Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU Should seating at swimming etc be reserved for adults

107 replies

ItsdefnotmeItsyou · 09/01/2024 19:40

So we go to swimming lessons, the lessons are 45mins long and my 2 children go one after the other, so I’m there for 1hr30mins. There’s 2 lessons at a time in the pool, up to max 8 children per class, but usually about 12/13 total. There aren’t many parents with more than 1 child swimming at a time so usually there are 12/13 or so parents plus some siblings maybe 3-5. There are however only 8/9 chairs. There’s not enough seats for all adults let alone children. More often than not, there are youngish children occupying seats, Or worse, Nintendo switches and such reserving seats that don’t end up sat on for the majority of the lesson. This leaves the adults to stand for 45mins(or in my case potentially 1 1/2 hours-although I can usually get a seat at changeover time if I didn’t have one) or sit on the floor in 1 of only 2 appropriate spaces to do so(some adults don’t mind standing and there are a few that always choose to stand up and watch even if seats are available- that’s their prerogative - I however do suffer with back pain (not that I expect anyone to know that) but that’s my reason for needing/wanting to sit and probably why it annoys me more than if I didn’t have an issue standing) When I have a seat I won’t let my other child occupy a seat unless it is clear no adult wishes to sit there (rarely) and even then if an adult is after a seat I will let them have it. We have also just changed which day we swim so encountered a whole different set of parents and the situation is exactly the same. AIBU to think this is just rude and inconsiderate? Or should children still have priority on a first come basis?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
JustAMinutePleass · 13/01/2024 04:30

ReadyForPumpkins · 10/01/2024 14:31

Most parents with kids in swimming lessons will be in their 30s and 40s. We aren't talking about giving seats to the elderly here.

where i live, grandparents take kids swimming not parents

TurquoiseSeasAndSilverSand · 10/01/2024 15:53

chocolatemademefat · 10/01/2024 15:05

Why on earth would we teach our children to have manners - according to mumsnetters. Of course the pampered snowflakes should have priority over everyone - especially the older generations who DO have manners.

sadly it’s the fault of their parents who give no thought to others and instill a sense of entitlement into their children.

We live in wonderful times.

Absolutely this. I'm a bit blown away by the replies here. Now we know where all those entitled teens who wouldn't give up their seat on a bus to an elderly person have got their shocking manners from.

And as for the adult who would be insulted by a child offering them a seat, the correct response would be to thank them for being thoughtful and politely decline. The next person that they offer it to might be grateful/in need of a seat.

MrsFezziwig · 10/01/2024 15:38

I will be very offended if a kid offer their seat to me because they think I am elderly.

@ReadyForPumpkins you’re part of the problem then. I think I can reasonably be classed as elderly. Yes, in an absolute sense I could stand, but I think it is a nice gesture on the part of a child to offer a seat and I wouldn’t want to throw their kindness back in their face by refusing, or cause them not to offer again when it may be for someone who really needs it. Also my sense of self esteem is not affected by a child thinking that I’m old enough to warrant a seat.

Joeslaol00 · 10/01/2024 15:30

ReadyForPumpkins · 10/01/2024 15:07

@Joeslaol00 you are making a generalisation that we can't. I'll find it an insult for a child to give their seat to me.

I didn’t write that all can’t! I said it’s a generalisation that all can sit on floor. Sorry you’re so offended by a person , whatever their age for being thoughtful.

MrsFezziwig · 10/01/2024 15:28

Surely the average adult is more capable of standing than a young child who has likely had a day at school and often a swimming lesson? Surely that's why children need to go to bed before adults?

Funny how parents posting on this site who have worked a full day and done several hours of childcare at each end are always complaining about how exhausted they are, then. Children need more sleep for correct development, not because they are more tired than their parents.

ReadyForPumpkins · 10/01/2024 15:07

@Joeslaol00 you are making a generalisation that we can't. I'll find it an insult for a child to give their seat to me.

chocolatemademefat · 10/01/2024 15:05

Why on earth would we teach our children to have manners - according to mumsnetters. Of course the pampered snowflakes should have priority over everyone - especially the older generations who DO have manners.

sadly it’s the fault of their parents who give no thought to others and instill a sense of entitlement into their children.

We live in wonderful times.

