Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think 2 hours of Fortnite after school is a lot for a just Year 8 DC?

204 replies

likesandlikes · 09/01/2024 19:25

I think 1.5 hours is more than enough but apparently 'everyone' allows their DC way more.

Interested to know facts from others (not judgments etc)

OP posts:
BubziOwl · 10/01/2024 10:15

waterrat · 10/01/2024 07:42

I think the issue is (and I've had this too) that when kids refuse other activities we can't bear the thought of them being bored -

When we were growing up adults didn't care if we were bored - and there was always - if dry/ not raining - the option of just leaving the house which is becoming socially less and less normal for children (at a great loss to childhood)

I really do think this parental fear of boredom starts in very early childhood, and it does nobody any good.

Desecratedcoconut · 10/01/2024 10:10

Why is the passive medium of watching television seen as a more benign form of entertainment than playing computer games socially with friends and co-operatively working out tactics and strategies of gameplay?

MuffinCoffee · 10/01/2024 10:05

Gaming only on weekends. Weekdays a bit of tv is allowed after school as a break. All devices are put away Sunday night and taken out for Friday evening. Gaming had increased since pandemic and we had to put down some ground rules. DC did have withdrawal symptoms but we worked through them and found activities to fill the boredom. No whatsapp after 5 pm. This helps others inviting them for gaming. Although there is a bit of messaging after school which is allowed for socialising.

UndertheCedartree · 10/01/2024 10:03

waterrat · 10/01/2024 06:58

ok @PurpleWisteria1 yes obviously in rain and dark its shit out - BUt let's be realistic, gaming is replacing outdoor time overall - my own child/ his friends - I see it, they do miss out or choose not to go outside because gaming is avaiable - Im v into getting my kids getting outside (and lucky we are in an area it's safe at their age I realise that) - but I can see that the lure of the game is often all consuming - and of course even when I get my child off the device and out with a ball under their arm - will their friends also be out? Or will they be gaming?

The picture painted here is that these children spend hours doing sports and music and then fill their spare hours with gaming

I know plenty of teachers who say it is the children who are most deprived - who live in flats or where it's harder to get out easily to play - who just spend hours gaming and apart from school will rarely do anything else

We have a health crisis for chilren - by 11 over half of 11 year olds are overweight - this is strikingly linked to poverty. In poorer areas child obesity is through the roof.

We also have a child mental health crisis - huge numbers of children and teens are unhappy - partly I believe because of the loss of free play/ independence/ time outdoors that previous generations had far more of

It's nice to hear of 'happy social gaming kids' - that is not what all gaming looks like.

And what is 3 / 4/ 5 hours of gaming replacing? It's replacing being bored - being bored is a driver of creativity! It pushes kids and adults to learn/ play/ make - let's not delude ourselves that sitting playing fortnigte for 14 hours a week is a healthy path in life - fun in moderation yes but that is not what many parents are fighting against.

In all honesty I don't recognise your description with my own DC. There doesn't seem to be any 'lure' about computer games anymore than all the other things they like. And all of my 11yo Dd"s gaming is social. Her older 16yo brother is more of a mix. I can't say gaming replaces being bored as they both have plenty of other things they enjoy - reading, arts and crafts, instruments, sports, board games. Both are very creative in different ways.

I wonder whether it is that you demonise gaming which makes it such a lure for your DC? As another poster says those DC that have strict limits tend to be obsessed with playing every last minute they can. But those that don't just see it as one option out of many others so won't often play for as long as those with limits.

SecondUsername4me · 10/01/2024 09:45

likesandlikes · 10/01/2024 09:30

Thanks all. More interesting replies - and looking at the screen broken down into different bits - gaming/consoles; Tv; phones etc.

I hate the console but I also hate the phone stuff, like YouTube and Tik Tok, and when I see him looking at those shitty 3 min videos, I really feel depressed. It's all empty calories.

I have to find a balance, though, which is what this post is about

Just like Mumsnet minutes are too. My ds mocks me for being on "Mums Web" as he likes to call it.

