Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Sacked for using 'N' word

797 replies

Horrace · 08/01/2024 22:08

I don't know how to copy link sorry but has anyone been following the story of the Lloyd's bank manager who was sacked for asking a relevant question in a so called anti racism training session by his employers but in his question he used the full 'N' word.
His question I believe was how would he be expected to deal with black employees or customers speaking to each other using that word.
The trainer was so offended by the word, she had to take 5 days off work. However, he got sacked.
He has since been awarded £500,00 but no apology from Lloyd's and no job back.
As far as we know, the ridiculous incompetent trainer is still employed.

I am close to this story but afraid to say how.
But will say that I'm losing sleep and furious more and more at this bank.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
14
Zarah123 · 09/01/2024 09:11

Horrace · 09/01/2024 08:56

Where have I said that critical thinking is using the N word.

Critical thinking in general for anything. They make it very difficult to question anything.
Some of you need to read the posts before responding. Take your time.

This topic isn't just about the employee using a bad word. It's a wider issue.
I posted to get a discussion going. Some of you are discussing.
Some of you are throwing insults when there is no need.

I'm leaving now to do some banking 😆

Shame you’re adding little to the discussion. What’s the wider issue then?

Your post is just ‘PC world gone mad’.

Inthebitterend · 09/01/2024 09:10

I've had a lot of DEI training in my working life and incredibly have managed to never use a slur out loud in front of colleagues under the guise of asking a question. I mean, what a miracle. It's almost like it doesn't take a single thing other than some common sense not to be a twat.

I don't feel sorry for him. Boohoo, poor white men have it so hard. Jesus christ.

Zarah123 · 09/01/2024 09:09

thiswillbedisplayed · 09/01/2024 05:56

What a shock that the guy in question just happened to be a Conservative counsellor (what are the odds!), who proceeded to then make a ridiculous “white middle class men are bottom of everything” rant.

So he was a racist. Quelle surprise.

MyCatWoofs · 09/01/2024 09:05

How is he at the top? As banks come, he is as low in the hierarchy as he could be. A payment system support clerk on 50K.

In society, as a white man, he’s at the top.

RandomPoster456 · 09/01/2024 08:57

MarieVanGoethem · 09/01/2024 08:27

@CwmYoy white people not being offended by the term, much as (white) teachers in the same period thought it was just fine to call their black students “jungle bunnies” doesn’t magically mean it was inoffensive 🤦‍♀️ The UK had an entire Empire full of black people it oppressed, abused & at some points enslaved - & it required legislation throughout the 1960s & 1970s (obviously said legislation only applied in GB as NI had own Parliament) to ensure black people wouldn’t be denied employment, housing, goods & services. Your man who thinks he’s suffered terribly because he’s a white man? Bit Enoch Powell-y that, & certainly precious.

——————————————————————

I don’t think he should have been dismissed, but disciplinary action should have been taken. His original question was vague & it’s no wonder the trainer was furious - “getting things wrong” means (for example) saying “coloured” or “half-caste” instead of “black” or “mixed race/heritage”. Not coming out with a word that’s been universally understood to be unacceptable for decades - even racists know it’s not considered ok, they just don’t care. Alarming that his colleagues hadn’t the wit, while being shocked at his using the word, to think that it clearly fell without the parameters of the expected errors in their “safe space”.

As for his claim it was due to his dyslexia… I’d love to read the medical evidence that was provided. Because I suspect the reason that Lloyd’s considered appealing (then decided against) was that he could not, in fact, evidence any such thing; but - rightly - with [certain] disabilities, Tribunals will err on the side of caution. So if I worked with him & right after he said that had a focal seizure that made it look like I’d just smacked him one - or several if he didn’t shift - & they fired me for thumping the racist (leaving aside the fact I’d do myself more damage) I’d be able to bring a disability discrimination claim because I have focal seizures (etc etc blah) even though it’s also true my uncle is black. Proving that he was able NOT to say the n-word = effectively impossible. It’s vanishingly unlikely that dyslexia did, in fact, force him to blurt out a word he knows to be so grossly offensive he’s not allowed to say it & he (allegedly 🤨) desired guidance on what to do should he overhear it being used by black people in the workplace. Zero sympathy for Mr “It’s So Hard Being Part Of One Of The Most Privileged Groups In British Society”. Foolish of Lloyd’s not to change their minds on his appeal though: they should have realised which way a tribunal would go.

