Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you have children in the next 5 years, thinking about climate change?

111 replies

Howbigaretherisks · 08/01/2024 21:13

I have fertility issues so it would not be easy anyway but sometimes I get so broody and start dreaming of having a child - always thought I would have them one day. I love kids and always saw them in my future.

But I'm also concerned about what the world will be like over the next 100 years, with crop failures and access to clean water making things harder, even for high income countries. Populations in rich countries will likely be insulated from the worst of it for a good long time, many decades hopefully. But things are incredibly bad for a large percentage of the global population already. It is only going to get worse.

Would you have more children, or start having them if you haven't already, at this point?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Alloftheskies · 12/01/2024 02:39

I mean people had kids during the black death which almost wiped out humanity.. people have kids in war zones..
I know we have a bit more choice about it at this period of time in the west but honestly life has its joy and pain whenever you have children. And it's a natural human instinct to reproduce.
I always think people are laughable when they say the planet would be better off without humans... like animals are all these innocent lovelies living in peace. Watch any nature documentary.. it's cutthroat out there even if you took humans out of the equation
And as for global warming... we absolutely should be trying to address it.. but even if we didn't exist it would still happen.. just much more slowly.. at some point albeit billions of years away.. the sun will consume the earth anyway... so if you really think about it human beings with our technology are the only chance any life on this planet has any chance of survival beyond that point.. as we are potentially capable of space travel and terraforming etc
Basically you cannot predict what the future will hold for your children. Every generation has a bunch of doommongers saying that's it everything's going to the dogs now.. and I'm not some sort of mad climate change denier. I know its a problem. But I think the answer lies more in working together to do the best we can rather than giving up and hoping we all die out (which would only slow it down not stop it anyway)
I mean maybe the generation 500 years in the future will look back at our time now and think how awful it must have been for us with the pandemic and the poverty and the struggle... yet actually being alive during this time I wouldn't take any of it back.. the joy I've felt, the love, the experience of being alive.
I wouldn't presume to think I know what my children will go thru. You just raise them the best you can and you hope the best for them. Maybe the world will be harder for them in some ways and easier in others.. maybe they'll be very unlucky and experience some great disaster.. maybe they'll live thru an age better than ours.. you honestly can't really know for sure.

aurynne · 12/01/2024 00:32

Mum824 · 11/01/2024 11:08

It means that if 2 people have 1 baby, or even worse, no babies, you either work until you die or the 1 person you produced, works 3x harder to keep you when you stop.

£300,000 will last approx 4.8 years in a good care home and 9 years in a standard one. If life expectancy is 20 years past retirement, who bridges that 11 - 16yr gap?

How much do you have saved or are you willing to work until you drop?
That's dependent on you being in the best of health, never needing to use public services of course.

It was better when people were able to be more resourceful, because they were healthier, less dependent on money and less stressed. However, they didn't make it much past 85......

This is because we've turned our society into a massive pyramid scheme in which we constantly need more people in order to just keep afloat. But the end of pyramid schemes come when they become unsustainable and everyone can see they're just a con, because the only ones making any profit/benefitting from what the scheme promises are a couple of lucky ones at the top. That time has come and passed.

Rosiiee · 11/01/2024 11:11

I’d be more worried about cost of living tbh. I worry about my kids financial future and if they’ll even be able to afford life!

Mum824 · 11/01/2024 11:08

It means that if 2 people have 1 baby, or even worse, no babies, you either work until you die or the 1 person you produced, works 3x harder to keep you when you stop.

£300,000 will last approx 4.8 years in a good care home and 9 years in a standard one. If life expectancy is 20 years past retirement, who bridges that 11 - 16yr gap?

How much do you have saved or are you willing to work until you drop?
That's dependent on you being in the best of health, never needing to use public services of course.

It was better when people were able to be more resourceful, because they were healthier, less dependent on money and less stressed. However, they didn't make it much past 85......

AlaskaThunderfuckHiiiiiiiii · 10/01/2024 13:28

@FPNFL too many old people and not e enough young people to pay taxes or look after them. We are already seeing this in healthcare

FPNFL · 10/01/2024 13:22

decisionssmecisions · 08/01/2024 22:24

I’m more worried about the shift in demographics, have babies people!!!

I’m more worried about the shift in demographics

What does this mean?

DyslexicPoster · 10/01/2024 13:05

Passingthethyme · 08/01/2024 23:47

For men, having sex with lots of women is a primatuve urge. Monogamy is a man-made concept. So I think arguments based on primatuve urges are fundamentally flawed, not to mention I don't think many women feel this strong urge or we'd all be having babies as teens.

