Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To consider leaving my 3yo to cry for me

164 replies

Newmama93 · 08/01/2024 01:35

I have my second DS 5 weeks ago, my first DS was sleeping with my husband consistently for about a year (to get this to happen I had to let him scream for 2 plus hours at bedtime with DH until he finally accepted it) and would call out for him when he woke during the night as I used to work nights. He’d randomly call out for me when I was pregnant and home and I’d go in occasionally (if I didn’t he’d have a meltdown)

since my baby has arrived I’ve been in my bedroom (where I’ve always been) with the baby and my DH has just moved himself into my sons room and attempted to just sleep there all night with him instead of him calling out and I’m also co sleeping with our baby so didn’t want an extra adult in the bed..

my first DS has started to wake up 3/4 times a night and scream for me, my dh leaves the room to get me and my son won’t have him back in. He would tantrum for over an hour so I’ve just been going in, he has a cuddle and goes straight back to sleep. Problem is, he wakes again and if it’s dh back in the bed and not me it starts again he’s screaming mummy where are you! He’s hysterical begging my DH to go and get me.

so I’m breastfeeding second DS every 2 hours by the time I settle and get him back to sleep my son is screaming for me and I’m running on probably an hour overall of broken sleep. I’m so exhausted. I don’t want to leave my son and have my husband say no you can’t have mummy it’s me in this bed as I don’t want him to feel replaced but I can’t have this anymore. I dread nights and bed. I’ve also been putting my son to bed instead of my husband now as he begs me too and goes on and seems sooo upset, but I want my husband to be able too as well.

also… sometimes to get some sleep I’ll go into my sons room while my husband goes in our room and settles baby so it’s probably confusing for us to say no mummy can’t come in this room then at times I am in there.

side note my son has always been a mummys
bot and preferred me but he’s really against his dad at the moment, won’t go anywhere with him without me etc which is such a shame.

what do I do!!!!

OP posts:
dazedandconfuzzed · 08/01/2024 13:37

is it also pandering if your child is distressed and you respond to them in the day time? 🤔
I disagree completely with the 'you need to teach them to go to sleep on their own' attitude. They know how to do that. What they are being taught is not to bother seeking comfort at night because they won't get it.

Temporaryname158 · 08/01/2024 13:33

Ayleston is right, you are making this worse with all this pandering and people sleeping in random rooms.

put your oldest to bed explaining he must not shout out at night unless it is a emergency as you need to sleep.

dad sleeps in your room or on the sofa. But not in son’s room. Every time he gets up in the night, he’s returned to his bed. If he shouts out husband goes. If he cries, he cries, he puts him straight back to bed with the same words you choose each time “it’s night time. Mummy and daddy need sleep, night night. We will play in the morning” ignore all screaming.

when baby is older and moves to the same room repeat. Do not keep up all this bed hopping. The only people I know who’s kids still get up and down and bed hop all night are the ones allowed to do so from babyhood and their parents are broken

dazedandconfuzzed · 08/01/2024 13:27

Newmama93 · 08/01/2024 12:44

This is a great idea!

we had a reward chart but he was too little to fully grasp it. I’ll try this, issue is if it’s daddy’s turn and then right as it’s time for him to go to bed he will have a meltdown and I’ll just have to stick to it with DH dragging him into bed because that’s the only way he’ll get into the room. But within a few days he’ll know on daddy’s nights we mean it’s definitely daddy. Still not sure how that’ll revise the many night call outs and him kicking my husband out from the bed!

Now and next stuff has helped us SO MUCH, especially when she's feeling unsettled by something. It makes things nice and predictable for them.

Another thing that has really helped us is working out what the trigger is for meltdowns that are the type that are triggered by an event and working out how to avoid that trigger for a few repeats. Either meeting them halfway or having a distraction so eg if daddy getting my daughter into the bedroom was consistently triggering a meltdown I'd introduce a bedtime routine for a cuddly toy, or a job for my daughter to do which involves her taking herself through the door and avoiding the trigger point of dad carrying her in (bonus points if the job involves something she's not normally allowed to do like doing the lightswitch). Or I would start with me coming too but daddy doing all the things.

The more settled and secure he feels, the better he will sleep and the night calls will get rarer. Everything is temporary, sleep ones just feel like they go on forever! you've got this! x

K37529 · 08/01/2024 13:27

My son was the same when I had new baby, he was 2.5. I don't really have any advice but it does get better, baby is 6 months old now and my son has reduced wakes to once a night. It's tough but you will get through this. Will baby take a bottle? Might be an idea, even for just a night so you can get some rest, if your dh could take the baby and you sleep in with your son.