“I don’t think he should have been dismissed, but disciplinary action should have been taken. His original question was vague & it’s no wonder the trainer was furious - “getting things wrong” means (for example) saying “coloured” or “half-caste” instead of “black” or “mixed race/heritage”. Not coming out with a word that’s been universally understood to be unacceptable for decades - even racists know it’s not considered ok, they just don’t care. Alarming that his colleagues hadn’t the wit, while being shocked at his using the word, to think that it clearly fell without the parameters of the expected errors in their “safe space”.

As for his claim it was due to his dyslexia… I’d love to read the medical evidence that was provided. Because I suspect the reason that Lloyd’s considered appealing (then decided against) was that he could not, in fact, evidence any such thing; but - rightly - with [certain] disabilities, Tribunals will err on the side of caution. So if I worked with him & right after he said that had a focal seizure that made it look like I’d just smacked him one - or several if he didn’t shift - & they fired me for thumping the racist (leaving aside the fact I’d do myself more damage) I’d be able to bring a disability discrimination claim because I have focal seizures (etc etc blah) even though it’s also true my uncle is black. Proving that he was able NOT to say the n-word = effectively impossible. It’s vanishingly unlikely that dyslexia did, in fact, force him to blurt out a word he knows to be so grossly offensive he’s not allowed to say it & he (allegedly 🤨) desired guidance on what to do should he overhear it being used by black people in the workplace. Zero sympathy for Mr “It’s So Hard Being Part Of One Of The Most Privileged Groups In British Society”. Foolish of Lloyd’s not to change their minds on his appeal though: they should have realised which way a tribunal would go”

I think this must be the longest put together waffle of speculation I have ever seen. Tribunals do not “err” on the side of caution ever. Especially when they have to be able to legally justify at an appeal, taking half a million pounds from a company. They have solicitors who are trained in all aspects of law working to make sure the law is fairly upheld for all parties. His original question wasn’t vague and that’s the point. His question was so obvious that for the trainer to claim not to know what word he was talking about when he said “The N word” when they are in fact qualified in this field is nothing other than wilful misinterpretation on the trainers part. The rest of your point about them being furious over the terms “coloured etc” is absolute nonsense. This trainer would have been trained themselves in recognising all the potential politically incorrect and racist terms and trained on how to deal with them. That is their job, only someone who wasn’t qualified in how to deal with this would react with such emotion because they do not possess the tools to be able to react to them appropriately in order to teach others. There’s a reason why Lloyds haven’t appealed and that is because they are 100% guilty beyond all doubt of discrimination. Whether you think it’s vanishingly unlikely or not, a tribunal thought otherwise enough to award him an enormous amount of money.

Horrace · 09/01/2024 08:56

Where have I said that critical thinking is using the N word.

Critical thinking in general for anything. They make it very difficult to question anything.
Some of you need to read the posts before responding. Take your time.

This topic isn't just about the employee using a bad word. It's a wider issue.
I posted to get a discussion going. Some of you are discussing.
Some of you are throwing insults when there is no need.

I'm leaving now to do some banking 😆

OP posts:
WeeJimmycranky · 09/01/2024 08:52

MyCatWoofs · 09/01/2024 08:49

So in reality, you absolutely cannot bring your whole self to work.

If someone’s whole self includes being racist then yes, they need to at least leave that cunty part at home.

No company really wants workers to bring their whole selves to work, it’s just more corporate bollock speak.

MyCatWoofs · 09/01/2024 08:49

So in reality, you absolutely cannot bring your whole self to work.

If someone’s whole self includes being racist then yes, they need to at least leave that cunty part at home.

WeeJimmycranky · 09/01/2024 08:49

Brefugee · 09/01/2024 08:47

i firmly believe in this kind of training. It definitely sorts the wheat from the chaff, and a good trainer would have identified this participant (and noticed other participents' reactions to him) as someone in need of further training.

The bank would have facilitated this - win-win for her company and people who need training.

The problem is the more we see things like this in the news, the more people DO attend these trainings to tick the boxes, don't listen, don't participate and don't learn anything. The only people who come out of it with anything positive are the training companies earning money.

I don’t think you can accuse this bloke of not participating by the sounds of it.

Bibisitsnow · 09/01/2024 08:48

‘If anyone dares to use critical thinking, ‘

ah, got you OP. So saying ‘n*er’ when questioning why you can’t when all the black people can is ‘critical thinking’ ?
Because to me it’s either ignorance, stupidity or baiting the trainer.

