Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Neighbour has stolen garden (with pic)!

237 replies

AnxiousAn · 07/01/2024 15:47

Please see the image as it helps to explain this situation!

We moved into our house 6 months ago, so we are fairly new to the area. This is important as we are trying to be careful as to how we approach this.

Essentially, all of the terraced houses in our street used to back on to disused land. Over the years, all of the neighbours have claimed their ‘extra’ bit of garden by incorporating the disused land directly behind their garden. Behind the ‘extra gardens’ is a footpath.

Prior to us living here, there was an elderly owner, who as we understand from the other neighbours, didn’t claim his ‘extra’ bit as he has mobility issues. This means that Neighbour 1 has not only claimed their ‘extra’ bit, but also the bit behind our garden. Whilst we aren’t that bothered about having a bigger garden, it does mean we:

  • Have no access to the back of our house via the footpath.
  • Have Neighbour 1 regularly walking around that bit, directly at the back of our garden (fences are low).
  • It’s quite an eyesore as Neighbour 1 uses it for storage / rubbish bins / extra wood / compost. The fence they built some years ago when they claimed it is dilapidated and looks terrible. They also have a dilapidated, rotten shed on it, which they have said they don’t use but have no reason to get rid of.

Additionally, we are the only house down our road that doesn’t have the ‘extra’ bit, and the only people whose garden is now overlooked and boxed in. Neighbour 1 has admitted he doesn’t own the land and has never bothered purchasing it.

What would you do?

To reference the photo - the black lines are the original gardens and the green is the extra bits that have been claimed. N1 stands for Neighbour 1, Ours is our garden, N2 is the neighbour on our other side… (I’ve included our neighbour on the other side so you can see what everyone else has ‘claimed’.. apart from Neighbour 1). The grey is the foot path.

Neighbour has stolen garden (with pic)!
OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
TheWorldisGoingMad · 08/01/2024 09:17

Evanesy · 07/01/2024 15:51

But it’s not your garden? So they haven’t taken anything from you?

Perhaps they have taken away the OPs ability to access their garden from the rear.

Evanesy · 08/01/2024 09:16

Missingmyusername · 08/01/2024 09:13

Post in legal or gardening. You won’t get decent responses on here.

The responses here are spot on. Unless OP has some sort of right of access, she has no right to the land, so all she can do is take steps to stop her neighbour using it, unless they have had it long enough to claim adverse possession.

She has no right whatsoever to appropriate that land just because other neighbours have.

Missingmyusername · 08/01/2024 09:13

Post in legal or gardening. You won’t get decent responses on here.

KingsleyBorder · 08/01/2024 09:11

Custardpudding · 07/01/2024 22:49

If the neighbour only has rubbish on your bit, whereas his bit is tidy that tells me he thinks he is only having it on a temporary basis? Also what boundary is between the rough ground and your garden now? Or is it just overgrown? If overgrown could you just not clear it and fence it ‘assuming it’s mine’…?

I think she said it was a fence the neighbour had built, which was very dilapidated. There will be no doubt that boundary is OP’s to fence, which is why I suggested that step 1 would be to tell the neighbour that she plans to re-fence it. This could result in a discussion where the neighbour gives up the bit directly behind OP’s garden, or they could “compromise” on a right of access across the “no man’s land”.
But OP definitely does not have to live with being able to see the neighbour’s mess at the end of her garden.

TreeBurrito · 08/01/2024 01:13

Xenia · 07/01/2024 19:58

As others have said start by paying £6 tonight online to do a land registry search of that land and buy the title and plan. Then see is same name as your neighbour (probably will not be). then you could contact the true owner and ask to buy the land.
If not you could start using it too and gradually push the neighbours junk stuff into "his" bit behind his garden.

Whatever you do, don't contact the owner of the land out of the blue and ask to buy it. Not unless you want to fall out with your immediate neighbour and everyone else in the terrace who has quietly adopted 'their' bit.

This is a legal 'textbook' type answer from MN's lawyer who famously bought an island.

You have neighbours OP and are very wisely treading carefully. You may well be able to adopt 'your' bit too if you go about it in the right way but writing to the owner or unilaterally shifting your neighbour's garden rubbish back into 'his' bit which he has planted up is likely to stir up a whole lot of anger and resentment which will last for years.

