend, and I had been doing some PR for Soreen and I had a branded linen shopping bag and about 20 small individual bars of Soreen leftover, as well as some of my own dogs treats in the car and some poop bags, so I put them all in the shopping bag and dashed over the road. I asked the woman if I could stroke her dog - and she said 'Yes' with a smile. I then asked her if she could make use of the bag and the goods inside and she was incredibly grateful. Clearly she was really genuine. I could see her afterwards from my car hugging her dog and smiling as if all her Christmases had come at once!

Please don't beat yourself up. I find it incredibly odd that such a scheme would ask a homeless person for money upfront! Most of these provisions are charity led.

IncognitoIsMyFavouriteWord · 12/01/2024 09:19

Captnip500 · 11/01/2024 20:37

But it’s not just £7.50 is it? He may have been begging for hours and made much more in total. Some DO make £100s a day to support major addictions. You are NOT helping homeless people who are begging in the street by giving them money, you are enabling their addiction. By all means but them food, pay for a hotel for the night if you can afford it, offer them advise and kindness but don’t kid yourself into thinking that giving them spare change is helping. I can see why people do it and that it usually comes from a place of kindness but it’s not helping.

Do you know that some people need to feed their addiction or they are in more danger of medical risk?

Your comment shows you don't.

The ignorance and lack of education on this post explains why we've had tories for 13 years.

OldPerson · 12/01/2024 02:16

During his year of homelessness, he could have walked to St Mungo's. He certainly could have walked there in the "all day" he was scrounging the £7.50. How far do you think £7:50 on a bus, train or in a taxi could have taken him? Or think again - he wasn't notified that morning he had a 12-week programme? From whom? How? By letter to which address? Or by phone? And to which company, is he paying the phone bill? Seriously? All organisations think through the logistics of how Person A can get to Help B. They honestly do. They don't assume some misguided well-intentioned person will hand out cash to fund their journey. They give them a travel voucher.

Captnip500 · 12/01/2024 00:34

MissersMercer · 11/01/2024 23:13

St Mungos do not charge so he was telling fibs. You were right to walk away op.

Why are people repeating this over and over again on this thread? It’s not the case. Not at St Mungos and not any of the other numerous homeless shelters have worked at. This thread is really opening my eyes to the how many posters on mumsnet simply repeat opinions of others upthread as fact.

Captnip500 · 12/01/2024 00:30

MissersMercer · 11/01/2024 23:13

St Mungos do not charge so he was telling fibs. You were right to walk away op.

They do charge their residents rent, I used to work there. Most hostels do as the point of them is to move people on to permanent house, where you would have to pay rent and bills, so it’s good practice for them to budget for this. They don’t charge people £7.50 on entry and don’t run these mysterious ‘12 week programs’. What would be the point in Housing someone for only 12 weeks?

DisabledDemon · 11/01/2024 23:33

Years ago, I was approached by a young woman at Waterloo Station. She said she was pregnant (didn't look it) and was trying to get some money to get into a shelter for the night. I didn't have any change so she walked off.

So, the train doesn't turn up and I'm still standing on the concourse half an hour later when she comes back to tell me that she's just had a baby and needs money for its care. The chap standing next to me immediately said, 'Well, you've had it pretty damned quickly - you were pregnant half an hour ago!'

You've never seen someone leave so quickly.

MissersMercer · 11/01/2024 23:13

St Mungos do not charge so he was telling fibs. You were right to walk away op.

pineapplecrushed · 11/01/2024 22:26

t's a lie. St Mungo's do not require £7.50.

janbaby2 · 11/01/2024 22:16

Rp735 · 11/01/2024 22:01

Sorry, he was lying. How do I know? Been in the exact situation few times and seen the person do it another person right after me. Feel so stupid but then proceed to make the mistake again.

Well you don't know do you? Just because a similar thing happened to you with a totally different person in a different place, it doesn't mean this particular person wasn't genuine.

