Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Bratty children and presents

279 replies

BrandySnaps1 · 09/01/2024 13:38

Gave my niece (through marriage) a Christmas present. Shes 14. Obsessed with make up, hair, and because of her dad, loves designer. Shes spoilt. 5* holidays, bags, you name it, shes got it or at least wants it.

Gave her some makeup items and she was SO disappointed. She opened it and the look on her face said it all. She expected Armani make up and i got her Boots items. Either way since when have pre-teens because so spoilt? Next time Im not even going to bother.

Anyone else experienced bratty children? How to handle them through gritted teeth. Shouldnt kids at least feign excitment?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
rookiemere · 12/01/2024 16:20

Also I do think that's why OP is so upset by the gift rejection.
She thought she was cool auntie by selecting a you tuber brand, but has found out in no uncertain terms, that she is not.

rookiemere · 12/01/2024 16:18

The other thing I remember from being a teen was wanting to be cool and edgy, and oh so different from my fuddy duddy older relatives.

So even if she absolutely loved the gift ( although I suspect that's not the case here) it would be somewhat unnerving that try hard auntie had got her so right, when she thinks she is unique.

BobbyBiscuits · 12/01/2024 16:14

I also only ever give to kids/ teens if they either send a thank you card (ideal) or thank you message. Babies of course get gifts but I would expect a thank you from parents. Old school maybe?
I still send thank you cards to all my rellies/ friends after being given money or a gift, meal, or just a card. It's good manners and sounds like her dad is not encouraging them.
What's her Mum like?
I think maybe you should stop gifts all together if she never does this!

BobbyBiscuits · 12/01/2024 15:59

At 14 a lot of kids can seem like that about gifts. It's kind of time to just stop buying them anything and just give them a bit of money. (Or F- all seeing as she's cheeky and spoilt)
We used to buy lots of toys etc for the young cousins but as they got older, the gifts would be more and more ignored and kids don't want makeup bought for them by an older relative. I made that mistake too. It's probably not 'sick' enough or whatever, lol.
I think she is rude, and her dad needs to give her head a wobble. He should tell her to get a (pt) job if she likes designer so much.
But yeah, stop gifting her entirely or stick to money only, that's what I've done with teens.

ISSTIUTNG · 12/01/2024 13:36

Joke’s on her - some Boots stuff, especially the serums, are the dog’s.
Her dad has done her no favours whatsoever. She’s in for a sharp shock sometime down the line, unless he’s going to subsidise her ridiculous demands forever.

Yes her dad's done her no favours allowing her the autonomy to make an independent decision about something that in the grand scheme of things is harming nobody at a time of her life when it's most acceptable for her to be a bit self-indulgent and experimental. Because not allowing her to make financial and social decisions at age 14 is really going to set her up to be a free-thinking and responsible adult when the time comes for her to stand on her own 2 feet ..

March2024baby · 11/01/2024 14:20

LuvSmallDogs · 11/01/2024 12:01

Standard teenage niece/nephew Xmas present when I was growing up was a selection box and a tenner in a card, as chocolate and cash tend to weather fads quite well. Maybe do something like that next time?

Kid doesn't have a great poker face, ok, it's not the same as being a brat though imo.

Yeah this is a good idea. She will probably still think it's a bit shit (just a guess based on what you've shared) but at least she can use the money. Better to get something safe that you sort of can't get wrong and that you can afford. That way you aren't left feeling irritated too.

Ponoka7 · 11/01/2024 12:43

PossumintheHouse · 09/01/2024 14:21

Joke’s on her - some Boots stuff, especially the serums, are the dog’s.
Her dad has done her no favours whatsoever. She’s in for a sharp shock sometime down the line, unless he’s going to subsidise her ridiculous demands forever.

14 year old girls don't need serums.

They want certain colours and brands. Always has been the same. Her family budget is high, so her wants are pricey. For my income when my girls wanted Paul Smith, Uggs and hunters, they were expensive for me. A high street pair from a relative wouldn't have been a treat. I used to ask my Mum for M&S champagne truffles, because the boxes were small, she'd get me a big box of their ordinary ones. They wasn't appreciated. I bought Ruby and Millie for their exclusive colours, again expensive for me and a pallet wouldn't have been wanted instead. Presents are supposed to be about who you are buying for. But what people want or give a voucher towards it. She said thanks. She doesn't have to want what you gave her.

Kittybythelighthouse · 11/01/2024 12:28

@BrandySnaps1 I didn’t see anyone say you should buy a more expensive item, but that you may have been better spending the same amount on something smaller from a brand you know she likes, or giving her the money/a gift voucher. When I was a teenager my dad would buy me big sets of cheap makeup because you could get so much more of it for the same £20. I would have preferred one quality mascara or lipstick every time. I did always say thank you though, as I knew his heart was in the right place. Your niece also said thank you.

I don’t think it’s fair to label her a ‘brat’ for this. It sounds like her family might be hard work and 14 is a really tricky age. She is still a growing and developing child and there’s likely some vulnerability and anxiety under the surface. I’d be kinder to her. BIL sounds like a dick though.

LuvSmallDogs · 11/01/2024 12:01

Standard teenage niece/nephew Xmas present when I was growing up was a selection box and a tenner in a card, as chocolate and cash tend to weather fads quite well. Maybe do something like that next time?

Kid doesn't have a great poker face, ok, it's not the same as being a brat though imo.

