Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Depressed about salary

315 replies

Porcupinesky · 08/01/2024 17:49

I’m feeling pretty down at the stories today around the national average wage now being £35k.

I only earn just above this amount. I had been offered a better paid role about 4 months ago but found out I was pregnant so turned it down, as I get a good maternity package in this role (25 weeks full pay) so it made better financial sense to stay. I’m waiting for a promotion but the company is tightening finances so I’m uncertain when this can be processed. I’ll probably get a small payrise in April before I start mat leave.

Is anyone else feeling this way? It’s what I think about most of the day. Luckily DH earns a decent salary and pays more bills but it’s a real knock to my self worth as I thought I would achieve more in life.

OP posts:
BeckyBloomwood3 · 09/01/2024 14:08

horseyhorsey17 · 09/01/2024 14:00

I'm in the Home Counties and we have an increasingly yawning gap between the rich and poor. The town I live in contains some of the most deprived areas in Bucks, and we have the highest food poverty in the country, but the average property price is over £400K and still going up. £35K would be just about liveable here, but you'd still struggle as rental is very high and buying on that would be out of reach unless you'd managed to save a huge deposit, or were buying a studio flat. You could do it on two 'average' salaries, but I think the idea that we all have to be in relationships just to navigate financially through life is archaic and weird, frankly.

I honestly, genuinely don't know how a lot of people are managing from day to day. Even on £35K, it doesn't leave you a lot of wiggle room if something goes wrong, if the roof needs fixing, or your car dies and you need a new one, or you lose your job and end up running up credit cards debt while you're looking for work, for example. We live in worrying times.

All of that has nothing to do with OP as an individual though. OP might be one of those people who could earn enough to buy that 400K house. She just didn't because reasons.
If OP was a teacher, or nurse, I'd sympathise and for all the reasons you said but she isn't.

@Eigen it's the OP conflating the two but also she is doing the opposite of 'working hard to provide a better life' because her career path has money, she just hasn't chosen to chase it .}

Again back to tech. People don't believe me when I say that some tech professionals earn 25K... because everything everywhere is all about how tech is so highly paid with career changes earning 60K after a 6 month bootcamp blah2. But there are plenty of lower paid ones too.

If the OP is one of these then how is the general 'race to the bottom' relevant. She is one of the erm 'lucky' few to be able to earn more. She just didn't want to. That's on her. Unlike say a paramedic who 'can't earn more in the same job. Being depressed as a result of having choices and actually choosing what suits you is just silly.

Whatnowfgs · 09/01/2024 14:07

I haven't read the full thread but this reminded me of an old saying..."Enough is as good as a feast"

I say this as a professionally qualified person with ill health. I work 15 hours a week as that is all I can manage. I therefore take home 2/5 of what my colleagues do.

Turned down for disability benefits.

I don't spend all day thinking about it because with Dh salary we get by.

I would love the holidays etc that others with my qualifications and job can afford but sometimes you have to decide to change something or settle. I can't really change my health so I have settled.

It's probably actually more difficult for Dh because he does long hours but it's ok as I said we get by.

Millions are in a much worse position.

Try to enjoy your maternity and baby and see if opportunities come along afterwards.

horseyhorsey17 · 09/01/2024 14:06

Eigen · 09/01/2024 14:03

Agree, the racetothebottomistas are out in force. That’s why it’s important to push back on this ‘I earn less than you, shut up and be grateful’ because that’s the attitude that gets you stuck with no wage progression and believing your boss when he says there’s no money in the pot for pay rises but the guy who threw his toys out of the pram at annual reviews magically gets the promotion.

By all means if people want to limit their horizons, do it but don’t tear down people who are going out to provide a better life for their families or get what they’re worth.

Your wage is not your worth as a person, but it is a (call it moderately correlated with) reflection of your worth on the job market. I’m sorry if that hurts but it’s true. Some people are incapable of separating the two and I’m not interested in arguing with someone until they can appreciate that difference.

Money is not everything, but it makes life a lot easier. There are enough COL crisis questions on the board to demonstrate that.

Completely agree.

The race to the bottomists on here fascinate me, as there are also loads of people on MN who appear to be living very glamorous lives - yet it's only the former who pop up on threads like these. Does make me wonder. Social media is going to play a large part in the next election and of course it suits the Tories if people are resigned to their lot and dragging down people who aspire to more.

blackpanth · 09/01/2024 14:03

Must be nice to earn that

Eigen · 09/01/2024 14:03

horseyhorsey17 · 09/01/2024 13:44

Yes I've read her posts. Not all 9 pages of people slagging her off for not thinking she's earning mega-bucks on £35K though.

