Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Overheard in the office, what men really think

238 replies

josephinebonaparted · 07/01/2024 21:48

A post from earlier thread got me thinking - the poster said she overheard men in the office saying that they DO hear the baby crying, but are only pretending to be asleep, even the ‘nice’ men. Another one from a few days ago was a poster being shocked at the things a group of ‘nice’ men where saying in a pub once their wives left.

It reminded me of when I was younger (and a lot less wise), I saw men in their 40/50s flirting with female clients at work (client facing role) and taking them out for cocktails and dinners, and literally stepping out of the bar to tell their wives that they were busy at work and can’t come home for bedtime. I was gobsmacked - one of them had a 2 week old baby!

Is this normal? If you work in a male dominated environment, is it really the case that guys don’t respect their partners like this?

OP posts:
Benibidibici · 08/01/2024 12:50

One of my male colleagues called out another guy for joking about not helping his wife with their baby.

My colleagues are mostly pretty respectful about their wives/partners and seem to be pretty hands on with kids too. Lots of proud dads (and mums) asking for time out in December to watch their kids in nativity plays etc.

I always make sure i offer the guys in my team as much flexibility as the women where families are concerned.

5128gap · 08/01/2024 12:31

LoobyDop · 08/01/2024 12:16

I don’t think “most” men are like this, but I do think the ones that are tend to be very dominant, and the “decent” ones don’t stand up to them. So as soon as you have two or three of them in any setting they will appear to be the majority.

I think this is true. You get a handful of bad ones surrounded by a whole flock of sheep. The sheep make up a lot of the nice guys as we percieve them, because they're people pleasers who when they're with women act in the way women want them to, and when with men act in the way the dominant men expect. Basically this cohort probably don't much care one way or another how women are spoken of, they bend with the wind as its not important enough to them to take a stand.

LoobyDop · 08/01/2024 12:16

I don’t think “most” men are like this, but I do think the ones that are tend to be very dominant, and the “decent” ones don’t stand up to them. So as soon as you have two or three of them in any setting they will appear to be the majority.

CasperGutman · 08/01/2024 12:04

These men sound like arseholes when they're talking to other men, and like decent people when talking to women.

How can you tell that the "lad" persona is their true self and the nice guy a pretence? It seems likely that a fair few of them are genuinely okay, and just pretending to seem somehow "cool" Infront of people they think will expect that.

Still a problem indicating a toxic masculine culture, but a slightly different problem.

Bibisitsnow · 08/01/2024 11:52

When I was in my 20s I was mates with my 40 year old boss. He used to come in early, dick about on football websites most of the day then about 4pm, put his head down and stay til 6.30pm/7pm after most of us were long gone. MD thought he was great.

I asked him why he stayed late, when there was no real need - everyone else was out the door at 5pm…
Well, he said. Because he had 2 kids age 4 and 6 so he left early to avoid having to do the nursery/school runs - his wife, a TEACHER did that- and if he timed it right getting home he arrived after the kids were fed, bathed changed etc by his FT teacher wife, just in time for bed. And he magnanimously would do stories while she got dinner ready.
His DW basically thought his job demanded he be there 8am- 6/7pm. When the reality was NONE of us really needed to be there outside of 9-5pm. The owner was ALL about work/life balance and flexibility for working parents in particular.

Opened my eyes. The worst thing was, he had a football season ticket - for him and a kid, and alternated taking one of his kids with him to home games so everyone in the office thought he was father of the year!

Long story short - I married a woman! And Steve, if you’re reading this, I’m glad she finally came to her senses and divorced you!

crostini · 08/01/2024 11:44

TravelInHope · 07/01/2024 22:21

Oh super. Another man-hating thread. Let’s all pile in. Men are such vile creatures aren’t they!

Correct

Agustus · 08/01/2024 11:38

Westernesse · 08/01/2024 11:30

Men have been told to butt out for years and years. Do other women ever step in and help you in these scenarios?

Have they?

And yes, the women in these 'scenarios' generally have a chat with me and other women until we reach our destination and are very thankful that some fucker stepped in and made the situation visible.

SaltyGod · 08/01/2024 11:38

I once worked in HR in a male dominated company.

The stories we came across were awful, multiple and persistent affairs, exchanging promotion for sex, deliberately getting younger female staff blind drunk, sexual assaults, harassment, openly offensive and derogatory comments, sleeping with clients.

Surprisingly it was often the ones you’d not expect, the ‘nice guys’ who took walking holidays and wore washable M&S suits and posted comments about supporting international women’s day and their amazing daughters.

The obvious sleazy guys you could keep out of the way of, but that nice chap who wanted to take you out for a drink to celebrate a project success and then sexually assaulted you, that was a real mind bender.

SpringHexagon · 08/01/2024 11:34

I work in a very male dominated workplace, think trades men and their managers etc. The way some of these men speak about their partners is quite shocking. There are a few really lovely guys who have nothing but nice things to say about their wives and girlfriends, but some are disgusting, such as having a wife and 3 kids but working late because 'its not like I have anything to go home for'. But on the other hand, although much less likely to hear, there are still some nasty women in my workplace who do the same about their partners.