We all have downtime. We usually always have a mix of "healthy" downtime (aka crafts and shit) and "unhealthy" downtime (aka MN and wine).

Kids are the same. Less wine though.

TheFastestSquirrel · 10/01/2024 09:37

The current thing that kids are into always needs to be controlled and vilified. TV, rock and roll, dancing the Charleston. It’s like the parents of the world have always been, and will always be, determined to give their kids a hard time.

Well yes but most young people didn't spend four hours a day (or more)after school dancing the Charleston

FreezyFord · 10/01/2024 09:31

Mine played it for much longer than that 😃

likesandlikes · 10/01/2024 09:30

Thanks all. More interesting replies - and looking at the screen broken down into different bits - gaming/consoles; Tv; phones etc.

I hate the console but I also hate the phone stuff, like YouTube and Tik Tok, and when I see him looking at those shitty 3 min videos, I really feel depressed. It's all empty calories.

I have to find a balance, though, which is what this post is about

OP posts:
TheFastestSquirrel · 10/01/2024 09:29

whiteboardking · 09/01/2024 19:54

I think when the weather is grim & they are all chatting on head sets with mates most prob easily do two hours between 3.30 and 10pm
Not sure what else they'd do - mine do do sport etc 1-2 hrs a night and eat tea / homework and then .... but still 6+ hours to fill

Obviously there's plenty to do after school that doesn't involve gaming.

UndertheCedartree · 10/01/2024 09:26

throughgrittedteeth · 09/01/2024 20:20

I have a DS exactly the same age OP and it seems like no one puts restrictions in place. I like DS to be off of everything by 9:30 and in bed reading til 10ish but he has friends who are on easily until 11pm on school nights and some are allowed on all night at the weekend if they want to, even then we tend to say 11pm. It's a hard one to stay strong about when sometimes it feels like he's being left out.
He's a good kid though and gets his homework done and spends time with his siblings so I don't get involved too often unless I can see it negatively impacting him. The thing we have to remember is that they are socialising on these games, him and his friends have so much fun playing, it sounds joyous most of the time.

In the past he's complained that he hasn't had enough time to do something else before bed because he's spent too long gaming and so that's been a natural consequence that he took on board. It is a tricky balance but I don't think demonising something they enjoy is the way forward.

It may appear they are on more than you think just due to when they have time to play.

As an example my Y7 DD has to finish playing by 8pm as she goes to bed at 9pm. So she could tell me that your DS is allowed to continue playing til 9.30pm. But of course that doesn't mean he's on it a lot more than her but maybe plays at different times.

SouperWoman · 10/01/2024 09:26

All the PPs saying their kids have no screen time during the week - do you mean TV as well?

Personally I’d much prefer my child to be gaming whilst chatting to his friends than watching a tv show, YouTube, or scrolling on social media.

The world has changed. Our children need to learn how to manage their time online. I have zero issues with (age-appropriate) gaming online. Two hours a night seems fine as long as DC are also getting some exercise and keeping up with homework.

SonicAllanKey · 10/01/2024 09:24

The current thing that kids are into always needs to be controlled and vilified. TV, rock and roll, dancing the Charleston. It’s like the parents of the world have always been, and will always be, determined to give their kids a hard time.

maybe an obsession with gaming will lead to winning an esports comp and them making mega bucks, or getting them into game design and building. Maybe it won’t. But it’s just one thing they are doing.

As long as they also meet their other commitments such as home work and household expectations then I can’t get too het up about them gaming. My kids socialise with their friends this way, especially in winter when I can’t just drop them at the park (we live in the middle of nowhere). They have the freedom to do what works for them and respect it enough to stop if I need them to.

