Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

"I've never found him attractive"

184 replies

starfro · 08/01/2024 09:19

I've seen this both in real life and on here. Women will marry guys they don't find attractive, just because they want someone to support them and their desire for babies.

Then 10 years later they are in an awful sexless marriage, and either splitting or "staying together for the kids".

AIBU to find it totally dishonest and selfish from the women that do this?

OP posts:
NotAUniqueProblem · 08/01/2024 11:44

I am this woman

FreeRider · 08/01/2024 11:34

@barbarahunter I did the same - first marriage because I was young/stupid/wanted to get away from parents...I remember getting drunk the weekend before the wedding and gaily telling my best friend that I didn't love my husband-to-be and hadn't for ages... like you my whole attitude was very 'oh it will be ok'...of course it wasn't and we were divorced 3 years later.

Second marriage was because - at the age of 30 - I felt 'old and past it' and panicked. Didn't help that I had my mother going on and on at me about having been with then boyfriend 5 years...looking back we should have split up, not married.

In both cases I took infatuation and limerence far too far. In both cases, I didn't have the guts to say 'this isn't working out for me anymore' and end it years before I did. In both cases, I was the one who finally pulled the plug. Both exes have gone on to have long term relationships with new people. I do draw comfort from the fact that as I never wanted children, there were none to be drawn into the messes I made.

SomeCatFromJapan · 08/01/2024 11:23

I find people seem to confuse someone being conventionaly good looking, with being attracted to them.
Granted, the more good looking someone is, the more people probably will be attracted to them, but there's so much more to it than that, the actual chemistry of falling in love.

Comedycook · 08/01/2024 11:08

I think it also depends on how unattractive you find someone. I mean are you repulsed by them? Or do you just not feel much attraction? To be honest I think there's something to be said for making sensible decisions about who you marry rather than waiting for a knight in shining armour. I know lots of women who are single and childless and rapidly approaching 50...it's not a position I'd envy . Meanwhile the woman I know who married a guy she's not attracted to has a family life, a home, a man who would do anything for her...it's probably preferable. I mean the absolute ideal would be to have that combined with the attraction!

Fionaville · 08/01/2024 11:00

In the past, I've dated a few men, who looking back weren't attractive at all. At the time though, I must have fallen for their personalities and love made me fancy them, they were attractive to me. Even if I knew I was overlooking some flaws. Now I don't love them at all, I look back and think what was I thinking?!
So, it suggests that if somebody 'Never found him attractive' Then they never were never madly in love with them, in which case why the hell did they marry and settle down with them?
I still fancy my DH of 25 years! I think he's very handsome, maybe it's still the love goggles in action, but I do think he's genuinely attractive and not just to me.

5128gap · 08/01/2024 10:55

HareSalient · 08/01/2024 10:45

What I think I find weird on here is an unquestioning acceptance that you trade off dependability/hard work for boringness in a partner.

I'm not sure it's that as much as being realistic enough to know that unless you're an incredibly desirable woman bringing everything possible to the table yourself, it's pretty unlikely you're going to have a queue of men who score ten out of ten in all criteria. Most women do have to compromise on their ideal in some way. The OP is asking us to judge women who compromise on physical attraction in favour of financial security.

Pestopastaandcheese · 08/01/2024 10:52

TakemedowntoPotatoCity · 08/01/2024 09:32

If you are unattractive to many men and desperate for kids I can see why it would be a valid choice. I couldn't have sex with someone I didn't fancy though, I would rather use a sperm donor if I wanted kids that much.

I ageee

User135644 · 08/01/2024 10:51

The problem is a lot of women are attracted to awful men. Either the alpha bad boy, the charmer or general dark triad traits. Therefore a marriage with one if them isn't going to go well either if the men you are attracted to are knobheads

Ladolcevita233 · 08/01/2024 10:49

I think many people of both sexes "settle".

And while it's kinda sad, it's understandable why they do. There are many valid reasons.

You then end up with people who are not all that attracted to or into their partners/spouses.

