Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To consider leaving my 3yo to cry for me

164 replies

Newmama93 · 08/01/2024 01:35

I have my second DS 5 weeks ago, my first DS was sleeping with my husband consistently for about a year (to get this to happen I had to let him scream for 2 plus hours at bedtime with DH until he finally accepted it) and would call out for him when he woke during the night as I used to work nights. He’d randomly call out for me when I was pregnant and home and I’d go in occasionally (if I didn’t he’d have a meltdown)

since my baby has arrived I’ve been in my bedroom (where I’ve always been) with the baby and my DH has just moved himself into my sons room and attempted to just sleep there all night with him instead of him calling out and I’m also co sleeping with our baby so didn’t want an extra adult in the bed..

my first DS has started to wake up 3/4 times a night and scream for me, my dh leaves the room to get me and my son won’t have him back in. He would tantrum for over an hour so I’ve just been going in, he has a cuddle and goes straight back to sleep. Problem is, he wakes again and if it’s dh back in the bed and not me it starts again he’s screaming mummy where are you! He’s hysterical begging my DH to go and get me.

so I’m breastfeeding second DS every 2 hours by the time I settle and get him back to sleep my son is screaming for me and I’m running on probably an hour overall of broken sleep. I’m so exhausted. I don’t want to leave my son and have my husband say no you can’t have mummy it’s me in this bed as I don’t want him to feel replaced but I can’t have this anymore. I dread nights and bed. I’ve also been putting my son to bed instead of my husband now as he begs me too and goes on and seems sooo upset, but I want my husband to be able too as well.

also… sometimes to get some sleep I’ll go into my sons room while my husband goes in our room and settles baby so it’s probably confusing for us to say no mummy can’t come in this room then at times I am in there.

side note my son has always been a mummys
bot and preferred me but he’s really against his dad at the moment, won’t go anywhere with him without me etc which is such a shame.

what do I do!!!!

OP posts:
JusticeTrade · 08/01/2024 22:20

Just remembered when my 20 yr old comes home from uni I will still sometimes find her fast asleep while Harry Potter is being read on her phone 😂😂

VampireWeekday · 08/01/2024 22:19

Next to me crib for the newborn all the way!

this may be a stupid question, but why does your DS call for you instead of coming in to your room and getting in bed himself? Mght be easier for you if he learned to wake up, come in and cuddle and go back to sleep, then DH could carry him back to bed or you could leave him there.

JusticeTrade · 08/01/2024 22:16

Actually @SpicyMoth is absolutely right. I was too exhausted to read to them at night with #3 so bought older dds (3 & 5) a cd player and lots of audio books - which I vetted very carefully! I am sure these days podcasts etc would have great age appropriate material. It really worked with mine and as an added bonus massively helped their future reading and vocabulary as they LOVED to listen to their favs over and over.
Even as they got older they listened to all of Harry Potter and loads of others series.

It honestly saved my life and assuaged my guilt of just not physically being capable of staying awake any longer! DH was just as knackered as me as he started work early and was on-call at night.

User415373 · 08/01/2024 22:16

Not sure if anyone has mentioned this but what working for my eldest was talking a lot in the day time about what was going to happen at night. I was really surprised at what a difference it made. So in the car or at breakfast or when playing we'd say 'and remember daddy is putting you to bed tonight, he can't wait, what stories will you choose' etc etc. she barely responded and seemed to ignore us sometimes but by the time evening rolled around there was so much less drama. Also talked a lot about how mummy would do bedtime again one day and the new way of doing things wasn't forever, as I realised she wouldn't understand that unless I explained it to her!

Lourdes12 · 08/01/2024 22:15

I would have both kids in bed with me and husband in other bed.Also, if you do your child's bedtime he's going to want you when he wakes up

SpicyMoth · 08/01/2024 22:09

Newmama93 · 08/01/2024 09:32

Any tips on how to get my toddler to sleep alone? We do books and he rolls over and goes to sleep after our 4th book. Then I leave the room. I’m not sure how to make him understand sleeping alone when he falls asleep with one of us there.

anyway not implementing anytime for prob a month or so as I don’t want to add anymore change!

"I’m not sure how to make him understand sleeping alone when he falls asleep with one of us there."

I'm only 1st trimester with my first, so take this with a pinch of salt perhaps as this is only from having been a child myself rather than parenting - But have you considered audiobooks rather than reading to him directly?

That way he can have the 1:1 bedtime moment of settling down, picking stories, goodnight kisses/cuddles etc, he also gets to see you leave that way and understand that he needs to sleep on his own.