Itsreallynotdifficult · 10/01/2024 14:51

I think there’s plenty of places, as people here have even mentioned that signs have been put up in places asking for people to be considerate with the seating, so I don’t think these sorts of thoughts/expectations are out of the ordinary in a lot of situations. Children sit on the floor ALL the time, at nursery and the first years of primary school, it’s very normal that the children sit on the floor for registration and assemblies or circle time or similar, it is literally expected of them to sit and stay on the floor. Whereas it isn’t normal for an adult to turn up to the equivalent (work) and have to sit on the floor? Pretty sure it’s the norm that an office or such like provide chairs? Yes I’m sure there’s certain places/types of jobs that are different or unusual but if you weren’t happy with that you wouldn’t work there. So I don’t thinks it’s abnormal for children to sit on a floor or a lap in this instance. There’s been a lot of mention of ‘tired’ children who should be allowed a seat etc, but if they were that tired they wouldn’t be arsing about getting on/off those seats that could be appreciated more by someone else. It seems it’s those incidences a lot of people on this post are referring to, rather than a ‘blanket’ rule as mentioned by someone else

Joeslaol00 · 10/01/2024 14:50

People saying that 40-50year olds can sit on the floor is a big generalisation. I definitely cannot sit on the ground because I don’t have the strength to get myself up. People cannot see the back ache and numb sensation I have in my thighs if I stand for a few minutes
My children were taught basic manners and would always offer their seat ,hold doors open to other people etc .
Thankfully my Grandchild has been brought up the same way.

ReadyForPumpkins · 10/01/2024 14:31

Most parents with kids in swimming lessons will be in their 30s and 40s. We aren't talking about giving seats to the elderly here.

ReadyForPumpkins · 10/01/2024 14:31

But most parents with kids in swimming classes aren't in their 60s. Kids go to swimming lessons only up to maybe 12-15. So mostly under 12. Even if you have a child at 45, that will put up late 50s at most.

WickDittington · 10/01/2024 13:54

They're also taught to stand for anyone who needs a seat more than them (we'll all stand if someone needs the seat we're sitting on with them on my lap).

How do you judge that, though? And why should someone else's comfort be dependent on a 12 year old's judgement?

I'm extremely fit & limber for my age (mid-60s) but even I have a bit of a huff & puff to get up and down from sitting on the floor or the ground.

Vinrouge4 · 10/01/2024 13:17

ReadyForPumpkins · 10/01/2024 13:10

@Vinrouge4 Yes, we are older parents. DH is ove 50 and he stands for DC swimming lessons. I am turning 50 this year and I sit on the floor. It's either the floor or standing. I prefer sitting and he prefers standing.

Are you 30 and think 50 year olds are very old?

Wish I was 30. I am a lot older than 50 and would find sitting on the floor very uncomfortable.

ReadyForPumpkins · 10/01/2024 13:10

@Vinrouge4 Yes, we are older parents. DH is ove 50 and he stands for DC swimming lessons. I am turning 50 this year and I sit on the floor. It's either the floor or standing. I prefer sitting and he prefers standing.

Are you 30 and think 50 year olds are very old?

Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 10/01/2024 13:03

Vinrouge4 · 10/01/2024 09:17

People can be so entitled these days with regards to their kids. Growing up my mum would make me give up my seat on a bus to an adult and sit on her lap. Embarrassing when you were about 10.

You don't get the irony in this comment?

Pastaeverywhere · 10/01/2024 12:49

WickDittington · 10/01/2024 12:28

Yes @Vinrouge4 I find this point of view very short-sighted and selfish. It’s teaching children that it’s OK to ignore other’s comfort for the sake of your own. And this isn’t a particularly sociable thing to teach your children.

Good manners are essentially considering others’ comfort. And children do need constant socialisation into consideration for others as they can often be quite self-centred. The principle that mostly, children give up seats for adults, stand up when an adult enters the room, ask to “get down” from the table, wait until everyone is served before starting to eat - all these things are about a gradual awareness that the world doesn’t revolve around us.

So if we don’t want a society where it’s accepted that no-one looks out for anyone but themselves, then go ahead. Allow your children to sit in chairs while adults stand. It’s all part of this deep selfishness that’s developed in Britain over the last couple of decades.

Surely the fact that so many healthy adults expect a tired child to stand shows that this kind of thinking hasn't worked? If a healthy adult cannot stand for the duration of a swimming lesson then they are neglecting their physical health. Why should that be something that demands respect and something that children aspire to?

I would like to think that 'look what a good little girl you are, putting yourself through discomfort to please grown ups' is a thinking of the past.

Children need to learn to think of others, but also have healthy boundaries and learn that their needs are also important.

Ofcourse DC that are feeling fine should give up a seat to an adult that is particularly struggling. But it shouldn't be an expectation that adults and their feelings have a higher value.