Maybe it helps that I game too 🤷‍♀️

likesandlikes · 10/01/2024 09:22

Mimami · 09/01/2024 21:15

I'd go as far as saying that playing it every day is unhealthy. Not been there yet but would make me sad, not so much the amount of time spent on videogames but more of what else they could be doing and are missing out. Maybe encourage sport, music, arts, reading, face to face games, being outdoors? And who cares what others are doing and as a pp said may not even be true! You need to set the boundaries you feel are right and get family involved in setting them with reasons why and alternatives. How about chores to earn gaming time? Or set certain days off to detox and realise fun can be had in other ways? Best of luck!

If you've not been there yet, then honestly, you can't know what it's like. I say that nicely - we have always been really restrictive, whilst pushing lots of other hobbies and expectations. And I think DC gets what we want from him - but the lure of being part of a group, the screen, the socialising and the fun involved - it's unavoidable for most boys, in particular. I only know one boy out of many of his age group who isn't that interested - and I think he might be but his parents are very anti gaming, and he's a very compliant kid

OP posts:
SecondUsername4me · 10/01/2024 09:16

the rolling stones/ the beatles/ any singer you can think of - none of them grew up with screens - I worry we are losing generations of free thinkers/ artists/ singers/ songwriters to gaming

This is daft. We have some really exceptional singer songwriters. Tv scripts have never been better. The vast majority of new books are fucking fantastic.

We are not losing any of this to gaming.

UndertheCedartree · 10/01/2024 09:13

waterrat · 10/01/2024 07:40

@user1492757084 yes! this is what I mean - so many health risks - and people comparing with other children when let's face it childhood is in crisis

The idea that it's torture for a child to do something 'boring' ie. not on a screen for a couple of hours after school - let them be a bit bored!

my kids have plenty of screen time/ gaming/ tv / watching total crap/ whatever they want - but I also expect them to fill the hours in other ways

I read a lot of autobiographies and it's v depressing reading as a modern parent - so many childhoods of artists/ musicians/ innovators - were hours and hours of 'boredom' - ie. strumming mindlessly at guitars, going to a friends to chat and listen to music - writing songs, writing poems - for the more scientific it was taking apart radios/ carrying out mad experiments -

and of course just reading/ daydreaming

the rolling stones/ the beatles/ any singer you can think of - none of them grew up with screens - I worry we are losing generations of free thinkers/ artists/ singers/ songwriters to gaming.

but lets face it kids are copying adults who are also noses into screens most of the time.

I have to say my DD is very creative - off screen as well as on. She's always making/painting/designing something. Even playing on Roblox/Minecraft for an hour or 2 a day still leaves plenty of time for doing other things.

CoffeeWithCheese · 10/01/2024 08:59

DD1 is in year 7. The deal we have is that homework gets done first, then whatever until dinner and then I want games off by about 7.15pm. With her and Fortnite I found she went through a period of being crazy over it, then the novelty wore off - if I'd limited it massively, she'd have continued hankering on and on and on after it, but riding out the phase lasted about 2-3 weeks and then she's back to spending loads of her time drawing on her iPad and things now.

You know how your child responds though at the end of the day - with DD2 she's a lot more someone who needs a hard time limit with games that engage her (not so much Fortnite as she's not bothered by that) because she will become utterly obsessed for a long period of time.

rockingbird · 10/01/2024 08:52

Somehow I've managed to avoid all this.. we have an Xbox and they play Minecraft sometimes and a meta 3 (upgraded this year from a 2) again played occasionally mostly at weekend. Never had Fortnite so really unsure what all the fuss is about. Yr 8 (12) & yr 6 (11) boys..! I've asked about it and both have declined which I suppose is a good thing. We tend to play board games in the evening 🤷🏼‍♀️

Pussygaloregalapagos · 10/01/2024 08:45

My son loves fortnight too. If there is nothing else going on (he is sporty and will prioritise that above Fortnite) he wil do just that. On a school night he will often play the game after dinner from 8 to about 10. He is usually in with friends and laughing and joking. He is 15.