Its fine to direct it and challenge and decide against it. But most scientists would say the meaning of life is to pass on dna in a biology sence. I don't really belive their is a meaning of life as science also says its all a happy accident.

However chemistry tells me that hormones are powerful things. Like someone else has said testosterone is a big driver for lots of things for example. We aren't so evolved that we can compartmentalise that primitive urges are just meaningly chemical signals.

If you ever feel sexual urges that's just hormones ( that want you to have sex to make a baby) wed don't have like it but that's science. Urges to have sex are to pass on DNA. There aren't many species who have sex just for fun in reality. And we are just mamals, we're nothing special. Just my thoughts anyway

Howbigaretherisks · 09/01/2024 21:03

But your future DC will probably get to have a more decent life than more animals on earth just by virtue of being human. If you're in a developed country, they probably won't be hugely affected by climate change in their lifetime.

I find it reassuring that people feel so confident that this will be ok, but I feel uncertain about it myself.

I think that quality of life could seriously diminish - food supply, and knock on effects on healthcare accessibility.

I can see the modern medical care we are used to becoming very expensive as the resources needed to keep all wheels in motion rise in price.

OP posts:
PineConeOrDogPoo · 09/01/2024 20:16

aurynne · 09/01/2024 00:01

The risk is not that all our children are going to die because of climate change.

The risk is that their life is going to become very, very hard. That they will start life enjoying many privileges that they will see removed from them soon, in a very abrupt way. That they will have to compete for basic resources with some people who have grown up in extreme poverty and will hence be much more adept at fighting for the same resources. That they are going to comfront loss of habitable land, overpopulation focused on small areas, loss of choice, loss of wellbeing and loss of freedom in a massive scale never experienced before in History.

Yes, I do believe I will see the beginning of this process at 47, and that every child born in the last 20 years will experience it in full.

So if your only concern is quality of life and climate change... my advice would be a massive NO, don't you have children, please.

Edited

This ^^

MsCactus · 09/01/2024 20:03

Howbigaretherisks · 08/01/2024 22:54

I mean - before people have children, it is common to look at the budget and ensure you can afford to feed them.

If climate change drove food prices up massively, that would mean a shift in what is affordable. So maybe people choose to have one kid and not any more. As one example.

There is a whole lot of middle ground between a meteorite knocking us into oblivion, and our lives continuing on as they are now.

Yeah I know. But your future DC will probably get to have a more decent life than more animals on earth just by virtue of being human. If you're in a developed country, they probably won't be hugely affected by climate change in their lifetime.

If you're talking in terms of "they will destroy the earth because of causing climate change" well... Um the earth will be destroyed anyway. The sun is going to implode in a few billion years. We know the earth will perish. And in the shorter term, your kids could be the ones who save the earth. There's no guarantee at all they'll contribute to destroying the earth.

I don't really understand people who say they won't have kids because of climate change tbh... There's always something that will wipe out the earth - it's inevitable anyway. If you want kids, just have them.

TripleDaisySummer · 09/01/2024 16:52

Climate no as there's a lot of quiet work going on and being where we area and still richer than many countries we'll have more ability to adapt. Economics possibly - luckily I've already had mine.

Western demographics don't look good and I think there may well be a drop in standards of living.

Allfur · 09/01/2024 16:05

Peakygold, arm yourself? what use are guns!

ohfook · 09/01/2024 15:47

I didn't factor it in. Not because I don't believe in it, but because I don't see the rich and powerful changing their behaviour because of climate fears. They have their large families, multiple homes, fleets of cars, long haul holidays and private jets with a carbon footprint many times larger than mine: I make many sacrifices even though I know they'll have little impact, but the size of my family wasn't something I was willing to compromise on.

I do worry about their future though just as my parents worried about the impact of the hole in the ozone on my future and their parents worried about how the Cold War would impact theirs.

Mauhea · 09/01/2024 11:33

It's a really tough one. I regularly browse the r/collapse subreddit to keep myself informed and the way things are going with the global sea temperature anomaly and the knock on of extreme weather on crops it's a bit bleak. Not to mention that we're unable to do a study on the impact of microplastics on the body because scientists couldn't form a control group.

Despite being conflicted I have decided to start a family in the hopes that being forewarned is forearmed. There's very little I as an individual can do to make a significant change but I'm hopeful that the climate-aware youth of today will grow up to make real significant changes on the current profit driven policies.

The economic and housing situation where I am is pretty buggered but I have a long term plan for putting savings aside in the hope that my child will be able to achieve what I haven't and eventually own a house.

Jumpingthruhoops · 09/01/2024 11:25

No, I wouldn't but it wouldn't be because of climate change. It would be because of war, poverty, greed... that sort of thing.

