Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu regarding in laws??

140 replies

Sfk34 · 07/01/2024 20:32

Sorry in advance veryyy long post...but I m kinda loosing my mind over it
Me and partner have a 10month old baby..first grandchild for both sides..everyone is super excited and going a bit crazy in regards to him. Me and partner from different cultural backgrounds.
Anyway..
My maternity will end soon and we are planning about me going back to work and all the logistics. Nursery was always one of our plans,and then in laws to help. I had agreed with that but that was before knowing what they are like.
Some examples... We live in a 1bedroom kinda smallish house..my mom who lives abroad,came here just before I gave birth and stayed with us for a couple of months to help us for the beginning.
(Which I found out later,it was a very sore subject for MIL,and she was/is jealous about the fact and shows it in comments about my mom till now). So 3 days post partum the in laws visited us and stayed for 3 days,I almost lost my mind with all the inconvenience they caused and the struggles I had at the time,(baby jaundice in out of hospital,tongue tie)but couldn't say much cause my mom was here and like her they wanted to see their grandchild so I was being unreasonable.
MIL always wants to know everything,has an opinion about everything regarding lo,is obsessed with me breastfeeding and if I have enough milk even to this day( which cause a lot of self doubts about my breastfeeding, just to say that I have depression/anxiety and on medication),always watching me when breastfeeding and had my boobs out.
I have to be careful what I say and how I say it with them even when it's regarding my child so they don't get offended.
Last example I told them please no TV with LO and they got upset cause I made them feel stupid?? And they went and complained to my partner. And many more..
Now to the looking after LO when I go back to work..we live 2 hours from each other. So they would have to stay with us while looking after him which is fair enough,but then I would expect them to go to their home when I won't be working. (They would be needed for Tuesday Wednesday Thursday,as the other days we are off,so ideally for me some weeks I would want them to go to their home,so we can be just us after that) and my partner says that I can't ask that of them when they are doing us a favour looking after him,and it's not right. So am I being unreasonable??
My mom,will of course say her own things as well about LO but if I say that's how I want it to be done she will respect me and not say anything on the matter. Also she would be the one saying I can look after LO when you need me but I don't want to be staying anymore than that so you as a couple family can be by yourselves. And that's why I see and think like that. So AIBU????
Thanks if you made it that far

OP posts:
Nanaof1 · 08/01/2024 06:31

Cantalever · 08/01/2024 01:01

Afford a nursery somehow OP - this will never work, and DH is kidding himself it will. Be firm now, and make arrangements to visit his parents regularly so they get to see and know your DC, but you don't have to have them in your home for much time. Make your boundaries clear now - it will be much harder later. But always appear to be "fair" about time spent between your DM and them with your DC.

Her family do not even live in the same country, so making the "time" between the two sets of grandparents "fair" will never happen.

Or, if she sees her family twice a year, they should then see PIL twice a year.
You're right, that would be the most fair to both families. It would definitely save the OP a world of pain, annoyance and heartache having his parents breathing down her neck.

Nanaof1 · 08/01/2024 05:49

Sfk34 · 08/01/2024 00:57

Yeap you got it. So whenever I say something I m hit with, this is how we do things,and it's normal for us. The cord was never cut and unfortunately for me I don't see it happening ever

And when they say that, YOU need to reply, "This is not how I do things. It is not your child and your ideas are not normal or agreeable to me. I am the mother and what I say goes concerning my child. My baby will be going to nursery, so your help with daily childcare is not needed, but thank you for offering. There is not room here, nor will there be room in the next house for all of us to live together. It's a house for the Mom, the Dad and the baby. That's it."

Then give your DP/DH, whatever he is a pair of scissors and tell him to feel free to cut the apron strings, as you are a family of THREE, not five.

IhateHPSDeaneCnt · 08/01/2024 05:43

Re assumptions re culture (I have made the same). It comes down to the denigration of women and being re-embedded by those that were under the cosh in the first place.

Nanaof1 · 08/01/2024 05:40

Sfk34 · 08/01/2024 00:54

My whole life i have been a people pleaser at the expense of me and my mental health. And you are right I need to start changing that. Unfortunately he has some mom issues from when he was a young little boy that he would need therapy so it's a very delicate subject to always bring up 8n what I want which is contrary to the mom

So, he had issues growing up with his mother, and now you and he want to subject your child to her? Do you see the folly in that? She will cause nothing but problems for your child and you. Don't be shocked when she starts to alienate your child from you,.

You may be a people pleaser, but you had better grow a backbone, or you will end up being on the sidelines with your own child, while DH's mother takes over everything as she pushes you out...and out...and out.

You may not fight for yourself but I hope you are willing to fight for your child.

I wish your DM could just move in with you all, as she at least sounds reasonable. If your PIL move in, they will not move out, you know that and they anticipate that.

And yes, I am a grandmother and what the PIL are pulling is disgusting and as I said in a previous post, I can almost write the next few chapters.