MissSookieStackhouse · 11/01/2024 11:56

Why are you even bothering buying this brat anything? I wouldn’t. Nor would I spend time with her or her parents. Let your DH see them if he wants to, if they’re his relatives. I really couldn’t be arsed to spend my valuable time with people like that.

bananamangoes · 11/01/2024 11:45

Vouchers or cash for 14 year olds

2ndMrsdeWinter · 11/01/2024 11:44

She’s 14 - all 14 year olds covet the latest brands. Her parents have the lifestyle to give her what she wants and you sound bitter. Stop slagging off a child - it’s distasteful and makes you look bad. If money is an issue or you don’t want to add to the view that she’s being overindulged, get her some nice chocolates. Makeup was an odd gift.

EmeraldA129 · 11/01/2024 09:57

Don’t take your annoyance with your SIL & BIL out on their daughter. It’s not her fault that she goes to private school, gets given designer things or goes on fancy holidays & gets taken to fancy restaurants.

don’t throw money away buying her something you know she doesn’t want - either put more thought into getting her something she will use, or get her a gift voucher so she can choose something herself.

If you don’t want to give her a present, that’s your choice but don’t blame it on her. Take ownership of your own choices.

her just looking disappointed isn’t exactly a bratty reaction. It sounds like you got her something you knew she wouldn’t use (which is a total waste of money) and are disappointed as she didn’t placate your ego enough. Gifts are about giving, not about the giver.

pineapplesundae · 11/01/2024 02:16

I’m not a kid and even I don’t like to receive gifts that I don’t want. I do, however, smile and say thank you. It’s time to switch to gift cards so niece can get what she wants. Teens are just that way. Doesn’t make her a bad person.

Eveeythingoknotok · 11/01/2024 00:04

Maybe she craves to have attention because she doesn't get much attention which is why maybe her dad gives gifts etc as feels like he is making up for being to busy with work etc. Not very nice to call you niece by marriage name tbh, you don't know what she is dealing with regards to her mum and dad and how she feels, not sure what you actually expected, she said thank you, she is a child

March2024baby · 10/01/2024 22:46

Yes fair enough @Goldbar at least she got a thank you.

GUARDIAN1 · 10/01/2024 22:42

Sounds as if she's being brought up to be a brand snob. Her dad isn't doing her any favours at all. It's a shame she couldn't at least thank you nicely. My older grandchildren (they're actually step-grandchildren) haven't even thanked me for what I bought them this year. Not even a text.

Goldbar · 10/01/2024 22:39

March2024baby · 10/01/2024 22:01

I just would never sit there and start judging someone's choice of gift for me. It's like FFs l realise other people have better things to do than sit around thinking of how to pander to my whims. Yeah if it was my husband or mum I might expect them to know me well enough to get something really tailored to me (perhaps!) but not an extended family member. Genuinely I would just think, bless nice of them to think of me. And I would have thought that at 14 too as my parents would not have let me turn out with such an inflated view of myself. Entitlement is a deeply unattractive trait.

But she didn't judge it, according to the OP. She just said thank you and put it to one side presumably because she wasn't enthused by it.

greengreengrass25 · 10/01/2024 22:09

SwordToFlamethrower · 10/01/2024 21:48

The people on here saying it's fine to spend £50 on some eye shadows!

I don't spend £50 total on makeup in a 3 year period!

Different world. If you want to get ripped off to put crap on to hide your face, you crack on.

Nor do I

At least OP didn't buy Constance Carol for herSmile

March2024baby · 10/01/2024 22:01

I just would never sit there and start judging someone's choice of gift for me. It's like FFs l realise other people have better things to do than sit around thinking of how to pander to my whims. Yeah if it was my husband or mum I might expect them to know me well enough to get something really tailored to me (perhaps!) but not an extended family member. Genuinely I would just think, bless nice of them to think of me. And I would have thought that at 14 too as my parents would not have let me turn out with such an inflated view of myself. Entitlement is a deeply unattractive trait.

SwordToFlamethrower · 10/01/2024 21:48

The people on here saying it's fine to spend £50 on some eye shadows!

I don't spend £50 total on makeup in a 3 year period!

Different world. If you want to get ripped off to put crap on to hide your face, you crack on.

NoodleDoodle24 · 10/01/2024 21:45

@SloaneyPhoney i was actually there on a scholarship and didn’t have the brands. And boy was i reminded of it every day by the delightful girls in my class.

Keep telling yourself that isn’t happening to your child if they’re the one who doesn’t have it. I never told my parents because I appreciated how hard they were working to get me there.

*edit typo

JayJayj · 10/01/2024 21:26

It’s the way op is talking about the child and the things they get and things they do comes across as jealousy to me. Not the gift. The gift seems thoughtless.

Wouldprefertobereading · 10/01/2024 20:42

What’s wrong with Bayliss and Harding?

March2024baby · 10/01/2024 20:42

JayJayj · 10/01/2024 20:33

I think you are very unreasonable.
you know she is really into make up/ skin care and that she likes more expensive stuff yet bought something cheap! I’m an adult and would not be happy if someone bought me something I clearly wouldn’t like or use.

You come across as jealous.

you could have given her money or a gift card for places she likes.

This is such a warped way of looking at it!!
I just don't understand some of these replies. Genuinely, I just don't get it.

If a grown up got me a present I wasn't thrilled with as a teen, it wouldn't occur to me to think they were 'jealous' or to turn my nose up at it. I would try and make the best of it and my parents had always talked to me about understanding that not everyone can afford certain things and to appreciate someone taking the time to think of you.

Also people set such a low bar of expectations- kids are able to understand and grasp these kinds of general values and attitudes from a young age if you take the time to talk to them. In a few short years this girl will be an adult.

I just don't get it! 🤯