Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I always keep my dc off school with a sore throat

139 replies

Responsiveness · 08/01/2024 19:26

Just reading latest government guidance regarding attendance- parents are being told to send children in even with a cough, cold symptoms or sore throat ? (But not to send with any symptoms of scarlet fever or chicken pox yet often a sore throat is a symptom of both these illnesses 🤦‍♀️)

I always keep mine off with sore throats ? They can be really painful even without a fever. I will continue to do so as well!

I can understand sending a child in with a tickly cough or runny nose etc but sore throats can be horrible not to mention for some dc with SEN especially ASD the sensory aspect of something like a sore throat and how it impacts eating and drinking / sound of voice/ the cold air in winter making it feel raw etc (my ds has ASD and has these issues every time)

AIBU to think that this latest advice isn’t going to help anyone ? It will just be kids in school feeling too unwell and distracted to learn or spreading germs !

OP posts:
Responsiveness · 09/01/2024 08:41

ds1 is year 6 now, other dc are years 2 and 4 so I’m hoping they at least build up immunity before primary school is over I think they just take a bit longer than other dc? When they were in nursery I thought as they caught bugs all the time it would boost their immune systems but no such luck they were just constantly ill and it hasn’t stopped !

OP posts:
Responsiveness · 09/01/2024 08:38

HoneyNuts · 09/01/2024 08:35

So you think all parents should keep their kids at home with sore throats even if it means they lose their jobs and have to stop working?

Or maybe just the mums?

No that’s not what I think or what I said. It’s an individual decision and my dc do need to be off in these situations but it spends on the child and the severity of their symptoms.

I had to give up work as on top of the medical appts the absence through illness was too much - and I couldn’t have just sent them in as they have been in too much pain, ibuprofen wasn’t helping enough to allow them to eat / drink or be distracted.

We had to downsize and I had to give up my car so we just share the one now. No more holidays for a few years either and we now have a strict budget till dc are a bit older and I can work again so I absolutely do understand the struggles of working parents !

OP posts:
HoneyNuts · 09/01/2024 08:35

Responsiveness · 09/01/2024 08:30

I haven’t changed how I do things at all - they were off the same when I was working as they are now I’m not. It just wasn’t working and I wasn’t prepared to neglect their needs and send them in unwell as it would have been the wrong thing to do so we had to take the huge financial hit.

So you think all parents should keep their kids at home with sore throats even if it means they lose their jobs and have to stop working?

Or maybe just the mums?

ZenNudist · 09/01/2024 08:31

SKG231 · 08/01/2024 19:33

You’re setting them up to be weak grown ups who will flake on responsibilities. Most of the time having a sore throat doesn’t stop you from daily life it’s just a mild inconvenience. Give them some soothers and suck it up. Literally.

This

Responsiveness · 09/01/2024 08:30

HoneyNuts · 09/01/2024 08:27

Which is why it’s not a big deal for you now to keep the kids home. For working parents, having to take days off to look after unwell kids is a massive stress. So they have to think carefully before doing so.

Odd that you have forgotten that, even though that’s why you quit work: the irony!

I haven’t changed how I do things at all - they were off the same when I was working as they are now I’m not. It just wasn’t working and I wasn’t prepared to neglect their needs and send them in unwell as it would have been the wrong thing to do so we had to take the huge financial hit.

OP posts:
Sk8erboi · 09/01/2024 08:30

I dont have a ticklist that decides whether I keep mine off, I know when they're too ill to attend and use my common sense.

What I have noticed is that the children who are off a lot with illness have a parent that doesn't work.
I think with attendance being in the news at the moment - it would be interesting if data relating to attendance and non working parents was collated.

HoneyNuts · 09/01/2024 08:27

Responsiveness · 09/01/2024 08:19

I’m a carer so don’t work due to ds SEN/ medical issues . I used to work and because he (and other dc) were unwell so often it just wasn’t possible to carry on

Which is why it’s not a big deal for you now to keep the kids home. For working parents, having to take days off to look after unwell kids is a massive stress. So they have to think carefully before doing so.