Do a Land Registry search, speak to your neighbour and sound out the others in the row.

VanGoghsDog · 07/01/2024 23:50

AnxiousAn · 07/01/2024 17:00

It’s a very good point raised that he may not want to risk the land directly at the back of his house. Funnily enough the land that is directly behind his, he has planted lovely trees, hedges, bushes… it’s the bit behind ours he is seemingly using as waste disposal.

That's just fly tipping then, report it to the council.

Alwaysanotherwine · 07/01/2024 23:05

your neighbour will likely give you your bit

your previous owner threw spanner in work by not taking the bit at the back

if you’re gonna pinch land then the whole row has to do it or someone would notice the staggered backs

a uniform boundary extended is much harder to spot

i know from personal experience as our row did same years ago

next door may not have really wanted it but took it so entire row would get away with it

Custardpudding · 07/01/2024 22:49

If the neighbour only has rubbish on your bit, whereas his bit is tidy that tells me he thinks he is only having it on a temporary basis? Also what boundary is between the rough ground and your garden now? Or is it just overgrown? If overgrown could you just not clear it and fence it ‘assuming it’s mine’…?

QuickDraining · 07/01/2024 20:37

There's always a flip side, if you were the owner how would you feel to have 12 or so squatters?

What I've learned is that give people an inch and they'll take a mile. And most people are greedy. Most of my neighbours are. I've seen neighbours widening their gardens by meters where it's obvious that the gardens can't be. And taking advantage of 'olds' that can't get out to their gardens. Plus re-wilded land and wild land, and out of bounds land often has lots of value in itself. With flim-flam about keeping it tidy, maintaining it. Sadly once someone does it, it's a race to the bottom.

Fangdango · 07/01/2024 20:07

I really would be careful of doing anything that could upset every neighbour on the street, over land that's not in use by its owner (if it has one)

Fangdango · 07/01/2024 20:05

Hairyfairy01 · 07/01/2024 19:36

Just have a chat with the neighbour. Explain that now you have sorted out your garden you would like to do what he and other neighbours have done with the 'spare' land. I'm sure he's expecting you to want to take it over.

Agree - if that's the culture of the area he is probably expecting the conversation.

Alwaystired23 · 07/01/2024 20:04

There's a row of terraced houses near where I live. They have claimed the disused land that backs on to their houses. They have built sheds, etc, on the land. I can't remember why, but the company who actually owned the land was doing a survey or something and saw people had used the land. They had letters from the company or solicitors asking to remove everything. I'm not sure what happened in the end. I think the residents were trying to claim the land, but it wasn't there's to claim. Do you know who actually owns it? Maybe you could buy it from them.

Fangdango · 07/01/2024 20:03

Talk to him about either buying it or sharing it. Happens a lot around here.

If he's had it long enough, he's likely have the right to be legal owner.

There's no way you have a right to it unless there were errors in the land registry documents you got when you bought the house.

Depending on the landscape your way, he may have done quite a big job keeping it cleared.

If he's not legal owner or entitled to be, I'd expect that he might be open to you crossing it at least. Have a chat.

There is absolutely no point in you bringing in solicitors to force him out.

user1492757084 · 07/01/2024 20:02

Building in a gate or removing part of your back fence would give you access through the parcel to the path, for a start.
The neighbour couldn't stop you. Gradually you could beautify more of the area.

Xenia · 07/01/2024 19:58

As others have said start by paying £6 tonight online to do a land registry search of that land and buy the title and plan. Then see is same name as your neighbour (probably will not be). then you could contact the true owner and ask to buy the land.
If not you could start using it too and gradually push the neighbours junk stuff into "his" bit behind his garden.

IbizaToTheNorfolkBroads · 07/01/2024 19:57

About 15% of land in the UK is unregistered, but I'd start with a land registry search. Anyone can do one, costs a few £. But I'm not sure you can force someone to give you access to land that neither of you own.

PyongyangKipperbang · 07/01/2024 19:54

I think that going in faux naive about finding out who owns it and seeing if you can buy it as he has confirmed he doesnt own it, and see what he says. Having to pay (or potentially lose) his section may well lead him to agree to you taking over that bit. Or not.

