Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say to DH that these payments to his ex should stop now?

505 replies

yardandbard · 09/01/2024 19:16

When me and DH first met he has a set up with his ex (who was single at the time and on a lower wage) where he'd contribute towards her going on holiday every year with their children. There was no maintenance paid as they've always done 50:50 but he used to pay towards her holidays.

We've now been together for nearly 6 years and this is still ongoing. Its not just expected and imo should stop. DH has made suggestions before in the past that it stops but it's always met with complaints and kick offs and to keep the peace he ends up carrying on for another year.

The ex is now with someone else herself and has been for a couple of years, we also have joint DC to think about too, a bigger home than before etc etc.. all meaning spare money isn't as easily found as it was before. Its not that it's not affordable but more that the money could be used for more important things for OUR family and in my opinion she should now be supporting her own holidays with her own job and partner if she wants to go away, I've always thought the arrangement was odd and a bit cheeky but I lived with it at first. Now I just think it's ridiculous.

Aibu to say to DH this really needs to stop now? He'll agree with me as he's wanted to stop for a while but I know she'll likely moan she can't go away with the children otherwise so it's just about getting him to keep saying no despite the fall out.

OP posts:
AcrossthePond55 · 09/01/2024 21:43

@yardandbard

You say 'the ex is with someone else now' but has her financial picture actually changed? She may 'be with' someone but that doesn't mean they have joint finances OR that this 'someone' is willing to foot the holiday bill for her children. Obvs your DH shouldn't subsidize this new 'someone', but if his ex is in the same financial situation I don't see why the arrangement should stop, although perhaps what he pays should.

Exactly what does he pay for? Is it a percentage of the total holiday (unreasonable if a partner is going) or does he pay a percentage of the children's actual costs (not unreasonable if a partner is going). And are the holidays the ex + kids take comparable to what you all take with the DSC? I think your DH is very nice to want his ex to have holidays with their children. But if they're spending 2 weeks on the French Riviera and you're spending a week camping in Cornwall, then that needs to change. But if you want them to have a week camping in Cornwall so you can spend 2 weeks on the French Riviera, I think that's mean.

The bottom line is though, that it's your DH's decision. I know you have joint finances so if you don't want any of 'your money' subsidizing this, then you'll have to separate finances or he can start a savings account and deposit money from his paycheck to pay for the holidays. Either way though, he'll have to still be able to meet his share of the regular household & family expenses.

853ax · 09/01/2024 21:39

How does it work does he contribute X amount a year for holiday or does she book a holiday and send him on receipt?
Guess he could say money tight from next year I'm going to give X towards kids holiday. A reduced amount that would cover kids portion.

AliceOlive · 09/01/2024 21:37

I would encourage the generosity. You may find yourself in her shoes one day.

Tinseltiss · 09/01/2024 21:35

So obvious reading this who’s a ex of a man who’s a new wife and who’s here to read and support 😂

I’m on the side of putting the children first and they should get to holiday with their mum if it isn’t financially able to happen without his support. Im a single mum and my child’s dad doesn’t pay but he walks rounf in designer and stuff so my kids miss out whilst he looks swaggey😂 I’d love someone who supports me to take them on holiday and if I had that and his new wife tried to stop it I’d be cross but it all depends on if she’s living in a nice house bug garden working her socks off and he’s just giving money or if she needs his help to get to have a holiday and I think you met a keeper who really cares about his kids and you should accept him for that x

jollygreenpea · 09/01/2024 21:35

I understand why this started, the ex was a single parent on a low wage.
Now she has a partner as well, if she has a low wage that's on her.

When this started 7 years ago I get the impression that he paid for most of the holiday while the ex paid a small amount, based on the information above.

He already pays 50% of all other costs, it's time to stop the holiday payment.

JudgeJ · 09/01/2024 21:32

C1N1C · 09/01/2024 21:30

I would be OK if he paid for his children's share... I.e. if she wanted to go on a holiday that was her, her partner and the kids... he should technically pay for 50% of each of his children... and maybe half of her's, but that's all.

Nothing of her holiday, why should he? The ex should be paying for her children's holidays with the OP's family.

coffeeaddict77 · 09/01/2024 21:32

Inkyblue123 · 09/01/2024 21:27

Mmm I’m not so sure. Is it really 50:50 ? Has she had to limit her career and earning potential to be the primary caregiver? If she earns significantly less than your DH becouse of the kids then I’m afraid that he should be contributing more towards their costs. Also he is not paying for her holiday - but the kids. In any case it’s between the two of them really

She hasn't been the primary caregiver for many years if the children have only been with her 50% of the time.

5128gap · 09/01/2024 21:31

StoppitRightNow · 09/01/2024 21:18

They go on holiday with their dad. Why should he pay for both his and the mother’s holidays?

No one said he 'should' just that he might be a particularly nice dad who is happy to, because that way his DC get to enjoy an extra holiday with their mum. Being a parent isn't just ticking off a list of the minimum you SHOULD do and not a thing more, is it? Sometimes parents like to do bit more for their DC, and aren't that fussed if that means an ex inadvertently benefits, because the priority is the DCs happiness.

Alicesmagicmushroom · 09/01/2024 21:31

@HunterHearstHelmsley well I disagree

HunterHearstHelmsley · 09/01/2024 21:31

Alicesmagicmushroom · 09/01/2024 21:29

@HunterHearstHelmsley but that’s not the agreement so entirely irrelevant to the discussion.

It's absolutely relevant when the discussion is about whether the payments should stop.

Abbimae · 09/01/2024 21:31

He pays for half the kids cost surely not half the whole?

JudgeJ · 09/01/2024 21:30

Terrrence · 09/01/2024 21:24

I don't think it's generous. I don't think paying for your family to go on holiday every year after you move out and move on and start another family counts as bare minimum.

As they have a 50'/50 split it's hardly a 'bare minimum', there are a lot of grabby ex wives on here tonight. Not only is it generous, it's crazy, the ex contributes nothing to her children's holidays with their father, she's doing very well.

C1N1C · 09/01/2024 21:30

I would be OK if he paid for his children's share... I.e. if she wanted to go on a holiday that was her, her partner and the kids... he should technically pay for 50% of each of his children... and maybe half of her's, but that's all.

Alicesmagicmushroom · 09/01/2024 21:29

@HunterHearstHelmsley but that’s not the agreement so entirely irrelevant to the discussion.

HunterHearstHelmsley · 09/01/2024 21:28

Terrrence · 09/01/2024 21:24

I don't think it's generous. I don't think paying for your family to go on holiday every year after you move out and move on and start another family counts as bare minimum.

Yeah, the ex has moved on and has a new partner. She should be doing the bare minimum and contributing to the holiday that her children take with their father.

Inkyblue123 · 09/01/2024 21:27

Mmm I’m not so sure. Is it really 50:50 ? Has she had to limit her career and earning potential to be the primary caregiver? If she earns significantly less than your DH becouse of the kids then I’m afraid that he should be contributing more towards their costs. Also he is not paying for her holiday - but the kids. In any case it’s between the two of them really

Alicesmagicmushroom · 09/01/2024 21:27

@Hayliebells makes absolute sense to me!

PumpkinsAndCoconuts · 09/01/2024 21:26

Maray1967 · 09/01/2024 19:34

The only way I think this might be fair is if it was the case that her earning potential was damaged by how they arranged childcare when they were together and if she is earning less than she might have been able to because her career is on a slower path. If that’s the case she might have a point.

If not, then I don’t see why this needs to go on - after he’s given fair warning.

Isn’t the earning potential of a majority of women damaged in some way due to pregnancy, childbirth, maternity leave and childcare (even if it is a „fair“ childcare arrangement)?

I am not saying the OP‘s DH should continue to pay. But even „just“ pregnancy, childbirth and mat leave without any additional childcare have the potential to disrupt a career. Especially if it’s a repeated occurrence (OP wrote about children)…

Dweetfidilove · 09/01/2024 21:26

My ex still funds holidays I take our daughter on because he’s a generous man and the most important thing to him, is that she has many and varied experiences.

He also hasn’t presented a partner or other children this may bother, so no problems there.

How old are the children now, OP? Is there likely to be many more years of this? The fact he hasn’t stopped it despite saying he wants to, suggests he is just making the right noises for you, but has no real intention of discontinuing this contribution.

Hayliebells · 09/01/2024 21:25

I may get flamed for this, but I do think that when a couple decide to have children, if one is a significantly lower earner and their earning potential has been or will be limited by having children, when they split the higher earner does have some ongoing financial obligation, even if they split care 50/50. The sensible thing would be to marry, so that a proper divorce arrangement can be put in place, but in the absence of that I don't think it's unreasonable for your DH to contine to support his ex financially in some way. Did his ex take any time off work or work part time when the children were small, which affected her career? That's all relevant imo. If a child free couple split, it's not difficult for a lower earner to adjust to the financial consequences of that, they can work to earn more and improve their circumstances. But kids make that so much more difficult, and often the lower earners career has been impacted by having kids. Given the decision to have children was a joint one when the couples income was shared running a single home, I don't think it's unreasonable for the higher earner to help mitigate some of the financial consequences if a split, and the costs that come with running two households, even if they don't legally have to. The lower earner presumably didn't think they'd be a single parent shouldering the costs of running a household that's appropriate for two children when they decided to have them, and they might have made a different decision had they known what was to come. Contributing to a holiday is hardly a fortune in the grand scheme of things.

lazyarse123 · 09/01/2024 21:25

I can't believe pp think he should be paying for his ex wife to have "quality" with their children. That's literally her job. It sounds like he provides at least half if not more than he legally and morally has to. How many children get more than one holiday a year? Not many I bet.

TooMuchRedMaybe · 09/01/2024 21:24

StoppitRightNow · 09/01/2024 21:17

Nope. They have them 50%.

You can still get child maintenance if the incomes are not the same between the exes. Since the childrens mother has a low income it’s quite possible she is owed maintenance that he isn’t paying so a contribution towards a holiday might be fair.

Terrrence · 09/01/2024 21:24

I don't think it's generous. I don't think paying for your family to go on holiday every year after you move out and move on and start another family counts as bare minimum.

Alicesmagicmushroom · 09/01/2024 21:18

It doesn’t affect her finances if he’s paying out of his income for his children to spend quality time with their mother.

Some real misers on here, it’s sad.

This appears to be a pre-existing agreement and good on the dad for honouring that.

StoppitRightNow · 09/01/2024 21:18

5128gap · 09/01/2024 21:15

What exactly does he pay OP? Because there's a world of difference between him paying for his ex, her new partner and the DC to go on holiday, and paying a 'contribution' towards the costs of his own DC having a holiday. If he's better off than her its a nice gesture to cover the DCs costs (even though he also pays for their holiday with him) as it enables his DC to have a holiday with their mum they wouldn't otherwise have, its being a good dad.

They go on holiday with their dad. Why should he pay for both his and the mother’s holidays?