Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Anger and sadness at this interaction with homeless person

361 replies

BlueCupOrangeCup · 09/01/2024 23:35

Tonight, a polite homeless man named Kevin told me he secured a spot in a 12-week program at St Mungo's after a year of homelessness. He needed £7.50 urgently to go there tonight and had been trying all day. Skeptical, I regretfully declined, later realizing he might have been genuine.

I'm replaying the whole conversation in my head and now I think I recall him almost bursting into tears as he asked if there was any way at all I could help him.

This one might have been genuine and I'm so disgusted with myself.

I could have helped. I had a £5 note in my purse....and I am fortunate enough that I wouldn't miss it or notice it gone.

And at the same time I'm also so angry at scammers of this thing. If someone stood in front of you asking begging for a small amount of money to help them and you knew it was genuine OF COURSE all of us would help! But genuine people don't get the help they need because scammers make people have attitudes like mine tonight.

There is no way to phone st Mungo's now to 'pre pay' for Kevin should he turn up tonight....meanwhile I'm going home to sleep in my warm bed and work my lovely job tomorrow.

Poor Kevin, I'm sorry I didn't help you.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
RubySlippersTakeMeHomeAgain · 14/01/2024 14:06

@SurelySmartie
Local authorities have a duty to find accommodation for homeless people including those presenting in an emergency.

No they don't.
They have a duty to assist people in finding accommodation. They don't actually have to conjure any up. They might just point you in the direction of private rentals and access to deposit schemes.

Those deemed to be in priority need (eg. with dependent children, disabled) are the only ones who are actually provided with any kind of emergency accommodation.

In many areas there is more provision but it is not a statutory duty.

NotQuiteNorma · 14/01/2024 13:05

Catsbreakfast · 12/01/2024 23:38

Yeah the person living on the streets is running a racket to defraud you. 🙄 even if he’s using the money for drugs or booze, he’s still on the streets and you’re going home to a warm bed. If you’re not happy to accept that, don’t give money, but a little empathy for their situation goes a long way. If I had to sleep in those conditions, I probably would also try forget as much about it as I could.

How do you know he's on the streets?

PinkCyclamen · 14/01/2024 13:03

Neighbour's son who was a heroin addict suddenly appeared on my FB timeline in a post that had gone viral claiming very similar story to the guy OP tried to help. A well meaning young adult had got talking to him in our nearest big city and he had sold her a cock and bull story about needing £25 to be allowed to stay in a shelter. Full of outrage at the system she set up a go fund me for him. He wasn't homeless but tucked up in bed two doors down from my house. The idiot had allowed her to take a photo which she then plastered all over FB, so it was stopped pretty quickly. The guy needed help but was an addict and a liar. The good news is he finally got the help he and his family desperately needed (after a spell in prison for domestic violence unfortunately) and he has been clean for over 5 years and is working.

NotQuiteNorma · 14/01/2024 12:52

Unfortunately do gooders are a huge part of the problem. I once intervened as an old lady was just about to give a well known addict money and explained to her that he wasn't homeless. She was really rude to me and said 'So what! It doesn't hurt to be nice!' . After that little outburst I didn't bother trying to explain to her that paying for an addict's heroin isn't being 'nice', it's fuelling street crime and killing people. It's almost like some people want to be conned sometimes. The local police told me that even when they try to move obvious addicts on to prevent begging members of the public start interfering and telling them to leave them alone. Like I said unfortunately do gooders are a large part of the problem.

Anonychangling · 14/01/2024 12:21

KickHimInTheCrotch · 14/01/2024 08:28

This is accurate - I've worked with homeless and addicted people for 20 years and can confirm that emergency/hostel housing is generally available for people who want the support and can put the effort in.

I'm not placing blame - the people who aren't able to access this support are often extremely damaged individuals. But it is out there.

Yes this is the case. The reason I pulled a friend off the streets & took him home with me was because he was unable to stop drinking so could not access accommodation. Actually there also wasn’t any - but there would have been in a reasonably short time had he been able to engage. He was also too intoxicated to engage with the services that ran during the day.

It’s all very complex but I do feel that giving money to an addict is rarely helpful.

dressedforcomfort · 14/01/2024 09:06

Years back I used to volunteer at a homeless shelter. It was free at the point of access and residents claimed housing benefit for their stay.

I think he was leading you on. But if you feel bad make a donation to St Mungos via their website.

itsmyp4rty · 14/01/2024 09:01

OP instead of feeling bad which doesn't help anyone why don't you make a small donation to St Mungo's?

Of course he wasn't telling the truth, it would make no sense for a homeless charity to put up silly barriers like that to helping people. Can you really imagine a charity saying - you can come here for 12 weeks completely for free, all food and accommodation paid for - but first you have to beg to get yourself £7.50 so you can get here/as an admin charge. I bet if you'd offered him a lift there to make sure he got his place that he'd have turned it down! If he appeared upset it was either to try to emotionally manipulate you into giving him money or because he didn't have enough for the drugs he desperately needed to stop the withdrawals.

