Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I always keep my dc off school with a sore throat

139 replies

Responsiveness · 08/01/2024 19:26

Just reading latest government guidance regarding attendance- parents are being told to send children in even with a cough, cold symptoms or sore throat ? (But not to send with any symptoms of scarlet fever or chicken pox yet often a sore throat is a symptom of both these illnesses 🤦‍♀️)

I always keep mine off with sore throats ? They can be really painful even without a fever. I will continue to do so as well!

I can understand sending a child in with a tickly cough or runny nose etc but sore throats can be horrible not to mention for some dc with SEN especially ASD the sensory aspect of something like a sore throat and how it impacts eating and drinking / sound of voice/ the cold air in winter making it feel raw etc (my ds has ASD and has these issues every time)

AIBU to think that this latest advice isn’t going to help anyone ? It will just be kids in school feeling too unwell and distracted to learn or spreading germs !

OP posts:
Pointlessuser · 09/01/2024 18:43

I’m not sure I’d keep my children off with a sore throat, but my school want you to send them in even with a high temp. Absolutely no way, I wouldn’t go into work with a temp, I certainly wouldn’t expect a child to deal with a day at school 🙄

UndertheCedartree · 09/01/2024 18:42

Singleandproud · 08/01/2024 19:36

You aren't keeping your son off just for a sore throat though, you are keeping him off because the sore throat exacerbates other aspects of his disability.

DD has autism, she gets dosed up with paracetamol and a single dose in her bag to take at lunch should she need it and sent on her way if she is low grade under the weather (same as I do for myself going to work) - I'll message her pastoral lead because often being under the weather makes her autism worse and she finds things harder to deal with so she'll be checked on during the day, offered a warm, quiet place to go during unstructured times.

Edited

That's a fair point. With my autistic DD one of the issues is due to her sensory additional needs she cannot tolerate any type of medicine/tablet/spray. She had a nasty cold and was off for 4 days. The first couple of days she had a fever. She would have probably been able to go back quicker if I could give her paracetamol and throat sweets for example.

43ontherocksporfavor · 09/01/2024 18:40

As for those saying they keep them off with a temperature, ours get given Calpol to mask it!

43ontherocksporfavor · 09/01/2024 18:38

I work in primary and parents don’t seem to keep kids off at all anymore. They lie about when children are sick( they forget that little chn can’t keep secrets and tell us ) so they don’t stick to 48 hrs after last episode of vomiting or diarrhoea. Currently most year 1s are coughing , have sore throats or snotty noses.

Benibidibici · 09/01/2024 18:35

Honestly - a child missing more than 20% of school should have you seriously concerned about their health and insisting on the GP getting further checks done.

If the doctor isn't doing anything, its perhaps that they are recognising that your DC aren't really as ill as you think they are. A child genuinely presenting as too ill to attend school one day in every 5 would have most doctors very concerned.

ChaosAndCrumbs · 09/01/2024 15:30

Responsiveness · 09/01/2024 12:29

There has to be a clinical need for tonsil removal they wouldn’t just do it for attendance issues. I asked about it and was told it’s viral and although their throats get extremely red and sore their tonsils aren’t that enlarged and there isn’t always pus and when there is it’s not severe so they dont feel it’s necessary to refer. The gp keeps reassuring us that some kids just take longer to build their immune systems and they aren’t concerned. A year or so ago they checked bloods and was all normal so it’s just one of those things. I was similar up till about age 16 just constantly unwell

Not sure if this is helpful, but my GP kept fobbing me off with the immune system line (vomiting for us) and I recorded it clearly in a diary. Seeing the marks on the pages suddenly made the GP think it was too often too and he investigated further. It turned out to be the prophylaxis antibiotics my son was on at the time. I’d push for further investigation if it’s genuinely bad enough to miss school and goes on for all three children for more than a year.

Responsiveness · 09/01/2024 12:29

PollyPut · 09/01/2024 12:21

what are the doctors saying about their health? e.g. Are they suggesting taking their tonsils out to improve attendance?

