Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Not believing in marriage is a luxury belief

186 replies

ironorchids · 08/01/2024 19:11

Is it me or are there a lot of men these days who disbelieve in marriage for various reasons at the expense of the women they are with who believe in it, want it and have wanted it their whole lives?

Whatever the various reasons they give for disbelieving in it, at the end of the day, it is a luxury belief for someone who will never ever have to worry about or to take on the risk of potentially getting pregnant, having to have months or years off work to recover, feed them from your body, or even risk being left holding the baby as you're the one physically pregnant, if their partner leaves?

Disbelief in marriage is a luxury, and it's usually (not always) when you are free from all that risk and have that luxury that you can afford to believe all the other reasons so many men give (at the expense of the women they're with) for not believing in it.

OP posts:
N4ish · 09/01/2024 11:29

AnneLovesGilbert · 09/01/2024 11:04

I wish laws would change for long-term partners as it's disgusting.

Is this advocating for common law marriage as a concept in law? That’s far more dangerous. Legal and financial committing to another adult should be an opt in action, not a default. But Labour are saying they’ll bring it in anyway.

I'm worried about this law changing too. I choose not to be married for many reasons and I don't want to be married by default without being able to opt out. Getting married is a huge financial commitment and should definitely be opt in only.

AnneLovesGilbert · 09/01/2024 11:04

I wish laws would change for long-term partners as it's disgusting.

Is this advocating for common law marriage as a concept in law? That’s far more dangerous. Legal and financial committing to another adult should be an opt in action, not a default. But Labour are saying they’ll bring it in anyway.

Circularargument · 09/01/2024 10:58

Issueatwork · 08/01/2024 22:40

Just an alternate view, but in my circles growing up I would deem it the opposite.
People didn’t have the luxury belief of marriage as they had fuck all financially. Not homeowners, no significant loss of earnings, no pension contributions lost. So what’s the point.
I think being worried about marriage and its financial implications is quite a middle class thing.

Because only the mc have assets? Oh, come on. These days the guys raking it in are trades. Ask my mum's Porsche owner mortagage free in Surrey plasterer neighbour

Gastropod · 09/01/2024 10:39

Marriage as a legal contract has very little to do with love or emotional commitment. It's a financial arrangement, first and foremost. I was one of those breadwinning women who suffered financially as a result of divorce. I paid out a heck of a lot more than my ex ever put in.

If I'd fully understood the immense financial risk that I was taking on simply by getting married I'd have certainly thought more carefully about it. I think that prenups, or some equivalent of them, should be a legal requirement before marriage.

With the benefit of hindsight, I now think it's astonishing that any man or woman would take on such a financial risk without fully informing themselves of all the implications. I don't blame the newlyweds, but rather the process of marriage itself. So easy to walk into, all hearts and flowers, but my god it's hellish to get out of, from a financial perspective - not to downplay the emotional fallout of course.

kiwiaddict · 09/01/2024 10:38

@NotSuchASmugMarriedAnymore

When I moved into university halls, mine was a little flat of 5 of us. One was my now ex-husband, and we became a couple while living together (6 weeks in).

It's a little difficult to go from living together to not living together

ironorchids · 09/01/2024 10:36

@LadyPeterWimsey

"The idea behind luxury beliefs is that they are positions you hold which you don't yourself practice but by giving them currency other less affluent people are therefore injured by them."

Thank you for the quotes and references.

It seems to be similar to people calling for the defunding of the police in parts of the US a few years ago. The poorest people who needed the police the most to protect them from robberies and violent crimes were not the ones calling to defund the police.

OP posts:
CurlewKate · 09/01/2024 10:35

I don't believe in marriage and I'm a woman!

In my experience, most men who "don't believe in marriage" also don't believe in fidelity or commitment- it's rarely a political or philosophical position.

puncheur · 09/01/2024 10:34

@ironorchids I don’t think there’s any cynical reasons for it. It’s more that in higher socioeconomic groups it’s more ‘the done thing’ and everyone, women and men, sees the benefit, especially when children are involved. There are also fewer ‘blended families’ in these groups because again, people are perhaps better equipped to see the advantages of nuclear families. So even if people in these groups do get divorced they are less likely to go on to have more children with a different partner. Boris Johnson excepted of course.

ironorchids · 09/01/2024 10:29

puncheur · 08/01/2024 23:17

If it was a luxury belief you would see more people in higher socioeconomic classes not marrying before having children than those in lower socioeconomic classes. This is in fact the inverse of what is observed. The wealthier and more educated you are, the more likely you are to marry before having children, ergo it is not a luxury belief, indeed it is quite the reverse.

That's a very good point. I would guess that the reason for this is that education leads to fewer women expecting to have to put up with men not marrying them and fewer men being able to get away with it.

OP posts:
N4ish · 09/01/2024 10:26

CleverLilViper · 09/01/2024 09:13

I don’t believe in marriage.

Its not for me. I don’t want kids either. I have my own job and home. I don’t need to financially tie myself to someone else for security. We should, as a society, be ensuring that women understand the value of financial independence not finding ways to further entrap them to men.

How many threads on MN are there where the married woman feels trapped in a bad, abusive marriage because she ceded financial independence to her husband?

If a woman wants children, and knows that she will be the one to sacrifice her earning potential, it may be wise to consider getting married before having kids. I don’t deny that, but I think there’s plenty of situations where women would be foolish to get married.

I own my own home. I earn more than my boyfriend. He doesn’t own a home and bar his car, he has no assets. I’d be a fool to get married and that is just a reality. And my home will be going to my nephew when the time comes. That’s my plan. I’m not here to make provision for grown adult men who can do for themselves same as I have done for myself.

I completely agree with this. We should be encouraging girls to work on being financially independent rather than pushing them to get married.

TizerorFizz · 09/01/2024 10:21

@blettedmedlar At least he had sorted a lot out. Without a will it’s difficult when people die younger and unexpectedly and have children.

blettedmedlar · 09/01/2024 10:16

@TizerorFizz He had a will where she was the sole beneficiary and she was named as the sole person who got death benefits from his pension. They owned their house jointly, bought outright. So she was covered as much as she could be despite not being married, but the post death admin has been made so much more difficult and distressing because they weren't married.

TizerorFizz · 09/01/2024 10:09

@blettedmedlar The problem is, your friend is not entitled to anything. She was not married. If her partner had no will, she’s not even entitled to any of his estate. Let alone make decisions for him if he was not capable. People don’t understand the legalities and protections that marriage confers. Yes, it is more complex if you split up but it’s not easy if you have joint assets and dc if you are not married either.

Gettingbysomehow · 09/01/2024 10:07

NotSuchASmugMarriedAnymore · 08/01/2024 22:37

Thats interesting that both the men who proposed to you left when you said no. You'd think they'd have stayed if they loved you so much they wanted to spend the rest of their life with you.

Incidently, where are they now? I presume they just found another woman to live with.

I don't trust men either. I think they see women as a "resource" - something that exists to benefit them.

Sadly both latched onto another woman almost immediately. The new woman had her own home of course.
Even if they had really loved me I'm sure I would still have ended up doing all the housework and being a widow to their hobbies. I just can't be bothered with it all.
When you are an older woman there is nearly always an ulterior motive to men approaching you.

TempleOfBloom · 09/01/2024 10:06

Dacadactyl · 08/01/2024 19:20

I agree.

I think only childless, FT working/financially independent people benefit from being unmarried when in a couple. And even then, you'd be better off married for tax purposes if one of you died.

Only if you each own more than £325k worth of assets (not including pension)

LardyCakeAgain · 09/01/2024 10:03

KVick · 09/01/2024 10:00

For a woman with a career, marriage is very much a losing proposition while it's a benefit for a man. Even when the woman works full-time, she's suddenly expected to become the cook, maid and nanny while he doesn't even change his golf schedule!

On the other hand when it comes to divorce, it's the man who's often the loser. Loses his kids, his house, half or more of his assets..... He winds up in his 30's or older having to move back in with elderly parents, crash on friends' sofas, or if that's not an option.... he's sleeping in his car....

But that's the point isn't it, it's a balance that's supposed to break even by retirement age. Why should the boyfriend get to enjoy career progression and time out on his hobbies while the girlfriend is knee-deep in nappies, then walk out and keep all of the assets built on the back of her free labour?

KVick · 09/01/2024 10:00

For a woman with a career, marriage is very much a losing proposition while it's a benefit for a man. Even when the woman works full-time, she's suddenly expected to become the cook, maid and nanny while he doesn't even change his golf schedule!

On the other hand when it comes to divorce, it's the man who's often the loser. Loses his kids, his house, half or more of his assets..... He winds up in his 30's or older having to move back in with elderly parents, crash on friends' sofas, or if that's not an option.... he's sleeping in his car....

LardyCakeAgain · 09/01/2024 09:52

I agree - in the main, it's immature men enjoying having a live-in maid / cleaner / cook / childcare provider, while they look around for what/whom they really want.

I was very clear with DH that if he wanted to buy a house we were getting married first - I wasn't spending a fortune getting solicitor documents drawn up when we could be married at the registry office for far less money. I also wasn't going to start a protracted, expensive legal argument about who owned what % of the house if we split, that didn't take into account anything like illness or pregnancy / maternity leave.

So many folk say "but having kids is a much bigger commitment to each other" - we know, that's the bloody point! They'll knock you up but won't sign a certificate giving you legal and financial protection? Fuck that!

LadyPeterWimsey · 09/01/2024 09:45

puncheur · 09/01/2024 09:06

@LadyPeterWimsey actually on reflection I think that I’m correct in my interpretation of the phrase as used in the U.K. Your examples and your use of “college degree” suggest you are coming et this from an American perspective and even if the phrase was originally American I think it’s meaning has diverged here.

I'm not American but Rob Henderson is, although I believe he is doing postgraduate work at Cambridge at the moment. He's the one who I quoted and whose post I linked to and he is the one who is credited with coming up with the concept of the luxury belief.

His point - and I think it stands both here and across the Atlantic - is that a luxury belief is one held by economic and intellectual elites to distinguish themselves from those in lower socio-economic groups. The elites hold these beliefs, but largely do not practice them themselves, or if they do, their many economic and social advantages protect them from the harmful effects of those beliefs.

TrashedSofa · 09/01/2024 09:43

ManateeFair · 08/01/2024 23:31

Marriage - like alcohol consumption - is one of those issues where Mumsnet is so out of step with the opinion of the general female population that I sometimes wonder whether some of the posters are actually characters from a Jane Austen novel.

It'll be because the MN demographic skews more privileged and educated.

Even the women on here who are quite against marriage often hold that view with a full understanding of the legal and financial implications. Sometimes that understanding is the reason they don't want to get married.

I know there's been a bit of it this thread, but I'd be surprised if we don't have a lower percentage than average of people who think marriage is just a piece of paper.

FurballFrenzy · 09/01/2024 09:40

NotSuchASmugMarriedAnymore · 08/01/2024 22:04

I'm always slightly puzzled at why women live with men they're not married to.

I mean, years ago, living together was like a kind of "trial marriage" where people lived together for 6-12 months to see if they were compatible before getting married.

So, those of you who live with men you're not married to, my question is this - why? (not talking about people who do it for financial reasons obviously)

In my case, because being married brings absolutely no benefits to either of us. No kids, no intention to have kids, and total value of estate well below IHT threshold.

Mirror wills and POA set up. Zero interest in marriage.

caramac04 · 09/01/2024 09:38

Much as I love DH, we married after many years of living together to formalise our finances. DH is the major earner/pension etc and I could have been hung out to dry had he died and we weren’t married.
His cousins, who are nice people, would have inherited. People aren’t always so nice when it comes to money.
A well written will would have sufficed but we both feel I am better cared for by being married.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 09/01/2024 09:33

From all I’ve ever read or heard, the men who ‘don’t believe in marriage’ soon start believing in it once they’ve left their partner of 9 years for someone they actually want to commit to.
‘It’s just a piece of paper’ is the usual excuse until then.

Rorlaa · 09/01/2024 09:28

I don't know. Looking from the perspective of men, marriage just only adds some uncomfortable loyal responsibility.
If I look at the other threads like the one about women not wanting a baby boy bc they don't want to raise a future @sshole/violator and another one expecting everyone to name their kids after the mothers as it's women who bear pregnancies (as it was the greatest sacrifise ever) so they have " more rights to the child" then I think the only reason there are still men wanting to be married is that they don't read boards like this :D

CleverLilViper · 09/01/2024 09:13

I don’t believe in marriage.

Its not for me. I don’t want kids either. I have my own job and home. I don’t need to financially tie myself to someone else for security. We should, as a society, be ensuring that women understand the value of financial independence not finding ways to further entrap them to men.

How many threads on MN are there where the married woman feels trapped in a bad, abusive marriage because she ceded financial independence to her husband?

If a woman wants children, and knows that she will be the one to sacrifice her earning potential, it may be wise to consider getting married before having kids. I don’t deny that, but I think there’s plenty of situations where women would be foolish to get married.

I own my own home. I earn more than my boyfriend. He doesn’t own a home and bar his car, he has no assets. I’d be a fool to get married and that is just a reality. And my home will be going to my nephew when the time comes. That’s my plan. I’m not here to make provision for grown adult men who can do for themselves same as I have done for myself.