Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Bratty children and presents

279 replies

BrandySnaps1 · 09/01/2024 13:38

Gave my niece (through marriage) a Christmas present. Shes 14. Obsessed with make up, hair, and because of her dad, loves designer. Shes spoilt. 5* holidays, bags, you name it, shes got it or at least wants it.

Gave her some makeup items and she was SO disappointed. She opened it and the look on her face said it all. She expected Armani make up and i got her Boots items. Either way since when have pre-teens because so spoilt? Next time Im not even going to bother.

Anyone else experienced bratty children? How to handle them through gritted teeth. Shouldnt kids at least feign excitment?

OP posts:
ClumsyNinja · 09/01/2024 14:50

YABU.

You don’t like her dad, fair enough, but it’s unfair to despise your niece when her dad is the one teaching her that brand named material stuff matters.

My DS (14) isn’t into brand named clothing at all as we don’t encourage wasting money in that way, but I can see how some of his friends are a bit obsessed because that’s what their parents value. 🤷🏻‍♀️

Most children look up to their parents and accept what they’re told at face value at that age. Private schooling will also reinforce those values.

You admitted that she thanked you for the gift and that should be enough. You’re the grown up here so you need to act like one in this scenario and accept her thanks graciously even if you’re seething inside.

Also, as a mature adult, I wouldn’t be too pleased with Boots cosmetics as a gift as they make my skin itch. But then I find Aldi moisturises are perfectly fine. I usually buy gift cards for teens and let them make their own decisions.

BrandySnaps1 · 09/01/2024 14:49

chaosmaker · 09/01/2024 14:47

@BrandySnaps1 I'd avoid him and if he ever forced his opinion on me I'd say very condescendingly that his opinions are worthless or just laugh at him and say 'really?'. He sounds like he has banker syndrome....

Banker syndrome? do tell me more

OP posts:
NoCloudsAllowed · 09/01/2024 14:49

Somewhat tricky one. On the one hand - teenager wants nice things and doesn't know the value of money, stop the press. They buy into branding, I bet you wouldn't have wanted some Lily of the Valley perfume or something when you were young either.

On the other hand, there's no reason to be bratty. I'd buy her a copy of Pride and Prejudice for next year and tell her to be more Lizzie and less Lydia.

MzHz · 09/01/2024 14:49

EarringsandLipstick · 09/01/2024 14:33

Horrible. If you're talking about a child.

Either don't offer to exchange it, or do, and then do it.

Although I've DC myself, I always ask my god children / their parents what they'd like as I don't assume that what my DC like, they would too.

You’re kidding right? What BETTER way to show how real world reactions to ungrateful behaviour? It’s a very gentle lesson and one designed to actually register

@BrandySnaps1 if your sil etc don’t bother then you too can stop the gifts.

if sil says anything, remind her how she/her H never bother with your dc, and after the totally obvious lack of gratitude, you’re not going to keep on flogging a dead horse and buying gifts which are unreciprocated and ungratefully received.

your niece isn’t hard done by, she’s not going without, but nobody is entitled to your money or time if they can’t treat you with respect.

she’s old enough, her parents know she’s being rude and aren’t correcting it. So leave them to it.

why is it your job to buy your H family gifts anyway. Give him back the job (with a strict budget) if he’s that bothered.

drop the rope.

pyjamaphile · 09/01/2024 14:48

MeinKraft · 09/01/2024 13:45

Everyone knows teens are into whatever is trending on tik tok now, it was a bit of a thoughtless present. It's like your MIL (for example) giving you a Bayliss and Harding set (and then grumbling for weeks when you aren't overjoyed about it)

Yes, this.