Flimpychunk · 10/01/2024 08:42

Got a 14 and 10 year old who have just got their first console for Christmas. We’ve agreed that their previous 45-minutes-on-school-nights screen time can be used for tv/gaming etc and that they can have an hour each weekend day, and unlimited on holidays. Seems to be working ok although still early days!

waterrat · 10/01/2024 08:26

@PurpleWisteria1 I completely agree about traffic and cars it's a massive massive loss to children and their freedom. And that's a reality parents can't change without huge social campaigning....I hope we see a push back at some point- instead I see kids just being driven inside to screens and the roads surrendered to cars.

PurpleWisteria1 · 10/01/2024 08:01

I agree that kids shouldn’t be on a video game every days for hours and hours but times are changing.
Kids arnt out as much partly because roads and housing is so busy now - packed in houses and far far more care on the roads than 30+ years ago when most of us were kids. My kids do go out when it’s light with friends to kick a ball, ride a bike or walk around (tweens) as we live in a relatively safe place but I constantly worry cars and even more all the delivery vans who just seem to bomb around with no care at all.
My dad who is now in his 70’s used to go off on a bike all day long and come back for dinner- he said he used to travel miles with friends and parents didn’t know or worry where he was- he just had to come back for dinner.
But the places he cycles wernt filled with cars and loads of busy roads. 60 years ago the landscape of the south of the UK and how many people were living here was dramatically different.

We are in a digital age. Yes it’s sad that lots of things are being lost. But times do change. Socialising in the cold winter months was once done over a phone. None of my tweens or teen (who isn’t into gaming) talk over the phone now. It’s all over headset inside a game or Snapchat.
They still go round friends houses but even then as everyone has a console they often game there too.
When I think back to my teen / tween years and try to remember what I did after school for downtime, all I remember is watching hours of rubbish TV as there were only 4 channels. I would easily rack up 14 hours of TV in the winter months.
The pressures on both parents to work full time now doesn’t help either because so many parents arnt there when their tween / young teen get home from school or they are there but working at home. So the child needs to be kept quiet and out of trouble whilst both parent is working. Again, totally different 30+ years ago for most people.

UndertheCedartree · 10/01/2024 07:49

strawberryandtomato · 09/01/2024 19:58

Those of secondary aged children. Did they play often in primary. At the moment, my kids aren't allowed screens in the week but it seems like a huge jump from none at all to 2 hours a day 🙈 kids are 10 and 8

My DD started playing Roblox in Y5. Probably only 45 min at most then. But by the end of Y6 they do want to spend more time socialising with their friends so was more like an hour or so.

waterrat · 10/01/2024 07:42

I think the issue is (and I've had this too) that when kids refuse other activities we can't bear the thought of them being bored -

When we were growing up adults didn't care if we were bored - and there was always - if dry/ not raining - the option of just leaving the house which is becoming socially less and less normal for children (at a great loss to childhood)

NorthernGirlie · 10/01/2024 07:42

My Year 7 plays freely as long as homework done. Sometimes he canes it, sometimes he plays lego instead.

I like to listen in - the seriousness with which they play is hilarious. One of his mates' sisters has started playing and they were coaching her last night - it sounded like very intense training!

waterrat · 10/01/2024 07:40

@user1492757084 yes! this is what I mean - so many health risks - and people comparing with other children when let's face it childhood is in crisis

The idea that it's torture for a child to do something 'boring' ie. not on a screen for a couple of hours after school - let them be a bit bored!

my kids have plenty of screen time/ gaming/ tv / watching total crap/ whatever they want - but I also expect them to fill the hours in other ways

I read a lot of autobiographies and it's v depressing reading as a modern parent - so many childhoods of artists/ musicians/ innovators - were hours and hours of 'boredom' - ie. strumming mindlessly at guitars, going to a friends to chat and listen to music - writing songs, writing poems - for the more scientific it was taking apart radios/ carrying out mad experiments -

and of course just reading/ daydreaming

the rolling stones/ the beatles/ any singer you can think of - none of them grew up with screens - I worry we are losing generations of free thinkers/ artists/ singers/ songwriters to gaming.

but lets face it kids are copying adults who are also noses into screens most of the time.