Point is, his reaction will tell you what you are batting back with, if anything.

StrictlyJowita · 07/01/2024 19:53

He was only able to dump his garden rubbish on it because the previous owner of OP's house was elderly and immobile and either didn't know or didn't care.

How do you know that? Perhaps he got on with the neighbour and thought nothing of it.

QuickDraining · 07/01/2024 19:52

Long thread so haven't read all. But the land registry polygon data is available, and you can map it yourself. It might give a clue as to whether it has an owner. If it has, I doubt any have a claim. If it hasn't then there's a legal process to go through to obtain it. It doesn't magically happen. Similar situation here with neighbours just informally laying claim, that was until the owner wrote them and they backed off. It's annoying feeling surrounded like that. I'd personally prefer a DMZ/no mans land.

ThreeAcross · 07/01/2024 19:51

That sounds pretty useful to me and I'd want my house to have the same benefit and not be the only one disadvantage

Well yes, but the OP doesn't have it, the neighbour has it. We don't know what happened before she moved in.

She bought the house as it is. She didn't have any difficulty buying it because the boundaries were in the wrong place.

She hasn't paid for a fence or maintained the land.

It's not her land. It's some land at the bottom of her garden.

TreeBurrito · 07/01/2024 19:48

But if the neighbour hasn't been using it long enough to claim adverse possession he doesn't have any more right to it than OP. Why should he continue to have 'double helpings' of this extra land?

He was only able to dump his garden rubbish on it because the previous owner of OP's house was elderly and immobile and either didn't know or didn't care.

All the other houses in the terrace now have access to their rear garden from the footpath having informally adopted 'their' bit of land. That sounds pretty useful to me and I'd want my house to have the same benefit and not be the only one disadvantaged.

Londonrach1 · 07/01/2024 19:46

Unless you lived there for over ten years you can't claim it. How owns the land, any background, what's on land register...it's a Honeypot of bees...you want to shake it....

Doppelgangers · 07/01/2024 19:45

Chickpea17 · 07/01/2024 19:38

I don't understand why you think you have any right to this land, OP? It's nothing to do with you that the neighbour has fenced off this land years ago. You are only moved in 6 months ago so lost your opportunity to take part of the land.

Agreed. The actual owner of the land has a claim to it and your neighbour has a claim depending on how long he's been using the land, you however have absolutely no claim to the land. There's simply no way to pursue this without pissing off your neighbours and even then you won't end up with the land so it just seems a pointless way in ensuring you piss them all off.

LittleBrenda · 07/01/2024 19:43

Chickpea17 · 07/01/2024 19:38

I don't understand why you think you have any right to this land, OP? It's nothing to do with you that the neighbour has fenced off this land years ago. You are only moved in 6 months ago so lost your opportunity to take part of the land.

I agree, the very fact that in the title of the thread you say he has stolen it says a lot.

You don't know what happened before you bought the house and you don't know who owns it. But you don't own it.

When we bought our house there was a 30cm strip at the bottom between our house and the neighbours that was inside of 'our' fence but that nobody owned and it was holding things up so much that the seller moved the fence to fence it out.

GrannyAchingsShepherdsHut · 07/01/2024 19:40

OP, you have absolutely no claim to the land at all, all you're going to do is piss off your neighbour and get nowhere.

The original owner of the extra land has a claim, obviously. If he's been occupying it unchallenged by the owner for 12 yrs, then so does your neighbour. He can legally be registered as the owner under adverse possession if he satisfies the criteria. You can't, you've not been possessing it.

If you approach him about having it, I'd expect him to tell you to jog on, just like if it was part of his original garden.

Just because it is behind your house it isn't more yours than his. You honestly have no claim at all.

You could try to trace the original owner and buy the bit, but if they then chuck everyone else off their extra bits of garden, you won't just have pissed off your neighbour, you'll have pissed off the whole street.

I honestly think the best thing to do is just accept you don't have a bigger garden.

The very most you could do is very very nicely ask your neighbour if they would let you put a gate into the extra bit so you can get to the footpath via his garden. He might let you, you never know.