Nobody on this post can know for certain if he was genuine or not op. You made a decision, no point dwelling on it now.

thatsjustthewayitisok · 11/01/2024 22:09

I had a similar situation quite a few years ago with a youngish woman sitting under a bridge that leads from Brighton station to the North Laines crying her eyes out because she was desperate to get a train home to see her mother before she died.

We were both about the same age (early 20s) and I really felt for her and said, don't worry come with me to the station and I will buy your ticket for you right now.

Which she really, adamantly did not want to do, but really was very keen to have the cash instead.

Ultimately it's you're money and if something doesn't sit right then it's up to you what you do with it.

I can't see how a 12 week programme would cost £7.50 , either

Lifeomars · 11/01/2024 22:02

Universalsnail · 11/01/2024 20:38

Both alcohol and benzodiazepines can cause death if abruptly stopped which is what I was referring to.

As for Opioids. No you can't die from opioid withdrawal but opioid sickness is horrendous and forcing someone to withdraw from opioids when they are not willing and ready to is cruel and completely useless

If you read what I said I did specify that abruptly ceasing to drink can be very dangerous. I also said that heroin withdrawal is horrible, it is trying to avoid rattling that drives people to keep using and scoring, the initial buzz/euphoria will just be a distant memory. I have never worked in a service that has advocated forcing people to withdraw, it was always managed by the use of substitute medication. Nobody I have ever worked with used benzos on anything other than an occasional basis, so knowledge about risky dependence within the context of street drug use is outside my sphere of experience. The people I supported would buy them if they were around, but the central focus was heroin and crack. They would combine the two and inject them, I have seen some horrible absecces and wounds from this practice as the crack numbs the injection site so people just keep digging away. I am aware that people who have long term prescriptions for benzos(which really should not be happening) should have clinical supervision to reduce and eventually stop taking them.

Rp735 · 11/01/2024 22:01

Sorry, he was lying. How do I know? Been in the exact situation few times and seen the person do it another person right after me. Feel so stupid but then proceed to make the mistake again.

Jumpingpogosticks · 11/01/2024 21:34

icelolly12 · 11/01/2024 19:09

@falafelover Some of these people seem to see a fix as a nice little treat, as if it was a cupcake or something.

😂Yes I am also quite surprised that some posters are basically telling others that they need to get off their high horse as so what if they use the fiver you donated for bus fare to injecting drugs into themselves to cheer them up. Hmm let's see how you feel if that happens on your doorstep/shoots up in front of your children then. Got a feeling a lot of such posters have never had any interaction with any drug users and don't realise just how manipulative addicts can be.

I agree. I live in an area with a high homeless and high addiction rates.
Our town is a shit hole because of the antisocial behaviour that goes hand in hand with begging and drug use.
Can't use a cash machine or a parking machine in the town without being asked for money. One afternoon I was told by a nice chap that I was lucky he even asked, as he could have just taken my purse.
There are needles everywhere. One of the local parks was shut by the council there were so many needles in the sand.
Oh and let's not forget the unfortunate incidents of when they overdose and they're found by members of the public..

Let's not even get into the people who get harassed for their medication outside the pharmacies, or the front doors being tried by addicts in the night, or the cars being broken into. I'm not a car person, so I'm not sure how they managed it, but one of my neighbours had their car battery taken by two of the local beggars. They forwarded on the ring footage of two of them carrying away said battery.

No it's not a nice life, and they do deserve help, but it isn't fair on the rest of the community to have to put up with begging and associated behaviour.

PonyPatter44 · 11/01/2024 20:45

£7.50 is quite a smart amount to ask for. More than a fiver, but if you're kind enough to give a tenner, you're not going to stand there and ask for the change, are you?!

Universalsnail · 11/01/2024 20:38

Lifeomars · 11/01/2024 19:06

Former drugs worker here, no someone will not die if they cannot get hold of their drug of choice, they might , as in the case of heroin withdrawal, feel like they want to die but they will not die without a hit.They will feel awful and do all they can to raise and score but they will not die specifically from not having their drug of choice. The lifestyle is risky too, blood bourne viruses, poor nutrition, not accessing healthcare for other physical problems, all these things have an adverse effects on a person's health Alcohol is different, if someone is drinking very heavily suddenly stopping can be really dangerous.

