Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you push for an ASD diagnosis when a teenager doesn’t want to

34 replies

Whenyourefifteen · 09/01/2024 14:28

DS is 15 (year 11) and absolutely adamant he doesn’t want any support at school because he doesn’t want to be ‘treated differently’ and is worried about stigma and bullying. I think a diagnosis would open up access to a lot of support but DS is adamant he doesn’t want to. I’ve been told informally by many people (including professionals) since he’s turned 13 that they suspect he’s got ASD and I’m sure he fits the criteria. Aibu to ask for your opinion?
YABU- yes push for a diagnosis against DS’s wishes
YANBU- No leave him to his own choice

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Flensburg · 09/01/2024 18:35

I had a lot of support at uni because of diagnosis and have support workers funded by social services because of it and so do other people I know. So it may open doors to support as an adult.
I would discuss with him putting his name down for assessment, with the agreement that he can decline to go through with it when it comes up if he wants to.

120GSM · 09/01/2024 18:25

I don’t think you can do it without his consent at his age. I’d ask him if he’d give consent to go on the list so he can move up whilst thinking about it. Explain other students would never need to know at school

My dd was diagnosed at 17 and got her EHCP at 18. It helps in several areas and an EHCP lasts until 25. Am ASC diagnosis may lead to an ADHD diagnosis too.Areas differ re adult support after. Ours provides work shops and support groups

Phuketponderings · 09/01/2024 18:19

An EHCP would be entitle them to education up to the age of 25 years

WhatNoUsername · 09/01/2024 17:59

Regulus · 09/01/2024 14:33

a diagnosis will open up a lot of support

If this is the only reason you are doing it then I wouldn't bother.

There is no support with just a diagnosis and little support with a EHCP, and you won't get one of those it time for it to even be a tiny bit useful.

Also at nearly 16 I think you have to take into account his feelings. Maybe if a diagnosis would significantly change things I'd feel differently but it won't. He will still have the same troubles.

My DS got tons of support with a diagnosis (private at that!) but no EHCP. It's a bit of a "postcode lottery" as to what you can access with just a diagnosis. Some people as you say barely access the right support with an EHCP.

However as a minimum it doesn't cost a school much to put in place accommodations around homework, time out cards, use of laptop, exam adjustments etc etc and they are often on board with this type of thing as improves the child's behaviour and exam chances.

You should be able to access charitable support with a diagnosis - In my area there are support groups for parents and groups for children/teens if appropriate. And it make things like applying for disability benefits easier.

If he's applying uni in the future he can access a DSA with just a diagnosis.

And you can get reasonable adjustments at work and elsewhere with a diagnosis. My DS got his job via a disability scheme with just a diagnosis. They aren't worthless.

Your DS is worried about bullying and stigma? How is that going for him currently. Personally I found that my DS was bullied much more before his diagnosis, once he was diagnosed and accommodations and support were put in place he calmed down a lot and coped better, he attracted less unwanted attention and was able to form some friendships.

Personally your son is only 15. He doesn't know what's best for him so I think you need to decide for him. Although forcing him at this age is likely to be counterproductive, so I would just try to persuade him focussing on the benefits to him. How much easier it will make things for him if he has accommodations in place now or in the future. And no one has to know anyway. Why does he think his peers will find out? He doesn't have to tell them if he doesn't want to.

Amplissimo · 09/01/2024 17:24

A couple of possibly relevant points:

He may change his mind later. Waiting lists for an autism assessment can be very long. Depending where you are in this process, and whether or not you plan to go private, then it could be worth staying on the waiting list and seeing how he feels when his turn finally comes up.

Getting an ASD diagnosis doesn't come with a neon badge that you have to wear at all times. If he doesn't tell his friends, then nobody else will. The list of who has to be informed is extremely small.

Getting labelled and singled out (or bullied) isn't just for diagnosed people. It can and does happen to anyone who seems outside the "normal" range. Which, frankly, is probably him. A diagnosis can get you better tools and support for dealing with it, though.

An ASD diagnosis can be extremely helpful if you're going to university, as others here have mentioned.

Hotchocolate2023 · 09/01/2024 17:00

At 15, if he doesn't want it that is his choice to make. No medical professional will go against his wishes. It's a moot point.

ntmdino · 09/01/2024 16:59

Regulus · 09/01/2024 16:03

@ntmdino I'm glad to hear that, I shield have said I was thinking in a school sense. However all the things you mentioned probably don't need a diagnosis- I can't imagine any of those scenarios asking for proof. It relies on you being willing to share the details which the teen doesn't want to do.

Ultimately I think it has to be your decision as the adult, but trying to force an older teen to get one isn't going to be easy.

I don't think it is the adults decision at 15, providing gillick competent.

There are scenarios where I've provided proof on the basis that the person I'm dealing with isn't convinced - that does happen, especially when the masking is strong that day, and it sucks when it's necessary; it's very difficult to convince someone that yes, I look totally normal, but we're entering a context where I know it could go wrong.

