Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say to DH that these payments to his ex should stop now?

505 replies

yardandbard · 09/01/2024 19:16

When me and DH first met he has a set up with his ex (who was single at the time and on a lower wage) where he'd contribute towards her going on holiday every year with their children. There was no maintenance paid as they've always done 50:50 but he used to pay towards her holidays.

We've now been together for nearly 6 years and this is still ongoing. Its not just expected and imo should stop. DH has made suggestions before in the past that it stops but it's always met with complaints and kick offs and to keep the peace he ends up carrying on for another year.

The ex is now with someone else herself and has been for a couple of years, we also have joint DC to think about too, a bigger home than before etc etc.. all meaning spare money isn't as easily found as it was before. Its not that it's not affordable but more that the money could be used for more important things for OUR family and in my opinion she should now be supporting her own holidays with her own job and partner if she wants to go away, I've always thought the arrangement was odd and a bit cheeky but I lived with it at first. Now I just think it's ridiculous.

Aibu to say to DH this really needs to stop now? He'll agree with me as he's wanted to stop for a while but I know she'll likely moan she can't go away with the children otherwise so it's just about getting him to keep saying no despite the fall out.

OP posts:
Nanaof1 · 11/01/2024 09:07

Alicesmagicmushroom · 10/01/2024 19:16

@ChristmasSugarplumFairy You mentioned embarrassing and I asked you what you meant.

Shes not going cap in hand, there is a private and preexisting agreement between the DH and his ex related to the DH, it’s that straightforward, he is honouring that as he should, I ask again, why is this such an issue.

You can flip the argument but the core reason for this conversation remains there is a preexisting agreement in place and it’s not for the OP to intervene in way she is trying to, it’s inappropriate for all the reasons cited.

I very much doubt it was a "lifetime" agreement. Since DH already is tired of paying for his exes' holiday, he has every right to say "no". It's past time for the ex to GTFU and do her part to raise their children, which includes funding their holidays with her and her new DP and stop sponging off OP's DH and OP.
According to OP, he already pays more than ex for the things they need and fees. Now he is no longer in the position to pay for ex to take their DC on a holiday, as OP has said that if they separate finances, he won't have the money. It certainly is not on the OP to fund some manipulative exes holiday time, nor her DHs, especially when it's been shown the ex takes it to excess (BIG SHOCK).

Isthisasgoodasitis · 11/01/2024 09:05

So is this the maintenance arrangement or in addition too? You need to tread carefully as if she goes to the state to have calculated contributions it doesn’t calculate your child with him at all so it could end up being he pays much more

DillDanding · 11/01/2024 09:01

I think she’s taking the piss. I would be stopping this contribution to holidays. She could be having the holiday she can afford.

iamstrugglingalot · 11/01/2024 08:58

Just wondering what responses I'd get if I posted this from the opposite perspective:

"I split with my DD's father over 10 years ago and at that time he agreed to pay for me to take DD on regular holidays. Now he's remarried and his wife isn't happy that their family funds my family holidays. AIBU to expect this arrangement to continue regardless of how his wife feels?"

Hmmmm. Would be a resounding "YABU!" And "pay for your own holidays" I imagine 🤔

SpringPen · 11/01/2024 08:56

5128gap · 10/01/2024 12:22

Why do you think its not about the children? My children were well provided for with 'sufficient' holidays (whatever people believe that to mean!) but adore their other parent and some of their happiest memories involve holidays he was part of. Had circumstances meant that it was a choice between my children losing out on that experience or me chipping in for it, I'd have paid. As I did so my parents could take them away. A holiday with me and my new partner isn't a substitute for one with their other parent or grandparents, it's something entirely different and if I could afford both for them I would have. That's not to say there's an obligation, but I really struggle with this idea of only doing what you absolutely have to for your DC, because God forbid an ex might benefit.

That's all very well, but it's a bit more nuanced than that, isn't it. Why can't their DM afford to take them away herself? Is it because she isn't saving over the year (like OP and DH have to) or spending the money in a different way? It's not as though she's living in poverty - and she has a new partner. She's happy enough for OP to support her holiday payments and support their own family holidays for her children with DH. Perhaps she should be as happy for her current partner to start supporting their trips away. Additionally, perhaps it is the case that she couldn't afford holidays like Disneyland but we all have to cut our cloth and if she could afford to take them away on a cheaper holiday - where I'm sure they could all make equally lovely memories - then why can't she do that.

If DH was a super high earner and the money wasn't relevant, I'd agree with you that it would be a nice thing to do, but OP has been clear that that isn't the case and that, whilst they can afford it, it's not a drop in the ocean to them. The money could be used in a different way to benefit the creation of their own family memories.