You would always be 100% better off making a donation to a charity then giving to an individual.

KickHimInTheCrotch · 14/01/2024 08:28

SurelySmartie · 13/01/2024 07:56

If you wouldn't miss it, why not give it? No questions asked.

Because there’s a 99% likelihood that you’d be supporting their addiction and contributing to making their health worse.

Local authorities have a duty to find accommodation for homeless people including those presenting in an emergency.

The people you see persistently on the street often aren’t capable of taking up an accommodation offer. Usually they’ve been chucked out or have repeatedly lost their place due to being

  • Violent to other residents or staff
  • Too intoxicated or mentally ill
  • Bringing large amounts of drugs and/ or other people in creating unsafe situations
  • Trying to keep dogs
  • Unable look after a room or unit, safely use kitchen, lock doors etc
  • Unable to cope with being on their own in a unit/ room
  • Out for days or weeks at a time losing their places

This is accurate - I've worked with homeless and addicted people for 20 years and can confirm that emergency/hostel housing is generally available for people who want the support and can put the effort in.

I'm not placing blame - the people who aren't able to access this support are often extremely damaged individuals. But it is out there.

Captnip500 · 14/01/2024 02:27

WineIsMyMainVice · 12/01/2024 23:49

At least you have a kind heart and a conscience op. Unlike some of the pp on this thread unfortunately.

My conscious doesn't sit easy thinking I might have payed for a bag of heroine for someone that might overdose them.

Captnip500 · 14/01/2024 02:20

IncognitoIsMyFavouriteWord · 12/01/2024 09:19

Do you know that some people need to feed their addiction or they are in more danger of medical risk?

Your comment shows you don't.

The ignorance and lack of education on this post explains why we've had tories for 13 years.

Oh come on now!! Blaming me for 13 years of Tory rule because I don’t agree with you, is just ridiculous. I can assure you I have never voted Tory in my life and never will.

Yes, I am aware of the risk of sudden detox with certain substances. If you had read my previous post you would see I have already stated that I worked with homeless people with addictions for many years. So I am well aware of the dangers. The thing to do in this situation is seek medical help or engage with services who can keep you safe. I know that’s not easy but in the mean time begging in order to access more of substance is not the answer. After all it’s not just the withdrawal that can kill you, it’s the substance itself.

Jamc93 · 13/01/2024 18:11

With you OP - I never give to the homeless now because I've been burnt. Gave a 'desperately hungry' homeless man money to get some food and I saw him 5 minutes later carrying a beer. Another time I offered a sandwich and they turned their nose up and swore at me as they just wanted money. I now only give pet food to the ones I see with animals.

Rikitiki78 · 13/01/2024 17:18

I’ve been approached a few times by people who claim to be in need. Give them what I feel comfortable wit giving and let God b the judge. If they really need it, my conscience is clear.

SurelySmartie · 13/01/2024 07:56

If you wouldn't miss it, why not give it? No questions asked.

Because there’s a 99% likelihood that you’d be supporting their addiction and contributing to making their health worse.

Local authorities have a duty to find accommodation for homeless people including those presenting in an emergency.

The people you see persistently on the street often aren’t capable of taking up an accommodation offer. Usually they’ve been chucked out or have repeatedly lost their place due to being

  • Violent to other residents or staff
  • Too intoxicated or mentally ill
  • Bringing large amounts of drugs and/ or other people in creating unsafe situations
  • Trying to keep dogs
  • Unable look after a room or unit, safely use kitchen, lock doors etc
  • Unable to cope with being on their own in a unit/ room
  • Out for days or weeks at a time losing their places
SherbetDips · 13/01/2024 04:18

It’s a scam! They always need 7 pounds to get into a hostel etc. I won’t give money only food.

Fantaandcola · 13/01/2024 03:35

I'm very jaded now and it is because of scammers that I would be reluctant to help other people in future.

I went to uni in a northern city and once this old man approached me near campus. He had a sob story about missing his train and needing to get back to Bristol. I literally had £80 left in my bank as I was a student and it was towards the end of the semester coming up to Christmas. My next student loan instalment didn’t come in for a few weeks so I knew it would be beans and toast if I gave him the £40 he wanted. I basically told him all that and more or less said please if you’re scamming find someone else who can afford it because I can’t lol. He maintained he was telling the truth and naive 19 year old me gave him £40 from the ATM. I remember it now, 2 x £20 notes.

I went off feeling rather good about myself helping this older man….Until a few days later I saw him up in another part of the campus giving the exact same story to another female student! 😩I intervened and told her he was a scammer that SHOULD be back in Bristol by now.

He looked furious but the girl was grateful and just walked off. It did give me some satisfaction knowing I’d thwarted his plans but no doubt he found some other gullible (probably female ) student to target. Although to be fair I never seen him again on our campus.

I was just disgusted that he had accepted money from me based on a lie and knowing I didn’t have much. Situations like that really helped opened my eyes to the nature of these scammers. Anyone is fair game to them.