Sunsetred · 08/01/2024 13:23

I let my 3 year old sleep with me and I put my baby in a next to me crib. I would breast feed baby in bed laying down until she fell asleep and transferred her to the next to me crib. If a next to me crib doesn't work for you then you could try something like this?

To consider leaving my 3yo to cry for me
Maray1967 · 08/01/2024 13:18

Yes, you need to be firm. He has to learn to fall asleep on his own - this is key. He will kick off big time but you have to stay firm and not give in. Mine was about 2 when we did this. The first night he got out of bed over 40 times. The next about 20. The next only a few. By about night 5 we’d sorted it.

Start on a night when you can sleep the next day - Friday night is probably best for most. Get prepared. Get shopping in beforehand so you can rest and recover the next day. At 3 he should be able to understand an explanation (earlier on) that not having sleep is tiring everyone. He won’t like it, but he needs to be told that the screaming has to stop and he needs to go to bed sensibly. Two stories and a cuddle, and then you leave the room. No lengthy conversations at bedtime - just short firm reminders that it’s bedtime.

jannier · 08/01/2024 13:08

I don't understand how if you do co sleeping you reject one child for the new one? He's already going to feel pushed out and this just reinforces it. Either sleep with both or don't start with the baby get a next to me cot and do somesettling with each parent.

pjani · 08/01/2024 12:53

Or a wild notion from me - can you sleep with your toddler and husband brings baby in for feeds, night nanny style?

It will over the long term help your baby learn to settle without being fed. It might get your toddler over this current abandonment fear - so could also be temporary.

I wouldn’t personally get tough with your toddler right now - most kids go through some difficulties when they get a baby sibling and it’s not because they are bad, it’s because they are feeling loss/abandonment.

It will get better than this, however you go about it!

Newmama93 · 08/01/2024 12:44

dazedandconfuzzed · 08/01/2024 10:09

I'm fairly sure if I had tried some of the suggestions in this thread my daughter would have screamed until she was sick and would have made an association and starting the bedtime routine would have triggered the same thing every night.

Is he old enough to understand a now and next type picture chart? have photos of you and your husband and velcro it onto the different bits of bedtime on alternating nights, so he knows that tonght is daddy doing teeth and story, then mummy will come and cuddle for a bit, tomorrow is mummy doing teeth and story then daddy will come and cuddle, so he gets used to daddy doing all the bits with the security of knowing you're coming back for the next bit?

This is a great idea!

we had a reward chart but he was too little to fully grasp it. I’ll try this, issue is if it’s daddy’s turn and then right as it’s time for him to go to bed he will have a meltdown and I’ll just have to stick to it with DH dragging him into bed because that’s the only way he’ll get into the room. But within a few days he’ll know on daddy’s nights we mean it’s definitely daddy. Still not sure how that’ll revise the many night call outs and him kicking my husband out from the bed!

OP posts:
Branleuse · 08/01/2024 10:10

User13579367337 · 08/01/2024 09:29

She’s got a newborn in her bed which is already very risky and against most guidelines. She’s already said the toddler doesn’t keep still and she’s a very light sleeper, so not only will no one get any sleep, it’s putting the baby at even further risk having the toddler crawling all over the bed. It would be making everything even more dangerous and even more exhausting. And it’s dragging out the actual issues instead of just addressing the fact that the children need to learn to sleep alone. Her older child does not ‘need’ her through the night at all.

noones getting any sleep at the moment. co sleeping with a newborn can be done safely, but obviously not in the middle of a bed with others in it, but with baby in crook of arm at one side, id say was how most mother and babys have slept since forever.
You do not have to teach children to sleep alone. Its a developmental stage for many. Forcing a small child to sleep alone can be traumatic. The child is really distressed about this. He needs his mum to be able to sleep. What on earth is the point of fighting this. My children are all a lot older than this now, and are teens and young adults, but Ive always let them sleep in my bed whenever theyve needed me. Kids grow up more independent and secure when their basic needs have been met when tiny.

dazedandconfuzzed · 08/01/2024 10:09

I'm fairly sure if I had tried some of the suggestions in this thread my daughter would have screamed until she was sick and would have made an association and starting the bedtime routine would have triggered the same thing every night.

Is he old enough to understand a now and next type picture chart? have photos of you and your husband and velcro it onto the different bits of bedtime on alternating nights, so he knows that tonght is daddy doing teeth and story, then mummy will come and cuddle for a bit, tomorrow is mummy doing teeth and story then daddy will come and cuddle, so he gets used to daddy doing all the bits with the security of knowing you're coming back for the next bit?