OP, ignore the entitled posters, who think your DH should continue paying towards his ex's family holidays as infinitum. Presumably they also think that his ex should contribute towards your family holiday too. If not, they're simply hypocrites. The payments need to stop, provided everything else you've explained is true about equal residence and sharing of costs for the children elsewhere. Speak to your DH openly and explain that if he is choosing to continue to finance these trips, whilst also maintaining a fair contribution to your own household, that's ofc up to him, but that you won't be supporting them anymore and so intend to separate finances, as it isn't fair that you're paying for something you don't want to. Keep it very calm and factual and follow through.

MsAmber · 11/01/2024 08:54

Having been divorced with 2 young children, 50/50 split and finances separated, however I paid him for 2.5 years as he played the poverty card despite earning more than me, for example refusing to put his heating on when the kids were with him.

Looking back, I'd never do that again but it's one of the reasons I called it a day, the man was quite incompetent.

I cannot imagine expecting my ex husband to finance my holidays. Although if he could have, I'm sure he'd have quite fancied this arrangement and would have continued to leech of me for even longer than he did.

It sounds like they agreed it at the time, things change, the children are taken on holiday every year with their dad and step mum.

I often wonder how these MNetters who think men should pay for their ex's will change their tunes when they become MILs and suddenly their special little boys are getting divorced and DIL is after their cash.

I don't think I've ever seen a post from a MIL insisting her son should finance an ex's lifestyle or lack of.

Nanaof1 · 11/01/2024 08:50

@yardandbard * Perhaps we could separate finances completely and then he really would have to stop as he'd only have his own pot to pay for it from!*

Personally, I think this is the best way to handle it. I cannot believe the posters who think you should continue paying. I can imagine WHY they are saying it (or the many reasons they favor the idea), but that doesn't make it right.

It's not your job to spend a dime on the ex's holiday, so separate your finances, so DH can see the reality. Hopefully, he'll grow a spine and stand up for himself, and soon.

Holliegee · 11/01/2024 08:44

Controversially-I think, if he wanted to stop-he would.
He had the children and that relationship before he met you and I don’t think a man honouring commitments he makes is a bad trait to have.
I see your point and accept it from your side of things but I think it’s a decision to be made by him and her, rather than you saying what should happen.

Nanaof1 · 11/01/2024 08:42

Grimchmas · 10/01/2024 05:49

If she's not already booked the holiday this year and he says hewill stop after this year I run he needs to also stipulate the amount he is willing to give this year....

OP, how old are the children now? What's the risk that she will withhold a visit now?

Good idea or she might pick a trip to the most expensive place she can find. She sounds like the type who would pull a stunt like that.

A PP mentioned giving the children spending money when they go on holiday and that is a nice idea. That way they have some of their own to use as they wish.

Peaceandquietandacuppa · 11/01/2024 08:38

If they live with you 50/50 the holiday contributions need to stop. You can take them on holiday, and their mum can take them on holiday if they wish. There is no legal basis to the payment so your DH should say ‘2024 will be the last year of this and it is £300’ etc

TheMamaYo · 11/01/2024 08:26

That’s beyond cheeky, especially as she is with someone else who goes on the holidays too. (Where’s their pride?)
If/when it was the only way to get the children away on holiday, it’s understandable. But things have changed a lot since then.
I’m with you, OP, and would say to give her notice asap that it’s not happening any more. The fall out will only be temporary, but if you don’t do it, the resentment will just build up whilst the expectations get cemented even further for this to be the norm.

NonPlayerCharacter · 11/01/2024 08:26

Teder · 10/01/2024 22:54

I’m sure the children won’t be adversely affected by having “only” one holiday per year as opposed to two. Some children don’t have any holidays because parents cannot afford it! This is a terribly MN post.

Some children don’t have any holidays because parents cannot afford it!

That's entirely beside the point.

PegasusReturns · 11/01/2024 08:03

Sounds like the children are a bit older (phone contracts, going on 7 years) and so unlikely there are many years of this request left.

in your DHs position I’d suck it up. It’s a nice thing to do, the DC will see it as a nice thing and for the sake of the cost for a time bound period I wouldn’t tick the boat. Just be clear it ends when they leave school.

Takenobull · 11/01/2024 08:01

So even if they didn’t have children together there’s still a chance by law he would have to give her some sort of maintenance.
If her life was financially impacted because of the split then he would have to make up the short fall.
The holidays are potentially that shortfall.

YerArseInParsley · 11/01/2024 07:57

@yardandbard

If he's paying 50/50 to all other things then I'd say the holiday is extra. His kids go on holiday with yous so there's no need for him to pay towards another holiday, I'd agree if your DH wasn't contributing 50/50 but he is. It's time to have that talk again and make sure he gets the message this time.

Nanaof1 · 11/01/2024 07:44

bellsbuss · 10/01/2024 13:06

This needs to stop , they have holidays with you so your DH shouldn't be contributing for his ex to take them away as well. Also I think she's been very cheeky to just book holidays and then ask for money she should have checked first that the amount she needed was ok. Your DH needs to tell her asap before she books another.