Katiesaidthat · 09/01/2024 11:23

Bonkers. Just stop worrying about this bull and think whether you can afford to have kids, and how many not to take a toll on your health. From the day we are born we are dying, so what can happen worse than death, which is unavoidable. This is the best time to be alive in the West. Life without some toil is fanciful idea. People had kids during Black Death and during the second world war. I sometimes despair as I find these 21st century "worries" infuriating.

MidgeFragnets · 09/01/2024 11:22

mydogisthebest · 09/01/2024 11:13

This thread shows that having children is very very selfish. The future looks very bleak indeed with climate change, rising sea levels, lack of food etc.

The UK is falling apart. The NHS is on its knees. Schools struggling with lack of funds and less and less people wanting to teach. The cost of housing. Overcrowding.

To bring children into the world as it is and knowing it will get much much worse is utterly selfish. Again the I WANT SO I SHALL HAVE mindset of most parents.

I agree that it is bleak, but to expect one generation to be ok to have kids but then expecting another not to have kids because the previous generations massively fucked up by ignoring problems and voting for people who ignore these problems is a selfish statement in itself. These kids may well be paying tax into the system so you can have your pension. If we all stopped having kids the many things may not function, similar to the effect of climate change.

enchantedsquirrelwood · 09/01/2024 11:18

No I wouldn't. I fear for what we've let our kids in for with climate change.

I agree it's better now than it was in the Middle Ages, but we have contraception and they didn't.

MrsSkylerWhite · 09/01/2024 11:15

Allfur · Yesterday 21:38

I'd rather be alive now than the middle ages, there's a lot of great things about life in the 21st century”

This. Every century has faced its challenges. (Including climate changes)

mydogisthebest · 09/01/2024 11:13

This thread shows that having children is very very selfish. The future looks very bleak indeed with climate change, rising sea levels, lack of food etc.

The UK is falling apart. The NHS is on its knees. Schools struggling with lack of funds and less and less people wanting to teach. The cost of housing. Overcrowding.

To bring children into the world as it is and knowing it will get much much worse is utterly selfish. Again the I WANT SO I SHALL HAVE mindset of most parents.

MidgeFragnets · 09/01/2024 11:13

In a way I wished I never had kids. The economic situation in the UK is shit with very poor social mobility and the rise of populist politics and right wing media. I think the UK is somewhat coming out if the other side of it and will hopefully not be ruled by thick, crazy walkers by the end if the year, but the damage has been done already and Europe and the rest of the world seem to be heading into this and not seeing the state of the UK as a warning.

Yes climate change us also an issue, but I think the global economy, a system where very wealthy people dominate the world and can change laws to suit their agendas and the rise of AI is more of a threat. Climate change ties into it as they don't want to acknowledge it as they are the biggest contributors to it.

My son has complex needs and the hate that is spouted by some crazy bitches on here simply because he has a brain disorder and can't work as a normal person in the economy really puts me off having children (lucky i dont want more children anyway). They are so fooled by divisive media. Even the government are at it too. I can't get my kid in a special school and I would be lucky if he even has an IQ of 50, but apparently its my son's fault for needing the place, not government neglect. That's how shit it is right now. I wouldn't want to risk having a child with special needs and having to fight such an appallingly inadequate system that we have now.

Fluffywhitecloudsinthesky · 09/01/2024 11:10

I support assisted dying precisely because modern health-care is very good and coupled with sanitation/water improvements, we all live a lot lot longer, and that's frightening as well as amazing.

preggegg · 09/01/2024 11:02

AlaskaThunderfuckHiiiiiiiii · 09/01/2024 09:06

@preggegg i work in healthcare and it is a very real problem now and is only going to get worse. I sincerely hope euthanasia is an option when I get there I’m not living the last years of my life with dementia or being kept alive with no quality of life

I do too and ditto about euthanasia!

TheNoonBell · 09/01/2024 10:35

This is literally the safest time to be alive in all history. Infant mortality is tiny, medical care and sanitation mean much healthier lives, life expectancy has doubled in the last 250 years. Natural distasters kill a fraction of what they did historically.

Stop worrying about the bullshit the watermelon eco-loons keep pumping out and get on with enjoying your life.

KimberleyClark · 09/01/2024 09:32

JustGotToKeepOnKeepingOn · 08/01/2024 22:11

Climate change wouldn't even enter my head as any reason to do/not do anything.

If you want a baby have one. Why let something you have zero control over stop you from experiencing the joy of having a baby?

(If you really feel that you have to justify having a baby... tell yourself that your child will grow up to save the world.)

People are always expected to justify not having them though. It’s always “why don’t you want them” not “why do you want them”.