This is so frustrating as it's people fighting over scraps. Politicians - the ones who make the policy that influence how much we earn - have a basic salary of over £80K, before expenses and second jobs. They wouldn't dream of trying to live on £35K. But it very much suits them that we live in a world where anyone (at least any woman) who admits she earns more than that is going to be torn down for being uppity.

Agree, the racetothebottomistas are out in force. That’s why it’s important to push back on this ‘I earn less than you, shut up and be grateful’ because that’s the attitude that gets you stuck with no wage progression and believing your boss when he says there’s no money in the pot for pay rises but the guy who threw his toys out of the pram at annual reviews magically gets the promotion.

By all means if people want to limit their horizons, do it but don’t tear down people who are going out to provide a better life for their families or get what they’re worth.

Your wage is not your worth as a person, but it is a (call it moderately correlated with) reflection of your worth on the job market. I’m sorry if that hurts but it’s true. Some people are incapable of separating the two and I’m not interested in arguing with someone until they can appreciate that difference.

Money is not everything, but it makes life a lot easier. There are enough COL crisis questions on the board to demonstrate that.

horseyhorsey17 · 09/01/2024 14:02

Oblomov23 · 09/01/2024 13:57

the national average wage is now £35k?
Blimey. I didn't know that.

It's not really though, that's just what the government wants us to think. If you take out the millionaires at one end who drag the average up and add in the people who are left out because they are carers etc on almost non-existent money at the other, the national median salary is something like £24K.

horseyhorsey17 · 09/01/2024 14:00

BeckyBloomwood3 · 09/01/2024 13:48

Yes there are PP who do that. But this post is not about the national economy and 'fighting over scraps'.
It's about the OP's own attitude. Since there is money to be made in her career and she thought she'd 'achieve more'. This is more to do with her individual choices.

Again, referring to the 25K earners... they could earn much more but choose not to. Different problem from wages at a macroeconomic level.

She has said no mitigating circs. Money to be made. Why has she as an individual not gone for the big bucks. What nurses, cleaners, air traffic control , , ,pilots earn is not relevant here. She said she turned down another job for 'family friendly' hours so there's the answer.

Btw here in the North West 35K single salary is enough to buy a 2 bed 30 min drive away from Manchester City Centre, excluding the deposit. 2 earners on 40K combined (barely above min wage) can very well buy a 3 bed terrace and many have done so. Young 20-somethings. Outside London 35K is not 'bad', it's not 'great' either.

Edited

I'm in the Home Counties and we have an increasingly yawning gap between the rich and poor. The town I live in contains some of the most deprived areas in Bucks, and we have the highest food poverty in the country, but the average property price is over £400K and still going up. £35K would be just about liveable here, but you'd still struggle as rental is very high and buying on that would be out of reach unless you'd managed to save a huge deposit, or were buying a studio flat. You could do it on two 'average' salaries, but I think the idea that we all have to be in relationships just to navigate financially through life is archaic and weird, frankly.

I honestly, genuinely don't know how a lot of people are managing from day to day. Even on £35K, it doesn't leave you a lot of wiggle room if something goes wrong, if the roof needs fixing, or your car dies and you need a new one, or you lose your job and end up running up credit cards debt while you're looking for work, for example. We live in worrying times.

Oblomov23 · 09/01/2024 13:57

the national average wage is now £35k?
Blimey. I didn't know that.

Cloudnumber9 · 09/01/2024 13:56

LaDerniereVacheFolle · 08/01/2024 18:10

Maybe you should cultivate some gratitude OP? It's key to happiness.

Be grateful you're not on minimum wage, zero hours contract or even unemployed with no support.

There will be some reading your post in exactly those situations.

This.

YABVU

herewegoroundthebastardbush · 09/01/2024 13:55

Porcupinesky · 08/01/2024 23:48

It’s interesting to hear different perspectives. My current employer is very flexible with working too and known for being sympathetic to those with families, the employer I turned down was a small company who offered no enhanced pay or flexibility with working so it felt like a step into the unknown. So I don’t regret the decision but do regret the pay!

Once you've had your child your priorities will change massively. A family-friendly employer with flexible approach to working hours/location is worth SO much more than extra money to parents of young children. You're young. You can coast for the next 10 years on a good salary with a reasonably easy life, and still have decades after to boost your earning potential once your child is more independent. Relax.

ManchesterLu · 09/01/2024 13:55

Make the most of what you have, strive to improve what you can, accept what you can't. That's it. There's no point spending 'most of the day' worrying about it. Seriously.

You earn A LOT more than people on minimum wage who work 60 hour weeks just to pay the bills, so how about being more aware of what's going on in other people's lives?

BeckyBloomwood3 · 09/01/2024 13:48

horseyhorsey17 · 09/01/2024 13:44

Yes I've read her posts. Not all 9 pages of people slagging her off for not thinking she's earning mega-bucks on £35K though.

This is so frustrating as it's people fighting over scraps. Politicians - the ones who make the policy that influence how much we earn - have a basic salary of over £80K, before expenses and second jobs. They wouldn't dream of trying to live on £35K. But it very much suits them that we live in a world where anyone (at least any woman) who admits she earns more than that is going to be torn down for being uppity.

Yes there are PP who do that. But this post is not about the national economy and 'fighting over scraps'.
It's about the OP's own attitude. Since there is money to be made in her career and she thought she'd 'achieve more'. This is more to do with her individual choices.

Again, referring to the 25K earners... they could earn much more but choose not to. Different problem from wages at a macroeconomic level.

She has said no mitigating circs. Money to be made. Why has she as an individual not gone for the big bucks. What nurses, cleaners, air traffic control , , ,pilots earn is not relevant here. She said she turned down another job for 'family friendly' hours so there's the answer.

Btw here in the North West 35K single salary is enough to buy a 2 bed 30 min drive away from Manchester City Centre, excluding the deposit. 2 earners on 40K combined (barely above min wage) can very well buy a 3 bed terrace and many have done so. Young 20-somethings. Outside London 35K is not 'bad', it's not 'great' either.

Ejismyf · 09/01/2024 13:46

Well you need to take in to consideration the average is bumped up by people older than you who have worked longer, progressed higher and earn more and realise at only 32 you still have that potential.

horseyhorsey17 · 09/01/2024 13:44

BeckyBloomwood3 · 09/01/2024 13:39

Have you RTFT?
I completely agree with you r.e. MN and our low wage economy.

But how do you know that the OP isn't in finance or tech? Her career path has £££ to be made. I've got mates who earn anywhere between 25-90K for the same 'tech' job role. For all you know OP is one of those and chose a lower paid job because she wanted flexible working and a 'family environment'.

OP posted in AIBU and I'd be quite sympathetic if she was in some 'ordinary' profession realising they've topped out after years. but she's married to a man who earns £££ and admits no 'extenuating' circumstances the only thing standing in the way is her choices really. She's U to moan here instead of doing something about it. Especially as she's still young.

Many many women go back to work. 35K from one parent is enough to pay for childcare. If OP wants to step back fine but again. Her choice. Nothing to be 'depressed' about her.

Edited

Yes I've read her posts. Not all 9 pages of people slagging her off for not thinking she's earning mega-bucks on £35K though.

This is so frustrating as it's people fighting over scraps. Politicians - the ones who make the policy that influence how much we earn - have a basic salary of over £80K, before expenses and second jobs. They wouldn't dream of trying to live on £35K. But it very much suits them that we live in a world where anyone (at least any woman) who admits she earns more than that is going to be torn down for being uppity.

BeckyBloomwood3 · 09/01/2024 13:39

horseyhorsey17 · 09/01/2024 13:28

You're going to get a lot of negativity for this OP - as the MN attitude appears to be that if you're even earning the average, you are a rich braggart who should be feeling financially flush and definitely shouldn't be 'boasting' on here - but I totally get it. Salaries are shocking in this country - I'd be earning more than twice my salary for the same job in the USA (although yes would have to pay for healthcare and have less job security). And yes, it makes you wonder why you work so hard and go to university and get great qualifications when you're still struggling to pay the bills every month.

The problem is that there's been almost no wage growth since 2010 (wonder what happened in that year) and what wage growth there has been since then has been concentrated in executive positions, tech and the financial sector. The actual real median salary, if you allow for that and take out all the millionaires, is considerably less than £30K a year.

Have you RTFT?
I completely agree with you r.e. MN and our low wage economy.

But how do you know that the OP isn't in finance or tech? Her career path has £££ to be made. I've got mates who earn anywhere between 25-90K for the same 'tech' job role. For all you know OP is one of those and chose a lower paid job because she wanted flexible working and a 'family environment'.

OP posted in AIBU and I'd be quite sympathetic if she was in some 'ordinary' profession realising they've topped out after years. but she's married to a man who earns £££ and admits no 'extenuating' circumstances the only thing standing in the way is her choices really. She's U to moan here instead of doing something about it. Especially as she's still young.

Many many women go back to work. 35K from one parent is enough to pay for childcare. If OP wants to step back fine but again. Her choice. Nothing to be 'depressed' about her.

TooManyPlatesInMotion · 09/01/2024 13:39

It isn't just about the salary though - you yourself mention the good maternity benefits, and other benefits are also relevant, plus working environment, working hours, prospects for promotion, health and well being at work.

BrandySnaps1 · 09/01/2024 13:36

OP you are coming across as entitled. Not only are you hitting 35k, you say you're above it!And you get decent mat leave.. be grateful. It's all relative. How old are you? What do you do?

Itdjgsurchg · 09/01/2024 13:34

It just shows how poor NHS workers are paid, I am band 4 but my team managers, who have a team of 12, are only band 5 and start on £28,407. It makes you think whats the point in going for promotion if you are earning less than the average wage.

However my job is stress free, I can work from home and use flexi time so I am happy whilst my children are young and my husband works away. It must be so demoralising for nurses who also start on band 5.

CattingAbout · 09/01/2024 13:32

I think the trick is to step away from MN for a bit I'm afraid. I was very happy with my lot until I found that everyone on MN seems to have at least one earner in their household on over 100k! That's worlds away from the people I generally meet in RL.

bringincrazyback · 09/01/2024 13:32

While I don't think anyone should be 'grateful' as such to have a job, as employment is a quid-pro-quo transaction in which both sides benefit, but normally the scales are firmly weighted in the employer's favour, I do agree with those who are pointing out a lot of people are having to manage on far less than £35k. If it helps, I'm 56 and a graduate (albeit in a creative industry that's never been known for generous pay) and I've never earned that amount in my life.

horseyhorsey17 · 09/01/2024 13:31

mynamesnotchris · 09/01/2024 13:28

THIS!

You should be very grateful & feel happy about your good financial situation! YABU. I find your post quite offensive because I am living with medically diagnosed depression.

It's not a race to the bottom, though. £35K a year isn't 'a good financial situation' - not with the ongoing cost-of-living crisis. At best it's an 'OK' financial situation, although that depends where you live in the country, you'd struggle on that in London. And of course, lots of people have it worse, but that doesn't mean the ones having it less bad should just shut up and stop moaning.

Speaking as one who also has medically diagnosed depression! I do work full-time and earn over the average though so not really sure what bearing it has on this?

Lexie12345 · 09/01/2024 13:31

I'm sorry but I do feel you over react. Depressed about earning over 35k? You're lucky. I earn 21k before tax and insurance, I work a 33 hour a week job but because we are short staffed and cannot take anyone else on I am basically doing more hours that I'm contracted to do, doing 3 peoples jobs, not claiming overtime because that is now a thing of the past, I have many health issues but still keep on going because I don't have a choice. I can't claim PIP because I'm not considered disabled enough so I keep going in order to run my household and pay my bills. You should think yourself lucky as I suffer from real depression and anxiety and stress but still carry on no matter what my salary is. Money is money and if you don't like what you're getting now you know the solution. Sorry if this seems harsh but that is the real world.

horseyhorsey17 · 09/01/2024 13:29

Marrongrass · 09/01/2024 13:11

Sounds like a high wage to me. Isn't the figure given as the average skewed by a relatively small number of very high workers, or by not counting all the people who earn nothing or very little (e.g. carers)?

Yes! I believe the actual median salary for the UK is closer to £24K.

mynamesnotchris · 09/01/2024 13:28

TotallyForgettableForNow · 08/01/2024 18:21

How do you think this thread comes across to people earning significantly less than 35K pa?
Are they worthless? Should they not bother getting out of bed in the morning?
You even said that 'luckily DH earns a decent salary' so you are apparently not struggling.
In the kindest possible way OP pull your head out of your arse!

THIS!

You should be very grateful & feel happy about your good financial situation! YABU. I find your post quite offensive because I am living with medically diagnosed depression.

horseyhorsey17 · 09/01/2024 13:28

You're going to get a lot of negativity for this OP - as the MN attitude appears to be that if you're even earning the average, you are a rich braggart who should be feeling financially flush and definitely shouldn't be 'boasting' on here - but I totally get it. Salaries are shocking in this country - I'd be earning more than twice my salary for the same job in the USA (although yes would have to pay for healthcare and have less job security). And yes, it makes you wonder why you work so hard and go to university and get great qualifications when you're still struggling to pay the bills every month.

The problem is that there's been almost no wage growth since 2010 (wonder what happened in that year) and what wage growth there has been since then has been concentrated in executive positions, tech and the financial sector. The actual real median salary, if you allow for that and take out all the millionaires, is considerably less than £30K a year.