Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Not believing in marriage is a luxury belief

186 replies

ironorchids · 08/01/2024 19:11

Is it me or are there a lot of men these days who disbelieve in marriage for various reasons at the expense of the women they are with who believe in it, want it and have wanted it their whole lives?

Whatever the various reasons they give for disbelieving in it, at the end of the day, it is a luxury belief for someone who will never ever have to worry about or to take on the risk of potentially getting pregnant, having to have months or years off work to recover, feed them from your body, or even risk being left holding the baby as you're the one physically pregnant, if their partner leaves?

Disbelief in marriage is a luxury, and it's usually (not always) when you are free from all that risk and have that luxury that you can afford to believe all the other reasons so many men give (at the expense of the women they're with) for not believing in it.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 11/01/2024 17:23

NaughtybutNice77 · 11/01/2024 15:19

I don't know 1 woman (or man) that has claimed spousal support. This would only really apply if the non resident ex spouse is a high earner. Most men are not in a financial situation to run 2 households.
Pensions would make a difference.

These days, the courts prefer clean-break settlements bar for child support.

NaughtybutNice77 · 11/01/2024 15:19

I don't know 1 woman (or man) that has claimed spousal support. This would only really apply if the non resident ex spouse is a high earner. Most men are not in a financial situation to run 2 households.
Pensions would make a difference.

TizerorFizz · 10/01/2024 20:44

@SisterHyster Yes. Totally agree. I do hope we can get more invested in childcare in the future.

SisterHyster · 10/01/2024 20:21

TizerorFizz · 10/01/2024 19:25

That’s quite a high commute cost. I think it also means the higher tax salary level
is too low. I would argue it needs adjusting upward by £10k at least. However it still remains that many women need a full time salary. I’m assuming you are not a single parent? This also makes a difference to many.

It is - but if I was to move; my mortgage would increase. And it’s not that much every day; but that’s how much it costs on a Friday when I have to do two school drop offs before work; and then the reverse on the way home.

Higher tax threshold is most definitely too low. My salary is £48k.

I do work full-time. But I’d actually be better off if I didn’t!

And I am not a single parent; I am however the main earner in our house by quite a margin. However; we would actually break even if I only worked 3 days per week. We would become eligible for free childcare and universal credit. And that is on a “professional” level job - the difference is even more stark for those on a lesser salary - however this is obviously short sighted as childcare costs obviously decrease as your children get older. Hence why I plod on full-time.

TizerorFizz · 10/01/2024 19:25

That’s quite a high commute cost. I think it also means the higher tax salary level
is too low. I would argue it needs adjusting upward by £10k at least. However it still remains that many women need a full time salary. I’m assuming you are not a single parent? This also makes a difference to many.

SisterHyster · 10/01/2024 18:59

TizerorFizz · 09/01/2024 20:32

What a luxury to only work part time! Now that’s something many can only dream of!

Depending on your wage; you might not actually be significantly worse off to go part time. It actually COSTS me money to go to work on my 5th day of my working week. I’ve got a decent but not amazing salary (I’m a teacher)

Im only just into the 40% tax bracket, but I wouldn’t be if I worked 4 days. So I only take home around £25 per Friday I work, after tax/NI/student loan/pensions are deducted. And then I pay £75 for childcare. My commute also costs £25.

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 10/01/2024 17:22

A man cannot have his own biological child without a women....ever!

Women can't either. That sperm donor is a man...

Not married means a father has no legal duty to support you financially.

Yup, and if you are able to say "well I don't need his money because I have my own well-paid career and none of my kids are disabled so I didn't have to quit work to be a full-time carer" then you are in a position of privilege. The "luxury beliefs" concept absolutely applies to you because you can use your money to protect yourself against the adverse consequences of your belief. Poorer women and those whose with disabled kids don't have that ability to self-protect.

I mention disabled kids because you can have all the best plans in the world about how financially independent you are going to be and then discover when a child is two or three that they have severe SEND.

TizerorFizz · 10/01/2024 15:40

@NaughtybutNice77 That is not the case for many women. Not married means a father has no legal duty to support you financially. Sadly many women with dc find this out too late.A bit of child maintenance often does not go far. When renting you might have no right to stay if the tenant asks you to leave when you are not joint tenants. You always have more protection when married.

NaughtybutNice77 · 10/01/2024 15:11

ironorchids · 08/01/2024 19:23

I know women don't believe I marriage too, but I have heard time and again of relationships where the man does not want marriage but the woman does and it causes a lot of pain.

I have never heard it in reverse where a man believes in marriage but the women they're with doesn't. Maybe I have a very biased perspective.

I wasn't bothered about being married but it meant a lot to my husband, so we married (willingly!) We also divorced. We did not own a home at the time but we had children. The outcome would have been exactly the same if we weren't married. Incidently he went on to marry again...4 times in total.
I do agree though that on the whole women tend to favour marriage more than men. It's hard to say if it's primarily the financial aspect or the psychological commitment. I suspect sometimes it's actually also about the fairytale wedding. I've heard women planning weddings and it's almost as if the groom was incidental!

NaughtybutNice77 · 10/01/2024 15:02

Yes I think there are more men now who 'do not believe in marriage' if by that you mean chose not to marry as it disadvantages them.
Why would that surprise you that a group of society chose things that are favourable/desirable to them if there's the choice to do so?
Generally speaking women earn less than men and women and tend to take on the bulk of childcare/raising. There are some things women have far more choice about eg do I want a baby and they chose the outcome that want. A man cannot have his own biological child without a women....ever! A man cannot chose to go ahead with/terminate a pregnancy....ever!
Taking away emotional/psychological impact, a marriage only benefits a woman if she is financially dependent on a man (and they separate/divorce). Marriage benefits a man in so far as it gives him 'rights' to the children.
Marriage (then divorce) doesn't give each equal rights, more "as fair as they can be'. The man will often lose out on family/home life (could end up living with his mum or in a bedsit) and the woman will often end up saddled with most (all) of the responsibility for the children. That's the same whether you're married or not really, it's the home that's the issue but that can be sorted before children.
The issue really is if a woman is financially dependent on a man she should consider seriously if she wants to have children. If she does there's always a risk...for both parties.
I guess the 'answer' is that once a relationship starts to get serious you establish what you both want. Marriage, children, finances should be the first things you agree on.
Of course people change there mind or back down. My friends SIL is desperate for a family but his wife is still delaying...at 38. We suspect she doesn't want a family. He has no choice. If they divorce he will lose half of his home to her. He's paid 80% of everything.
It works both ways.

TizerorFizz · 10/01/2024 14:12

@TedMullins He was extremely successful and the company was making a lot of money. However they were a professional engineering consultancy and you just cannot leave it to others for months on end. They didn’t have “managers”. They had professional engineers running design projects. Plus, for me, it was better that he kept his eye on the goose that was laying the golden egg. Leaving it to others wasn’t in his dna or mine. AsI have said, there is not a one size fits all. So people who keep working should not be called out either. We were and are married though so he was not walking off with £million!

vivainsomnia · 10/01/2024 13:03

You just have to read about the thread with many women admitting they marry despite not being attracted to their husband but have picked them for their security and reliability, ie. Their money.

They want the kids and they want to only work pt or not at all. They enjoy the life when they can have their chosen lifetime until they realise sharing your life with a dependable someone you are not attracted to is not enough.

They want their freedom and as much money as they can and claim that they deserve it because they sacrificed everything for their husband when ultimately, they chose him to be able to choose that lifestyle in the first place.

I both told my kids not to marry until they find an equal. I raised them with the attitude that there are not kale or female tasks and roles. All should be shared equally and if a partner demands what suits them more than my kids, including marriage, don't agree to it.

BIossomtoes · 10/01/2024 12:46

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 10/01/2024 12:37

The first rule of human relationships is "trust no one".

Marriage involves putting your trust in the law to protect your and your children's future. Having children out of wedlock means trusting him.

I know which I’d rather trust.

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 10/01/2024 12:43

LorlieS · 10/01/2024 12:39

@VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia Certainly do not trust the law to protect you or your children upon divorce.

It's rather more reliable than trusting his pinky swear, don't you think?

LorlieS · 10/01/2024 12:39

@VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia Certainly do not trust the law to protect you or your children upon divorce.

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 10/01/2024 12:37

The first rule of human relationships is "trust no one".

Marriage involves putting your trust in the law to protect your and your children's future. Having children out of wedlock means trusting him.

LardyCakeAgain · 10/01/2024 12:28

CoffeeMachineNewbie · 10/01/2024 11:27

Depressingly I suspect a male contareceptive would lead to a rise in abortions for young girls believing their 16 year old boyfriends are on the pill because they told them that and an increase in couples seeking IVF as some men would rather string uncomfortable relationship along and waste fertile years for women by pretending they want babies that they dont.

If a woman wants a baby, it's up to the woman whether they get strung along or not, they can end the relationship if the man is dithering. The solution isn't to withhold choice from men - it's up to everyone to take responsibility for their own contraception, rather than rely on others.

So many women on MN seem to think that men should be forced to 'grow up' and become parents and marry - personally, marriage was important to me but I was clear to DH that it was his choice. I was also clear that our relationship wouldn't continue long term without that commitment.

So much can be resolved by confident, clear communication, but we indoctrinate women and girls that they're more valued if they receive a fairytale surprise proposal - so lots of women hang around for years waiting for one that was never going to come.

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 10/01/2024 12:14

CoffeeMachineNewbie · 10/01/2024 11:27

Depressingly I suspect a male contareceptive would lead to a rise in abortions for young girls believing their 16 year old boyfriends are on the pill because they told them that and an increase in couples seeking IVF as some men would rather string uncomfortable relationship along and waste fertile years for women by pretending they want babies that they dont.

young girls believing their 16 year old boyfriends are on the pill because they told them that

The first rule of human relationships is "trust no one". Particularly when they don't lose anything themselves. I would strongly recommend that women continue to insist on contraception that they control or can at least see in use, regardless of any claims by the man involved.

CoffeeMachineNewbie · 10/01/2024 11:27

Depressingly I suspect a male contareceptive would lead to a rise in abortions for young girls believing their 16 year old boyfriends are on the pill because they told them that and an increase in couples seeking IVF as some men would rather string uncomfortable relationship along and waste fertile years for women by pretending they want babies that they dont.

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 10/01/2024 10:39

I agree, but men who were clear with the women upfront that they didn't want children, shouldn't be used as an 18-year meal ticket either. I know so many friends who confided they "forgot, herhee" their pill once they starting dating a high-earning man.

  1. The man is not a "meal ticket" for the woman, he is paying maintenance towards his innocent child.
  2. No child should be deprived of paternal support because of the mother's immoral acts.
  3. Even if she is meticulous about using her contraceptives, they can fail. A sensible man uses condoms if he doesn't want children, regardless of the woman's claimed or actual contraceptive use.

both parties having an upfront conversation about marriage, and accepting that the other doesn't want that long term legal commitment, should be the catalyst for finding someone else to marry

I'm on another thread where a woman is complaining that her FWB didn't interpret her invitation to "takeaway and movie" as meaning "sex". Some people have a long way to go on the "upfront conversation" front.

LardyCakeAgain · 10/01/2024 10:14

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 10/01/2024 09:39

Men who don't want kids with a one night stand deserve as many options as women have, there would definitely be fewer unwanted accidents.

Yes, they do. I have personally donated to fund Vasalgel research because I agree with you so much.

  1. It is not women's fault that the male-dominated medical establishment does not prioritise male contraceptive research.
  2. It is not the resulting child's fault either.
  3. Lack of male options doesn't justify coercing women into abortions.

Lack of male options doesn't mean women should be coerced into abortions, I agree, but men who were clear with the women upfront that they didn't want children, shouldn't be used as an 18-year meal ticket either. I know so many friends who confided they "forgot, herhee" their pill once they starting dating a high-earning man. Men having less control over their reproductive choices and financial consequences doesn't lead to happy relationships - both parties having an upfront conversation about marriage, and accepting that the other doesn't want that long term legal commitment, should be the catalyst for finding someone else to marry if you're unhappy about it.

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 10/01/2024 09:39

LardyCakeAgain · 10/01/2024 09:25

Men do this all the time! Even if they are sure they don't want children yet, the only option they have is condoms (88% effective) if they wish to preserve their fertility. They have to trust women to take the pill on top of that - 99% effective if taken correctly but they have to trust the woman that they've done it. Men who don't want kids with a one night stand deserve as many options as women have, there would definitely be fewer unwanted accidents.

Men who don't want kids with a one night stand deserve as many options as women have, there would definitely be fewer unwanted accidents.

Yes, they do. I have personally donated to fund Vasalgel research because I agree with you so much.

  1. It is not women's fault that the male-dominated medical establishment does not prioritise male contraceptive research.
  2. It is not the resulting child's fault either.
  3. Lack of male options doesn't justify coercing women into abortions.
VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 10/01/2024 09:34

LardyCakeAgain · 10/01/2024 09:26

You could say that to women wanting abortions, but we don't, because it's not the 1950s anymore.

Men can use their own bodies to avoid parenthood. Women can use their own bodies to avoid parenthood. Biology means that women have more options for this; evertheless, both sexes have the right to use their own bodies to prevent parenthood.

MrsRachelDanvers · 10/01/2024 09:31

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 08/01/2024 19:30

I have no idea how many men behave this way. What I often see on Mumsnet, though, is confusion about what marriage is and why it is or isn't a good idea for each individual couple.

Firstly, there is no such thing in the UK as common law marriage. If you want your position as partners recognised in law you need to marry or get a civil partnership.

Secondly, don't get confused between marriage and a wedding. By all means have a party when you get married if you can afford it, but if you can see it would be best to get married don't put it off because you can't afford a big wedding.

What it is: a legal contract that gives each spouse legal responsibilities and rights. These matter if the relationship breaks down or if one partner dies.

There will be posters on this thread saying that they earn as much as their partner or more, and therefore if their relationship broke down or their partner died they'd be OK. That's great for them, but those women are very much in the minority of the population as a whole. Most women earn less than their partners once they have children. If they are not married or in a civil partnership and their partner leaves or dies they may be left in a difficult position. No rights over their partner's assets or pension pot. If the partner owns the house and the woman's name isn't on the deeds, she has no right to stay there. This lack of legal status really matters for a lot of women.

The big group who need to think carefully about marriage/CPs are people with children from an earlier relationship who want to protect their assets to pass them onto the children. If they married/CPd their partner would become entitled to a large share of those assets through the courts, even if the parent has made a will leaving everything to the children. Once they've been married for a while, that might well be what they both want, but in the early stages it probably isn't.

That’s a bit scaremongering and not true about spouses with children from a previous marriage. If you don’t make a will, the surviving spouse will inherit the lion’s share. However, you can make a will leaving everything to your children. What you need to remember is that marriage invalidates wills made prior to getting married.

LardyCakeAgain · 10/01/2024 09:26

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 10/01/2024 09:19

Men don't have to have PIV. They won't die without it. They don't have to risk fatherhood.

You could say that to women wanting abortions, but we don't, because it's not the 1950s anymore.