Klcak · 13/01/2024 00:23

BreakingAndBroke · 13/01/2024 00:00

When I first moved to London, I assumed that everyone who asked for money was genuinely in need of a little bit of cash to get the last train home/make a phone call/get a bus ticket etc. After a while, you see the same people in the same places asking again and again and it makes you feel foolish and duped and it hardens you to any further requests. I'm very jaded now and it is because of scammers that I would be reluctant to help other people in future.

Yep, this

BreakingAndBroke · 13/01/2024 00:00

When I first moved to London, I assumed that everyone who asked for money was genuinely in need of a little bit of cash to get the last train home/make a phone call/get a bus ticket etc. After a while, you see the same people in the same places asking again and again and it makes you feel foolish and duped and it hardens you to any further requests. I'm very jaded now and it is because of scammers that I would be reluctant to help other people in future.

WineIsMyMainVice · 12/01/2024 23:49

At least you have a kind heart and a conscience op. Unlike some of the pp on this thread unfortunately.

Catsbreakfast · 12/01/2024 23:44

OhBumBags · 09/01/2024 23:49

Just to add if 'enabling' a homeless person's lifestyle means giving them a couple of quid when I know they're going to drink it, I'm happy with that.

God knows how many addicts are on the street, but even if every single one of them decided to get help tomorrow, the NHS and other charities couldn't cope at all.

The government would rather keep the addicts on the streets, being 'enabled' by passers by, rather than government money.

The whole “you’re enabling them”
nonsense is really winding me up. These people are out on their own, sleep in the cold and probably will use the money for booze and/or drugs. If I had to deal with that life every day I probably would too just to forget. It’s shameful how little services there are that effectively deal with these issues. Many have been abusing substances because they’ve gone through abhorrent abuse from a young age. There are no mental health services that would be able to address these and help these people long term, so what are they meant to do? Ideally there would be, but realistically there aren’t. I’m not going to begrudge people that. I would never judge anyone for not giving them any money, but when people get judgy about where their money goes, they’re better off not giving anything before rolling out the big lecture.

Catsbreakfast · 12/01/2024 23:38

Yeah the person living on the streets is running a racket to defraud you. 🙄 even if he’s using the money for drugs or booze, he’s still on the streets and you’re going home to a warm bed. If you’re not happy to accept that, don’t give money, but a little empathy for their situation goes a long way. If I had to sleep in those conditions, I probably would also try forget as much about it as I could.

Abouttimemum · 12/01/2024 22:40

Oh this happened to me not long ago - I was dashing through the city centre and was stopped by a man virtually in tears with a story about how he needed to get to the local hospital etc, all seemed very genuine. I gave him a fiver to grab the bus.

As I was walking on I sort of gathered my thoughts and stopped to look back, and there he was with a couple (clearly more switched on than me) clearly giving them the same story. I then watched him go into Wetherspoons.

I thought about going back but left it. I was mad at myself as I should have known better having worked for the police and know this goes on literally all of the time. And if I’d had more presence of mind I’d have realised he could actually WALK to the hospital from there!

Jeannie88 · 12/01/2024 18:50

I can rarely pass by, scam or not, so I would've given a couple of quid and at the point of him crying as much as I could tbh. There was a lady outside of a shop store all the time and I always gave her a bit and treats for her dog, turns out she wasn't what I thought. Fair enough but at least dog got some food. X

Fantaandcola · 12/01/2024 15:05

@Bertiesmum3 doesn't surprise me to hear that. There was a guy who was begging on the street most days in Twickenham about a decade ago. Eventually when he died it it came out in the local paper about him and he lived in a lovely house in Twickenham, not sure if he inherited it or his family still lived there but that was his residence. I’m glad I didn’t give him a penny as I was the one working for very little and in grotty houseshares in London 😂. What he needed was probably mental health services.

Bertiesmum3 · 12/01/2024 13:02

Having just recently a homeless man come into the place I work, don’t believe half of what they say, this man was offered supported living accommodation and refused it, he then had an accident and was unable to live on the streets.
Hes absolutely loaded, alcoholic and drug abuse history, it’s his choice to live on the street’s and he says a lot of homeless people choose that lifestyle especially the ones with animals as not a lot of accommodation take in animals too!
I know this is just an example of one person, but believe me you would be shocked and wouldn’t donate another penny after hearing what we’ve been told
Some do have somewhere to live and beg on the streets and pretend to be homeless when infact they’re not!

JustanotherMNSlapperTwat · 12/01/2024 12:09

Justfacts · 12/01/2024 10:15

I always give out and no I’m no schmuck either. Their lives are crap one way or another. So what if they use it for other purposes. Human trafficking involves a lot more than begging on the street. If they are? Maybe they need to amass the money to escape. If you can, always give.

This is incredibly naive when it comes to human trafficking specifically

No the money will not go to them for them to amass to leave. The money will fund the human trafficking of more people to work in slavery either begging or in the drugs trade or in nail bars etc

If you actually think someone is a slave the better thing to do would be to report it to the modern slavery hotline, rather than give them money that will go towards the entrapment of more slaves.

Swipe left for the next trending thread