Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say to DH that these payments to his ex should stop now?

505 replies

yardandbard · 09/01/2024 19:16

When me and DH first met he has a set up with his ex (who was single at the time and on a lower wage) where he'd contribute towards her going on holiday every year with their children. There was no maintenance paid as they've always done 50:50 but he used to pay towards her holidays.

We've now been together for nearly 6 years and this is still ongoing. Its not just expected and imo should stop. DH has made suggestions before in the past that it stops but it's always met with complaints and kick offs and to keep the peace he ends up carrying on for another year.

The ex is now with someone else herself and has been for a couple of years, we also have joint DC to think about too, a bigger home than before etc etc.. all meaning spare money isn't as easily found as it was before. Its not that it's not affordable but more that the money could be used for more important things for OUR family and in my opinion she should now be supporting her own holidays with her own job and partner if she wants to go away, I've always thought the arrangement was odd and a bit cheeky but I lived with it at first. Now I just think it's ridiculous.

Aibu to say to DH this really needs to stop now? He'll agree with me as he's wanted to stop for a while but I know she'll likely moan she can't go away with the children otherwise so it's just about getting him to keep saying no despite the fall out.

OP posts:
Grimchmas · 09/01/2024 22:34

Is she on any higher income than before, and has her partner moved in?

Either way he ought to contribute to that family's holidays, and it ought to be 50/50 or close between those two adults. Your DH could chuck them £100 spending money for the kids if he wants to maintain a good will gesture but I do agree with you that it is time to stop. She needs to cut her cloth according to her means and if that means a cheaper holiday, so be it.

And OF COURSE she was going to complain about it, he's taking something away from her - that doesn't mean that the right thing to do is to back down.

Mumof118 · 09/01/2024 22:34

Utterly ridiculous. Screw keeping the peace and just say no.

Teder · 09/01/2024 22:34

MN is soooooo anti step mum but I’m a step mum who thinks YANBU. If he’s loaded and mum doesn’t have much, helping out for a holiday is a lovely thing to do. However, if it is not financially viable for the whole family, it needs to stop. It’s been over 7 years! The children get a holiday so they’re not missing out, not that having a holiday is an essential.

JudgeJ · 09/01/2024 22:31

Basically, she's doing him a favour for entertaining/considering the kids like that and should get some renumeration.

Presumably the holiday will be in her 50% of the time so no favour involved. Should he be remunerated for entertaining/considering the 'kids' when he takes them on holiday?

Clearinguptheclutter · 09/01/2024 22:31

Nah unless they wouldn’t go on holiday otherwise he needs to stop.

you pay for taking them on holiday with you.
she (and perhaps her new DP) pays for taking them on holiday with her!

jollygreenpea · 09/01/2024 22:30

Sorry I have just re read all of the op posts, and now I'm not sure they do live with the op and DH half the time.

AnneValentine · 09/01/2024 22:29

StoppitRightNow · 09/01/2024 21:17

Nope. They have them 50%.

Assuming that’s true it doesn’t mean maintenance isn’t payable.

littlemousebigcheese · 09/01/2024 22:28

Are they with you 50% of the time?

DeeLusional · 09/01/2024 22:25

No maintainance you say, 50-50 you say, do you mean he has them half the time? If not and he pays no maintainance he should be in jail.

jollygreenpea · 09/01/2024 22:24

K37529

From the op

He pays half of everything they need always has. He probably even pays a little more on paper than her as he pays for phone contracts too for both. I don't have a problem with any of that. But I do think 7+ years on is time to start funding your own holidays. I feel like we're essentially sending another family on holiday every year (she has a partner now who goes!). We don't have anyone paying for ours, we work hard and save for it like other people have to. And because of this have to save that bit harder for our own holidays knowing we've got to fork out for hers too.

They also live with their father and the op 50% so yes he is paying 50% of their food, rent, bills etc as well.

caringcarer · 09/01/2024 22:24

IncompleteSenten · 09/01/2024 19:20

He should say to her that from now on he'll pay for the holidays he takes his children on and she can pay for the holidays she takes them on. Perhaps suggest they alternate years.

A good compromise. Suggest you take his DC on holiday this summer.

Lantyslee · 09/01/2024 22:22

YANBU. There's no need for your DH to pay. It's up to the ex what she choses to do with them when she's looking after them. The DC are getting a holiday with you, if the ex can also afford to do something with them then it's a bonus but not essential.

ThomasinaLivesHere · 09/01/2024 22:17

I think giving her a year’s notice is fair.

GuinnessBird · 09/01/2024 22:09

I'd continue to pay, for a £10 Sun holiday.

K37529 · 09/01/2024 22:00

When you say he pays 50% of everything they need, do you mean he's paying half their rent, bills, food cost, etc or do you mean he pays half for things like clothes, school stuff etc? Obviously if he is paying half their bills then he should not be paying for her to go on holiday. If he's only paying half of their expenses like clothes etc then he probably should keep paying for the holiday, unless custody is split 50/50? More info and what he's actually paying for is needed here

confusedaboutclothes · 09/01/2024 21:59

Some of the replies here are madness!!

You’re OH pays 50% and more for the children, they never go without by the sounds of things yet some people are still suggesting it’s reasonable for him to contribute towards a holiday for them and his ex. WHAT?!!
Im sorry but a holiday is lovely but it’s not a given right they should be entitled to one - if all their needs are met then it stops there!

Sweetglossy · 09/01/2024 21:59

@yardandbard

How many kids does ex have?
How much is father paying fir holidays?
anything up to £1000 or £2000 a year, is fine.

£5k-£7K a year, only if DP earns enough to support that.

so his earnings and how much he sends each year.

because op is being cagey, i believe it is a sum that is just good for op to have, but doesn't cripple dp financially.

too many useless words and no figures. ex's salary, dp salary- those 2 remain relevant for as long as they share kids unless father wants to be selfish.

Realdeal1 · 09/01/2024 21:58

@yardandbard your partner sounds very generous but sometimes people like this are played for fools and just can't/havent got the courage to change things. I dated a guy who contributed 1K for child maintenance for one child. He should have paid about 300 but he felt guilty about the breakup (his depression). He and ex get on well but it's blatantly obvious he funds their lifestyle/holidays etc even though now he doesn't earn that much plus lived very frugally. I thought it was mad as I got 350 for two kids!

Anyway, he always said he wanted his child to be happy and that meant giving the mum a lot. Maybe your DH feels this way too. If it affected my own kids, I'd get him to explain to her that you haven't got much yourself now so need to reduce it down.

Goldbar · 09/01/2024 21:57

How old are the kids? Are family holidays really so great for the adults?

Might just be me, but I find holidays with kids stressful and hard work. I'd happily pay someone else to take my kids on holiday if I could and give them all the holiday experiences without having to do it myself. It might be that your husband sees it this way - his kids are having a great experience and he's not having to make any effort for it.

Viviennemary · 09/01/2024 21:55

It is commendable he still cares about his ex and his children. Stop being so selfish.

C1N1C · 09/01/2024 21:55

JudgeJ · 09/01/2024 21:32

Nothing of her holiday, why should he? The ex should be paying for her children's holidays with the OP's family.

I thought about this and felt that the kids can't technically travel alone.

He should pay for half the kids' costs (flight, food, hotel split etc)

He COULD also pay for the added costs and time that mum is putting in to keep them more entertained on holiday than she might otherwise be doing at home.

But as it is also a holiday for her, she shouldn't be getting it for free... she should at least pay half her way.

Basically, she's doing him a favour for entertaining/considering the kids like that and should get some renumeration.

(My view)

TooMuchRedMaybe · 09/01/2024 21:53

The easiest would be if she just claimed child maintenance and put that money aside monthly for holidays. I am sure she is owed something if she on a low income. Even if he’s on £50k a year he should pay her £230/month, that’s nearly £3k per year.

Ponderingwindow · 09/01/2024 21:52

I’m coming at it with the same bias as aliceolive. Even with 50:50 custody, a higher earner would be expected to pay maintenance where I live. Depending on the salary disparity, the maintenance could be substantial.

instead this father just pays for a holiday once a year. Seems like a bargain.

cadburyegg · 09/01/2024 21:46

YANBU and I say this as an ex wife / single mum. You don't say how much the contribution is but perhaps suggest reducing it on a sliding scale so it's not such a big shock. Say this year he could pay 75% of what he'd normally pay, next year 50%, following year 25%, then 0%. This gives her time to prepare for the shortfall.

DorisDoesDoncaster · 09/01/2024 21:43

The ex should pay for herself, your husband could pay 50% for each child but he doesn’t have to. Holidays away are a luxury, not a necessity. No child has ever died from not going away for a holiday.