My 10 year old can tell you why they can’t say the n word when rappers can, or why white people shouldn’t.
And BTW, NONE of my black friends use that word. Ever. Not in any context.

Brefugee · 09/01/2024 08:47

Bibisitsnow · 09/01/2024 08:43

‘I've always declined this sort of training.’
I bet you have OP, sorry you find DE&I ‘exhausting’.
But as you have the option not to do it, then so what?
I have to do all sorts of mandatory training at work that notes the tits off me, but Injust crack on. I would mind a DE&I one just to change it up a bit…
I can’t believe a bank who have thousands of staff in customer facing roles feel the need to make sure those staff have appropriate training for dealing with customers. What utter, utter bastards.

i firmly believe in this kind of training. It definitely sorts the wheat from the chaff, and a good trainer would have identified this participant (and noticed other participents' reactions to him) as someone in need of further training.

The bank would have facilitated this - win-win for her company and people who need training.

The problem is the more we see things like this in the news, the more people DO attend these trainings to tick the boxes, don't listen, don't participate and don't learn anything. The only people who come out of it with anything positive are the training companies earning money.

zendeveloper · 09/01/2024 08:46

MyCatWoofs · 09/01/2024 08:44

But this is exactly what he did, and the trainer then asked for an example of such a word.

And his answer should have been ‘the n word’, not to say it in full.

Despite him claiming to believe that white middle aged men are at the bottom of everything, I think it’s likely he said what he did because he thought he could get away with it, precisely because he has the privilege of being a white middle aged man who had worked at the bank for years and is at the top. People rarely stand up to them.

How is he at the top? As banks come, he is as low in the hierarchy as he could be. A payment system support clerk on 50K.

Brefugee · 09/01/2024 08:45

PickledPegs · 09/01/2024 08:40

Then he should have said ‘it’s not a word I’m comfortable using’ as a decent person would. I don’t actually blame the trainer for the fact that she didn’t expect someone to actually blurt out the n word - who these days doesn’t realise that it’s totally unacceptable?

There are people who will do whatever they can to excuse racists, but why? They don’t deserve it.

except that a) she's an EDI trainer and b) she said "safe space, ok to make mistakes" and c) launched into a tirade rather than calmly listening to his apology and then possibly telling him he was muted for the rest of the session.

TBH she lost a massive opportunity there to show the rest of the trainees how to cope with the kind of racism that he was both talking about AND displaying.

MyCatWoofs · 09/01/2024 08:44

But this is exactly what he did, and the trainer then asked for an example of such a word.

And his answer should have been ‘the n word’, not to say it in full.

Despite him claiming to believe that white middle aged men are at the bottom of everything, I think it’s likely he said what he did because he thought he could get away with it, precisely because he has the privilege of being a white middle aged man who had worked at the bank for years and is at the top. People rarely stand up to them.

Bibisitsnow · 09/01/2024 08:43

‘I've always declined this sort of training.’
I bet you have OP, sorry you find DE&I ‘exhausting’.
But as you have the option not to do it, then so what?
I have to do all sorts of mandatory training at work that notes the tits off me, but Injust crack on. I would mind a DE&I one just to change it up a bit…
I can’t believe a bank who have thousands of staff in customer facing roles feel the need to make sure those staff have appropriate training for dealing with customers. What utter, utter bastards.

PickledPegs · 09/01/2024 08:41

Horrace · 09/01/2024 08:40

Because all it does is call out our differences under the guise of us all being equal.
It the same with training on religious beliefs, sexuality, gender or whatever they come up with.
We are all the same/equal/bring your whole self to work. Unless we say otherwise.
In reality, these courses and constant conversations are just reminders that we are all individual and shouldn't be pigeonholed. We are all different. And that's ok.
If anyone dares to use critical thinking, question anything, you are reported. So in reality, you absolutely cannot bring your whole self to work.

But also, it's a bank. We just want to get on with our work. It's numbers. Let's get on with our work.

I’ve never seen saying the n word described as ‘critical thinking’ before.

PickledPegs · 09/01/2024 08:40

zendeveloper · 09/01/2024 08:37

But this is exactly what he did, and the trainer then asked for an example of such a word.

Then he should have said ‘it’s not a word I’m comfortable using’ as a decent person would. I don’t actually blame the trainer for the fact that she didn’t expect someone to actually blurt out the n word - who these days doesn’t realise that it’s totally unacceptable?

