Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Not believing in marriage is a luxury belief

186 replies

ironorchids · 08/01/2024 19:11

Is it me or are there a lot of men these days who disbelieve in marriage for various reasons at the expense of the women they are with who believe in it, want it and have wanted it their whole lives?

Whatever the various reasons they give for disbelieving in it, at the end of the day, it is a luxury belief for someone who will never ever have to worry about or to take on the risk of potentially getting pregnant, having to have months or years off work to recover, feed them from your body, or even risk being left holding the baby as you're the one physically pregnant, if their partner leaves?

Disbelief in marriage is a luxury, and it's usually (not always) when you are free from all that risk and have that luxury that you can afford to believe all the other reasons so many men give (at the expense of the women they're with) for not believing in it.

OP posts:
N4ish · 09/01/2024 13:40

ironorchids · 09/01/2024 13:26

@Cosywintertime
No woman should be forced to have a child
What you're saying here is effectively unless women have been forced to have a child, then the risks of pregnancy and childbirth are their problem because they chose to do it.

It's not common women need to take years to recover from pregnancy
It's quite common for women to still be breastfeeding years after pregnancy, to have issues like impaired pelvic floor function, haemorrhoids, continence and other issues years after as a result of pregnancy. It is quite common for women to have long lasting effects on their careers, slower promotions, and other effects that have a lifelong impact on their finances, even those who are very highly paid.

And as for the myth of the little girl dreaming of being a bride, I think the popularity of things like Hallmark movies involving marriage at the end should indicate that this is not a myth.

I don't understand why you think my post is about women dreaming about having babies "for their partners".

None of what I've said is about women having the children to please their partners.

With the Hallmark movies promoting marriage aren't you looking at it the wrong way around? Surely the movies are instilling a very conservative idea of marriage as the ultimate end goal into the minds of gullable young girls rather than genuinely reflecting an innate desire that girls are born with?

herewegoroundthebastardbush · 09/01/2024 13:39

@ironorchids

What you're saying here is effectively unless women have been forced to have a child, then the risks of pregnancy and childbirth are their problem because they chose to do it.

Fundamentally, yes. Absolutely yes. Obviously in a good world we should have a responsive functioning health service to support women through difficulties in pregnancy and postnatally; but no-one can remove that risk. Just as no-one should be able to remove a woman's right to control her fertility. So the only person who can or should take responsibility and ownership of that decision is the person who would be undertaking the very real risk.

Being married won't stop you getting pre-eclampsia, or haemorrhaging during labour, or becoming doubly incontinent through childbirth. Being married won't stop you getting PND. Being married won't prevent you getting mastitis. Being married won't stop you from dying in childbirth.

These are the risks; also the risks are obvious that a man can up and leave his wife and child, married or not, and contribute very little subsequently (even if married, a clever lawyer or being even remotely savvy about concealing wealth or income, or he goes on to start another family with someone else, and the ex is fucked for money). Or he can die penniless having secretly gambled away the savings. Anything can happen and being married is little or no protection from bad things happening.

So you should only have children if you are 100% comfortable about being the only one who is there for them when the rubber meets the road.

ironorchids · 09/01/2024 13:33

canttellyouwhereorwhatido · 09/01/2024 11:59

I'll tell you what would be an interesting test of men's beliefs on marriage.. and cavalier attitude to fatherhood. ..

Change the law so that the current marital rights accorded to marriage change - so that fathering or mothering a child guaranteed the same rights.

ie . I get pregnant by Joe Smith and instead of me being left with the baby and he skips off into the sunset - that dna proof gives me the legal right to half his property .. to bring up his child . Or vice versa for a man..

Watch the accidental pregnancy rate plummet as men try harder to protect their fertility and marriage become more popular as it makes no financial difference once you have decided to have kids.

Unlikely ever to happen but it should.

This is a fantastic idea.