Odd that you have forgotten that, even though that’s why you quit work: the irony!

Responsiveness · 09/01/2024 08:23

ComfyBoobs · 09/01/2024 08:13

That’s a very low attendance rate and their education will be suffering. Does that not bother you?

It also means that the expectations of the working world are going to come as a huge shock to them. They really won’t be able to call in sick with a sore throat and being frequently off sick with minor ailments is likely to be very annoying for coworkers and managers who pick up the slack, and make them less employable.

Do you go off sick with just a sore throat?

In any event, you are doing them a real disservice.

They are all actually above average and even excelling in some areas. Attendance doesn’t always affect attainment. I don’t think any of them will have issues gaining qualifications or jobs, I’m sure by then their immune systems will have improved (I hope!) they are only at primary so I’d hope so !

OP posts:
Responsiveness · 09/01/2024 08:19

HoneyNuts · 09/01/2024 08:17

I see you are refusing to answer whether you work or not OP.

You don’t have a job do you?

I’m a carer so don’t work due to ds SEN/ medical issues . I used to work and because he (and other dc) were unwell so often it just wasn’t possible to carry on

OP posts:
HoneyNuts · 09/01/2024 08:17

I see you are refusing to answer whether you work or not OP.

You don’t have a job do you?

ComfyBoobs · 09/01/2024 08:13

That’s a very low attendance rate and their education will be suffering. Does that not bother you?

It also means that the expectations of the working world are going to come as a huge shock to them. They really won’t be able to call in sick with a sore throat and being frequently off sick with minor ailments is likely to be very annoying for coworkers and managers who pick up the slack, and make them less employable.

Do you go off sick with just a sore throat?

In any event, you are doing them a real disservice.

Responsiveness · 09/01/2024 08:12

Merryoldgoat · 09/01/2024 07:48

This is the issue - people don’t think.

It’s a 13 week term. Thats about 14/15 days off. Absolutely loads but can easily happen with multiple kids in germy schools where attendance is all.

Mine was out for a full week for D&V, the HFM was another 4 days and a hospital visit for croup with viral nonsense was another 4.

What do you do? Send them in sick?

Its perfectly normal as well as any GP will concur.

Yes the gp has told us repeatedly that it’s not an issue that children get a lot of viruses some more than others and they can take longer to build immunity and to just wait . To take vitamin d. Luckily they’ve always been happy to print off for free the appts so we can give to the school which i think is what has stopped further action as well as then seeing how bad ds was when he got ill during the school day once.

OP posts:
ladyofshertonabbas · 09/01/2024 08:01

Common sense- send child if they only have a mild sore throat, keep them off if they’re feeling dreadful.

Merryoldgoat · 09/01/2024 07:48

Benibidibici · 09/01/2024 07:26

Bloody hell 78% attendance is appalling. Thats the equivalent of more than a day off every single week all year. You definitely to see a doctor - its absolutely not normal for a child to be off school ill so much.

This is the issue - people don’t think.

It’s a 13 week term. Thats about 14/15 days off. Absolutely loads but can easily happen with multiple kids in germy schools where attendance is all.

Mine was out for a full week for D&V, the HFM was another 4 days and a hospital visit for croup with viral nonsense was another 4.

What do you do? Send them in sick?

Its perfectly normal as well as any GP will concur.

Rocknrollstar · 09/01/2024 07:32

The rule in our house was that if you were well enough to get up, get dressed and eat breakfast you went to school. Admittedly DS did once get up, get dressed and faint and DD did have to be brought home by Zoe Teacher and put to bed (I was also a teacher) but generally it worked and they got an education.

Benibidibici · 09/01/2024 07:26

Bloody hell 78% attendance is appalling. Thats the equivalent of more than a day off every single week all year. You definitely to see a doctor - its absolutely not normal for a child to be off school ill so much.

demonheed · 09/01/2024 03:11

"If I thought my mum would keep me off every time I had a bad sore throat I suspect my sore throats would entirely coincidentally become very bad."

Yup

TheSkyWasMadeOfAmethyst · 09/01/2024 03:01

Depends how sore, surely.

DS's sore throats invariably quickly turn into tonsilitis, and I can see that he genuinely feels absolutely rotten. No.way he's going to school.

DD gets the odd sore throat where her voice goes a bit husky, she has a bit of a moan, but is generally ok after a strepsil. She goes in.

thaegumathteth · 09/01/2024 02:21

@Responsiveness definitely think you should speak to GP if they are unwell enough often enough to have such low attendance.

I am NOT an advocate of 100% attendance at all costs but I do know that in all the years I've been parenting only once has one child fell below 90% and that was when he had whooping cough which exasperated his asthma and he missed a lot of school.

everythingthelighttouches · 09/01/2024 02:13

My DS gets bad sore throats often but he is usually well in himself and is not too affected by it.
*editing to say so of course I send him in.

Sometimes it will hurt more at night and so he will have calpol or ibuprofen, but I find he is distracted at school and comes home not mentioning it. He is being investigated for adhd and asd and I am reluctant to put him at any further disadvantage by taking him out of school unnecessarily.

His tonsils get pretty inflamed but it is not a reflection of the severity or infectiousness of the disease, just his body’s reaction to it. We all have different immune systems with slightly different responses.

It would be bonkers to say every time he had a sore throat it could be chicken pox or scarlet fever, those things are likely to only happen once in the whole of childhood!

He did recently have proper tonsillitis, was poorly, tired, off his food and had a fever of 39.9. I did of course have him straight down to the doctor who promptly prescribed antibiotics and I had him off school for a week. Luckily for us, these days, proper tonsillitis is a once or twice per year event.

I have got pretty good at keeping track of these things and taking photos. So attached is 1) normal “sore throat” and 2) tonsillitis which made him ill.(hopefully they load in correct order but you will be able to see the difference.)

Saschka · 09/01/2024 01:31

DS goes in unless he has D&V (thank god only had it once), or a high temp. And even with the high temperature, there have been times when he has been bouncing around the house fit as a fiddle with a temp of 38, and I have wondered whether to just give him some Calpol and send him in. The pandemic was a bloody nightmare, having to keep him home for ten days, 9 of which he looked healthier than me.

He used to get quite ill with viruses as a toddler (he used to be really lethargic when he had a high temperature), but since starting school he honestly doesn’t really get sick, and when he does he only has very mild symptoms. So obviously I don’t keep him off. And honestly I think he has a better time going to school and playing with his friends than he would sat on the sofa “being ill” for the day.

DH, on the other hand, gets the dressing gown of doom out every time he gets a sniffle.

Mariposistaa · 09/01/2024 01:15

you must have a cushy flexible job if you are allowed that much time off to be with them when they are ‘ill but not that ill’ x3.

PollyPut · 09/01/2024 00:11

@Responsiveness The sore throats your DC get seem unusual. I cannot recall my DC ever having them, not even once. Do you know why they are getting them? Is it under investigation? might there be an allergic reaction to something in the house? do they get itchy eyes or runny nose, or any other symtoms?

Chloroseptic was great when I used it - does it work for your family? and a really good scarf/snood to breath through always helped in winter

FuckOffTom · 08/01/2024 23:33

I think I am lucky that DS6 is rarely ill, and if he is - he is ill enough to keep him off. Either D&V or a temp. But circumstances dictate too - I wfh so if he was really ill without those things I would consider keeping him off. Parents that need to go to a place of work to earn may not do.
Im sure I remember when I was at school that attendance wasn’t such an issue. I’m sure they’d have investigated if it was really low but all this ‘needs to be 98%’ or whatever is a bit shit

Geekylover · 08/01/2024 23:25

You know your children best, if they are unwell with it keep them home. Ignore the judgey comments from others here!