Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

"I've never found him attractive"

184 replies

starfro · 08/01/2024 09:19

I've seen this both in real life and on here. Women will marry guys they don't find attractive, just because they want someone to support them and their desire for babies.

Then 10 years later they are in an awful sexless marriage, and either splitting or "staying together for the kids".

AIBU to find it totally dishonest and selfish from the women that do this?

OP posts:
Doteycat · 08/01/2024 15:02

Ayse1 · 08/01/2024 14:56

@Doteycat it will come eventually to one of you at least.

Unlikely really.
38 years and counting.
And now they kids have moved on its better than ever.
Quite sad you think that really.

upthehills1 · 08/01/2024 14:59

Sexual attraction isn't solely dependent on physical appearance. If it was, the human population would be far lower and far better looking 😅I've met good looking men who I have no desire towards whatsoever, and average looking men who I have been extremely attracted to.

Besides sexual attraction and money, there are other things needed in relationships - shared ideals and interests, similar views on life and hopes for the future, emotional support and availability...

If the question asked is about someone having never been attracted to their partner (whatever they look like), I think that is rather strange and I feel sorry for any men conned into a relationship based on dishonesty.

Ideally, have your own financial independence so you don't need to 'settle' and accept money over all else.

SomeCatFromJapan · 08/01/2024 14:56

So there is no guarantee that even if you married someone who you found attractive at the time that they would stay attractive to you for the rest of your life

This is where I think the importance of both head and heart comes in for making a marriage decision. While I don't think people should settle for someone they have no romantic interest in, purely as they'd be a good spouse on paper, neither do I think they should ignore the parade of red flags just because they're head over heels in love.

Ayse1 · 08/01/2024 14:56

@Doteycat it will come eventually to one of you at least.

EliflurtleAndTheInfiniteMadness · 08/01/2024 14:52

Worldgonecrazy · 08/01/2024 09:58

Women are sold a lie that looks and attraction are unimportant.

“Women settle. It’s social conditioning. They are frequently told to give ‘nice guys a chance’ and they give years to these apparent ‘nice’ guys who actually are just mediocre.”

This is so true. And whilst the early hormones can blind women to many things, once they wear off and you see your fat icky ugly husband, many women prefer to stay in the marriage for many and sometimes complex reasons.

This is not true for men. The various medical funny stories are evidence that men do not need to find a person or object attractive to enjoy having sex. I’m not even sure men get the ick the way women do?

My abusive XH would have happily gone on having sex with me while despising me. In fact one of the things that made him angry was that i stopped having sex with him after he told me he didn't think he loved me anymore. I was supposed to put out while he made up his mind.

TheaBrandt · 08/01/2024 14:49

Read your Victorian social history. Men and women needed each other to survive in a harsh eorld so linked up in couples for that reason. The perfect romantic love match is amazing but reality is many couples get together for practical reasons. Not me I got very lucky but wouldn’t judge pragmatists.

notlucreziaborgia · 08/01/2024 14:48

When I’ve seen it, it’s invariably done in a virtue signalling way, and the in contrast to a woman that isn’t happy about finding her partner unattractive:

“you’re a shallow harpy that is doomed to misery for thinking looks are even the slightest bit important. I’ve never found my partner attractive, because I’m the deep sort that considers physical attraction to be entirely irrelevant!”.

Because apparently it’s impossible to find a partner that is attractive AND a good person AND financially stable (and if that’s important to you, not because you expect to live off them, but want someone on equal footing to you, then you’re a gold digging harpy as well), and you should accept that you need to settle for three-teeth-Keith. Or die alone with cats, as if that isn’t indeed preferable.

Usernamen · 08/01/2024 14:47

User373433 · 08/01/2024 10:47

You can he attracted to somebody's personality and have a good sex life with them without being physically attracted to them.

This is such a crock of shite. 😂

Unwisebutnotillegal · 08/01/2024 14:46

No one is talking about it working the other way round, sometimes people marry and then the love and mutual respect grows. Some of my in laws have had arranged marriages and over time developed true genuine love and affection. No passionate beginnings but real love.

Usernamen · 08/01/2024 14:42

Skidmarink · 08/01/2024 09:48

Having undesirable sex once a week is preferable to putting up with being poor. The fact is, women still get paid less than men, motherhood still vastly reduces women’s earnings, and decent houses in respectable areas cost two salaries. You have to think about your kids as well as yourself - you do it to keep them in a nice house.

Yes, and what’s more, these women are not having sex they don’t want once a week. If the threads on dissatisfying/sexless marriages are anything to go by, it’s closer to once a year after kids are on the scene.

