Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Anger and sadness at this interaction with homeless person

361 replies

BlueCupOrangeCup · 09/01/2024 23:35

Tonight, a polite homeless man named Kevin told me he secured a spot in a 12-week program at St Mungo's after a year of homelessness. He needed £7.50 urgently to go there tonight and had been trying all day. Skeptical, I regretfully declined, later realizing he might have been genuine.

I'm replaying the whole conversation in my head and now I think I recall him almost bursting into tears as he asked if there was any way at all I could help him.

This one might have been genuine and I'm so disgusted with myself.

I could have helped. I had a £5 note in my purse....and I am fortunate enough that I wouldn't miss it or notice it gone.

And at the same time I'm also so angry at scammers of this thing. If someone stood in front of you asking begging for a small amount of money to help them and you knew it was genuine OF COURSE all of us would help! But genuine people don't get the help they need because scammers make people have attitudes like mine tonight.

There is no way to phone st Mungo's now to 'pre pay' for Kevin should he turn up tonight....meanwhile I'm going home to sleep in my warm bed and work my lovely job tomorrow.

Poor Kevin, I'm sorry I didn't help you.

OP posts:
NigelHarmansNewWife · 10/01/2024 04:15

Flufferblub · 10/01/2024 02:26

You're better off giving to homeless charities

Yes - charities help those in genuine need. Otherwise you're either funding someone's next fix and/or organised crime in some way.

Manyandyoucanwalkover · 10/01/2024 04:14

You should never give money to beggars. I’ve worked for the homeless and part of our role was educating the public about not giving the homeless money. It doesn’t help, not one bit.

ek20 · 10/01/2024 03:17

Yes totally agree, although I do remember being told some sob story for a bus ticket and actually pulling out a bus ticket for him (our city sells them in multi-packs). Saw him 2 minutes later trying to sell the bus ticket onto somebody else, which has made me wary of doing even that sadly.

CurlewKate · 10/01/2024 03:13

I act on the principle that if I can afford it, I give. If it's a scam, so what? If it isn't, then the person's life is a bit easier.

YankSplaining · 10/01/2024 03:02

I never give money to people begging for it on the street. They tend to ask women specifically because they think we’re an easy target - basically, they’re banking on the fact that a lot of women have a hard time saying no or disappointing people.

When I was in school, there was a man who always stood by a nearby street with a sign reading WILL WORK FOR FOOD. Some of the older girls I knew went shopping one day and bought him a whole big box filled with non-perishable food. When they tried to give it to him, he stared at them for a few seconds and then just ignored them.

Latewinter · 10/01/2024 02:50

How about we stop this abhorrent government enabling the destruction of the last vestiges of compassion for those who most need it?

Great idea, all for it. How?
I didn't vote for them, did you?
It's really not that simple. If it was they wouldn't have been flushing our country down the toilet for the last decade plus.
But enjoy your simplistic outrage if it helps you.

Latewinter · 10/01/2024 02:47

I'm not morally offended about being lied to to get money for drugs or booze and think it's fair enough to take a chance and give, but OP was not "bang out of order" for not giving the money. She doesn't have to.

Anonychangling · 10/01/2024 02:38

Whilst I understand that it feel patronising & dehumanising to not allow adults the choice of how to spend their money the reality is that £20 would have been enough to kill my friend at that particular time. He became seriously unwell less than 24 hours after being picked up and imo there is a good chance he would not have made it into hospital from the streets. A bottle of spirits would have been enough to prevent him engaging with the rough sleepers team.

Addiction is very complex obviously but I just cannot and will not fund drugs or alcohol directly because ime it’s access to money which immediately keeps people in extremely vulnerable places.

Scrumbleton · 10/01/2024 02:36

For that reason i make a £10 monthly donation to the Glasshouse homeless charity near me in London. I passed a guy so many times I was sure was a scammer but couldn't live with the possibility he wasn't - so I've done a direct contribution for the past 5 years

DC1888 · 10/01/2024 02:29

therealcookiemonster · 10/01/2024 01:52

it's a sad experience to have OP. I can understand why you feel terrible. every time I say no to someone like this, I feel awful. I have several strategies

  1. I offer to buy them food
  2. if they wanted a bus ticket or something, I buy it for them
  3. sometimes I just give them money even if I suspect they will buy drugs with it because 20 quids worth of drugs or whatever is not going to harm them but if they actually would stay in a hostel for the night etc. them that would help them

Very wise with 1 and 2. Never give money though as it's likely to be used for drink/drugs which is often why they are in the state they are in. Offer to buy a ticket (in this case) and they will likely decline as they are after only one thing; if they accept the offer then obviously they are genuine.

More generally though you can't go wrong with giving sandwiches and tea/coffee, as well as some words of encouragement.

Flufferblub · 10/01/2024 02:26

You're better off giving to homeless charities

thinslicedham · 10/01/2024 02:15

Sorry, but I also think it's a scam. As for it not being my business how they spend the money, I disagree. I'm not interested in paying for someone's fix, no matter how much they may want it or how hard life is for them at the moment. I'm simply not going to give cash, so I don't engage. If you want to do something to help, donating to a charity seems like a better way. Otherwise, let it go.

Sunshineandrainbows23 · 10/01/2024 02:12

Treeper22 · 10/01/2024 00:47

I'm sorry, but what services?

Honestly, do people have any idea of the often complex psychological problems of those that end up on the street/in addiction/both? People on mumsnet seem to think you should stop 'enabling' so these people can finally take 'responsibility' to stop drugs/drink and once that's out of the way, rock up to a GP and ask for some intensive and ongoing psychosocial intervention that will help the individual unpick a lifetime of, quite often, severe trauma. None of this exists.