There has to be a clinical need for tonsil removal they wouldn’t just do it for attendance issues. I asked about it and was told it’s viral and although their throats get extremely red and sore their tonsils aren’t that enlarged and there isn’t always pus and when there is it’s not severe so they dont feel it’s necessary to refer. The gp keeps reassuring us that some kids just take longer to build their immune systems and they aren’t concerned. A year or so ago they checked bloods and was all normal so it’s just one of those things. I was similar up till about age 16 just constantly unwell

OP posts:
PollyPut · 09/01/2024 12:21

Responsiveness · 09/01/2024 10:43

Or they could just be unusually affected by Illnesses…… they aren’t faking - they aren’t exaggerating- they love school (and they love food!) so I know when they are genuinely ill as they get upset they can’t go and are upset they can’t manage to eat

what are the doctors saying about their health? e.g. Are they suggesting taking their tonsils out to improve attendance?

Responsiveness · 09/01/2024 11:33

Sk8erboi · 09/01/2024 11:15

If it was one child who unusually suffers it would be more believable but what are the chances that all of them do.

I don't think its them though I think its you keeping them off with slight illnesses because you can.. because you're home.

Well they are obviously siblings so share genetics ! Things run in families !

I kept them off the same amount when I was in work (that’s why I ended up unable to work) I haven’t changed my thresholds based on my own circumstances I’m doing the same I always did

OP posts:
Sk8erboi · 09/01/2024 11:15

Responsiveness · 09/01/2024 10:43

Or they could just be unusually affected by Illnesses…… they aren’t faking - they aren’t exaggerating- they love school (and they love food!) so I know when they are genuinely ill as they get upset they can’t go and are upset they can’t manage to eat

If it was one child who unusually suffers it would be more believable but what are the chances that all of them do.

I don't think its them though I think its you keeping them off with slight illnesses because you can.. because you're home.

Responsiveness · 09/01/2024 10:43

Pestopastaandcheese · 09/01/2024 10:31

No wonder all three of your kids (coincidentally) have extreme sore throats when they have a normal seasonal illness that doesn't inhibit them from going to school, because it guarantees them a day off or two every couple of weeks.

Winner for them!

Or they could just be unusually affected by Illnesses…… they aren’t faking - they aren’t exaggerating- they love school (and they love food!) so I know when they are genuinely ill as they get upset they can’t go and are upset they can’t manage to eat

OP posts:
Pestopastaandcheese · 09/01/2024 10:31

No wonder all three of your kids (coincidentally) have extreme sore throats when they have a normal seasonal illness that doesn't inhibit them from going to school, because it guarantees them a day off or two every couple of weeks.

Winner for them!

BMWM340 · 09/01/2024 10:22

demonheed · 09/01/2024 03:11

"If I thought my mum would keep me off every time I had a bad sore throat I suspect my sore throats would entirely coincidentally become very bad."

Yup

Agreed.

It's no surprise your children's attendance is what it is.

ManateeFair · 09/01/2024 09:48

I don't have kids, but there are many different levels of 'sore throat'. A slightly sore throat due to a cold is one thing, and probably something that wouldn't stop someone being fine at work/school. But a horrible sore throat where it's agony to swallow and you've got spots all over your tonsils etc isn't something I'd ever expect a child to have to go to school with.

Responsiveness · 09/01/2024 09:29

eurochick · 09/01/2024 09:14

You are really not doing your kids any favours OP. You might think you are being kind but it is really not kind to have them miss a fifth of the school year unless it is 100% necessary.

If it’s not affecting their attainment and they still have friends and are happy when not unwell then what exactly is the negative impact of being off school when too unwell to go in ? Because In our case I see no benefit to my dc from being pushed in when sick

OP posts:
eurochick · 09/01/2024 09:14

You are really not doing your kids any favours OP. You might think you are being kind but it is really not kind to have them miss a fifth of the school year unless it is 100% necessary.