Latewinter · 08/01/2024 10:09

Fiddlerdragon · 08/01/2024 09:44

That’s the first mistake a lot of people make with their babies, they only put them down or leave them after they’ve fallen asleep. So they don’t learn to fall asleep alone. I think you’re just going to have a few tough nights. Read him a couple of stories and then leave the room when he’s looking sleepy, but not quite asleep. Say goodnight to him. And after that completely refuse to engage. If he cries just leave him to cry, if he gets up then pick him up without making eye contact, don’t say a word to him, and put him straight back to bed. Over and over again. You may have to do this over 50 times until he gives in. He will eventually though. Every night you do this it’ll get easier, you can’t give in even once because then he thinks he can change the rules. I know you think you’re being nice to him by getting up all through the night, but he’s suffering just as much as you op. A young child with disrupted sleep and waking up like yours does is at more risk of mental health and behavioural problems. It can cause impulsivity, stress, depression, aggression issues, anxiety and thinking problems in young children. It can also affect his physical development. He’s only waking as he’s learnt to use you as some sort of security blanket that he’s never had to go without. The quicker you teach him to sleep without you, the quicker HE can get the benefits of sleeping properly.

The baby is five weeks old. This is not developmentally appropriate and it certainly won't get the OP the sleep she needs.

Latewinter · 08/01/2024 10:07

At @User13579367337 safe co-sleeping is NOT risky and "against most guidelines", stop propounding ignorance.

Having the toddler in her bed with the younger one would be but she is not doing that.

dazedandconfuzzed · 08/01/2024 10:00

Would a next2me or something for the baby work, then they'd be safe in their own bit of the bed in case the 3 year old wanted to come to you?

We have always let our daughter come into our bed when she needs to. We've had some stages when she was in our bed every night and I thought it would never end, but it was important to me to be available to her when she needed me. For me, not coming to them in the night when I do in the day is confusing behaviour, night times are frightening for little ones, it's dark and lonely and dreams are weird things.

Training a child in their own room all night is a popular thing and people will tell you it's the only way for them to get enough sleep, but them wanting to be near you is a built-in survival instinct which is stronger in some kids than others.

Mariposistaa · 08/01/2024 09:55

Newmama93 · 08/01/2024 09:36

It is! It wasn’t like this before baby. He’d sleep alone until like 2am then call out for husband which is still not great at almost 3 but it was much better than what he used to be!

so then do I just refuse to go in when he’s calling out screaming in the night or send husband in?

Better for husband to do it, but he needs to be firm too. It's time to sleep (DS name). Put back to bed. Leave. Don't keep going in, or he will learn that he gets attention by hollering. And you will all be in for a crap next day as everyone will be tired. It will be brutal, but it will be worth it. Sadly all hard lessons that we need to learn are often hard.

Fiddlerdragon · 08/01/2024 09:44

That’s the first mistake a lot of people make with their babies, they only put them down or leave them after they’ve fallen asleep. So they don’t learn to fall asleep alone. I think you’re just going to have a few tough nights. Read him a couple of stories and then leave the room when he’s looking sleepy, but not quite asleep. Say goodnight to him. And after that completely refuse to engage. If he cries just leave him to cry, if he gets up then pick him up without making eye contact, don’t say a word to him, and put him straight back to bed. Over and over again. You may have to do this over 50 times until he gives in. He will eventually though. Every night you do this it’ll get easier, you can’t give in even once because then he thinks he can change the rules. I know you think you’re being nice to him by getting up all through the night, but he’s suffering just as much as you op. A young child with disrupted sleep and waking up like yours does is at more risk of mental health and behavioural problems. It can cause impulsivity, stress, depression, aggression issues, anxiety and thinking problems in young children. It can also affect his physical development. He’s only waking as he’s learnt to use you as some sort of security blanket that he’s never had to go without. The quicker you teach him to sleep without you, the quicker HE can get the benefits of sleeping properly.

Newmama93 · 08/01/2024 09:36

Mariposistaa · 08/01/2024 09:34

This sounds like absolute chaos.
Everyone needs to be in their own bed. And it sounds like you give your older child plenty of attention in the day. He needs to be told nicely but firmly that nighttime is for rest and sleeping and you will see him in the morning. Atm he is calling the shots. He will yell and scream until he can’t anymore - but he won’t do it for more than a couple of nights! Don’t make a rod for your own back. You all need sleep - especially when you are back at work in a few months.

Edited

It is! It wasn’t like this before baby. He’d sleep alone until like 2am then call out for husband which is still not great at almost 3 but it was much better than what he used to be!

so then do I just refuse to go in when he’s calling out screaming in the night or send husband in?

OP posts:
Mariposistaa · 08/01/2024 09:34

This sounds like absolute chaos.
Everyone needs to be in their own bed. And it sounds like you give your older child plenty of attention in the day. He needs to be told nicely but firmly that nighttime is for rest and sleeping and you will see him in the morning. Atm he is calling the shots. He will yell and scream until he can’t anymore - but he won’t do it for more than a couple of nights! Don’t make a rod for your own back. You all need sleep - especially when you are back at work in a few months.

Newmama93 · 08/01/2024 09:32

Any tips on how to get my toddler to sleep alone? We do books and he rolls over and goes to sleep after our 4th book. Then I leave the room. I’m not sure how to make him understand sleeping alone when he falls asleep with one of us there.

anyway not implementing anytime for prob a month or so as I don’t want to add anymore change!

OP posts:
User13579367337 · 08/01/2024 09:29

Branleuse · 08/01/2024 09:21

What about getting a big super king bed and having a family bed. Just give in to it. You all need some sleep and your son clearly needs you in the night a lot.

She’s got a newborn in her bed which is already very risky and against most guidelines. She’s already said the toddler doesn’t keep still and she’s a very light sleeper, so not only will no one get any sleep, it’s putting the baby at even further risk having the toddler crawling all over the bed. It would be making everything even more dangerous and even more exhausting. And it’s dragging out the actual issues instead of just addressing the fact that the children need to learn to sleep alone. Her older child does not ‘need’ her through the night at all.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 08/01/2024 09:26

Would your baby take a bottle - even of expressed milk - from DH in the night? Then you could get some sleep but still be there for your eldest? Even if DH was only doing one night feed with the baby it would help. Or if not doing the settling with the baby after you’ve fed.

I agree with those saying everyone being in their own bed would help - and the baby in a cot near your bed.

User13579367337 · 08/01/2024 09:25

whitebreadjamsandwich · 08/01/2024 09:06

I'd have both kids in the bed with me and leave dh in a bed on his own - your 3 year old will sleep through any newborn fussing and you can side lay, feed + doze at the same time. Path of least resistance so you get some sleep for now

That is 100% just trying to make a bad situation worse. Short term relief like pp said. Then she’s got 2 non sleepers in her bed, potentially for at least another 3 years if the baby is as bad as her current 3yo. I’d have no relationship left if I kicked my dh out of bed for 6 years instead of learning how to settle my children in their own beds. I’ve got no time for children in my bed, I don’t know how anyone who does gets any sleep at all. The only time they’ve even slept in my room is when they’re sick so I’ve dragged their mattress in on the floor. It’s been non negotiable at all, so funnily enough I’ve had zero issues with any of my children. If my children where still waking me up at 3 years old I’d either be in a mental hospital or I’d have put them up for adoption 😂

Branleuse · 08/01/2024 09:21

What about getting a big super king bed and having a family bed. Just give in to it. You all need some sleep and your son clearly needs you in the night a lot.

Aylestone · 08/01/2024 09:19

mamacorn1 · 08/01/2024 04:28

You should take baby and go into ds room. Ds is feeling replaced and he is taking this out on your dh. I don’t understand the need for dh to be in son’s bed. Your son should be in his own bed, so he learns to settle himself without parent in his bed. Can you get a camp bed to go in his room ?
all this Co sleeping the whole nighttime routine sounds a nightmare. I exclusively bf all my girls, but they had their own cots and moved into their own beds, I never experienced difficulties like this. You might want to rethink.

This. I know you can’t see the forest for the trees when you’re exhausted, so it’s just easier to bung them in bed with you for some short term relief, but all it does is create these ridiculous situations where your child gets to 3 years old and is still crying for you through the night like a newborn. And you’re training your new baby to be exactly the same. You’re going to have to bite the bullet with your 3 year old, accept you’re going to have a few really shit nights, and pretty much super nanny him to get him to sleep alone in his own bed. And get that baby out of your bed asap, you don’t need to co sleep with a newborn, get one of those next to me cribs at least. I say this with the upmost sympathy because I made the same mistake with mine at first. I also made the same excuses that I see a lot of people saying on here like ‘oh I HAVE to go sleep with them or they won’t settle at all, they just WON’T’!! Except they WILL! If you flatly refuse to have to baby sleep on or next to you and put them in the crib for every single nap, they’re not going to decide to just not sleep ever again. They have to sleep op, and the quicker you get into good habits, the better.

Newmama93 · 08/01/2024 09:10

whitebreadjamsandwich · 08/01/2024 09:06

I'd have both kids in the bed with me and leave dh in a bed on his own - your 3 year old will sleep through any newborn fussing and you can side lay, feed + doze at the same time. Path of least resistance so you get some sleep for now

We were going to do this! But my toddler literally climbs around the bed at night in his sleep ! I’m an extremely light sleeper but I still don’t want to risk it.

I might try the single bed option in the room or try to get baby sleeping alone. My concern is also when I am not here / just wish he was ok with DH sometimes! I feel so so so needed 24/7!

OP posts: