Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Neighbour has stolen garden (with pic)!

237 replies

AnxiousAn · 07/01/2024 15:47

Please see the image as it helps to explain this situation!

We moved into our house 6 months ago, so we are fairly new to the area. This is important as we are trying to be careful as to how we approach this.

Essentially, all of the terraced houses in our street used to back on to disused land. Over the years, all of the neighbours have claimed their ‘extra’ bit of garden by incorporating the disused land directly behind their garden. Behind the ‘extra gardens’ is a footpath.

Prior to us living here, there was an elderly owner, who as we understand from the other neighbours, didn’t claim his ‘extra’ bit as he has mobility issues. This means that Neighbour 1 has not only claimed their ‘extra’ bit, but also the bit behind our garden. Whilst we aren’t that bothered about having a bigger garden, it does mean we:

  • Have no access to the back of our house via the footpath.
  • Have Neighbour 1 regularly walking around that bit, directly at the back of our garden (fences are low).
  • It’s quite an eyesore as Neighbour 1 uses it for storage / rubbish bins / extra wood / compost. The fence they built some years ago when they claimed it is dilapidated and looks terrible. They also have a dilapidated, rotten shed on it, which they have said they don’t use but have no reason to get rid of.

Additionally, we are the only house down our road that doesn’t have the ‘extra’ bit, and the only people whose garden is now overlooked and boxed in. Neighbour 1 has admitted he doesn’t own the land and has never bothered purchasing it.

What would you do?

To reference the photo - the black lines are the original gardens and the green is the extra bits that have been claimed. N1 stands for Neighbour 1, Ours is our garden, N2 is the neighbour on our other side… (I’ve included our neighbour on the other side so you can see what everyone else has ‘claimed’.. apart from Neighbour 1). The grey is the foot path.

Neighbour has stolen garden (with pic)!
OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Falkenburg · 07/01/2024 18:16

Personally I think you are just wasting money in hiring a solicitor and trying to buy the land if your garden is an adequate size.

I would invest in a decent high fence at the rear and plant along the pack some tall shrubs or trees that will give w nice backdrop to the end of your garden.

I think that is preferable to having a footpath at the bottom of the garden.

GabriellaMontez · 07/01/2024 18:14

LIZS · 07/01/2024 18:03

Did the owners have a right of access to the footpath originally via the extra land. If not your plot has lost nothing.

This would be my question for a solicitor.

Has he blocked your right if way?

Would his adverse possession beat your right of way?

martinisforeveryone · 07/01/2024 18:13

I can't believe people are giving @AnxiousAn a hard time over this. She clearly states they're being careful, not wanting to cause an upset, not bothered about having a bigger garden etc. She actually asks 'what would you do?'

No one in the row of houses had a right of access. No one appears to know the actual owner of the land, whether it's registered or not. No one apparently has adverse possession, although they may have the right to apply for it if the time frame conforms.

Useful blog on adverse possession, in lay man's terms here
Adverse possession of registered land: The importance of serving a counternotice when trying to defend a claim brought against your land (gosschalks.co.uk) including the land owner right to refute.

I've made my suggestions above as to how the OP could handle the situation to mutual benefit. I forgot to add, in conversation you could add that you're concerned about a potential rodent issue, they love to nest under old undisturbed sheds and amongst piles of hoarded materials. The point being that the previous infirm owner was passive, but now it's a good time to overhaul things and have some uniformity and order.

Everyone comes at situations like this from the opinion that the neighbour is going to be resistant, but he may well fancy someone else doing the tidy up and a better outlook all round, so long as he still has an amount of land for his utility bits, sorted out by OP's new scheme.

https://www.gosschalks.co.uk/blog/2023/03/27/adverse-possession-of-registered-land-the-importance-of-serving-a-counternotice-when-trying-to-defend-a-claim-brought-against-your-land

ASGIRC · 07/01/2024 18:13

Newsenmum · 07/01/2024 18:11

well then you can tell him you’re taking it back 🤷‍♀️

Its not the OPs to "take back", though!
The neighbour actually has more claim to the land than the OP

Newsenmum · 07/01/2024 18:11

AnxiousAn · 07/01/2024 16:55

@Whinge The deeds show that we don’t own it, and the neighbour has admitted they don’t own it either. All of the land was just disused and the neighbours have gradually, over the years, taken the bits at the back of their gardens. Neighbour 1 has taken the bit directly at the back of theirs and ours.

Sorry I thought that was clear? Nobody owns it…

well then you can tell him you’re taking it back 🤷‍♀️

ASGIRC · 07/01/2024 18:11

Honestly, if I was the neighbour and I had been using the land for 10+ years, and then the OP started clearing mys tuff away, I would be making the official claim to the land by adverse possession.
He might not own the land, but if hes been using it for long enough, there is very little the OP can do, unless the neighbour is willing to relinquish that bit.

silverbubbles · 07/01/2024 18:10

You need to start using this land too

Newsenmum · 07/01/2024 18:10

I don’t like being ‘that person’ but was it not something you discussed when buying the house? You need to find out how long he’s been doing it for.

penjil · 07/01/2024 18:07

Legoroses · 07/01/2024 17:48

Wow. You bought a house and garden that were clearly demarcated and now you're going to tell your neighbour that you're simply going to take over his land, which he probably has adverse possession over. Amazing.

I hope the ensuing fuss, distress, bad neighbourly relations and legal expense causes the original owners to come and build a house and garden on everyone's baggsied gardens.