CrispsandCheeseSandwich · 10/01/2024 12:44

Good manners are essentially considering others’ comfort. And children do need constant socialisation into consideration for others as they can often be quite self-centred. The principle that mostly, children give up seats for adults, stand up when an adult enters the room, ask to “get down” from the table, wait until everyone is served before starting to eat - all these things are about a gradual awareness that the world doesn’t revolve around us.

And yet, plenty of adults who were made to stand up for adults when they were children now seem to think they are entitled to a seat. So they haven't particularly learned the lesson you're talking about.
"Give me your seat so I can teach you that it's entitled to insist on a seat".

My young DDs are put on my lap if someone needs a seat. They're also taught to stand for anyone who needs a seat more than them (we'll all stand if someone needs the seat we're sitting on with them on my lap). But I don't think I'm more entitled to a seat than a 12 year old who was there first, for example. And I'm not really going to teach my children that I am.

BassoContinuo · 10/01/2024 12:38

The principle that mostly, children give up seats for adults, stand up when an adult enters the room, ask to “get down” from the table, wait until everyone is served before starting to eat

Children standing up when an adult enters the room is just ridiculous - why would they need to do that? Only setting I ever did that in as a child was at school and I thought it was bloody stupid then!

Blondeshavemorefun · 10/01/2024 12:31

dancinfeet · 09/01/2024 20:19

children do get tired too, but they are generally far more capable of sitting on the floor and taking up less space while doing so than an adult. therefore where possible, children should be seated on the floor and the chairs occupied by adults.

This

Blondeshavemorefun · 10/01/2024 12:30

I could have written this post ans struggle to stand for ages due to ankle operation I had last year

Others must have felt the same as we got this via email the other day and I could have jumped for joy

So will be asking a child to move

Please could adults use the chairs provided for spectating and encourage siblings to sit on the floor to wait for their lessons. Thank you.

WickDittington · 10/01/2024 12:28

Vinrouge4 · 10/01/2024 12:07

Seriously? You think a fifty year old should sit on the floor instead of a kid.

Yes @Vinrouge4 I find this point of view very short-sighted and selfish. It’s teaching children that it’s OK to ignore other’s comfort for the sake of your own. And this isn’t a particularly sociable thing to teach your children.

Good manners are essentially considering others’ comfort. And children do need constant socialisation into consideration for others as they can often be quite self-centred. The principle that mostly, children give up seats for adults, stand up when an adult enters the room, ask to “get down” from the table, wait until everyone is served before starting to eat - all these things are about a gradual awareness that the world doesn’t revolve around us.

So if we don’t want a society where it’s accepted that no-one looks out for anyone but themselves, then go ahead. Allow your children to sit in chairs while adults stand. It’s all part of this deep selfishness that’s developed in Britain over the last couple of decades.

Missingmybabysomuch · 10/01/2024 12:28

It amazes me how children are still seen as second class citizens 🙄
It depends a lot on the specific situation though. My 7 year old sits through a swimming lesson and after a day at school and her own swimming yes she's tired and wants to sit and read which I think she's perfectly entitled to do. I dont see why an adult should automatically have more rights to the chair. However, if the child isn't using the chair, it's being used as toy storage, or the child is young enough to sit on a parents lap comfortably, then I don't think they should be taking up a seat whilst others are standing. It also depends what other "seating" is available. At our swimming, the floor is not an option for adults or kids as it's poolside and soaking wet.

Vinrouge4 · 10/01/2024 12:07

ReadyForPumpkins · 10/01/2024 09:23

Many parents sit on the floor too. I really don't see a problem for someone in their 40s and 50s sitting on the floor. Let alone those in their 20s or 30s. We aren't invalids. We don't want people to age discriminate us in the workplace, and here I see people asking us to be treated as the elderly.

Seriously? You think a fifty year old should sit on the floor instead of a kid.

fitzwilliamdarcy · 10/01/2024 11:56

@mindutopia I saw this every time I used to use my local pool - parents shouting at others for dumping their stuff outside the changing rooms they’d “reserved”.

I now use a pool where they have adults only time and it’s so much better, haven’t had a single issue since!

fitzwilliamdarcy · 10/01/2024 11:54

One of my friends had endless bother with this, to the point where she took her own fold down chair. She stood up for 10 seconds to grab something and returned to find a child sitting in the chair.

She pointed out to his mum that she had brought her own chair in order to, you know, use it, not for the benefit of the other kids. Mum started arguing about why adults should take priority over kids!

I think swimming pools are where human decency goes to die.