Both alcohol and benzodiazepines can cause death if abruptly stopped which is what I was referring to.

As for Opioids. No you can't die from opioid withdrawal but opioid sickness is horrendous and forcing someone to withdraw from opioids when they are not willing and ready to is cruel and completely useless

Captnip500 · 11/01/2024 20:37

IncognitoIsMyFavouriteWord · 11/01/2024 20:27

But if they do want to buy drugs (god knows what for 7.50) or alcohol, then they wouldn't say, would they, because of the refusal and the judgment?

I understand homelessness and the issues surrounding it very well.

But it’s not just £7.50 is it? He may have been begging for hours and made much more in total. Some DO make £100s a day to support major addictions. You are NOT helping homeless people who are begging in the street by giving them money, you are enabling their addiction. By all means but them food, pay for a hotel for the night if you can afford it, offer them advise and kindness but don’t kid yourself into thinking that giving them spare change is helping. I can see why people do it and that it usually comes from a place of kindness but it’s not helping.

IncognitoIsMyFavouriteWord · 11/01/2024 20:27

ShoePalaver · 11/01/2024 20:21

It's a scam because they are lying about what they want money for. If they asked for 7.50 without specifying a reason it wouldn't be a scam, regardless of their situation. Although it would still be illegal.

And the reason not to give to them is it's unlikely to help and will probably make things worse and if you genuinely care about homeless people there are ways to actually help.

This is not the same as ignoring those with addiction issues!

But if they do want to buy drugs (god knows what for 7.50) or alcohol, then they wouldn't say, would they, because of the refusal and the judgment?

I understand homelessness and the issues surrounding it very well.

ShoePalaver · 11/01/2024 20:21

IncognitoIsMyFavouriteWord · 11/01/2024 20:13

If you wouldn't miss it, why not give it to him anyway?

Would he spend it on his addiction?
Possibly, addiction is a mental illness and can contribute to homelessness.
Does this mean we ignore all those who have addiction issues because they're not worthy of our help?

Why is a homeless person asking for 7.50 a scam? (I'm aiming this at other posters, not just you, OP)

If someone is on the street asking for 7.50, do you automatically think they're lying? Oh, some people are working, and then they beg on the streets to scam people out of money. Do they? I work full time, and 1) I don't have time to stand on the streets and try and scam people for money. 2) there is a massive cost of living crisis. Parents who work full-time have to reach out to clothing banks and food banks to clothe and feed their children.

If you wouldn't miss it, why not give it? No questions asked.

It's a scam because they are lying about what they want money for. If they asked for 7.50 without specifying a reason it wouldn't be a scam, regardless of their situation. Although it would still be illegal.

And the reason not to give to them is it's unlikely to help and will probably make things worse and if you genuinely care about homeless people there are ways to actually help.

This is not the same as ignoring those with addiction issues!

ShoePalaver · 11/01/2024 20:15

When I was in student halls in Liverpool there used to be a middle aged man begging outside most days and he would always show this big ulcer on his leg and say he needed money to get to hospital. We were about 3 blocks from the Royal but he always said he needed to go to Broadgreen which is further away. Anyway one of my flatmates had a visitor from the US, very generous and chatty. He got talking to the man and next thing we knew he was putting him in a taxi and accompanying him to the hospital. The man wasn't seen for a few months but when he did come back his leg had been amputated. He carried on begging as before.

It was over 20 years ago when things were much easier benefits wise and you never really saw that many homeless in Liverpool in those days, so I'm sure he would have been offered housing and benefits after his operation or maybe he already had them before. He was a fixture and lots of people knew him locally. Begging and homelessness is a serious problem in Liverpool now, even in suburban areas. It really ramped up after austerity. I remember being shocked to see disabled people begging as previously it would only have been able bodied. At least we aren't at the point of having young children begging on the street as I have witnessed in Belgium.