Thank you. The ex isn't just booking a holiday close by or a day's drive. Instead, she decides to take them to Disneyland and of course, she cannot afford it. OP's DH should have said "no" at that time and that he would take the children to Disneyland so he could watch them enjoy it.

Sunandsea26 · 11/01/2024 07:33

I think they should stop. It’s not as if you’re not taking them away, each family pays to take them away I would say!

Beentheredonethat123 · 11/01/2024 00:01

Stephy1024 · 09/01/2024 19:33

It's funny how people think just because he's been generous so far that he should continue to do so. Even though his circumstances have changed. If the ex complains that he doesn't pay for/towards her holidays then tell her you expect her to start paying towards yours too. Its only fair after all.

This

tinkertee · 10/01/2024 23:47

littlemousebigcheese · 10/01/2024 23:36

From your perspective I completely get it. She's settled, earning a decent salary, capable of paying for a holiday in theory.

On the other hand though; he's contributing to a child related cost. His children. They don't need a holiday, no. They won't die without one, sure. But they are used to it and he's not paying for his ex and her bf to go off on a jolly; he's paying TOWARDS his children going away with their mother. You have them 50% of the time and I'm not saying that isn't true but so often it ends up being slightly different to reality - they share a room at yours because their 'real' home is with their mum, you get holidays and weekends whilst she has the mundane day to day, mum does the mental load of life admin, school admin, emotional labour etc. if you have them half the time but she's doing majority of the unseen labour that keeps everything ticking over, it isn't 50/50 etc

I'm not saying any of that is true by the way, just that it could be, and could explain why she thinks it's an ok set up.

Where are you getting your info from? The parents share 50:50. No maintenance is paid as there's an equal split. How does that equate to the DH getting weekend and holidays and the mum having all the mental load?
You've literally made that up!

littlemousebigcheese · 10/01/2024 23:36

From your perspective I completely get it. She's settled, earning a decent salary, capable of paying for a holiday in theory.

On the other hand though; he's contributing to a child related cost. His children. They don't need a holiday, no. They won't die without one, sure. But they are used to it and he's not paying for his ex and her bf to go off on a jolly; he's paying TOWARDS his children going away with their mother. You have them 50% of the time and I'm not saying that isn't true but so often it ends up being slightly different to reality - they share a room at yours because their 'real' home is with their mum, you get holidays and weekends whilst she has the mundane day to day, mum does the mental load of life admin, school admin, emotional labour etc. if you have them half the time but she's doing majority of the unseen labour that keeps everything ticking over, it isn't 50/50 etc

I'm not saying any of that is true by the way, just that it could be, and could explain why she thinks it's an ok set up.

Teder · 10/01/2024 22:54

cremebrulait · 10/01/2024 21:19

I really hate this when I hear it from people I know. A woman meets a man who already has a child and then has a child with him. Some time gors by and she starts to be territorial about what he gives HER when its OUR money, house etc.

OP when he left DC’s mum he made a commitment to his child via their mum to help support their holidays.

I say this as a single parent. Why does another grown woman who decided to have a kid with man get to change the commitment he has made to his first child or children? You knew what you were getting into before you got into bed.

The child did not. The end.

I’m sure the children won’t be adversely affected by having “only” one holiday per year as opposed to two. Some children don’t have any holidays because parents cannot afford it! This is a terribly MN post.

Takenoprisoner · 10/01/2024 21:25

op i agree with you. No one is owed a holiday, and the children go on holiday with their dad and you, so they're not missing out. But why are you arguing about it on here when you should be having this conversation/argument with your husband?

cremebrulait · 10/01/2024 21:19

I really hate this when I hear it from people I know. A woman meets a man who already has a child and then has a child with him. Some time gors by and she starts to be territorial about what he gives HER when its OUR money, house etc.

OP when he left DC’s mum he made a commitment to his child via their mum to help support their holidays.

I say this as a single parent. Why does another grown woman who decided to have a kid with man get to change the commitment he has made to his first child or children? You knew what you were getting into before you got into bed.

The child did not. The end.

belgiumchocolates · 10/01/2024 20:33

It sounds like ex is CF who still has OP's DH wrapped round her little finger.

I agree with you OP it needs to stop. If DH wants to give the kids holiday pocket money that is a normal thing to do. But the cost of the holiday should be for ex to pay. She needs to save and also choose somewhere within her own budget same as OP has to do.

HamBone · 10/01/2024 20:28

Lollypop701 · 10/01/2024 20:22

Save the ex holiday money for court costs for access… at least that’s a one off.

basically you’ve accepted this for x years so it’s easier to moan at you and pay than face the ex… who is fully aware that if she shouts he will cave. So it’s now or never imo

@Lollypop701 Although I imagine the children are older now so access may not be an issue. You can’t really stop a teenager from seeing their parent.