Westernesse · 08/01/2024 11:30

Agustus · 08/01/2024 10:55

Cool.

Next time I'm in a situation where a young woman is being sexually abused (this has happened three times, in recent years, so I know of what I fucking speak), I won't step in. And it's always on trains, I'll do fuck all.

Because men don't. They see it, I see them seeing it, I see them looking at me as I do 'Something'. I see them waiting until I get thumped until they 'step in'.

I never do, and they never do.

Last time was a bloke about 6' 4", I got on a packed train, he was obviously beered up, and was 'bantering' with every woman in his vicinity. There was a very attractive young woman near him and he suggested very loudly that he'd like to come on her face. I got between them and told him that was not OK and he needed to leave her alone.

And I stood in front of him for the rest of the journey. And I could see all the blokes in the carriage looking, waiting.

They did fuck-all though. I had a very nice conversation with the young woman, and was called a 'Fucking Dirty Dyke' by the man in question as he left the train.

I obviously told him to 'fuck off, just fucking do one'.

Not. One. Man. Helped. Me.

Men have been told to butt out for years and years. Do other women ever step in and help you in these scenarios?

Allfur · 08/01/2024 11:29

It's not equally awful, not really in the same ball park, I watched some of the andrew tate documentary last night, it was sickening

LumiB · 08/01/2024 11:25

Agustus · 08/01/2024 11:12

Is it?

Has a woman ever touched you in a way you didn't want and you were scared (because the threat of harm was there) to say no?

Because I have been touched by men like that.

But never by women.

I'm very cool with saying no, fuck off. But there's a risk with men that there isn't with women. And I've never been in a situation with women that felt dangerous.

Well OP is talking about things that get overhead that men are saying. So its about talking and words they use. So that's what my comment was addressing. Women say equally awful things too

Agustus · 08/01/2024 11:12

LumiB · 08/01/2024 10:56

Well is it any worse than what women do when they get together and moan about their husbands. Not all women just some.

Is it?

Has a woman ever touched you in a way you didn't want and you were scared (because the threat of harm was there) to say no?

Because I have been touched by men like that.

But never by women.

I'm very cool with saying no, fuck off. But there's a risk with men that there isn't with women. And I've never been in a situation with women that felt dangerous.

5128gap · 08/01/2024 11:07

I think women typically don't get to see male bad behaviour to its fullest extent. Most men are aware of what women will find acceptable and know how to conceal the unacceptable from women who's opinions matter to them.
If you've been a woman who doesnt matter to them, such as bar staff, the office cleaner, invisible woman on the train, you will often witness a great deal their wives, and female friends and colleagues wouldn't.
Also if you're a woman with men in your life who are open with you about their interactions with other men, you learn a great deal. My DS to whom I'm very close has repeated things to me said in all male groups that have I wouldn't have expected from the 'nice' men concerned.

LumiB · 08/01/2024 10:56

Well is it any worse than what women do when they get together and moan about their husbands. Not all women just some.

Agustus · 08/01/2024 10:55

Westernesse · 08/01/2024 09:36

Ok. Just let us know when white knighting goes out of fashion again and is seen as male entitlement.

Cool.

Next time I'm in a situation where a young woman is being sexually abused (this has happened three times, in recent years, so I know of what I fucking speak), I won't step in. And it's always on trains, I'll do fuck all.

Because men don't. They see it, I see them seeing it, I see them looking at me as I do 'Something'. I see them waiting until I get thumped until they 'step in'.

I never do, and they never do.

Last time was a bloke about 6' 4", I got on a packed train, he was obviously beered up, and was 'bantering' with every woman in his vicinity. There was a very attractive young woman near him and he suggested very loudly that he'd like to come on her face. I got between them and told him that was not OK and he needed to leave her alone.

And I stood in front of him for the rest of the journey. And I could see all the blokes in the carriage looking, waiting.

They did fuck-all though. I had a very nice conversation with the young woman, and was called a 'Fucking Dirty Dyke' by the man in question as he left the train.

I obviously told him to 'fuck off, just fucking do one'.

Not. One. Man. Helped. Me.

YYURYYUCICYYUR4ME · 08/01/2024 10:41

There will always be people that behave badly and always have and probably always will, whatever their sex!! I have worked with odious creatures of both sexes and I'd not say men were worse, just too easy to target / label for this behaviour, as they are generally a little more verbal and visible with it!! I have (not always been popular for this) confronted this behaviour, as I found that one of the worst for flirting / affairs and abusing her DH's trust used me as an excuse and sorry, that's not something I condon or allow and she ended up lonely and on her own, as she played away one too many times! I knew her DH who was lovely and simply confronted her and cut off the friendship in the workplace as she had the morals of an alleycat, with her actively chasing anything and everything and sometimes making the men very uncomfortable with her behaviour, let alone the women. I've worked in sales environments, where the 'chaps' would try it on, but I made it clear that they I would not lie, cover for them and interestingly once you have this conversation out in the open neither do most of their other colleagues want to. Culture feeds this behaviour and it was generally the exception and I think that not confronting it allows it to continue. Same with derogatory language, you let that go, it continues and we all need to make it clear why it is not acceptable and shame those using it; you can start to change behaviours, or at least behaviours in your presence.

Tinselunderthetv · 08/01/2024 10:15

My colleagues, all men are really good. Love their partners and kids, see their parents and siblings frequently too. I think I’m lucky to work with these guys. Women in other teams also talk fondly of them

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 08/01/2024 10:10

isthisrockbottomyet · 08/01/2024 02:17

I think sometimes when people ask if all men are really like this, what they're getting at is is it really the case that any man can be like this behind our backs, even the ones who seem nice?

This, and IMO "yes". You can't know what a man is actually thinking because you aren't in his head, so the safest assumption for your own safety is to assume that he would be like this under at least some circumstances. If he's in a group with other men who are misogynist, he will probably join in to fit in even if he doesn't personally believe those things himself because most people will try to fit in sooner than challenge the group consensus, and will downplay his peers' comments as "jokes" to resolve the cognitive dissonance inherent in doing this. In doing this, he endorses the misogynists' behaviour.

CoffeeMachineNewbie · 08/01/2024 10:08

@Doodar I think men willing to talk about it are generally immature and not worthy though.

Whilst any man might think something, only the pricks voice it.

I dont doubt there are arseholes masquerading as nice guys but if they are among genuinely nice men or in the right culture, they wont feel able to voice it, which creates a culture of change.

VampireWeekday · 08/01/2024 10:05

Not in my workplace. The senior men say things like "I can only stay for drinks and not dinner because I need to get home for bedtime" or "I'm off to do school pick up now". In my mid 20s before my own DC were born I found it a bit eye rolling, like they wanted a medal for doing normal parent things that women would do without announcement. But as soon as I had my own DC I really appreciated it and realised that they were doing great work in vocally normalising childcare commitments fitting around work, and in normalising men picking up the slack. In general the men I know at work talk about their wives as if they are equal partners.

CoffeeMachineNewbie · 08/01/2024 10:04

It's unlikely where I work.

Most of the male senior leaders with primary aged kids have a mix of compressed hours, part time hours, relationships with women of the same seniority and actively take time off for sick children. We have a few single dads too.

They take shared parental leave and one Director took 6 months off as sole carer for the latter half of paternity leave.

They schedule in school runs and label school activities in their calendar and take time off for it. They are on the PTA.

These men don't go to the pub every week after work and they look to organise away days during working hours as they want to get home as much as we do. They talk about being tired from being up with the kids and changing sicky beds.

There arent WhatsApp groups bringing work and banter home.

By role modelling respectful behaviour, it encourages their middle management to do to the same as it's part of the culture.

Its astounding the difference that can be made to workplace culture when men take responsibility for their kids properly and show this at a senior level.

I'm sure I'll be shot down for this but I think a lot of them have senior level wives and wives that made clear that going back to work after maternity leave was important to them and set out an expectation of juggling childcare, not all of it falling to her. E.g. Director household probably couldn't afford 6 months off if wife wasnt back at work.

Westernesse · 08/01/2024 09:36

Agustus · 08/01/2024 09:05

They absolutely should.

I have had so many situations where I have spoken and 'saved' a woman where men have stood around because they're scared. Ok they're scared because if a bloke says NO, that can cause violence. I get why men 'don't want to get involved'.

I get it.

BUT, fucking hell, I've been in situations that I have dealt with and I have looked around for a bit of male involvement, and they always look away, they look around for another Man to deal with it.

And No Man Does. I always end up dealing with it myself.

That is shitty. It pisses me off Every Fucking Time.

Ok. Just let us know when white knighting goes out of fashion again and is seen as male entitlement.

KimberleyClark · 08/01/2024 09:27

DH and I never had children, but whenever we watch a drama with a couple in bed and a baby crying and the man waits for the wife to get up he berates the man.

Agustus · 08/01/2024 09:05

Westernesse · 08/01/2024 08:53

Men are absolutely not responsible for “sorting other men out”. Should normal adjusted males be going around in capes, chastising miscreant males? It’s got absolutely nothing to do with them. They are not the morality police and have their own lives and families to see to.

and is “white knighting” now in vogue again? For a few years this was supposedly bad.

They absolutely should.

I have had so many situations where I have spoken and 'saved' a woman where men have stood around because they're scared. Ok they're scared because if a bloke says NO, that can cause violence. I get why men 'don't want to get involved'.

I get it.

BUT, fucking hell, I've been in situations that I have dealt with and I have looked around for a bit of male involvement, and they always look away, they look around for another Man to deal with it.

And No Man Does. I always end up dealing with it myself.

That is shitty. It pisses me off Every Fucking Time.