Mummyoflittledragon · 08/01/2024 05:29

Sfk34 · 08/01/2024 00:57

Yeap you got it. So whenever I say something I m hit with, this is how we do things,and it's normal for us. The cord was never cut and unfortunately for me I don't see it happening ever

I note that you say partner so you’re not married. Maybe use that as a ‘we are doing things our way’ example for your dp. And while we are at it, you are perfectly entitled to holiday alone with him and your baby. Whilst it isn’t your responsibility to cut the apron strings, if he refuses to put up boundaries with you, you will either be subsumed by his family and risk depression or you will split.

Nanaof1 · 08/01/2024 05:18

Sfk34 · 07/01/2024 23:18

Yes eventually the conversation will happen. And I will look as I always look at the end like the bad person. But as you are saying it has to be done if we want our relationship to work.

But, you are not the bad person here. If your DH is trying to pressure you to let his parents basically take over your life, you have a BIG DH problem.

I am not sure what culture says it's okay for parents to run over the mother like this, but you need to be strong, or it will affect your whole life and not in a good way. To me, it sounds like they will try to take over the baby and your DH, leaving you as the chief cook and bottle washer/maid.

Free childcare is never free, and the price of this childcare maybe too expensive to survive as a family unit yourselves.

I can almost imagine the next two years and what will happen with this if they "move in" for a week or two at a time.

GrumpyPanda · 08/01/2024 05:17

This sounds appalling OP. Agree with others you need to keep PILs out of childcare completely, else you'll never hear the end of it. And don't let your partner guilt-trip you about not liking his mother - maybe turn it around and ask him what his mother's actively done to make you like her? Invading your bedroom without your consent sure isn't it.

Oh and the TV would drive me bonkers. Never mind DC watching or not watching. Your ILs sound like the sort of people to have TV constantly blaring in the background and that would be a hard no in my house (and I actively avoid visiting any house where the hosts are so rude to prioritize TV over facilitating conversation with guests.) I think the remote needs to be hidden away on all further visits OP - just tell them it gives you a headache.

Shoxfordian · 08/01/2024 05:13

Your dh needs to be on your side over theirs or you'll just resent him. If you can afford a nursery then that has to be the best option

IhateHPSDeaneCnt · 08/01/2024 05:07

Just want to bump @DPotter and @LifeExperience to hopefully, underpin that you're not a loon and you need more support from (yuck) DH.

GreatGateauxsby · 08/01/2024 05:07

@Sfk34 I 100% didn’t RTFT 😬 my bad.

i especially missed the south East Asian parent bit! The enmeshment is real. You have a (big) DH problem which has been left to drag on.

Re childcare it’s really difficult especially if your DH disagrees but you have to weigh up the trade offs work out what you want and push for that. Going back to work is hard and you need to be happy with childcare arrangements.

I'm biased as I my job cannot be made part time and so I needed FT care as I didn’t believe family could or would be available reliably and consistently (I stand by this and have examples now that back this view up to my DH) . They do provide most emergency care which I am happy with / has worked well.

But as a result we will be paying £4.5k pm from Jan next year for FT children care for 2 kids in London.
It’s beyond painful but it was my best available choice.

I think the positioning around nuclear families is not a bad suggestion. Also “broken record” technique where you use bland phrases on repeat to assert boundaries/shut down comments.

we had similar WAY less extreme issues with my in-laws vs my family. DH was very defensive of them and wanted everything equal like the baby was a cake being doled out. We eventually got to a place where he accepted fair isn’t equal or the same. But then again I went totally nuclear and DH knew it was a hill I’d die on for a strong offensive position early on…

you need a proper conversation with your DH about the future…

101Nutella · 08/01/2024 04:52

@Sfk34 you need to sort this now or it will get worse. You are the mother. This is your child. Your feelings matter.
if you don’t want them watching TV- they don’t watch TV. If you are polite to your in laws then their emotions are not your responsibility.

i would have a stock phrase you use every time eg thanks for your feedback. Eg ‘no TV, thanks for supporting us with this.’ Then don’t really engage or just say ‘sorry you feel that way but no tv. Thanks for understanding’. Leave the situation.

you have a partner issue btw. Sit down and talk to him. Discuss boundaries and what feels acceptable to you both. Honestly don’t let these people take over your parenting and time with your child. You won’t get that time back and they don’t respect you. Use nursery and get some space.

IhateHPSDeaneCnt · 08/01/2024 04:52

P.s Sod the 'in my culture' malarkey; you're the babies mother and naturally, knows how to nurture!

user1492757084 · 08/01/2024 04:50

I would not have your inlaws do childcare for three days per week. Try having your LO in paid nursery care for one or two days to begin with and for your PIL to mind LO for one day only.
Whoever looks after your child will have to be happy following your guidelines on how much TV etc. You might be okay for the LO to have TV for one day per week.
It would be very stressful with your PIL; they seem stubborn.

Mikimoto · 08/01/2024 04:46

You really have to do anything so as NOT to depend on them.
They sound like the sort of people who would hold it over you for ever: "We do THIS for you...we do THAT for you..."

