Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you have children in the next 5 years, thinking about climate change?

111 replies

Howbigaretherisks · 08/01/2024 21:13

I have fertility issues so it would not be easy anyway but sometimes I get so broody and start dreaming of having a child - always thought I would have them one day. I love kids and always saw them in my future.

But I'm also concerned about what the world will be like over the next 100 years, with crop failures and access to clean water making things harder, even for high income countries. Populations in rich countries will likely be insulated from the worst of it for a good long time, many decades hopefully. But things are incredibly bad for a large percentage of the global population already. It is only going to get worse.

Would you have more children, or start having them if you haven't already, at this point?

OP posts:
PickledPegs · 09/01/2024 09:16

Yes. I find this kind of defeatist environmental posturing hysterical and infuriating.

Yes, climate change is a disaster. No, we are not beyond hope or salvation.

People throwing up their arms and saying ‘There is nothing we can do, the planet is doomed already, let’s just accept the inevitability of societal collapse, my children will never know joy’ are playing directly into the hands of unclean energy industries which rely on the public’s apathy towards their continued existence.

Instead of moralistic hand wringing about how hopeless it all is and how terrible it would be to bring a child into this world, get angry, because we have every opportunity to turn this ship around if people are passionate enough and committed enough.

(And before you come for me I am an environmentalist. I’m an active member of the Green Party, don’t fly, don’t eat meat or fish, barely drive, go on marches, lobby my MP and MSP, sign petitions, pick up litter etc ad nauseam).

AlaskaThunderfuckHiiiiiiiii · 09/01/2024 09:06

@preggegg i work in healthcare and it is a very real problem now and is only going to get worse. I sincerely hope euthanasia is an option when I get there I’m not living the last years of my life with dementia or being kept alive with no quality of life

Daisies12 · 09/01/2024 09:00

I do worry about it, and I would never have more than two kids because of the environmental impact. Currently trying for no1 so let's see! The best we can do is do what we can to reduce our impact on the planet, and teach kids to do the same. I do think the next generation are more conscious of it

peakygold · 09/01/2024 08:59

My darling Dad died just over 18 years ago, and during our last conversation he told me to "arm yourself because things are going to get bad". So I had two DCs. My tribe.

Xoxoxoxoxoxox · 09/01/2024 08:48

Since the invention of contraception and women able to control their fertility the birth rate of the planet has dropped - and when an agrarian economy industrialises and everyone moves to small flats in the cities there is no room for children.
In some countries this is really extreme.
The birthrate in China has dropped by 70% since 2017 the fastest drop ever recorded by humanity.
Germany in particular and most European countries have extreme drops in childbirth (except France).

If your main concern is that resources will be scarce then this is not a concern as the world population is going to decline in the next 100 years.

s

s

Don't Be Surprised by China's Collapse || Peter Zeihan

It's time to come out from under your rock and face the music - China is collapsing. If that comes as a shock to you, watch this video to get up to speed.Ful...

https://www.youtube.com/watch?ab_channel=ZeihanonGeopolitics&v=mqA5NODRnQI

Pickles2023 · 09/01/2024 00:41

Even if it wasnt climate change, it would be something. Everything has a cycle, suns, planets, all life.

Would you never exist, never be born because at some point life ends? Whether that be your lifespan or the planets?

If thats the case then there is no point in anything as there is always a cycle of birth and death since the dawn of time, even the dinosaurs.

A comet might kill us all before climate change does.

I dont particularly see any point in history where there is no suffering of some sort. Famine, drought, plagues, wars.

ConsuelaHammock · 09/01/2024 00:08

I would always have had my children regardless of climate change. I won’t be told what to do by those who carry on doing whatever they want. It’s not a good idea for self sustaining people to limit their family size while those who don’t give it a second thought just carry on as normal.

theprincessthepea · 09/01/2024 00:05

Both mine were unplanned. Whilst I have been broody I have never really wanted children - not because of climate change but because it is difficult. However this isn’t the case for absolutely everyone, everywhere in the world. You can live a decent life based on where you live, income etc. The West is becoming less and less attractive and I know people moving to other countries and building a life out there whilst taking advantage of some of the possibilities that many Western counties have probably exploited.

Our schools now have climate change and solutions being taught in real time - everything is happening right now and we need to bring up the next generation to have an interest in the jobs and new economies that will better the planet. Yes we have a long way to go, but I am hoping that over the years more people that make the right choices are in higher positions.

aurynne · 09/01/2024 00:01

The risk is not that all our children are going to die because of climate change.