I used to go to bed with cassette tapes and I don't recall my mum ever mentioning sleep issues with me -

One thing I will say though is try to "vet" the audiobooks if poss.

It was a cassette tape story that enlightened me to the nature of Father Christmas and The Easter Bunny - it wasn't long after that that I ended up saying something along the lines of "So is God like Santa too then?" - We weren't even a religious family! 😂

OhwhyOY · 08/01/2024 22:07

Also if you do have to cope on your own before you get your son to sleep on his own properly I'd second the advice of the PP above who said have one of them either side of you - I've had to do that when home alone and toddler won't settle or stay asleep. It's not ideal and I find I don't sleep much but it's a helpful emergency measure.

JusticeTrade · 08/01/2024 22:06

Toddler is 3 and if he gets 1 on 1 time with mum and dad during the day he gradually should learn that he is safe with dad in another room. He has the typical anxiety when a new sibling comes along.
If you stay calm as parents and don't feed his anxiety, but do lots of reassuring whenever he settles calmly he will gradually change his associations.
A family should balance everyone's needs (age appropriately). Mum's sleep is also a priority for her mental health and sanity.

We had 3 and I extended BF them all and co-slept, but DH and I worked to help the children transition into their own rooms as toddlers and eventually they slept deeper and longer.

We also had a toddler mattress at the foot of our bed and the kids sometimes slept there when they were making a transition from co-slèeping. It depends on the child.

They pick up a lot of cues from us and if we are getting anxious they get fearful too and think they can't do something.

We didn't let our kids CIO but we also were firm but kind when teaching them transitions.

It's very important that although you are exhausted you get 1 on 1 time during the day with your toddler so he doesn't just associate you with nighttime comfort. 3 yr old is also a world away from 2 when they are still really babies. You can have full on conversation with a 3 old and they can wait and understand in a way that most 2 yr olds can't.

OhwhyOY · 08/01/2024 22:04

Sorry, world's longest post there!

OhwhyOY · 08/01/2024 22:04

We have been going through exactly the same and it has only really calmed down in the last month or so. Things that worked for me:

-Telling my two year old in advance about what would happen (that morning, then again during dinner, then before bed) - 'tonight daddy is going to put you to bed won't that be lovely? He will help you put on your pyjamas, then brush your teeth, then you can come in for a cuddle with mummy before story and sleep.' I'd go on about how lovely daddy was etc. Even though she was still sad it did help .
-Made a big point of everyone having their own bed - daddy sleeps in his bed in the blue room, you sleep in your bed with your lovely fish sheets, mummy sleeps in her bed, and baby sleeps in his basket. I made sure she saw the baby sleeping in his basket at times as well to reinforce the idea that he slept in there, even though he often didn't.
-Keep some consistency in routine as that's reassuring for them, even if it's not what they really want. Work out what works and keep doing it. I was trying to put both kids separately to bed and becoming exhausted and felt desperate as they were both not getting what they needed. We switched to dad putting toddler down and me just doing baby which means both are now sleeping better in the night as they are getting to sleep earlier. For us dad takes baby during dinner so I can hang out with DD, then dad gets DD ready for bed whilst I feed baby, then she comes in and has a cuddle, then goes to bed with dad. If he falls asleep with dad there he won't be upset to find you gone and dad there. I mostly ignored my toddler calling and left dad to comfort her (well, in reality I heard her and was devastated nor to be able to go to her) but if she wqs really really getting worked up I would go in and cuddle her and tell her how much I loved her and that mummy was just next door, but mummy needed to sleep in her own bed and DD in hers so we could get good rest, and she would see me in thw morning for a cuddle when she woke up. Then we had a consistent routine of her coming in for a cuddle before going downstairs so she knew she'd see me. It did work eventually but there were a few nights of 'I don't want you daddy!!!!'
-Re sleeping in her own bed alone we did the 'gradual retreat' method which actually was much easier than I feared. Again I told her in the morning then again during dinner about what would happen- tonight instead of being in bed with you mummy is going to sit in the rocking chair until you fall asleep. Then a couple of nights later I moved to sitting outside the door, then to my room. I also made a big deal about it being her big girl bed, wow aren't those sheets really cool, aren't you lucky to have such a lovely bed etc basically making her excited about her room. Before bed I would tell her how she would be so snuggly and warm and safe in her cosy bed, and if she wanted us she could call out and 'mummy or daddy' would come. Then we made sure to come quickly if she woke up scared, but not stay long, repeating the same gradual retreat step (e.g. hug, reassure, shall mummy stay in the rocking chair until you fall asleep again?). We leave her with books and a nightlight and she would just chat to herself and fall asleep. I would NOT recommend you do this yet though, wait until baby is 6 months plus as otherwise DS is likely to feel abandoned.

newmum0604 · 08/01/2024 21:55

@Kezb16091983

Just because this worked on your kids doesn't mean it's a simple solution for everyone. Some children will cry and scream until they vomit rather than self-settle.

gemma19846 · 08/01/2024 21:51

Wow give your 5 year old some love and affection. Id personally let 5 year old sleep with me and put baby in a next to me crib/cot where its also safer

Kezb16091983 · 08/01/2024 21:44

I think co sleeping is where its going wrong. You need to start a whole new fresh plan. I get baby is colicky , get them their own sleep pod or moses basket and a breathing monitor for peace of mind which lays under that mattress. You can't go on like this anymore, try pumping and your husband do a night feed. Haven't Co slept with any of my kids, straight to moses basket and the same routine every night and they know ehat to expect . Sorry your going through this, I'm not meaning to sound harsh, we are all learning as parents

hot2trotter · 08/01/2024 21:41

I was a single parent to a 2 year old and a newborn a few years ago. 2 year old had always co-slept so there was no way I was going to move him into his own bed once newborn was here. So I co-slept with them both, one on one side of me and one on the other - I did have a big king size bed though so there was plenty of room. Meant I could comfort both (and BF newborn) as and when needed. I would not have coped on my own 24/7 otherwise - I only had one pair of hands and couldn't be in 2 different rooms at the same time obviously.

Those early days are about survival, you do what you can to get through - and get some sleep.

RKP123 · 08/01/2024 21:32

I have a 3.5 year old son and a 5 month old son. Luckily my eldest is back to having a daddy moment but I ended up having both boys with me for a bit and hubby slept in eldests bed.

Fiddlerdragon · 08/01/2024 21:06

Latewinter · 08/01/2024 10:09

The baby is five weeks old. This is not developmentally appropriate and it certainly won't get the OP the sleep she needs.

I was talking about the 3yo ffs 😂

jannier · 08/01/2024 20:21

Newmama93 · 08/01/2024 15:10

Maybe because I’m up every 2 hours with a hard to settle baby? Im not closing the newborn because I prefer it. My newborn son needs me constantly, I also never slept with my toddler. If I could sleep with my toddler all night I would, I’d sleep 10 hours it’d be great but I can’t as I have a tiny baby to constantly attend too. Pretty silly question

Most of us have had multiple children and babies that don't sleep mine fed 2 hourly night and day but your eldest doesn't understand have you tried expressing and letting dad have a go?

lifehappens12 · 08/01/2024 19:11

Hard question to ask but is the crying real or for effect? I ask this of a mother of a three year old who starts to cry and kick off if I say it's daddy's turn to do bedtime. Then if I do it - crying stops immediately.

It's still feels like a kick in the stomach to here my son cry even when I know it's really to get his own way but we are started to be consistent by staying no it's daddies turn etc.

We also 'lie' as well. Lat night it was daddy's turn, he cried and I said mummy is going to work now walked out the door and stood in the garden for 5 mins before going back in. He accepted that so that I what we do.

Sleeping on his own is tough though I struggle with this one as we adults don't always want to sleep alone. However he was got your husband. Mummy smelling teddy bear? I did this with one of my babies - gave them a comforter that smelled of me.

Also - I have a 3 and 5 year old. When the 3 year old was newborn - all wakes up from the elder child were on my husband. You can't do both:

Nosleepforthismum · 08/01/2024 18:14

My two year old went through a phase of waking in the middle of the night after I had my second DC and calling for me. My DH dealt with him every time he got out of bed and told him “mummy’s sleeping, let’s go back to bed” etc. kept it calm and reassuring but didn’t give in. Only lasted a couple of weeks and sleep was back to normal. I would honestly just encourage your DH to completely take over night time duties with your three year old and he will settle eventually. I suspect the lack of consistency is making things worse.

JusticeTrade · 08/01/2024 16:58

It's very normal developmentally for the toddler to feel displaced by a sibling and this usually settles down in a few months as your new schedule becomes the norm. A couple of thoughts:

A) Although all of us sleep best in total darkness, if he is having anxious nights right now, do you have a nightlight for him? Just so that he doesn't wake in a panic and not understand what's happening in the dark.

B) Create really positive associations with his dad. For example, to help him sleep well, before starting his bedtime routine they can spend time 1 on 1 doing something your toddler loves: going to the park/outside in the garden for 20 minutes, playing a game he loves etc etc just whatever creates a strong positive association with DH. You can both also big this time up by you saying "You're so lucky! Daddy's taking you to the park again!" and DH saying "I can't wait for our special take again, this is going to be fun tonight!". He obviously definitely needs 1 on 1 time with both of you during the day to reassure him of your attention.
He could even get a small sweet treat if it makes him super excited to be with his dad.
Hopefully as he creates a stronger more positive bond with his dad he will feel less anxious to find he is sleeping with him when he wakes up. Make sure dad is giving him plenty of physical touch, hugs and kisses so he doesn't just associate that physical comfort with you.

C) Make sure if he stays with you instead you make it as boring as possible, stay stuff like "oh if only you could play with daddy tonight, we'll just need to fold these towels instead" - or whatever.

D) It also has the added bonus of getting him extra tired before bedtime - it must be BEFORE his bedtime routine, not when he is in PJs or anything.

Superscientist · 08/01/2024 16:42

We only have 1 but one that doesn't like sleep.

We got a good routine in the evening that got her sleeping in her own room. It involved 2 of us. We are in the position that we think we can push a bit of independence so we are alternating days so either me or my partner does bed time. At the moment we are needing to give a strong reason for why mummy isn't there. The first day I pretended to be more late home from work. I got home just before she went up to bed and I stayed in the car for 15 minutes so she had settled upstairs when I creeped in. The next time dad took the bed time as I had a migraine so mummy couldn't do it because she had a poorly head. This was only the second day that I didn't do it recently and she accepted this reason more readily than she has done previously.

Over nights we are trying to stay out of her bed when she wakes. I'm not a saint and after 30-45 minutes of screaming and over an hour of quiet awake I get in with her. We have done it for 2 weeks so far and after the first 2 days when she really wasn't happy with the new arrangements it's been once a week that I have had to get in with her. We keep trying to slowly push her independence. Keep with dad doing the bulk of the work over night but find some ground rules for you stepping in and doing a swap.

CatMadam · 08/01/2024 16:24

Fiddlerdragon · 08/01/2024 09:44

That’s the first mistake a lot of people make with their babies, they only put them down or leave them after they’ve fallen asleep. So they don’t learn to fall asleep alone. I think you’re just going to have a few tough nights. Read him a couple of stories and then leave the room when he’s looking sleepy, but not quite asleep. Say goodnight to him. And after that completely refuse to engage. If he cries just leave him to cry, if he gets up then pick him up without making eye contact, don’t say a word to him, and put him straight back to bed. Over and over again. You may have to do this over 50 times until he gives in. He will eventually though. Every night you do this it’ll get easier, you can’t give in even once because then he thinks he can change the rules. I know you think you’re being nice to him by getting up all through the night, but he’s suffering just as much as you op. A young child with disrupted sleep and waking up like yours does is at more risk of mental health and behavioural problems. It can cause impulsivity, stress, depression, aggression issues, anxiety and thinking problems in young children. It can also affect his physical development. He’s only waking as he’s learnt to use you as some sort of security blanket that he’s never had to go without. The quicker you teach him to sleep without you, the quicker HE can get the benefits of sleeping properly.

I don’t think leaving a child to cry is ever a good idea, and will definitely cause them stress!

Campinginthewinter · 08/01/2024 15:51

For some reason, some posters do stick the boot in when you have a new baby and an older child. It’s horrible, same thing happened to me with the same poster Flowers

Newmama93 · 08/01/2024 15:10

jannier · 08/01/2024 13:08

I don't understand how if you do co sleeping you reject one child for the new one? He's already going to feel pushed out and this just reinforces it. Either sleep with both or don't start with the baby get a next to me cot and do somesettling with each parent.

Maybe because I’m up every 2 hours with a hard to settle baby? Im not closing the newborn because I prefer it. My newborn son needs me constantly, I also never slept with my toddler. If I could sleep with my toddler all night I would, I’d sleep 10 hours it’d be great but I can’t as I have a tiny baby to constantly attend too. Pretty silly question

OP posts:
UnbeatenMum · 08/01/2024 13:42

DS has significant separation anxiety but we've had to be firm that Daddy does some things because otherwise I would not have ever been able to leave him. It has got much better over time. I think the key in your case is consistency. So if you want it to be DH all night every night then do that and stick with it. If you want to alternate then a firm 'it's Daddy tonight' and no giving in. Longer term it will be good for him to accept your DH doing some of his care and meeting his needs, and for you to get the sleep you need.

Swipe left for the next trending thread