The poor, the traumatised, the marginalised, the mentally ill and drug addicts are left to rot under this government as they have slashed and slashed any meaningful intervention. And apparantly it's the most vulnerable that we should stop 'enabling'? How about we stop this abhorrent government enabling the destruction of the last vestiges of compassion for those who most need it?

This.

Anonychangling · 10/01/2024 01:55

And when I say I saw where he slept that’s because I collected him. It will honestly haunt me always. I can’t tell you how bad it was. He was very vulnerable at that time & didn’t need money for alcohol - it was very close to killing him. But it was the rough sleepers team who directly got him out of that situation.

Whether someone is scamming or vulnerable the money is better off going to those doing direct work. Although buying food is a good alternative if you want to do something more direct.

therealcookiemonster · 10/01/2024 01:52

it's a sad experience to have OP. I can understand why you feel terrible. every time I say no to someone like this, I feel awful. I have several strategies

  1. I offer to buy them food
  2. if they wanted a bus ticket or something, I buy it for them
  3. sometimes I just give them money even if I suspect they will buy drugs with it because 20 quids worth of drugs or whatever is not going to harm them but if they actually would stay in a hostel for the night etc. them that would help them
Finbrek · 10/01/2024 01:49

@Anonychangling exactly. Money doesn't help addiction. Money makes it worse. Addicts asking for money didn't start out that way. They had their own money to begin with and the addiction burned through that, through money their friends and families had whether given or stolen, through every bit of cash they could get their hands on and any money coming to them from other people while in active addiction heads the same way. It's a bottomless pit and bottomless pits stay deep whatever you chuck in them.

Anonychangling · 10/01/2024 01:42

It’s a scam and would likely have been used for drink or drugs. And I say that as someone who shares a house with someone who was at times a rough sleeper. He could only think about alcohol when on the streets. He didn’t have some pad to crash in or work as part of a gang - his situation was desperate. I saw where he slept and it was bloody awful. I’m not saying any of this judgementally - I love him dearly - but having access to alcohol kept him on the streets & nearly killed him & I won’t fund that for anyone.

I often donate money to the local charity that funds the rough sleepers team in our city. They do a good job, work closely with addiction services & are of course underfunded. Give the £7.50 to a charity working with rough sleepers.

FuckinghellthatsUnbelievable · 10/01/2024 01:40

CrashyTime · 10/01/2024 01:38

Guy asked me for a cigarette in Birmingham recently, smoking area at New St. station, I said no because he looked like a professional "I need something from you" type, but lied that I didn`t have enough cigarettes, should I feel bad?

Price of cigarettes now it’s like asking someone for a quid just about. I don’t smoke anymore but I can’t imagine people freely share cigarettes anymore.

CrashyTime · 10/01/2024 01:38

Karwomannghia · 09/01/2024 23:42

He was lying.

Guy asked me for a cigarette in Birmingham recently, smoking area at New St. station, I said no because he looked like a professional "I need something from you" type, but lied that I didn`t have enough cigarettes, should I feel bad?

FuckinghellthatsUnbelievable · 10/01/2024 01:38

XenoBitch · 09/01/2024 23:51

Same here. You get to recognise the same faces and same tales.

There is a chap where I live who does the same. Young teens give him money for "food". He spends it in the bookies.

Haha I recognise this I was stopped by a woman with a plausible story about losing her cards/ wallet just needed to get home. I gave but then she stopped me again a week later same story. After that I saw her regularly. Lots of people do this it’s not an uncommon way to earn money to feed a habit.

Finbrek · 10/01/2024 01:36

He wasn't telling you the truth OP. St Mungo's doesn't charge people. So you haven't prevented him from getting into a programme.

What you do with your money is up to you. If you want to give it to anyone you can.

One thing to maybe bear in mind though is that for a person struggling with addiction, their struggle is made worse by being enabled to fund the addiction. I do understand the "what's the harm in giving cash that might go towards a quick fix while having a horrendous time" argument. But the harm comes from every quick fix that holds a person within the mire.

There are organisations and agencies that work with rough sleepers and addicts. They don't have the resources they need but they know what they're doing. Giving that £7.50 to people who know what they're doing, even if they can't reach everyone, will potentially help Kevin and will definitely help someone in the long run. Giving Kevin £7.50 would just have made it more difficult for him to win his fight.

Klcak · 10/01/2024 01:35

Changedasouting · 09/01/2024 23:38

Yet you were bang out of order. It’s £7,5 you wouldn’t miss it why wouldn’t you help. Even if he was gonna piss it up a wall his life isn’t good he might need the outlet

His life might be great if he makes a living begging and doesn’t need to pay tax and claims benefits on top.

or he might be a gang victim.

Klcak · 10/01/2024 01:34

dontgobaconmyheart · 10/01/2024 01:18

Well he's not going to see this, is he. Unfortunately you're just going to have to accept how you feel and act differently next time if you feel you did wrong.

I don't consider it my business what a homeless person does with the money I give them and certainly am not placed to be their moral guardian. I only hope they do something with it that provides them anything, of any benefit.

There's nothing stopping anyone from giving a small amount and then going home to donate more to the organisations that are trying to solve the issues more permanently if they feel at all strongly about it.

The narrative that anyone made homeless cannot be trusted is incredibly distasteful diversion IMO and a dated excuse for the fact people want nothing do with them.

the point is that the homeless person likely not to actually be homeless

MrsSunshine2b · 10/01/2024 01:34

Homeless shelters never charge for entry. I'm sure Kevin was a lovely guy fallen on hard times but he was spinning you a yarn.

ConsuelaHammock · 10/01/2024 01:33

Don’t feel bad. He’s most probably lying.