There are people who will do whatever they can to excuse racists, but why? They don’t deserve it.

Horrace · 09/01/2024 08:40

Ladybughello · 09/01/2024 08:01

In what way is the content racist, OP? Please elaborate

Because all it does is call out our differences under the guise of us all being equal.
It the same with training on religious beliefs, sexuality, gender or whatever they come up with.
We are all the same/equal/bring your whole self to work. Unless we say otherwise.
In reality, these courses and constant conversations are just reminders that we are all individual and shouldn't be pigeonholed. We are all different. And that's ok.
If anyone dares to use critical thinking, question anything, you are reported. So in reality, you absolutely cannot bring your whole self to work.

But also, it's a bank. We just want to get on with our work. It's numbers. Let's get on with our work.

OP posts:
SoupDragon · 09/01/2024 08:39

Why couldn’t he say ‘how should I respond if my black colleagues are using words that are conventionally understood to be slurs?’ without actually saying it?

That is what he did say. The instructor claimed not to understand what he meant.

Bibisitsnow · 09/01/2024 08:38

It REALLY isn’t that hard to not say it. Just don’t. Just as you wouldn’t ( I hope) call a gay woman a ‘dyke’ even in ‘training’ or a gay man a ‘faggot’.
There are some words that groups have ‘reclaimed’ that have been used as slurs against them but if you aren’t in that group, don’t use them.

zendeveloper · 09/01/2024 08:37

PickledPegs · 09/01/2024 08:31

Tbh he should be sacked. Why did he need to say the word? Why couldn’t he say ‘how should I respond if my black colleagues are using words that are conventionally understood to be slurs?’ without actually saying it?

There is, unfortunately, a small cohort of white people who love looking for ‘loopholes’ allowing them to use slurs without facing repercussions. The reality is there is no need. Legitimate, good faith questions can be asked without using profoundly offensive terms, as is clear from the thousands of people who manage to get through diversity training every year without using them.

But this is exactly what he did, and the trainer then asked for an example of such a word.

Beezknees · 09/01/2024 08:35

Just don't say the "n" word, it's not hard. There's no reason to say it even in training, just say "n" word.

zendeveloper · 09/01/2024 08:35

Brefugee · 09/01/2024 08:26

that's what i mean. It is fine for attendees of the course to not know what the c-word, the n-word etc are.

As a DEI trainer? it is totally unacceptable. And if i were the company using that trainer's company? I would be a) asking for all my money back and compensation for time wasted (because their trainers don't know their subject and b) looking for a competent training company who do know what all the things mean

Again: I don't think it is necessary in any context - but especially as a white person - to use the n-word.

But i worry that other people, knowing what the trainer said at the start of that session (safe space, don't worry about making mistakes) who go on EDI training will now just switch off, nod, smile, give the textbook answers and just accept the certificate for having "done the training" without doing any such thing. Because, tedious as it is, these training sessions often throw up useful snippets (even if it is: beware, your company is totally captured watch your words)

Ah I see. I must say that the absolute worst examples of corporate racism I've witnessed were not accompanied by any slavery-era slurs. Quite the opposite, were delivered in a very polite way with a smile, in a way that everyone understood what was going on, but there was zero to report.

Also, anyone asking questions of any nature (contentious or not) on corporate trainings like that is totally nuts, in my opinion. They exist as tick-box exercises. I've attended dozens by now and very rarely someone from audience asks a question - and if they do, it is usually to indirectly proudly signal how super-tolerant they are, or someone from HR mentioning the relevant policies.

Bibisitsnow · 09/01/2024 08:33

‘In the 1960s you could walk into a haberdashery and ask for cotton that was n*** brown. It wasn't always seen as insulting in the UK. ‘

insulting to who exactly? Do you think black people were okay with that? Seriously? Do you think black people were walking in to shops and asking for things in ‘ n brown’?

my mother sure as hell never used that word, and no one I know ever used that word and I’m in my 50s and from a very white region where there wasn’t much diversity and people probably were more racist than other U.K. cities. But even in my back water we knew what racist language was.

Brefugee · 09/01/2024 08:32

it is ageism though. it is a blanket assumption that people who are now of pensionable age are generally racist.

FWIW i'm glad the tribunal actually dismissed the claim that he was a subject of racism. The idea that - in banking! - mc middle aged white men are in any way anything except top of the pile is hilarious.