BrandySnaps1 · 09/01/2024 14:48

krustykittens · 09/01/2024 14:44

Apologies, I read your OP wrong. I really would just take a step back. My BIL and SIL are very like this as well. They are not bad people but the constant bragging and competing over who owns what and how much it cost, is tedious. They live in a different country, though, so it is much easier for me to be polite and cordial. I keep myself busy when they visit my DH!

we live in differnet london boroughs which is equivalent to chalk and cheese. SIL isnt too much of a problem, its BIL. SIL is also completely controlled by him as she is a SAHM and relies on him financially.

and when she isnt relying on BIL, she is constantly calling my DH (her brother) to help her with any old problem she comes across. Maybe this goes deeper than the lack of gratitude for the present!😂

OP posts:
BoohooWoohoo · 09/01/2024 14:48

She’s the product of her upbringing. The Boots palette was never a good gift considering that she probably uses high end designer like Dior at home. If you don’t want to spend high end prices then stick some cash in a card so she can buy something that she wants. I guarantee that she will see this much better than a gift selected by you and it will be no hassle for you too.

chaosmaker · 09/01/2024 14:47

@BrandySnaps1 I'd avoid him and if he ever forced his opinion on me I'd say very condescendingly that his opinions are worthless or just laugh at him and say 'really?'. He sounds like he has banker syndrome....

herewegoroundthebastardbush · 09/01/2024 14:47

God you sound horrible. Bitter and snarky and judgmental about a little girl, just because you obviously hate her parents' guts and are jealous of what they have.

FrenchandSaunders · 09/01/2024 14:46

I can't stand this and I'm pleased my DDs have managed to fake complete joy over crap presents. Prob too much so to be honest.

BrandySnaps1 · 09/01/2024 14:44

ImCamembertTheBigCheese · 09/01/2024 14:42

Are you sure you didn't subconsciously buy her Boots make up to make a point?

You've made it clear her parents have brought her up to have a certain level of expectation for designers clothes and make up etc. What did you think her reaction would be to some Boots make up?

Yes it was lovely for you to buy her a gift but, as PP said, surely you knew it would be an own goal given how she is being raised.

In my defense i thought it would have been receievd better as for the last few years we have all agreed not to exchange presents due to DH losing job and cost of living. I didnt have to gift anything at all but i did because i know she loves makeup

OP posts:
krustykittens · 09/01/2024 14:44

BrandySnaps1 · 09/01/2024 14:34

Brother in law and sister in laws kid. My DH is her maternal uncle and used to spoilt her to death as she was the first child to be born. I assume this also has a part to play in her entitlement of standards of gifts.

Apologies, I read your OP wrong. I really would just take a step back. My BIL and SIL are very like this as well. They are not bad people but the constant bragging and competing over who owns what and how much it cost, is tedious. They live in a different country, though, so it is much easier for me to be polite and cordial. I keep myself busy when they visit my DH!

88inchesoftherapy · 09/01/2024 14:43

It comes across like im setting her up for a fall? WHy and how?

She expected Armani make up and i got her Boots items.
She once asked me to buy her a Chanel perfume

you list many many ways in which your niece is spoilt, entitled and a terrible person (in your opinion). You list ways in which her parents are. Yet you buy her a cheap palette. Thats why it looks like you're setting her up. Someone who expects Armani and asks for Chanel does not want a James Charles palette.

Babysharkdoodoodood · 09/01/2024 14:43

Shoud have got her one of TheseThere's ususally something on a designer site that's fairly affordable but still lovable. Boots is a bit meh.

Mini Eye Shadow Palette

Six-shade mini; smokey splendour.

https://www.patmcgrath.com/products/mini-eye-shadow-palette

sandrapinchedmysandwich · 09/01/2024 14:43

PossumintheHouse · 09/01/2024 14:21

Joke’s on her - some Boots stuff, especially the serums, are the dog’s.
Her dad has done her no favours whatsoever. She’s in for a sharp shock sometime down the line, unless he’s going to subsidise her ridiculous demands forever.

This. It always makes me wonder what happens to these teens who are so indulged that they will only accept luxury products, when they move out and enter the real world. Many young adults find the actual cost of living a huge shock once they have to pay their own bills. I imagine a good few find that they can no longer afford high end brands and 5 star Holidays which must be a huge shock to the system

ImCamembertTheBigCheese · 09/01/2024 14:42

Are you sure you didn't subconsciously buy her Boots make up to make a point?