IncognitoIsMyFavouriteWord · 11/01/2024 20:13

BlueCupOrangeCup · 09/01/2024 23:35

Tonight, a polite homeless man named Kevin told me he secured a spot in a 12-week program at St Mungo's after a year of homelessness. He needed £7.50 urgently to go there tonight and had been trying all day. Skeptical, I regretfully declined, later realizing he might have been genuine.

I'm replaying the whole conversation in my head and now I think I recall him almost bursting into tears as he asked if there was any way at all I could help him.

This one might have been genuine and I'm so disgusted with myself.

I could have helped. I had a £5 note in my purse....and I am fortunate enough that I wouldn't miss it or notice it gone.

And at the same time I'm also so angry at scammers of this thing. If someone stood in front of you asking begging for a small amount of money to help them and you knew it was genuine OF COURSE all of us would help! But genuine people don't get the help they need because scammers make people have attitudes like mine tonight.

There is no way to phone st Mungo's now to 'pre pay' for Kevin should he turn up tonight....meanwhile I'm going home to sleep in my warm bed and work my lovely job tomorrow.

Poor Kevin, I'm sorry I didn't help you.

If you wouldn't miss it, why not give it to him anyway?

Would he spend it on his addiction?
Possibly, addiction is a mental illness and can contribute to homelessness.
Does this mean we ignore all those who have addiction issues because they're not worthy of our help?

Why is a homeless person asking for 7.50 a scam? (I'm aiming this at other posters, not just you, OP)

If someone is on the street asking for 7.50, do you automatically think they're lying? Oh, some people are working, and then they beg on the streets to scam people out of money. Do they? I work full time, and 1) I don't have time to stand on the streets and try and scam people for money. 2) there is a massive cost of living crisis. Parents who work full-time have to reach out to clothing banks and food banks to clothe and feed their children.

If you wouldn't miss it, why not give it? No questions asked.

ShoePalaver · 11/01/2024 19:49

dontgobaconmyheart · 10/01/2024 01:18

Well he's not going to see this, is he. Unfortunately you're just going to have to accept how you feel and act differently next time if you feel you did wrong.

I don't consider it my business what a homeless person does with the money I give them and certainly am not placed to be their moral guardian. I only hope they do something with it that provides them anything, of any benefit.

There's nothing stopping anyone from giving a small amount and then going home to donate more to the organisations that are trying to solve the issues more permanently if they feel at all strongly about it.

The narrative that anyone made homeless cannot be trusted is incredibly distasteful diversion IMO and a dated excuse for the fact people want nothing do with them.

It's not that a homeless person can't be trusted, it's that giving cash on the street is not necessarily helpful as it often causes someone struggling with addiction to get worse. If you genuinely care about homeless people then give money to organisations that know what they are doing, and or provide practical or social help - talk to them, offer to wash their clothes, ask if you can give them food, drink, clothing etc. Also obviously never vote Tory. Giving cash to beggars and voting Tory has to be the ultimate in virtue signalling hypocrisy

Boomboom22 · 11/01/2024 19:35

People just refuse to accept the words of those who know and work in this area.
Housing is available. But many refuse / are unable to meet the conditions. These are very basic and not onerous conditions.
Therefore far greater help os required than just getting them somewhere to live and on benefits, because they are homeless for a reason. Addiction, severe sen, not being able to meet societies norms.
There is a lot of help but it's not great, hotels, bedsits, many of the counted figures live with family / friends so the ones you see on the streets are disproportionately the ones who don't meet the council conditions or the hostel requirements, eg being sober when you arrive.

Natles22 · 11/01/2024 19:33

I'd rather people just be honest and say they need money. Preferably not an amount. But honestly at the end of the day, people aren't homeless bc they want to be. Whatever reasons might play into their life. We know that a meal, a warm drink, a smoke or a few dollars won't break most of us . At the same time, when someone tells me their house got burnt down and 2 months later the same guy tells me the same thing ( different place) I called him out. I told him just tell the truth and gave him a few bucks.

Most places will not charge esp that amount. It's either covered through a government or charity program. Don't beat yourself up.