Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Not believing in marriage is a luxury belief

186 replies

ironorchids · 08/01/2024 19:11

Is it me or are there a lot of men these days who disbelieve in marriage for various reasons at the expense of the women they are with who believe in it, want it and have wanted it their whole lives?

Whatever the various reasons they give for disbelieving in it, at the end of the day, it is a luxury belief for someone who will never ever have to worry about or to take on the risk of potentially getting pregnant, having to have months or years off work to recover, feed them from your body, or even risk being left holding the baby as you're the one physically pregnant, if their partner leaves?

Disbelief in marriage is a luxury, and it's usually (not always) when you are free from all that risk and have that luxury that you can afford to believe all the other reasons so many men give (at the expense of the women they're with) for not believing in it.

OP posts:
blettedmedlar · 09/01/2024 09:10

@Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g I spent years gently correcting a friend who kept saying she was in a common law marriage, telling her the phrase is meaningless, but she wouldn't listen. Sadly her partner died last year, and their not being married has made a difficult time even harder. Six months down the line one of his pension providers is asking for yet more evidence they were a couple, while she is really struggling without the half of his pension and lump sum that she is entitled to.

Justfinking · 09/01/2024 09:06

I genuinely believe that being married makes you actually stop and think about if you actually want to be with that person forever. It's very easy to let a relationship grow organically, move in together, have kids etc. I also think this is why many men when actually asked to commit don't want to despite 'being married' unofficially

puncheur · 09/01/2024 09:06

@LadyPeterWimsey actually on reflection I think that I’m correct in my interpretation of the phrase as used in the U.K. Your examples and your use of “college degree” suggest you are coming et this from an American perspective and even if the phrase was originally American I think it’s meaning has diverged here.

puncheur · 09/01/2024 08:59

@LadyPeterWimsey oh, I thought it meant a belief that was more prevalent among well off people. That’s how I’ve always interpreted the phrase when I’ve read it in news articles etc.

Nospecialcharactersplease · 09/01/2024 08:33

Totally agree, OP. However, just as important is the ‘these are my terms if we’re having children’ chat. I sat my husband down before he even moved in, five years or so before we married, and got his agreement that if we ever had kids we would share the parental leave and I would take exactly the same number of months off as him. Then the child is going to full time nursery, with the costs met from our salaries proportionally. In lots of little ways I’ve made him see that I have no intention of being default parent or sacrificing a jot more than him. I’ll do the first nine months of pregnancy, necessarily, and it’s 50/50 from then.

I don’t know why more women don’t do this. It’s a contract. Somebody needs your labour (literally). Negotiate.

Hereyoume · 09/01/2024 08:29

ironorchids · 08/01/2024 19:11

Is it me or are there a lot of men these days who disbelieve in marriage for various reasons at the expense of the women they are with who believe in it, want it and have wanted it their whole lives?

Whatever the various reasons they give for disbelieving in it, at the end of the day, it is a luxury belief for someone who will never ever have to worry about or to take on the risk of potentially getting pregnant, having to have months or years off work to recover, feed them from your body, or even risk being left holding the baby as you're the one physically pregnant, if their partner leaves?

Disbelief in marriage is a luxury, and it's usually (not always) when you are free from all that risk and have that luxury that you can afford to believe all the other reasons so many men give (at the expense of the women they're with) for not believing in it.

Getting married is a choice.

For those who don't want any, having children is a choice.

There are some places on the planet where neither of the above is a choice for women, but that's a much more serious and complex issue.

If a woman is willing to live with a man as his wife, have children with a man, and not be married to that man, what incentive is there for that man to get married?

What else would he gain?

By not marrying in those circumstances the man is financially way better off. No lean on his pension, assets or inheritance.

The bigger question is why some of us make such poor decisions about the men we have children with.

BadLad · 09/01/2024 08:09

heartofglass23 · 09/01/2024 07:30

It's not something to 'believe' in, it's not Santa or the Easter bunny!

It's a legal contract that confers rights & responsibilities on parties.

You and a few previous posters appear to be unaware that “believe in” has more than one meaning.

be of the opinion that something is right or acceptable.

have confidence in a person or a course of action.

heartofglass23 · 09/01/2024 07:30

It's not something to 'believe' in, it's not Santa or the Easter bunny!

It's a legal contract that confers rights & responsibilities on parties.

RedMinnie · 09/01/2024 07:22

ironorchids · 08/01/2024 19:23

I know women don't believe I marriage too, but I have heard time and again of relationships where the man does not want marriage but the woman does and it causes a lot of pain.