The risk is that their life is going to become very, very hard. That they will start life enjoying many privileges that they will see removed from them soon, in a very abrupt way. That they will have to compete for basic resources with some people who have grown up in extreme poverty and will hence be much more adept at fighting for the same resources. That they are going to comfront loss of habitable land, overpopulation focused on small areas, loss of choice, loss of wellbeing and loss of freedom in a massive scale never experienced before in History.

Yes, I do believe I will see the beginning of this process at 47, and that every child born in the last 20 years will experience it in full.

So if your only concern is quality of life and climate change... my advice would be a massive NO, don't you have children, please.

preggegg · 08/01/2024 23:59

Lilacdressinggown · 08/01/2024 21:55

No I wouldn’t.
Because of climate change and AI taking all the jobs in the next 10 years.

They’ll still get jobs in healthcare … which will be desperately needed to cope with our aging population that will now likely live to over 100. Many more years will be lived incapable of caring for oneself.

Erasethelimegreenandpurple · 08/01/2024 23:54

Yes of course I would.

The world has always been a dangerous and precarious place to be born.

Fifteen per cent of babies born in the uk in the 1840s died before their first birthday.

Education and technology are improving all of the time and pretty soon all of those babies weaned on tablets and screens will be in charge and technology will accelerate massively.

I understand that global weather catastrophe is a different category of dangerous altogether and something we cannot necessarily combat, but we need young people so they can at least try and come up with some solutions.

Passingthethyme · 08/01/2024 23:47

Howbigaretherisks · 08/01/2024 23:35

Yes because it’s a basic driver of life in science term to pass on your dna. It’s a primitive urge.

Agree it is definitely a primitive urge to want a child. I feel that wanting on a very primitive level at times but...I don't want to make such an important decision based on a biological urge.

For men, having sex with lots of women is a primatuve urge. Monogamy is a man-made concept. So I think arguments based on primatuve urges are fundamentally flawed, not to mention I don't think many women feel this strong urge or we'd all be having babies as teens.

Howbigaretherisks · 08/01/2024 23:35

Yes because it’s a basic driver of life in science term to pass on your dna. It’s a primitive urge.

Agree it is definitely a primitive urge to want a child. I feel that wanting on a very primitive level at times but...I don't want to make such an important decision based on a biological urge.

OP posts:
DyslexicPoster · 08/01/2024 23:26

Yes because it’s a basic driver of life in science term to pass on your dna. It’s a primitive urge. Also, we as a species need to die out at some point. We evolved from something so why should our species stay in a static state? Why are we so sure we a especially immune to what dishes out?

everything is in such a fine balance. Not having kids won’t save this species or ur planet as we know. It. We are so good at destroying everything.

marshmallowfinder · 08/01/2024 23:19

I wouldn't have children now, definitely not. The future for them is really worrying.

Passingthethyme · 08/01/2024 23:00

Not climate change, but general shit-ness of the world. Cost of living, price of houses etc. If it had been a year later I wouldn't have had a child. The future looks very bleak for young people now unless their parents are wealthy. Luckily I'll be able to help my DC with a house when it comes to it, but this wouldn't have been possible if I had more than one

Howbigaretherisks · 08/01/2024 22:54

MsCactus · 08/01/2024 22:49

I mean, a meteorite could destroy us all in a second. Or in five years, ten years, fifty...

The natural world is terrifying and unpredictable. So no I don't factor climate change into my decision to have kids

I mean - before people have children, it is common to look at the budget and ensure you can afford to feed them.

If climate change drove food prices up massively, that would mean a shift in what is affordable. So maybe people choose to have one kid and not any more. As one example.

There is a whole lot of middle ground between a meteorite knocking us into oblivion, and our lives continuing on as they are now.

OP posts:
Mum824 · 08/01/2024 22:54

EmpressSoleil · 08/01/2024 22:33

Climate change wouldn't bother me. The state of the world would.

Maybe if your child excels at school/uni, gets a high flying job and you gift them a hefty house deposit, their life might be OK! For a far greater percentage of the population its a struggle. And I don't see it getting better.

Public services are on their knees. More teachers are going to get burnt out and leave the profession so if you want a good education in future, you're probably talking private school. Can't see how much longer the NHS can continue, except for those who cannot pay privately, and the waiting lists for those people will be long. Crime is on the up and we don't have enough police, prison places or even Courts now to hear all the cases. Retirement age will continue to increase and state pension will be means tested (its inevitable).

Then you have the rest of the world and all the issues there. But this post would be extremely long if I started on that!

Just to say, public services are on their knees because of a failure to plan and prepare for the future. They thought that by projection that everyone would replace themselves, migration would be equal and by the time the elderly needed care or health services, they would die.
Instead, people have had less babies, the elderly are living longer and the working people can't keep up. That's why there isn't enough money and not enough to encourage people into essential professions.

So, the elderly population saved for 15 years of retirement, however, because of better living conditions and healthcare, they are living 25 years. So the money doesn't stretch. A care home before they retired was say £600pwk but now is £1200pwk. A £300,000 house (which is decent) will cover 4.8 years. So, the working population, has to bridge the gap. Which, in turn, causes burn-out and stops some of them working. Bare in mind that the working population is less than the elderly generation. The working population decides to have less babies for whatever reason (socially, genetically, financially etc) and when the working population retires, their children have to work 3x harder and longer than their grandparents.

Just to say too that this is not localised to our country, it is every country in the world. If China has relaxed the 1 child rule because they can see the economy cannot handle it, we should all be concerned economically.

I don't fear our children's future, I fear my own.

I don't buy that 2 lots of dinosaurs died because of meteor strikes, it's a bit coincidental for it to happen twice. It was climate change 100%
I am concerned about the lack of trees and removal of plants because without them absorbing the carbon, it will build up. All about balance.
Oh, and how do the politicians get to COP22/23/24? I doubt they walk or cycle...... Surely they could skype?

climatelife · 08/01/2024 22:54

Howbigaretherisks · 08/01/2024 22:48

Really interesting perspective @climatelife

Have you read Hannah Ritchie's book as mentioned by another poster above?

I haven’t, although I attended a small event with her recently where she spoke on stage and was very good.

Children are great btw - I am very, very glad we had ours and now want to make sure we leave the planet in decent shape for them.

Howbigaretherisks · 08/01/2024 22:51

I also think the implications of drought, mass migration because of climate change, working in hot temps etc just aren’t understood by most people.

Yes.

I think a lot of people don't really think about what the reality of this actually looks like, if it comes to pass.

They think oh it won't affect me, and zone out.

OP posts:
MsCactus · 08/01/2024 22:49

I mean, a meteorite could destroy us all in a second. Or in five years, ten years, fifty...

The natural world is terrifying and unpredictable. So no I don't factor climate change into my decision to have kids

Howbigaretherisks · 08/01/2024 22:48

Really interesting perspective @climatelife

Have you read Hannah Ritchie's book as mentioned by another poster above?

OP posts:
Howbigaretherisks · 08/01/2024 22:45

TotesABoats · 08/01/2024 22:42

Look at this way: if it's going to be a fight to the death for scarce resources, I want a bunch of healthy blood-thirsty teenagers who have some filial loyalty to me on my team 😂

This strategy hadn't occurred to me Grin

OP posts:
climatelife · 08/01/2024 22:45

my husband and I both work in the area of climate change (I was at the recent COP28 summit for example, regularly speak to world leading climate scientists etc. My husband works on solutions). I expect we have more knowledge of climate change than most people on the street (have actually read the IPCC reports and speak with the authors for example). And we have two young children.

We still have a (short) window of opportunity to fairly effectively deal with climate change. So there is still hope, although of course we aren’t moving fast enough. But each brutal year we have of unprecedented weather events - and the science tells us they are unprecedented- the more politicians and ordinary people are waking up to the issues.

the idea that China and the US are doing nothing is farcical. They are not doing enough, not near enough. But China is rolling out more renewables than anywhere else on this planet, it’s starting to look at methane etc. The US’s inflation reduction act is changing how the US does business and how it powers itself (and that changes economies globally).

there is so much interesting work being done around the world.

sometimes I feel down about it all and that we are screwed. And the science for what might happen at tipping points is really worrying. I also think the implications of drought, mass migration because of climate change, working in hot temps etc just aren’t understood by most people. If the world chooses not to limit global temperature rises, the impact of that will be felt around the world, including in the UK.

But for now, I think it is better to try to focus on solutions.

StarDolphins · 08/01/2024 22:42

EmpressSoleil · 08/01/2024 22:33

Climate change wouldn't bother me. The state of the world would.

Maybe if your child excels at school/uni, gets a high flying job and you gift them a hefty house deposit, their life might be OK! For a far greater percentage of the population its a struggle. And I don't see it getting better.

Public services are on their knees. More teachers are going to get burnt out and leave the profession so if you want a good education in future, you're probably talking private school. Can't see how much longer the NHS can continue, except for those who cannot pay privately, and the waiting lists for those people will be long. Crime is on the up and we don't have enough police, prison places or even Courts now to hear all the cases. Retirement age will continue to increase and state pension will be means tested (its inevitable).

Then you have the rest of the world and all the issues there. But this post would be extremely long if I started on that!

I agree with all this.

I hope the state pension won’t be means tested when I get it, I’m living frugally to save so will be pissed off of I’m penalised for doing so.

Swipe left for the next trending thread