OP posts:
ironorchids · 09/01/2024 13:26

@Cosywintertime
No woman should be forced to have a child
What you're saying here is effectively unless women have been forced to have a child, then the risks of pregnancy and childbirth are their problem because they chose to do it.

It's not common women need to take years to recover from pregnancy
It's quite common for women to still be breastfeeding years after pregnancy, to have issues like impaired pelvic floor function, haemorrhoids, continence and other issues years after as a result of pregnancy. It is quite common for women to have long lasting effects on their careers, slower promotions, and other effects that have a lifelong impact on their finances, even those who are very highly paid.

And as for the myth of the little girl dreaming of being a bride, I think the popularity of things like Hallmark movies involving marriage at the end should indicate that this is not a myth.

I don't understand why you think my post is about women dreaming about having babies "for their partners".

None of what I've said is about women having the children to please their partners.

OP posts:
VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 09/01/2024 13:20

canttellyouwhereorwhatido · 09/01/2024 11:59

I'll tell you what would be an interesting test of men's beliefs on marriage.. and cavalier attitude to fatherhood. ..

Change the law so that the current marital rights accorded to marriage change - so that fathering or mothering a child guaranteed the same rights.

ie . I get pregnant by Joe Smith and instead of me being left with the baby and he skips off into the sunset - that dna proof gives me the legal right to half his property .. to bring up his child . Or vice versa for a man..

Watch the accidental pregnancy rate plummet as men try harder to protect their fertility and marriage become more popular as it makes no financial difference once you have decided to have kids.

Unlikely ever to happen but it should.

I came back here to suggest this brilliant idea but you beat me to it.

This would protect all mothers. I agree with it.

TrashedSofa · 09/01/2024 13:19

Cosywintertime · 09/01/2024 13:05

Where as that does happen, let us be completely honest, in many instances the woman prefers to be the one to provide the care. And for the man to work, not she works and her husband is the carer.

'Preference' is one way of looking at it.

Mine and DHs ND child doesn't preclude either of us from working, fortunately. If one of us had had to quit entirely, I earn less than him. Interestingly, I earned more until experiencing maternity discrimination.

If we'd have been in a position where only one income had to cover the bills, we'd have had to pick the higher one. And of course, as women tend to be younger than male partners and jobs we do tend to be worse paid anyway (often because of their association with our femaleness) the male partner is likely to be the higher earner. Thousands and thousands of families face this choice every year. They do so in a climate of significant structural factors that make it more likely the woman will be the one to provide the care.

ironorchids · 09/01/2024 13:15

Wolfpa · 09/01/2024 13:09

I don’t believe in marriage, I believe it’s an outdated concept and the laws need to change to reflect this.

I do also have the luxury of being financially independent from my partner. If I wasn’t marriage will be the easiest way to protect myself financially

ie, you have the luxury of not believing in it

OP posts:
TrashedSofa · 09/01/2024 13:14

YetAnotherSpartacus · 09/01/2024 12:32

This is even before we consider longer term issues like DC who need more substantial care. You can't opt out of this either, and neither can you necessarily choose for it not to affect your career

Comparatively few women have that level of complications and as for children needing more substantial care there is nothing to say that men can’t do this.

'Comparatively few' doesn't really mean anything here. Some women do, you don't get to decide whether you're going to be one of them, therefore it is not a risk that you can good choice yourself out of.

As for men doing it, yes, some do, but this is what I was referring to with the bit about the toxic combination of patriarchy and bad luck. There are structural and societal reasons why this falls disproportionately on women and again, it is naive to think this is something you can avoid by simply staying in work.

And your argument does need to address the impact of maternity discrimination, speaking as someone who's experienced it and got the settlement agreement to prove it. Took me a while to get back to where I wanted to be afterwards, and there's been an impact on my career total earnings because of the way in which I was penalised for biology. There is no way in which my male partner could've taken an equal share of that load and it's just plain wrong to suggest otherwise.

Wolfpa · 09/01/2024 13:09

I don’t believe in marriage, I believe it’s an outdated concept and the laws need to change to reflect this.

I do also have the luxury of being financially independent from my partner. If I wasn’t marriage will be the easiest way to protect myself financially

Cosywintertime · 09/01/2024 13:05

user1477391263 · 09/01/2024 12:38

Of course men can do this.

They mostly don’t, though.

When a couple has a child who requires a really challenging level of care, it’s so common that the father just won’t provide it at the standard required. They’re not openly hostile, they just… don’t really step up, not to the level that the child needs. And so the mother starts to realize that either she stops working and provides the care needed, or her child will be neglected.

As women, we have the caring thing going on in our brains. It’s hard to switch off, even though it may impoverish us and make us very vulnerable.

Where as that does happen, let us be completely honest, in many instances the woman prefers to be the one to provide the care. And for the man to work, not she works and her husband is the carer.

Cosywintertime · 09/01/2024 13:03

ironorchids · 08/01/2024 19:11

Is it me or are there a lot of men these days who disbelieve in marriage for various reasons at the expense of the women they are with who believe in it, want it and have wanted it their whole lives?

Whatever the various reasons they give for disbelieving in it, at the end of the day, it is a luxury belief for someone who will never ever have to worry about or to take on the risk of potentially getting pregnant, having to have months or years off work to recover, feed them from your body, or even risk being left holding the baby as you're the one physically pregnant, if their partner leaves?

Disbelief in marriage is a luxury, and it's usually (not always) when you are free from all that risk and have that luxury that you can afford to believe all the other reasons so many men give (at the expense of the women they're with) for not believing in it.

I just find this such a dated, discomforting view.

firstly no woman should be forced to have a child , it should be a decision a woman makes in full knowledge of the consequences and risks. Ultimately the woman’s decision.

secondly, it’s not common women need to take years to recover from pregnancy or birth, yes it happens, but this is a risk the woman should chose to take as she wishes to, not to please a man.

thirdly, if the potential to manage as a single parent or co parenting, isn’t something the woman could deal with, then she shouldn’t proceed. It’s not just men leaving, people die, become incapacitated.

and the whole “have wanted it their whole lives” is quite nauseating for me. Like the whole myth of the little girl dreaming of being a bride.

tne whole undercurrent of this op is women dream of marriage, have babies for their partners, and are on the whole vulnerable.

we should be teaching women to make decisions in the full knowledge of the risks and benefits, and be accepting of the risks before proceeding.

and plenty of women don’t want to marry, a close friend of mine is one of them, she loves him deeply. As he does her, but for personal reasons she sees no need to marry, he’d marry her in a shot if she wished,

user1477391263 · 09/01/2024 12:38

Of course men can do this.

They mostly don’t, though.

When a couple has a child who requires a really challenging level of care, it’s so common that the father just won’t provide it at the standard required. They’re not openly hostile, they just… don’t really step up, not to the level that the child needs. And so the mother starts to realize that either she stops working and provides the care needed, or her child will be neglected.

As women, we have the caring thing going on in our brains. It’s hard to switch off, even though it may impoverish us and make us very vulnerable.

YetAnotherSpartacus · 09/01/2024 12:32

This is even before we consider longer term issues like DC who need more substantial care. You can't opt out of this either, and neither can you necessarily choose for it not to affect your career

Comparatively few women have that level of complications and as for children needing more substantial care there is nothing to say that men can’t do this.

VampireWeekday · 09/01/2024 12:23

Dacadactyl · 08/01/2024 19:20

I agree.

I think only childless, FT working/financially independent people benefit from being unmarried when in a couple. And even then, you'd be better off married for tax purposes if one of you died.

This isn't true. I have children but am unmarried to their dad. I earn more than him and have a better pension, so as things stand a divorce would cost me much more than simply breaking up. I took time off to raise our children so I don't feel that he's had a raw deal, in fact he benefits from my wage.

But I do agree with the OP's general point, that typically it's the people who don't benefit who don't believe, and those people tend to be men.

TrashedSofa · 09/01/2024 12:18

YetAnotherSpartacus · 09/01/2024 12:12

Women take on risk merely by being the sex who bear children. There isn't a way to make a male partner take on an equal share of that. It's nice and comforting to think you can just good choice your way out of the most toxic ramifications of patriarchy combined with bad luck and you'll be fine, but it's not that simple.

That's nine months plus a year maybe if a woman chooses to breastfeed. There is maternity leave. After that there is nothing to say it's a woman;s biological role.

This goes to my point about luck. You're talking about a situation where things have gone physically well, with no complications, and also when a woman hasn't suffered in her career due to being one of the thousands a year who lose their jobs due to being pregnant. Neither of these risks can ever be shared equally with a man, and some women are utterly fucked over by them.

This is even before we consider longer term issues like DC who need more substantial care. You can't opt out of this either, and neither can you necessarily choose for it not to affect your career.

YetAnotherSpartacus · 09/01/2024 12:12

Women take on risk merely by being the sex who bear children. There isn't a way to make a male partner take on an equal share of that. It's nice and comforting to think you can just good choice your way out of the most toxic ramifications of patriarchy combined with bad luck and you'll be fine, but it's not that simple.

That's nine months plus a year maybe if a woman chooses to breastfeed. There is maternity leave. After that there is nothing to say it's a woman;s biological role.

TrashedSofa · 09/01/2024 12:09

It's a mumsnet myth that you can simply choose to keep your career and thus never need any of the legal and financial safeguards marriage can provide.

Women take on risk merely by being the sex who bear children. There isn't a way to make a male partner take on an equal share of that. It's nice and comforting to think you can just good choice your way out of the most toxic ramifications of patriarchy combined with bad luck and you'll be fine, but it's not that simple.

None of which is to say anyone should rely solely on marriage for protection, of course. But then very few posts on here say you should.

YetAnotherSpartacus · 09/01/2024 12:00

I completely agree with this. We should be encouraging girls to work on being financially independent rather than pushing them to get married.

It's a Mumsnet myth that marriage is the saviour of women. The relationships board will reveal many who fell for this and who are traded in in middle-age when they have no financial independence and with a share in the marital wealth that won't enable them to live well independently and with limited skill or capacity to earn their own income. Best to ditch the ring for good legal financial advice about asset distribution and keep one's own earning capacity while making sure he sacrifices an equal amount for the children.

CoffeeMachineNewbie · 09/01/2024 11:59

People who dont believe it in rarely stand to benefit from hit. Hence mostly men dont believe in it because they dont expect their wife to out earn them or spit up and leave him with kids to look after.

Its self serving.

We dont believe in marriage as an expression of love or commitment but we married for the legal and financial benefits. Less than £300 all in so money is rarely a reason, hence men delay and delay by saying crap like wanting to give you a day you deserve.

canttellyouwhereorwhatido · 09/01/2024 11:59

I'll tell you what would be an interesting test of men's beliefs on marriage.. and cavalier attitude to fatherhood. ..

Change the law so that the current marital rights accorded to marriage change - so that fathering or mothering a child guaranteed the same rights.

ie . I get pregnant by Joe Smith and instead of me being left with the baby and he skips off into the sunset - that dna proof gives me the legal right to half his property .. to bring up his child . Or vice versa for a man..

Watch the accidental pregnancy rate plummet as men try harder to protect their fertility and marriage become more popular as it makes no financial difference once you have decided to have kids.

Unlikely ever to happen but it should.

herewegoroundthebastardbush · 09/01/2024 11:58

Also re my kids - I'd take them, with or without him, so his being in or out has no bearing on whether I'd want them or not. I couldn't have had them without him, and for that I'll always be grateful to him; but it's not like I wouldn't have chosen to if I thought there was a chance of him leaving me later with nothing. Of course there's a chance of that; there always is. Just like there's a chance he could drop dead or lose his job or cheat. None of those things would have made me regret having the kids, or thinking it was anything less than a privilege to raise them.

herewegoroundthebastardbush · 09/01/2024 11:55

ironorchids · 08/01/2024 19:23

I know women don't believe I marriage too, but I have heard time and again of relationships where the man does not want marriage but the woman does and it causes a lot of pain.

I have never heard it in reverse where a man believes in marriage but the women they're with doesn't. Maybe I have a very biased perspective.

I'm the reverse. Partner would happily get married, I wouldn't - will happily set all the legal protections in place, and have (joint on mortgage, named as pension/life insurance beneficiary, will etc) but I don't believe in the ceremony of declaring the commitment to family and friends and the state, as if that affects whether our relationship survives or not. I've seen too many weddings that end in divorces, and too many miserable marriages. Beyond the legalities, which can be taken care of other ways, it is totally meaningless (or at least only as meaningful as you make it over the long term). I choose to demonstrate my commitment to my partner and our joint children via, you know, actually showing up every day, actually sharing our assets. If I ever felt that I couldn't do that any more, being married would make no difference to that.

If marriage is important to you, don't get with or stay with (or god forbid have children with) a man who doesn't. Simple.

NotSuchASmugMarriedAnymore · 09/01/2024 11:46

LardyCakeAgain · 09/01/2024 09:52

I agree - in the main, it's immature men enjoying having a live-in maid / cleaner / cook / childcare provider, while they look around for what/whom they really want.

I was very clear with DH that if he wanted to buy a house we were getting married first - I wasn't spending a fortune getting solicitor documents drawn up when we could be married at the registry office for far less money. I also wasn't going to start a protracted, expensive legal argument about who owned what % of the house if we split, that didn't take into account anything like illness or pregnancy / maternity leave.

So many folk say "but having kids is a much bigger commitment to each other" - we know, that's the bloody point! They'll knock you up but won't sign a certificate giving you legal and financial protection? Fuck that!

I think having kids is a commitment for women but the commitment for men is marriage. That's why so many of them are quite happy to have kids but not so keen to get married - because it IS a bigger commitment than just having kids.

Gastropod · 09/01/2024 11:36

TrashedSofa · 09/01/2024 11:30

You're not wrong about the implications, but the same principle also applies to cohabiting. That's also a potentially substantial financial risk, depending on ones circumstances. There's obviously no practical way to force people to think about this at the point they move in together, so I don't know what the answer is. Ultimately there's no way to have a live in relationship with someone, particularly if it's going to involve jointly held property and/or DC, that doesn't involve potentially very significant legal and financial implications.

I would agree. I remember before getting married we were sat down by the church minister to talk about the commitment of getting married. But it was all about duties to each other and not a single word on "oh, and by the way, you could be financially ruined if you decide to separate"...

TrashedSofa · 09/01/2024 11:30

Gastropod · 09/01/2024 10:39

Marriage as a legal contract has very little to do with love or emotional commitment. It's a financial arrangement, first and foremost. I was one of those breadwinning women who suffered financially as a result of divorce. I paid out a heck of a lot more than my ex ever put in.

If I'd fully understood the immense financial risk that I was taking on simply by getting married I'd have certainly thought more carefully about it. I think that prenups, or some equivalent of them, should be a legal requirement before marriage.

With the benefit of hindsight, I now think it's astonishing that any man or woman would take on such a financial risk without fully informing themselves of all the implications. I don't blame the newlyweds, but rather the process of marriage itself. So easy to walk into, all hearts and flowers, but my god it's hellish to get out of, from a financial perspective - not to downplay the emotional fallout of course.

You're not wrong about the implications, but the same principle also applies to cohabiting. That's also a potentially substantial financial risk, depending on ones circumstances. There's obviously no practical way to force people to think about this at the point they move in together, so I don't know what the answer is. Ultimately there's no way to have a live in relationship with someone, particularly if it's going to involve jointly held property and/or DC, that doesn't involve potentially very significant legal and financial implications.