I have never heard it in reverse where a man believes in marriage but the women they're with doesn't. Maybe I have a very biased perspective.

Why is one person’s view more important than the other? Neither is wrong or right. They just have different expectations

AndThatWasNY · 09/01/2024 07:20

I didn't believe in marriage and was quite happy to never get married. I am very anti religion and couldn't see what the government had to do with my relationship.
However when I met my partner he already had a child (and had been treated badly by his ex, not given PR, before it was automatic for men on the birth certificate, had years of fighting for custody, acutely aware that if she died her very difficult mother would have as much right to custody as him). They had only found out she was pregnant after they split up so after a disastrously year of trying again they split up.
We met about 4 years later. He was happy to stay unmarried but would not have any more children outside of marriage. I knew I wanted to have children with him and so agreed to get married. 20 years this year. I am happy to be married as I love him so much and it means so much to him.

I wish laws would change for long-term partners as it's disgusting. Of course people can cheat the system but they can now. One of my clients has married his male housemate, both retired, both straight, but get each others pensions if die!

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 09/01/2024 07:04

BarelyLiterate · 08/01/2024 23:42

If I owned significant assets, I certainly wouldn’t believe in marriage to someone who owned none, so I completely understand why a man who owned his house wouldn’t believe in marriage to a woman who didn’t own a property.

As it is, DP & I have been together for 20+ years and have no plans to marry. We are childfree by choice, both of us have good jobs, our mortgage is paid off, we are financially comfortable & we keep our finances separate. What would be the point of getting married?

Inheritance tax. Hopefully you both have long healthy lives ahead of you, but when the first partner dies if you are married there's no Inheritance tax on what you leave to your spouse. If you're not married and leave enough to attract tax, that could take a big chunk out of the estate.

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 09/01/2024 00:54

albalass · 08/01/2024 23:39

There's always a handful of women on these threads who'll be better off not marrying, but it really is such a small minority.

But isn't that so depressing? Surely we want the next generation of women to seek security through education and a career rather than marriage?

That all goes to hell in a handcart as soon as she has kids. The gendersexed pay gap kicks in on the first day of her first maternity leave when her drops by 10% because mat pay is only 90% of salary.

If a woman plans to have children, she should marry their father or second female parent (SFP) first. Mothers do vital work for both the father/SFP and the State by bearing and doing the bulk of raising children and they are wise to make sure that that work's value is reflected financially in the event of the relationship breaking down.

Trilateralcommission · 09/01/2024 00:47

being married does not stop people having affairs

SouthLondonMum22 · 09/01/2024 00:36

If someone wants to get married, they need to be with someone who wants to get married too. They don't have to stay with someone who is clear that they don't want to get married and won't change their mind.

DH wanted to get married, I didn't but ultimately agreed because I love him and it meant a lot to him so did change my mind in the end. I'm now the higher earner but I have no regrets.

SisterHyster · 09/01/2024 00:30

NotSuchASmugMarriedAnymore · 08/01/2024 22:04

I'm always slightly puzzled at why women live with men they're not married to.

I mean, years ago, living together was like a kind of "trial marriage" where people lived together for 6-12 months to see if they were compatible before getting married.

So, those of you who live with men you're not married to, my question is this - why? (not talking about people who do it for financial reasons obviously)

Why would I get married to him? Things are perfectly good the way they are. Neither of us would gain or lose out by being married. We don’t need to prove ourselves to others.

theconfidenceofwho · 09/01/2024 00:24

ElevenSeven · 08/01/2024 19:34

I know women don't believe I marriage too, but I have heard time and again of relationships where the man does not want marriage but the woman does and it causes a lot of pain.

Those men often go on to marry someone else though, very quickly after they start dating. Sometimes I think people need to read the room and leave, if they’re not getting what they want.

Absolutely - have sadly known a couple of women where this has happened - 10 year plus relationships with no marriage & no kids then they split and both guys met & married their new wives within 6-12 months of meeting!

From my perspective, marriage isn't a religion, its a contract that you either agree or disagree with, but it's not something to believe in as it very much exists and there is proof of existence. If people view it this way, then I think it would help clarify what people actually want / where they are compatible.