Kellogscorncrakes · 09/01/2024 09:10

I used to be an attendance officer in a secondary. Every year group would have a small number of the same kids who'd be off for a day or two every other week with a sore throat or upset stomach. The frustrating thing is nothing would change from year 7 to 11 and it would seriously affect their attainment. Suggestions of visiting a GP for these unusually high levels of sickness would just be met with abuse. Don't miss that job! I'd add that these cases were different to OP in that the students had no SEN

ComfyBoobs · 09/01/2024 09:07

Responsiveness · 09/01/2024 08:23

They are all actually above average and even excelling in some areas. Attendance doesn’t always affect attainment. I don’t think any of them will have issues gaining qualifications or jobs, I’m sure by then their immune systems will have improved (I hope!) they are only at primary so I’d hope so !

Attendance will eventually affect attainment. It’s easy enough to fill the cracks when they’re little and learning basic stuff, but you’ll find that they are quickly outpaced when they miss lessons at secondary. If they miss 20% of their lessons in a fast paced curriculum that will of course be reflected in their performance.

When talking about future employability I wasn’t talking about their immune system - rather that it will have been embedded into their thinking that they’re entitled to soft days off every time they have a sniffle. Either you need to unwind that with them and build some resilience or they will need to do it themselves. Or maybe they’ll just quit work like you did?

TheTigerWhoCameToEatMyHusband · 09/01/2024 09:00

KnickerlessParsons · 09/01/2024 08:52

I wonder if children of parents who don't work stay off school more often than children from homes where both work out of the house?
It would be interesting to see if there's any correlation, particularly at primary and younger years of secondary. 🤔

I think there definitely will be. I had to send mine in and occasionally just hope the school would ring work to say they needed picking up as I could take it as emergency family leave. I couldn't afford to take the time off we would've been homeless and hungry if I didn't send them in anytime they sneezed.

EddieHoweBlackandWhiteArmy · 09/01/2024 08:56

I should imagine that’s a given, especially since COVID, people are more able to work at home and so err on the side of caution.

HoneyNuts · 09/01/2024 08:55

Responsiveness · 09/01/2024 08:38

No that’s not what I think or what I said. It’s an individual decision and my dc do need to be off in these situations but it spends on the child and the severity of their symptoms.

I had to give up work as on top of the medical appts the absence through illness was too much - and I couldn’t have just sent them in as they have been in too much pain, ibuprofen wasn’t helping enough to allow them to eat / drink or be distracted.

We had to downsize and I had to give up my car so we just share the one now. No more holidays for a few years either and we now have a strict budget till dc are a bit older and I can work again so I absolutely do understand the struggles of working parents !

Well if you understand the struggles, then I guess it should not be too much of a stretch to understand why parents keep their kids at school with mild sore throats 🤷🏼‍♀️

RedPony1 · 09/01/2024 08:55

I'm so glad i had faffless parents, making me get on with life regardless because i had responsibilities (ponies) I'd have really struggled with adulthood if i was allowed a break every time i was under the weather.

Also, I've never been in pain with a sore throat. discomfort? of course. Pain? except tonsilitis, never.

KnickerlessParsons · 09/01/2024 08:52

I wonder if children of parents who don't work stay off school more often than children from homes where both work out of the house?
It would be interesting to see if there's any correlation, particularly at primary and younger years of secondary. 🤔

Bornonsunday · 09/01/2024 08:46

You won't get much sympathy on AIBU. Patenting a kid with special needs is hard and kids with asd often struggle more due to other illnesses or sensory issues.

I have one kid with asd bit thankfully he wasn't ill much. But I did take time out of work to care for him.

Those saying they'll be flaky at work - sadly only 16% of adults with asd work full, and it's not due to sore throats. They have it harder in all sorts of ways.

EddieHoweBlackandWhiteArmy · 09/01/2024 08:44

This is written for younger children but still useful!

I always keep my dc off school with a sore throat