One was a police incident; the transition from "masking enough to appear neurotypical" to "can't mask this" looks to a police officer very much like the shift from "I'm fooling them!" to "downright suspicious". I have enough awareness of myself and confidence in my diagnosis to be completely up-front about it; it took some time to get there, however, and get past the ego-bruising fact that my mask isn't absolute and perfect. I keep my diagnosis report on my phone for exactly this kind of circumstance; it's pretty well-known that you can't rely on the police to treat autistic folk with dignity without them being forced to.

Another was my employer - a couple of us in the same team both had diagnoses, but the other one refused to disclose it to anyone but me. He ended up being fired for, essentially, autistic behaviour and he preferred to lose his job and get paid for his notice period than tell them (that put me in shitty position, since I was nominally his boss, but his disclosure to me was strictly personal and he explicitly told me it wasn't to be used in a professional context). When I disclosed my diagnosis to them, I could see exactly why - their attitude was awful - so I simply sent them the diagnosis report along with a summary of the relevant parts of the Equality Act. I only lasted a year in that job, mainly because it was a very hostile environment, but still...I had a concrete example of what the environment would've looked like had I not been able to smack them over the head with it.

Which is all to say...yes, you're right that proof isn't always required in many of those situations, but having the option of producing it can be very useful and can actually avoid situations which can deteriorate fast.

It's very true what another poster said, that his primary concern is the social implications - and that's not necessarily wrong. If he is autistic, then his life up to this point has been 90% about blending in, and making sure nobody sees the differences he can see from the inside. It's very, very difficult to get out of that mindset and forgive yourself for all the things about you that you think are "wrong" instead of "different". Hell, I went through this in my 40s and without the raging hormones of the teen years, and it still took me two years to be convinced that I should seek assessment. I'm absolutely glad that I did, though; it's changed my life, and not just in terms of the accommodations I can get if I feel I need them.

Just as an idea, maybe it might help him to actually speak to folk with a formal diagnosis, to see how they feel they've seen the benefits? That could be a bit less adversarial than a parent telling him he should do it...there are probably local charities who have group meetings that might be appropriate for that.

beetr00 · 09/01/2024 16:29

@Whenyourefifteen respect your son's wishes, he may very well change his mind at a later date.

There is a huge amount of support online which you could access together.

This is just one such site

community.autism.org.uk/f/mental-health-and-wellbeing/35299/why-is-school-so-hard

surlycurly · 09/01/2024 16:22

As a parent you can make a clear stand if you feel it's beneficial- that doesn't question Gillick competency but relates to your position on the matter with your child. I chose to support my son's decision, but I know others that haven't. They've had solid reasons for doing so. It's not just a matter of competency but maturity. The decision for this teen is based on social issues and not wanting to be different. That is not a reason to not get a diagnosis if it is in the overall best interest of the child.

GreatAuntMaude · 09/01/2024 16:20

Crazycatlady79 · 09/01/2024 16:12

If you think a diagnosis will open avenues of support, you clearly haven't done your research.

At his age, the decision should be his, not yours.

Everyone is being very cynical but actually a diagnosis does make a difference, even if not in "one to one support in class".

A diagnosed condition means exam special arrangements are covered by equality act reasonable adjustments and much easier to arrange.
It means he can go on to get DSA much more easily at uni if he wants to go - this can be really helpful and the difference between succeeding at uni or not. He could also get priority quiet housing etc.
He would also be entitled more easily in adulthood to workplace adjustments, again via equality act.

Most importantly a diagnosis is important to understand who you are and who your community is.

willingtolearn · 09/01/2024 16:18

Echoing others.

We had a diagnosis at 11 to re-enter secondary school. It wasn't easy but it meant the school viewed them as 'having a problem' rather than 'being a problem'

Around 14 they totally rejected the diagnosis, refused all help and support and have done so ever since.

It has made university life (who have no idea of diagnosis) particularly difficult and the only support accepted is from us. Independent living has also proved tricky and the whole process of finding and working a job is also going to need some help.

Not that there is much support out there as far I could tell - you get given the diagnosis letter, some leaflets and off you go. It's very much up to you to hunt down support and find out if it works for you.

Crazycatlady79 · 09/01/2024 16:12

If you think a diagnosis will open avenues of support, you clearly haven't done your research.

At his age, the decision should be his, not yours.

Mariposistaa · 09/01/2024 16:10

At this age you can't force him.

Regulus · 09/01/2024 16:03

@ntmdino I'm glad to hear that, I shield have said I was thinking in a school sense. However all the things you mentioned probably don't need a diagnosis- I can't imagine any of those scenarios asking for proof. It relies on you being willing to share the details which the teen doesn't want to do.

Ultimately I think it has to be your decision as the adult, but trying to force an older teen to get one isn't going to be easy.

I don't think it is the adults decision at 15, providing gillick competent.

surlycurly · 09/01/2024 16:03

And a diagnosis doesn't mean that you can't parent him as someone with ASD, or that the school can't support him accordingly. It's widely accepted in my family, and at my son's school, that he is undiagnosed ASD. He gets alternative arrangements for exams and his head of year is great. We've also worked with the Ed psych at the school for school refusing and selective mutism, both common with kids with ASD. He accepts it to a degree himself, just doesn't want to formalise it. It is tough though, good luck with whatever you/ he decide.