ConsuelaHammock · 09/01/2024 00:18

I think some men get away with stringing women along because some women let them. If you want to get married then don’t settle for less. No children before marriage, don’t become their live in maid, cleaner, cook and for gods sake don’t give up working. They have everything they want with the added bonus that they can walk away when it suits them without any legal ties whatsoever. And then the women is screwed!

purpletrees16 · 08/01/2024 23:45

I know a couple who never believed in marriage but who got a civil partnership when she had to take a second year off after maternity (due to redundancies in her industry.)

we had pizza in the park afterwards.

civil partnerships tend to iron out the feminist objections & are often chosen for those who don’t want traditional obligations.

e.g. To invite family that don’t get on with each other or to have 100 people when they are both introverts.

BarelyLiterate · 08/01/2024 23:42

If I owned significant assets, I certainly wouldn’t believe in marriage to someone who owned none, so I completely understand why a man who owned his house wouldn’t believe in marriage to a woman who didn’t own a property.

As it is, DP & I have been together for 20+ years and have no plans to marry. We are childfree by choice, both of us have good jobs, our mortgage is paid off, we are financially comfortable & we keep our finances separate. What would be the point of getting married?

albalass · 08/01/2024 23:39

There's always a handful of women on these threads who'll be better off not marrying, but it really is such a small minority.

But isn't that so depressing? Surely we want the next generation of women to seek security through education and a career rather than marriage?

LadyPeterWimsey · 08/01/2024 23:38

The other point about luxury beliefs is that if you are wealthy, you can afford to put them into practice because your money will insulate you from the negative effects that less affluent people will experience.

YabbaDabbaDooooo · 08/01/2024 23:34

TizerorFizz · 08/01/2024 23:25

Hope your DS likes the inheritance tax payment when the time comes. Every unmarried couple I know has property.

The worse off in the relationship won’t have any grounds for negotiating a settlement if they split up if they are not married. That is usually the woman. It’s naive to think anyone is better off being a single parent. You simply have no negotiating rights. Unless you are the rich one with all the assets you don’t want to share of course. It is, however, mostly men that hide assets. Some women believe not marrying is equality. For most it’s inequality.

Some women believe not marrying is equality. For most it’s inequality.

So very true 👏👏👏

There's always a handful of women on these threads who'll be better off not marrying, but it really is such a small minority.

LadyPeterWimsey · 08/01/2024 23:33

puncheur · 08/01/2024 23:17

If it was a luxury belief you would see more people in higher socioeconomic classes not marrying before having children than those in lower socioeconomic classes. This is in fact the inverse of what is observed. The wealthier and more educated you are, the more likely you are to marry before having children, ergo it is not a luxury belief, indeed it is quite the reverse.

The idea behind luxury beliefs is that they are positions you hold which you don't yourself practice but by giving them currency other less affluent people are therefore injured by them. I think it was coined by Rob Henderson, who puts it like this:

'The original luxury belief is that family structure is unimportant, despite a vast body of research indicating that a stable two-parent home is one of the strongest factors for a child’s wellbeing and future.

Among U.S. college graduates, onlyy 25 percent think couples should be married before having kids. Their actions, though, contradict their luxury belief: the majorityy of American college graduates who have children are married.
Affluent people are the most likely to promote the view that marriage is unimportant, despite their behavior suggesting otherwise.
And they have assigned a lot of value to this nonjudgmental view, such that if you challenge it, many will respond defensively.
Upper-middle and upper-class people will say things like marriage is “just a piece of paper.” People shouldn’t have to prove their commitment to their spouse with a document, they tell me.
I have never heard them ridicule a college degree as “just a piece of paper.” Many affluent people belittle marriage. But not college. Because they view a degree as critical for their self-worth and social positions.
In fact, if you challenge the importance of college, many people will respond with anger. They hold the belief that college is good and are reluctant to part with it.'

www.robkhenderson.com/p/luxury-beliefs-are-like-possessions

ManateeFair · 08/01/2024 23:31

Marriage - like alcohol consumption - is one of those issues where Mumsnet is so out of step with the opinion of the general female population that I sometimes wonder whether some of the posters are actually characters from a Jane Austen novel.

TizerorFizz · 08/01/2024 23:25

Hope your DS likes the inheritance tax payment when the time comes. Every unmarried couple I know has property.

The worse off in the relationship won’t have any grounds for negotiating a settlement if they split up if they are not married. That is usually the woman. It’s naive to think anyone is better off being a single parent. You simply have no negotiating rights. Unless you are the rich one with all the assets you don’t want to share of course. It is, however, mostly men that hide assets. Some women believe not marrying is equality. For most it’s inequality.