🙄

Atacamadesert · 07/01/2024 18:06

You can have a right of access over land you don’t own. However you should have clarified this when you bought it. Check back with your solicitor and in your deeds. If there is nothing then as he doesn’t own it and doesn’t have the deeds I would be tempted to try and bluff him into giving you access by saying you were told there was a deeded access and you don’t want to upset his apple cart by contacting the real owner of the land and suggest you just sort it out between you. Then record your right of access with the land registry.

PigletJohn · 07/01/2024 18:06

Start walking through it regularly, without asking his personal isdoon, and get someone to photograph you accessing it.

LIZS · 07/01/2024 18:03

Did the owners have a right of access to the footpath originally via the extra land. If not your plot has lost nothing.

GabriellaMontez · 07/01/2024 17:58

It's hard to believe you don't have the right to access the path at the back.

Presumably this is intended to be used for bins/large deliveries etc

I would try and establish that, very clearly first. Possibly with a solicitor.

Then speak to the neighbour. Something nice like "we'd like to chat about the path at the back. We need to be able to access it to have some garden equipment delivered". He's Possibly expecting it.

LE987 · 07/01/2024 17:57

Just find out who owns the land and buy it off them? At the end of the day he doesn’t own it so.

donquixotedelamancha · 07/01/2024 17:55

I don't understand why you think you have any right to this land, OP? It's nothing to do with you that the neighbour has fenced off this land years ago.

The best case scenario for you is that some 3rd party still owns this land and will start a battle with all your neighbours to get it back so you might, eventually, be able to buy it- at the cost of all your neighbours hating you.

The more likely outcome is that he now owns the land and you get a reputation as the cunts who moved in and immediately started demanding bits of your neighbour's garden.

It's not your land. If you are that desperate, leave it a long time, get friendly and then try to buy it off them. By that point presumably adverse possession will be certain and you just need to sort out the legal side.

Legoroses · 07/01/2024 17:48

Wow. You bought a house and garden that were clearly demarcated and now you're going to tell your neighbour that you're simply going to take over his land, which he probably has adverse possession over. Amazing.

I hope the ensuing fuss, distress, bad neighbourly relations and legal expense causes the original owners to come and build a house and garden on everyone's baggsied gardens.

CatamaranViper · 07/01/2024 17:45

If he's been using and somewhat maintaining that land for a number of years, having paid for fencing, sheds etc then you'll definitely piss him off if you just try and claim it. It's not yours to claim. I appreciate it's not his either but if he's been looking after it for x long and you rock up and try and demand it, you'll ruin the relationship and possibly piss off all your neighbours if they end up losing their claimed bits as well.

He hasn't stolen anything from you. He is just occupying space around what is legally yours.

You can certainly ask the question but if he says no and you do basically anything other than accept it, you've ruined your relationship.

RowanMayfair · 07/01/2024 17:45

Talk to him and say you'd like to use the piece of land just like he and all the other neighbours do. If he is reluctant tell him you would rather not have to trace the owners to propose buying it, as that could cause issues for him and all the other neighbours, but it's important to you so you will if you have to. Hopefully he will see sense.

martinisforeveryone · 07/01/2024 17:40

@AnxiousAn I'd be inclined to speak to your neighbour directly, better if you can ask the PP here for any useful intel about them so that you approach in the best way.

It sounds like he's just used the land as a dumping ground come utility area and is not inclined to tidy up the view. You could appeal to his better nature and offer to initiate a make over so that you could have access to the footpath and a spruced up storage and compost section. I'm sure you could work out a reasonable scheme.

Sell it as you doing the bulk or all of the heavy work and the outcome being a much better outlook for all of you. Hopefully that's one way or sorting it out without upset and without involving any legal bodies calling everyone's gardens into question.

Talipesmum · 07/01/2024 17:39

we have this sort of arrangement too. Tbh I’d just start cheerily clearing his things out and occupying it with your stuff. He doesn’t own it or the bit behind his house and he hasn’t got a leg to stand on. Ask him nicely where he’d like his things now that you’ll be using that area.

12345change · 07/01/2024 17:36

AnxiousAn · 07/01/2024 17:28

@PossumintheHouse Hmm maybe not then, as it is a sizeable chunk of land.

The neighbour definitely doesn’t own it, he’s confirmed that himself.

On reflection, it’s probably better to just approach the neighbour directly rather than instructing solicitors.

Definitely if you want to maintain good relations with your neighbours.

Vistada · 07/01/2024 17:35

Say you want to start using it so can he please move his stuff, if he refuses then say you'll trace the owners and get their view.

If its a hill he wants to die on then he's at risk of not only losing his own bit of land, but losing it for the whole street too

I get you want to keep relations but this is probably the best way

Duckingfun · 07/01/2024 17:32

Whinge · 07/01/2024 17:30

Even a nice person would be daft to give up a large section of their garden.

lots of people struggling with maintaining a garden and wouldn’t mind it going, he’s not using it except for a dumping site so worth an ask.

SecondUsername4me · 07/01/2024 17:32

Start off with a conversation about "sorting the rear access out" with him and getting that space emptied so you can extend in line with neighbours.

If he pushes back, maybe just say "tbh I don't really want to instruct my solicitor as its likely going to end up us all losing this extra land" and get him to begrudgingly agree to release it to you for "the greater good".

location · 07/01/2024 17:31

Can you not ask him if he would let you clear it and fence it off to be in line with the others. If he’s only using as a dumping ground then he might agree. You might be opening a can of worms by trying to formalise it via solicitor.

Swipe left for the next trending thread