You've made it clear her parents have brought her up to have a certain level of expectation for designers clothes and make up etc. What did you think her reaction would be to some Boots make up?

Yes it was lovely for you to buy her a gift but, as PP said, surely you knew it would be an own goal given how she is being raised.

BrandySnaps1 · 09/01/2024 14:42

It isnt only the way she said thank you. She opened it, gave a fake thanks and left it on the side like she couldnt have cared less.

OP posts:
MzHz · 09/01/2024 14:41

candlelog · 09/01/2024 14:12

If you know she likes specific brands then I wouldn't have bothered getting her boots brand. Especially when it comes to skincare/ make up which is very personal. My pre teen is very into skincare (as are all her friends). It's not cheap either- drunk elephant and SOL de janeiro etc. she got a few bits for Xmas but knew this would impact on other gifts due to cost which she was fine with. She's not spoilt.

You dn should've said thanks though.

You do realise that this make up skin care isn’t safe for children’s skin? All the peptides and retinol etc, you really shouldn’t be allowing this stuff to be used on her

I learned this from one of the make up specialists quite recently, I was shocked. I’d urge you to do some homework to check this out

I know some people who work in high end makeup retail who won’t sell this stuff to children because of the chemical compositions used.

CarterBeatsTheDevil · 09/01/2024 14:41

If you want pure, unalloyed joy from a teen gift recipient, put a banknote in a greetings card.

salsmum · 09/01/2024 14:40

I started Christmas shopping early ( October) and found out that my 3 DGS needed new iPads as theirs are older models that aren't meeting their needs ( nor will in the future) they are twin boys of nearly 7 and older nearly 9. So I saved and bought in Black Friday sale ( cheaper end iPads) I also gave them a selection box each which I gave first and waited for their disappointment when opening the joke rebounded on me because they unwrapped and were really excited to get the chocolate and showed no disappointment at all. It was heartwarming that they were so happy and of course when they then were presented with the iPads were totally over the moon ❤️ I'm so glad they they are being brought up to appreciate gifts no matter how big or small. At 14 she should receive with good grace and understand the feelings of the giver when they act so obviously disappointed.

a222 · 09/01/2024 14:40

its a bit insane that you’re hung up on the way she said thankyou…she was hardly being bratty.

i enjoy expensive things and a small but ‘expensive’ brand token gift like a nail polish etc from a ‘higher class’ brand i’d prefer over a bigger present from a cheaper brand imho.

ColleenDonaghy · 09/01/2024 14:39

So she did thank you, she just isn't a good enough actress? I'm 40 and not particularly materialistic but I have no doubt that those who know me well can read me when I'm saying thank you for a gift but thinking "Yikes, what will I do with this".

You're coming off much worse than her tbh OP.

And hard agree on us all being perfect parents before we have children.

BrandySnaps1 · 09/01/2024 14:39

Tempnamechng · 09/01/2024 14:31

Oh dear, you really don't like them, do you!
A random eye make up palette from a brand you know she won't like is probably the worst present you could get. It's as though you are trying to set her up for a fall? We stopped gifting with my sil because she brought my dd a make up palette for Christmas, because I just thought what's the point. Next year do a gift voucher or just the cash.

I actually thought the palette was really nice! It has all the colours she would have liked and was from one of those youtubers all the teenagers loved.

It comes across like im setting her up for a fall? WHy and how?

OP posts:
EarringsandLipstick · 09/01/2024 14:38

This. she is entitled and selfish, and also attention seeking. Ive noticed she gets super jealous when other people, children in particular are getting attention.

Get over yourself.

This is a child. Stop calling her awful names. You don't have to get her a gift, but don't go on an internet forum & slag her off

DavinaTheDonkey · 09/01/2024 14:38

I think make up was a poor choice tbh. If there's anything I'd encourage a girl in her teens to spend money on, it would be things she's going to put on her face!

I don't see that as snobbishness really.

I don't agree she should be bought designer bags etc though, unless they are mega wealthy and it's the norm in their circles. It wouldn't be in mine, but spending a bit more on skincare and make up products definitely is.