Whatevs23 · 09/01/2024 15:51

I don't know that an ASD diagnosis would open up a lot of support. The reason I would want it for my child would be because the more knowledge a person has about their neurodiversity the better. It just helps in understanding struggles and behaviors. But at his age I think it has to be his decision.

iPreferBooks · 09/01/2024 15:47

I'm 24 and recently diagnosed. Didn't have any support at gcse's or A level. It sometimes takes the effort of trying to 'manage everything' to notice that something was actually wrong. By then the demand of trying to keep up with my effort wasn't balanced.

Basically college was a complete nightmare and I dropped out of A Levels to do something coursework based. I'm now at uni and have appropriate acommodations/adjustments in place.

I don't think you can force him to get diagnosed if he doesn't think anything is wrong, although if he does use something like Tiktok or youtube it might be worth encouraging him to watch some ones that might be relatable to him.

TheCountessofFitzdotterel · 09/01/2024 15:38

Our ds is 17 and we are doing it in preparation for university (if he manages university). School have been great about supporting him without a diagnosis but this is unlikely to be true of bigger institutions where the key people won’t know him as well and who may be less flexible in their procedures.

We are doing it privately (CAMHS wanted us to after a mental health crisis but it took 6 months to even officially get on the waiting list for NHS) and ds thinks it’s a waste of money but is going along with it to humour us. Obviously if he was adamant we wouldn’t- couldn’t, as I have said above. However he is coming round to the idea there might be some point.

ntmdino · 09/01/2024 15:25

Regulus · 09/01/2024 14:33

a diagnosis will open up a lot of support

If this is the only reason you are doing it then I wouldn't bother.

There is no support with just a diagnosis and little support with a EHCP, and you won't get one of those it time for it to even be a tiny bit useful.

Also at nearly 16 I think you have to take into account his feelings. Maybe if a diagnosis would significantly change things I'd feel differently but it won't. He will still have the same troubles.

Actually, you might be surprised - my experience since diagnosis is only as an adult, but it's quite surprising how much is actually out there. There are the charity groups, but also things like guided walkthroughs at airports, call centres being more patient etc. Hell, even restaurants are willing to bend a bit and find quiet tables for us, and all of these are happy to be discreet about it.

@Whenyourefifteen - it could be worth pointing these things out to him, suggesting that the benefits of a formal diagnosis extend past the school environment...not least, because it'll allow him to forgive himself for the ways in which he feels like some sort of weird alien (that's my terminology for myself as a child...I wouldn't suggest using that with him unless he's described himself as such, obviously).

There's also the fact that, given a formal diagnosis, he doesn't actually need to act on it with the school - he can just keep it in his back pocket as an emergency "Hey, teacher, I'm really struggling with sensory issues today, could I be excused to the quiet room for a bit?" option. The school will almost certainly be glad that he doesn't require constant accommodations if that was the case, and as such I'm sure they'd be happy to work it in.

Personally, if he's thinking of going to university, I'd absolutely recommend it - when I lost my familiar environment and friends group in the transition to university, I completely fell apart both academically and as a human being. Even if he doesn't want anything from it now, the time may come when he really needs it...and the waiting lists being what they are, by the time he does need it, it'll be too late. So maybe you could sell it to him as future insurance, just in case?

The fact is, though, it's extremely difficult to formally diagnose an uncooperative patient - so your only real options are to sell him on the benefits, wait until he comes to the conclusion he wants to do it, or not do it at all.

surlycurly · 09/01/2024 15:19

My 19 yr old DD absolutely had to get her diagnosis. She needed it and she wanted it. My 17 yr old DS is adamant he doesn't want a diagnosis, despite being obviously ASD. It would have made no difference to him positively, and he's achieved what he wanted to at school to date without one. I respected his wishes despite feeling like we should pursue it. The field he wants to go in to will be quite accommodating of his 'quirks'. My daughter, on the other hand, has wanted lots of support through school and uni and immediately tells people about her diagnosis. I think it depends on the person and the circumstances. Ultimately I think it has to be your decision as the adult, but trying to force an older teen to get one isn't going to be easy.

CatPancake · 09/01/2024 15:12

Yes push for a diagnosis.

but stop talking about it. Appointments are few and far between that the child will be involved in

anothernamechangeagainsndagain · 09/01/2024 15:11

No at 15 I wouldn't because if someone has reached teen years without diagnosis, the amount of support is likely to be tiny if not zero - diagnosis doesn't equal support

Catza · 09/01/2024 15:09

No point. The support simply isn't there especially for adults (and he will be one by the time he gets an appointment). Most services operate on assess and discharge basis.

blackteaplease · 09/01/2024 15:04

First pp has nailed it. A diagnoses makes no difference with support. SEN provision should be made on a needs basis but if your dc is rejecting all support I'm not sure what you can do.

TheCountessofFitzdotterel · 09/01/2024 14:50

You can’t physically force him to do it because you can’t make him turn up to appointments or talk. However with waiting lists the length they are there’s a good chance he will have changed his mind by the time he reaches the top. Get him put on the list and you can always cancel later.