Doteycat · 08/01/2024 14:41

Ayse1 · 08/01/2024 14:12

Attraction wears off anyway over time so your marriage could be in tatters anyway. Plus the men often find partners less attractive after a certain age anyway so it works both ways. Marriage isn't just about from the chandeliers I'm afraid. There is more to it than that.

Not always.

I am still v attracted to dh and him to me.
I still get butterflies when he winks at me.
It can wear off but not always.

Happilyobtuse · 08/01/2024 14:40

Well sometimes you have a great sex life initially and then after a couple of years it dwindles down with kids, work stress, health issues, irritating personality, infidelity, ED etc. So there is no guarantee that even if you married someone who you found attractive at the time that they would stay attractive to you for the rest of your life. Or your spouse might lose interest for the reasons mentioned above.

Usernamen · 08/01/2024 14:40

starfro · 08/01/2024 09:42

There's "mind blowing sex", and even normal fun sex.

But 20 years of gritting your teeth and doing the deed once a week? It sounds awful for both parties.

They’re not doing it once a week though, that’s the point. You said so yourself in your OP - these marriages invariably end up sexless or with such low frequency of sex they may as well be sexless (in a recent thread a woman said her and her husband hadn’t had sex for 5 years). Women in this situation are only gritting their teeth for a couple of years until they’re married/pregnant. For some that is acceptable to get the baby and financial security they want.

It’s the men who walk straight into these situations that you should direct you concern/pity towards, the women are being rational and realistic in order to get what they want in the timeframe they want it.

User1789 · 08/01/2024 14:40

5128gap · 08/01/2024 12:51

That's not really what I meant. I imagine that most happily married couples enjoy closeness and intimacy because they love the other person. But there's a difference between that and the type of sexual attraction that would mean that if you met your long term partner for the first time, today, in a room full of other men of varying ages and levels of attractiveness, then you'd still find him the most sexually attractive man in the room. You might of course. But I'd suspect that wouldn't be the norm for most long term relationships, which evolve so that what is lost from the initial spark is replaced by something deeper that transcends it. My point being that some couples can skip the spark bit altogether and be none the worse for it.

It is funny you should say that. I secretly play a game in my head to pass the time while at children's parties where I imagine I am a single woman again, at a house party, and wonder which one I would try to catch the eye of. It is always, always the one who looks most like my DH, and I have, to date, never come across a bloke in these scenarios that I would rather shag than my DH.

I am lucky in that I have always had a clear type (brown eyes and dark colouring have reduced me to putty since my mid-teens) and my DH is conventionally attractive in a tall, dark and handsome kind of a way.

We met when I was 21 and he was 25, have been together 15 years and celebrate 10 years married soon, and I love and fancy him more, and want and have sex with him more than I have ever done before. Sure, time will change our bodies but I do believe there will always be a spark if we bother to keep at it. The spark and the deeper intimacy can very much co-exist.

Offwiththecircus · 08/01/2024 14:38

Skidmarink · 08/01/2024 09:48

Having undesirable sex once a week is preferable to putting up with being poor. The fact is, women still get paid less than men, motherhood still vastly reduces women’s earnings, and decent houses in respectable areas cost two salaries. You have to think about your kids as well as yourself - you do it to keep them in a nice house.

oh the horror - does love and lust in a less than "respectable" area score anything? Have you plotted the respectable areas in rightmove's next world map?

Worries123 · 08/01/2024 14:35

I never heard anyone saying this.

Besides, beauty is in the eye of the beholder. Anyone is attractive if the right person lays their eyes on them.

SomeCatFromJapan · 08/01/2024 14:32

I do think there's a difference, again, between "I want to marry a handsome man", and "I want to marry a man I am physically attracted to", and that seems to be something that gets confused here. Like some people have difficulty unpicking their own attraction from what society deems good looking.

Mummysgogetter · 08/01/2024 14:30

barbarahunter · 08/01/2024 09:27

For a range of reasons, eg being young and foolish, wanting to get away from parents, I married my first husband thinking 'oh, it'll be ok'. Growing up, just about every marriage I'd ever seen had seemed to feature a bullying father and compliant mother and I guess I thought that that was what marriage was.

Second time around, I married because I was in love with him. In short, that was just as disastrous as the first.

My conclusion to all this is I'm not cut out for marriage and maybe a lot of people aren't too. I'm not against it per se but society used to see it as the norm and I don't think it should be seen as such.

Exactly this ^^ whether you marry with your head or your heart (or more likely other regions), it's a risk as to whether it works out or not. You could marry someone you don't find attractive physically but your bond grows and you have a happy marriage. Or conversely, you could marry someone you are besotted by and find as the years go by, you are not suited. There are no guarantees. Everyone has their own reasons for their choice in partner - one person might have had a really insecure upbringing and find a safe, secure, compatible partner with low attraction at the top of their list of relationship needs. However, for another, attraction might be on their list of non-negotiables.

phoenixrosehere · 08/01/2024 14:29

thelovingkind · 08/01/2024 14:07

I was friends with a woman like this. She was very attractive and her husband was not remotely, though he was very nice. When she introduced me to her husband, she told me (not in front of him) that he was 'not the best looking creature!' I could understand why she was with him as he was really nice and they did appear to be quite loved up, but I always wonder if he knew that she thought he was ugly.

Did she say she thought he was ugly, just those words, or did she say more about his looks.

Not the best-looking doesn’t automatically mean ugly.

aliceinanwonderland · 08/01/2024 14:27

Comedycook · 08/01/2024 10:12

I have a friend who did this.... getting to late thirties and married a very kind dependable man..but she admits she has never found him attractive. It blows my mind to be honest....I couldn't bear to sleep with a man I didn't find attractive. They don't appear unhappy though....she loves him like a brother I think. She has a nice house and children. Conversely I know a woman who is single and childless and it's now to late for her to meet a man and have kids. I'm not sure thats an especially happier scenario

There was definitely an era 25-30 years ago where if a woman wasn’t married by 30 she started panicking. Older people would warn her that she’d be left “on the shelf”. I know lots of people who sort of settled, because spinsters did exist and were scorned. It’s so different now. Yes some were lucky but they were super attractive. Plain girls often did settle for someone who wasn’t repulsive, but where the chemistry was fading.

gannett · 08/01/2024 14:21

wellhello24 · 08/01/2024 13:35

Yep. Biologically it’s the alpha male we are programmed to find attractive but unfortunately this is the type most likely to cheat and or behave entitled & selfish.

Alpha males don't exist

User135644 · 08/01/2024 14:18

Hereyoume · 08/01/2024 13:04

Is it really that difficult to understand though?

I think we sometimes forget that the desire to have children is not a rational one, and we have a limited time frame, (unlike men) to become parents.

Now, and I'm going to get slated for this (hard hat on) most of us aren't supermodels either. It's socially acceptable for us (women) to "lie" about every single aspect of ourselves. We can wear foundation and lippy, we can get hair extensions, wigs, perms, eyelashes, we can later ourselves in fake tan, moisturiser, wear fake nails, have fake boobs, lips, you name it.

Men generally don't do anything except maybe shave and put a shirt on.

Would you leave the house without your "armour" on?

I know I wouldn't. And the "before and after" versions of me are not even remotely related 😂

I think most of us are a little delusional about our own attractiveness!

I don't think we choose men we're not attracted to. I think we choose men who are about our own level, we just hide the "real" us behind a facade. Whereas men just show up as is, warts and all (literally)

The thing is men are far less picky and have low standards when it comes to the casual (I.e. sex). Most women can very easily attract most men for sex. It doesn't mean the man wants more than that though.

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 08/01/2024 14:16

sickbucket67 · 08/01/2024 09:32

you’re looking at this all wrong.

Women settle. It’s social conditioning. They are frequently told to give ‘nice guys a chance’ and they give years to these apparent ‘nice’ guys who actually are just mediocre.

If they look for a stable provider,
funny, kind type AND someone that gets them hot under the collar- there is quite often baying harpies telling them they are being too picky and they will end up alone. A thread like this pops up weekly with someone expressing faux concern for their ‘picky’ friend ending up alone.

There's at least two motives that can drive "settling".

  1. Women are conditioned to believe that a bad marriage is better than no marriage. "You're too picky, you'll end up old and alone" narrative with "old and alone" regarded as a bad thing when it's actually not.
  2. The woman who wants children doesn't have time to spend searching for "Mr Right" so she has to settle for "Mr Right Now" to father her kids and then divorce him later.
Ayse1 · 08/01/2024 14:12

Attraction wears off anyway over time so your marriage could be in tatters anyway. Plus the men often find partners less attractive after a certain age anyway so it works both ways. Marriage isn't just about from the chandeliers I'm afraid. There is more to it than that.

TTCMama88 · 08/01/2024 14:11

YABU. How attractive a man is in his 20s has nothing to do with whether a couple is in an unhappy marriage 20 years later. I don't know any woman who openly says they married someone they didn't fancy. And attractiveness is influenced by many things, not just physical.

You are conflating a lot of different issues and blaming women for failing marriages. Think there is some internalised misogyny you need to work on.