IhateHPSDeaneCnt · 08/01/2024 04:34

Bloody hell. You have to tell DH to 'man up' when you are able to talk to each other without scrutiny. I assume normal interaction hasn't worked. I would suggest showing him this thread but he wouldn't recognise Oedipus if He bopped him on the nose and offered him a sharpened spoon to take his eye out. On the other hand, assume lack of your privacy has ensured no follow up bundle of joy and more grounds to entrench PILs further. No joke aside, you have to let him know how stressful this is for you. I'd be tempted to say how it was affecting breastfeeding but no doubt, MIL would be thrilled. Is there anywhere you can go for a break? I'm nowhere near SW London and it would be bonkers to go to a stranger with a baby but any family / friends?! I'm sure his family were expecting this sort of crap!

Erdinger · 08/01/2024 03:31

I can’t get my head around 2 couples , 1 adult and 1 new born in a one bed …

Cantbelieveit101 · 08/01/2024 03:28

He wants to save money on nursery, but wants to move to a bigger place.... surely that would be more expensive!

LifeExperience · 08/01/2024 03:03

You are letting his culture decide how you live your life because you've put family peace over the well-being of you and your family unit. That needs to stop, because your child deserves better than a mom who is slowly losing her sanity because she's been forced into living with her controlling, overbearing MIL. What happens to your baby if your mental health suffers even more? You have to take care of yourself so that you can be a good mum. Put your foot down and stop the craziness. Do it for your baby.

DPotter · 08/01/2024 02:53

You need to find your voice.

You don't have to be strident, rude or confrontational.

Just calm, measured and firm.

The more quiet you are the more, people will step on and over you.

So if MIL is watching you breastfed, ask her to leave the room, that you want some quiet time with your child. If comments are made about what you are dressing the baby in - well I'm his / her mother and I decide what he /she wears. As I say calm, measured & firm. You may have to repeat as necessary.

And the love of all things holy - don't move to a 2 bed place & don't let them pick up childcare. Nursery or childminder, or even a nanny. You will need to be firm with your DP - you don't want family living with you. You want to be your own small family.

And you will need to be really firm on the idea of ever sharing a home with the PILs. This is something you can not be quiet about and assume people will not push your boundaries - get your defence in first here. Oh and don't fall for the 'it's tradition in my culture' - you aren't married so your man has shown he's not that traditional.

Setting the scene on this will help with other attempts at your boundaries - get them up and established as soon as you can

LonelynSad · 08/01/2024 02:49

@Sfk34 Why does your DH's culture come first here? Why is his family's feelings more important than yours and your parents?

LonelynSad · 08/01/2024 02:43

No TV around a baby? WTH?! What on earth for? I think you've been watching too many horror films or something

Sfk34 · 08/01/2024 02:31

star8 · 08/01/2024 02:09

The thing is the mother is most likely making him feel bad however youbre the priority now. You must stand your ground. Alot of asian mothers, i mean older ones, will not let their sons move on and love independently and will use emotional blackmail as a tool for everything. If he says "but its my culture" again just say "well it isn't mine". End of. I suspect even after you let them run everything their way it is still bot enough.

I don't like when they use their culture on me so I try not to do that's as well. Maybe I should start doing it though,if I want to stay mentally well.
You know he had tried to warm me about Asian families but I thought that it can't be that bad,and also from where I am from it used to be like that in the past,so I thought it would be manageable. But I was so wrong.
Yes it true I have seen plenty of times the emotional blackmail,and have tried to tell him that but not much luck. I have suggested therapy for him as well cause I think it would be helpful but he is not very keen on it. And yes their way and still not enough

OP posts:
Sfk34 · 08/01/2024 02:24

LouOver · 08/01/2024 01:34

Your DH has greatly let you down at the birth of your child OP, it doesn't get better from there. The small elements you have describes whilst may have cultural inclinations are still abusive. Do NOT even give this a try, set up nursery or childminding.

What your husband is doing I would put money on being premeditated to have you all living together full time. Once he gets them in 2 nights a week it will slowly go up.

I have been thinking about that lately. The "abusive" part but then I m thinking that maybe my hormones are still running wild so I m overthinking some stuff.
That's why I m trying to start therapy again(stopped after the birth as I didn't have the time) just maybe to get help in seeing things again clearly.

OP posts:
Sfk34 · 08/01/2024 02:20

QueenBean22 · 08/01/2024 01:20

This sounds like hell. Can you afford nursery?

I think we would be okayish with nursery. We would have to do some changes here and there but we should be able to make it.

OP posts:
Sfk34 · 08/01/2024 02:19

Cantalever · 08/01/2024 01:13

Of course you are not a bad person,. OP. Please stop thinking that way just because you have feelings and opinions that are not the same as others, and please don't let them pressurise you or use emotional blackmail on you about what is normal for them. What matters for you and your DC is what is normal for YOU - that takes priority as you are now the parent. I agree with the poster upthread who said that you and DH need to prioritise being a nuclear family and each other, not the parents' whims and wishes. This can be done on your terms - you just have to state them.
How did you ever get the idea that this makes you a bad person?

Thank you,
Everytime we have discussions about the PIL in the end I feel like that. I got accused of my partner of not liking his mother and that it was upsetting for him,he thought about later and took it back while saying sorry. But that was enough to make me feel bad.

OP posts: