Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say to DH that these payments to his ex should stop now?

505 replies

yardandbard · 09/01/2024 19:16

When me and DH first met he has a set up with his ex (who was single at the time and on a lower wage) where he'd contribute towards her going on holiday every year with their children. There was no maintenance paid as they've always done 50:50 but he used to pay towards her holidays.

We've now been together for nearly 6 years and this is still ongoing. Its not just expected and imo should stop. DH has made suggestions before in the past that it stops but it's always met with complaints and kick offs and to keep the peace he ends up carrying on for another year.

The ex is now with someone else herself and has been for a couple of years, we also have joint DC to think about too, a bigger home than before etc etc.. all meaning spare money isn't as easily found as it was before. Its not that it's not affordable but more that the money could be used for more important things for OUR family and in my opinion she should now be supporting her own holidays with her own job and partner if she wants to go away, I've always thought the arrangement was odd and a bit cheeky but I lived with it at first. Now I just think it's ridiculous.

Aibu to say to DH this really needs to stop now? He'll agree with me as he's wanted to stop for a while but I know she'll likely moan she can't go away with the children otherwise so it's just about getting him to keep saying no despite the fall out.

OP posts:
Cherrysoup · 10/01/2024 20:27

Your Dh seems to be worried the ex will start messing with contact as she did previously. Are the dc old enough to simply come to your house independently? He is being a mug funding her holidays, she doesn’t fund his! I’d be asking him to stop, especially given you take them away yourselves.

K37529 · 10/01/2024 20:25

After reading your updates he definitely should not be paying for her to go on holidays.

Lollypop701 · 10/01/2024 20:22

Save the ex holiday money for court costs for access… at least that’s a one off.

basically you’ve accepted this for x years so it’s easier to moan at you and pay than face the ex… who is fully aware that if she shouts he will cave. So it’s now or never imo

Xmasdaft2023 · 10/01/2024 20:16

Oh and to top it all off she lied about her income to get the payment to what it was! She’s sat in a £500k house with 4 cars on the drive 🤯

Xmasdaft2023 · 10/01/2024 20:15

She’s a CF! And your husband is a door mat. This should change as with life things have changed, subsequently 2 (?) further children he now has to fund as well as the others, if this was a CSA payment then it would be adjusted as their were other children involved…
your OH has to have this conversation with her and say it’s not possible to continue the contribution any longer.

just as a side note I am a SM but one that had the care of her SK.. we received £40 per month for 2 children. She point blank refused to pay anything further than her payment as that was the calculation 🤯 wasn’t even enough for school lunches for a week for 2 never mind anything else. She refused to pay towards trips etc so I can’t imagine she’d have EVER have contributed towards a holiday that we would take SK on!!! (When she had the SK my OH paid £400 per month plus purchased school wear, paid towards trips so mind boggles with her shocking attitude) my OH was a door mat too but very quickly learnt what a manipulative witch his ex was!

Illpickthatup · 10/01/2024 20:07

sbhydrogen · 10/01/2024 19:33

So when the arrangement started she was just starting out in her career (or similar?). Fine, that made sense. She now has a career now and a DP she lives with... But still asks for money for a holiday ??? The cheek!

Your DH should buy them all camping equipment and say "there are all your future holidays. Enjoy!"

Exactly. I don't know how she's not embarrassed by this. Or the partner. I know my DH would certainly feel a kind of way about going on a holiday part funded by one of my ex's.

Alicesmagicmushroom · 10/01/2024 20:05

@tinkertee Im not rewriting post you have failed to read

Illpickthatup · 10/01/2024 20:04

juicyfruitmtume · 10/01/2024 18:39

If he stops then won't she just start claiming maintenance?

They share childcare 50:50 so she wouldn't be entitled to any maintenance.

tinkertee · 10/01/2024 20:03

Alicesmagicmushroom · 10/01/2024 18:56

@ChristmasSugarplumFairy I meant your own children too, however that’s fine, but this is not about whether the children are fine though, that was never in question, this was about a principle that as there was a long standing agreement agreement with the OPs DH which she is now objecting to the the DH appears to not be upset enough about to stop.

The third party you also refer to are are the DHs children, and his family, (is your DSD not your DHs family, also why is a holiday so embarrassing )and again the point is he’s not ‘paying for his ex-girlfriend to go on holiday’, he’s facilitating family time with his children and their mother. A very decent gesture which I’m sure the children will appreciate and modelling something positive for them I’m sure.
Again, so miserly to begrudge this, and for those saying the ex should facilitate the holiday, maybe the DH should get a better job too if he can’t fulfil his long standing commitments which enrich the lives of his D.C. etc etc

Anyway, OP separate your finances and find a way not to be so resentful, or go through official channels, never know it may end up being more if he’s extremely frugal in general.

The DH enriches their lives by taking them on holiday himself.
Following your logic, should the ex also pay towards that? If your answer is no then you need to justify why.

HamBone · 10/01/2024 20:00

Newliferequired · 10/01/2024 19:52

It sounds like he earns a lot more money than his ex and I think it's fair for him to contribute to their holiday as its likely they wouldn't have one or as good of one otherwise. If you didn't agree to the commitments he made to his ex and his kids before you were on the scene why get together and have a kid with him.

@Newliferequired Well, they estimate about a £9K difference, it’s not as if he earns double her salary.

He already pays for his own family holiday, I personally don’t think he needs to pay for hers too-unless he still wants to. If he does, fine, but it sounds as if he doesn’t anymore. 🤷

HunterHearstHelmsley · 10/01/2024 20:00

Newliferequired · 10/01/2024 19:52

It sounds like he earns a lot more money than his ex and I think it's fair for him to contribute to their holiday as its likely they wouldn't have one or as good of one otherwise. If you didn't agree to the commitments he made to his ex and his kids before you were on the scene why get together and have a kid with him.

He earns around 9k more. It's not like he's a massively high earner and she's on minimum wage.

Newliferequired · 10/01/2024 19:52

It sounds like he earns a lot more money than his ex and I think it's fair for him to contribute to their holiday as its likely they wouldn't have one or as good of one otherwise. If you didn't agree to the commitments he made to his ex and his kids before you were on the scene why get together and have a kid with him.

Ohhbaby · 10/01/2024 19:38

Blueblell · 10/01/2024 18:11

I think he should go pay towards his children to go on holiday yes.

Okay, so he pays so his children can go on holiday with their mom. Then she should pay so that her children can go on holiday with their dad, no?

sbhydrogen · 10/01/2024 19:33

So when the arrangement started she was just starting out in her career (or similar?). Fine, that made sense. She now has a career now and a DP she lives with... But still asks for money for a holiday ??? The cheek!

Your DH should buy them all camping equipment and say "there are all your future holidays. Enjoy!"

Alicesmagicmushroom · 10/01/2024 19:28

@ChristmasSugarplumFairy OP made it her ‘problem’ as it came before her.

ChristmasSugarplumFairy · 10/01/2024 19:24

Alicesmagicmushroom · 10/01/2024 19:16

@ChristmasSugarplumFairy You mentioned embarrassing and I asked you what you meant.

Shes not going cap in hand, there is a private and preexisting agreement between the DH and his ex related to the DH, it’s that straightforward, he is honouring that as he should, I ask again, why is this such an issue.

You can flip the argument but the core reason for this conversation remains there is a preexisting agreement in place and it’s not for the OP to intervene in way she is trying to, it’s inappropriate for all the reasons cited.

It is inappropriate for it to continue now that he has other responsibilities to balance, it's not an obligation and its not just his own money he's handing out. Oh and the fact that she books then demands the cash is incredible.
As you said, it looks like OP will be shaking up the finances and her DH can give as much of his own money to his ex as he likes. A shame for their marriage but this should never have be made into OPs problem to deal with.

Alicesmagicmushroom · 10/01/2024 19:16

Related to the DC rather

Alicesmagicmushroom · 10/01/2024 19:16

@ChristmasSugarplumFairy You mentioned embarrassing and I asked you what you meant.

Shes not going cap in hand, there is a private and preexisting agreement between the DH and his ex related to the DH, it’s that straightforward, he is honouring that as he should, I ask again, why is this such an issue.

You can flip the argument but the core reason for this conversation remains there is a preexisting agreement in place and it’s not for the OP to intervene in way she is trying to, it’s inappropriate for all the reasons cited.

huwhuwbarnymcgrew · 10/01/2024 19:15

Th ex is taking the right royal p*ss. If her fella lives with her then it stops now, not next year.

WhereverIlaymycatthatsmyhome · 10/01/2024 19:11

It’s all very well posters telling OP what she should do.

Her actual problem is that DH clearly doesn’t want to stop making this contribution to his children going on holiday with their mum. She has a very clear DH problem.

There is very little OP can do in this situation, other than follow the very good advice to tell DH they will have separate finances from now on. Whether their relationship will withstand her standing up for herself in this way remains to be seen.

ChristmasSugarplumFairy · 10/01/2024 19:10

Alicesmagicmushroom · 10/01/2024 18:56

@ChristmasSugarplumFairy I meant your own children too, however that’s fine, but this is not about whether the children are fine though, that was never in question, this was about a principle that as there was a long standing agreement agreement with the OPs DH which she is now objecting to the the DH appears to not be upset enough about to stop.

The third party you also refer to are are the DHs children, and his family, (is your DSD not your DHs family, also why is a holiday so embarrassing )and again the point is he’s not ‘paying for his ex-girlfriend to go on holiday’, he’s facilitating family time with his children and their mother. A very decent gesture which I’m sure the children will appreciate and modelling something positive for them I’m sure.
Again, so miserly to begrudge this, and for those saying the ex should facilitate the holiday, maybe the DH should get a better job too if he can’t fulfil his long standing commitments which enrich the lives of his D.C. etc etc

Anyway, OP separate your finances and find a way not to be so resentful, or go through official channels, never know it may end up being more if he’s extremely frugal in general.

The third party I was referring to was his ex, actually.
I agree if the DH was wealthy and she was poor it would be a lovely gesture. But he's not and she earns a decent wage herself. He's undermining his own finances and marriage by saying "I'd rather upset you, my wife, than her, my ex".
Do you have a good reason why this woman shouldn't be expected to pay for her own holidays?
Why wouldn't the children appreciate their mother modelling that hard work and perseverance gets you a decent wage and a chance to go on holiday your own steam?
Why is she so miserly that she won't pay for her own family holidays or give the OPs DH money to fund family time abroad with their father?
Holidays aren't embarrassing. Going cap in hand to another adult and threatening to go in a tantrum if they don't pay what you demand is embarrassing.

Sweetglossy · 10/01/2024 19:05

tinkertee · 10/01/2024 17:13

@Sweetglossy or the DH tells his ex that he will no longer be contributing anything towards her holidays with the DC's? Unless she also contributes to his holidays with them of course.

Whatever flouts HIS boat!

Alicesmagicmushroom · 10/01/2024 18:59

Re the school fees, I’ve know of a situation where the previous DC are at independent schools and the new D.C. isn’t so the new wife is unhappy as she doesn’t think this is fair.

I agree though school fees are non negotiable - just an example - a bad one - as this sprung to mine

Alicesmagicmushroom · 10/01/2024 18:56

@ChristmasSugarplumFairy I meant your own children too, however that’s fine, but this is not about whether the children are fine though, that was never in question, this was about a principle that as there was a long standing agreement agreement with the OPs DH which she is now objecting to the the DH appears to not be upset enough about to stop.

The third party you also refer to are are the DHs children, and his family, (is your DSD not your DHs family, also why is a holiday so embarrassing )and again the point is he’s not ‘paying for his ex-girlfriend to go on holiday’, he’s facilitating family time with his children and their mother. A very decent gesture which I’m sure the children will appreciate and modelling something positive for them I’m sure.
Again, so miserly to begrudge this, and for those saying the ex should facilitate the holiday, maybe the DH should get a better job too if he can’t fulfil his long standing commitments which enrich the lives of his D.C. etc etc

Anyway, OP separate your finances and find a way not to be so resentful, or go through official channels, never know it may end up being more if he’s extremely frugal in general.

roastedrapidly · 10/01/2024 18:55

juicyfruitmtume · 10/01/2024 18:39

If he stops then won't she just start claiming maintenance?

She can't claim maintenance because they share the kids 50:50

The holiday payment is an added extra that us completely unnecessary, of course he should stop paying this. But he needs to come to that conclusion and have that conversation with his ex.