User373433 · 08/01/2024 10:47

You can he attracted to somebody's personality and have a good sex life with them without being physically attracted to them.

HareSalient · 08/01/2024 10:45

5128gap · 08/01/2024 10:43

I've not really seen this as any sort of trend tbh. I'm sure it happens, but most of the threads from women who don't find their partners attractive add 'anymore', because of certain changes in their partner, often around his behaviour. However, supposing this is a thing, as you suggest, it seems to me just another way to judge women for their choices. Women who prioritise sexual attraction are generally regarded as 'shallow' so whatever criteria a woman uses to pick a partner there'll doubtless be someone waiting around to criticise her. Value looks and the ugly men and their cheerleaders will moan. Value financial stability and the poorer ones will have a problem with it. Value personality and unfortunately you may be looking for hens teeth.

What I think I find weird on here is an unquestioning acceptance that you trade off dependability/hard work for boringness in a partner.

swimsong · 08/01/2024 10:43

gannett · 08/01/2024 10:16

I sometimes think that many MNers have never actually talked to a man, maybe never even met a man, given all the bizarre stereotypes that get trotted out about them.

How many actual honest conversations have you had with men about male sexuality (which, spoiler alert, is not the same for every man, just like female sexuality is not the same for every woman).

Stereotyping women while complaining about women stereotyping men is not a good look.

5128gap · 08/01/2024 10:43

I've not really seen this as any sort of trend tbh. I'm sure it happens, but most of the threads from women who don't find their partners attractive add 'anymore', because of certain changes in their partner, often around his behaviour. However, supposing this is a thing, as you suggest, it seems to me just another way to judge women for their choices. Women who prioritise sexual attraction are generally regarded as 'shallow' so whatever criteria a woman uses to pick a partner there'll doubtless be someone waiting around to criticise her. Value looks and the ugly men and their cheerleaders will moan. Value financial stability and the poorer ones will have a problem with it. Value personality and unfortunately you may be looking for hens teeth.

Ladolcevita233 · 08/01/2024 10:43

also- contrary to your point above, I’m probably not the ‘hottest’ woman out there!

Yeah, that statement was very black & white/over simplified.

Men go for all kinds of looks, types, personalities. I know plenty of attractive, stable men who have relatively average looking partners.
The hottest school Dad at our school is married to a definitely not above average looks lady (and he seems stable and a good Dad too).

AuntMarch · 08/01/2024 10:43

It could have been me, but there was nothing malicious in it, I just felt too guilty to break his heart and because he was a decent man at the time, I thought I should be happy.
If he hadn't done something that gave me a "reason" to end it, I've no idea if I'd have gone through with getting married. (Of course now I know any reason is enough)

Older and wiser now, it would have to be something very special to get heavily involved.

Echobelly · 08/01/2024 10:35

I don't think I've come across anyone who's admitted to marrying or seems to have married a man they see nothing in for the sake of security/kids.

FurballFrenzy · 08/01/2024 10:32

sickbucket67 · 08/01/2024 09:32

you’re looking at this all wrong.

Women settle. It’s social conditioning. They are frequently told to give ‘nice guys a chance’ and they give years to these apparent ‘nice’ guys who actually are just mediocre.

If they look for a stable provider,
funny, kind type AND someone that gets them hot under the collar- there is quite often baying harpies telling them they are being too picky and they will end up alone. A thread like this pops up weekly with someone expressing faux concern for their ‘picky’ friend ending up alone.

The number of times i was told i was being too picky when i was doing OLD was unreal. I was single and dating for 4 years before i met DP. It was worth the 4 years of being single to hold out for someone like him.

Copen · 08/01/2024 10:25

Some women are just like that I guess. Growing up, when I was about 19 my best friend indicated the least attractive person we knew and said 'I would rather marry him than marry nobody'. She duly then went on to marry very young, but it wasn't for kids, she didn't want or have them. More just for company and security.

I didn't settle, never married and am happy. I can't imagine being shackled to someone I have little interest in and having to have sex with. I have better things to do with my time!

GrumpyMoose · 08/01/2024 10:24

@gannett i think, and i could well be wrong, but if you are business minded about marriage you wouldn't leave and blow.up their lives only because you were never attracted, usually the conversation goes like:" but can you work on rekindling that spark?" And she would say "well I was never attracted" And the separation if it does happen will be down to other factors because she was already the type who doesn't prioritise or capable of ignoring physical attraction. I would argue that the ones who do separate due to lack of physical attraction are the very ones who got together because of thr physical attraction.

I would also say that the husband would have known she isn't as into him from her luke warm enthusiam, i don't think the woman has to pretend to fancy him. It's an unspoken mutual understanding like a much younger beautiful woman and an old rich man. They both get what they need.

I think it's more wrong to decide to have a family with a man based on physical attraction than based on finances and personality. Some people might say well have both! Physical and personal attraction! To which I say this is rare to find together in a person who also finds us equally attractive in and outside. Meanwhile, clock is ticking, time wasters fucking us around, you have to be realistic about life.

Comedycook · 08/01/2024 10:17

Women will marry guys they don't find attractive, just because they want someone to support them and their desire for babies

I know this is the way a lot of men nowadays like to think ..I mean it's all a bit incel(y) but there are far less gold diggers around than they like to think and actually there are very very few men around who are happy to totally financially support a woman.

YeahIsaidit · 08/01/2024 10:16

I've seen women saying on here that they've done just that, the guy has ended up being useless and they've gone to have several children with them and then blaming "the patriarchal society we live in" on the whole thing, just refusing to take any kind of responsibility for their actions

gannett · 08/01/2024 10:16

Worldgonecrazy · 08/01/2024 09:58

Women are sold a lie that looks and attraction are unimportant.

“Women settle. It’s social conditioning. They are frequently told to give ‘nice guys a chance’ and they give years to these apparent ‘nice’ guys who actually are just mediocre.”

This is so true. And whilst the early hormones can blind women to many things, once they wear off and you see your fat icky ugly husband, many women prefer to stay in the marriage for many and sometimes complex reasons.

This is not true for men. The various medical funny stories are evidence that men do not need to find a person or object attractive to enjoy having sex. I’m not even sure men get the ick the way women do?

I sometimes think that many MNers have never actually talked to a man, maybe never even met a man, given all the bizarre stereotypes that get trotted out about them.

How many actual honest conversations have you had with men about male sexuality (which, spoiler alert, is not the same for every man, just like female sexuality is not the same for every woman).

VampireWeekday · 08/01/2024 10:14

Women will marry guys they don't find attractive, just because they want someone to support them and their desire for babies.

Very funny, but it's not the weekend anymore so it's probably best to make the sexist baiting threads somewhat believable.

Obviously you know this, but - women don't need to be supported by men, women have compelx desires that sometimes but not always includes "babies". Attraction is often interpersonal and comes and goes with how the relationship in general is going.

Why don't you start a thread about gold diggers marrying old men for their money, that will be fun too.

Deadringer · 08/01/2024 10:13

I don't know anyway irl with this attitude, everyone I know married because they were madly in love. I can't say it worked out for all of them though. I don't recall reading about those situations on here either, surely most women start off being attracted to their partners, but go off them in time?

gannett · 08/01/2024 10:13

GrumpyMoose · 08/01/2024 09:46

It might be bad for you but some people have a loe libido or find financial security a bigger turn on. People have different priorities and are willing to put up with different things.
I would give up good sex and good looks for a fat wallet.

OK but then you have to actually put up with it.

I wouldn't judge anyone for entering into a relationship for money or stability as long as they'd been honest with their partner and they were both on the same page*, and then if they accepted that was the choice they had made.

Settling for someone you never loved, never found attractive and then once you've got the kids you wanted turning round to moan about it (and potentially blow up their lives)? No sympathy at all.

*Settling for someone you don't love, while fooling them into thinking you love them, is just vile behaviour and no amount of "social conditioning" can excuse it

Swipe left for the next trending thread