Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Neighbour has stolen garden (with pic)!

237 replies

AnxiousAn · 07/01/2024 15:47

Please see the image as it helps to explain this situation!

We moved into our house 6 months ago, so we are fairly new to the area. This is important as we are trying to be careful as to how we approach this.

Essentially, all of the terraced houses in our street used to back on to disused land. Over the years, all of the neighbours have claimed their ‘extra’ bit of garden by incorporating the disused land directly behind their garden. Behind the ‘extra gardens’ is a footpath.

Prior to us living here, there was an elderly owner, who as we understand from the other neighbours, didn’t claim his ‘extra’ bit as he has mobility issues. This means that Neighbour 1 has not only claimed their ‘extra’ bit, but also the bit behind our garden. Whilst we aren’t that bothered about having a bigger garden, it does mean we:

  • Have no access to the back of our house via the footpath.
  • Have Neighbour 1 regularly walking around that bit, directly at the back of our garden (fences are low).
  • It’s quite an eyesore as Neighbour 1 uses it for storage / rubbish bins / extra wood / compost. The fence they built some years ago when they claimed it is dilapidated and looks terrible. They also have a dilapidated, rotten shed on it, which they have said they don’t use but have no reason to get rid of.

Additionally, we are the only house down our road that doesn’t have the ‘extra’ bit, and the only people whose garden is now overlooked and boxed in. Neighbour 1 has admitted he doesn’t own the land and has never bothered purchasing it.

What would you do?

To reference the photo - the black lines are the original gardens and the green is the extra bits that have been claimed. N1 stands for Neighbour 1, Ours is our garden, N2 is the neighbour on our other side… (I’ve included our neighbour on the other side so you can see what everyone else has ‘claimed’.. apart from Neighbour 1). The grey is the foot path.

Neighbour has stolen garden (with pic)!
OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
akkakk · 08/01/2024 11:29

There is a lot of good sense on here, but also some inaccuracies - adverse possession is not simple - yes there is a basis now (since the law changed in 2002) of 10 years possession of registered land - but there are lots of different situations where it is not that easy - for example, crown foreshore is 60 years, crown lands or various ecclesiastical lands 30 years etc. Similarly, if the land has at any point in the last 10 years been in trust, then you can't apply for adverse possession - and that can happen if the owner has died (probate being a form of trust), or a business goes bust etc. There are different situations for land owned by foreign corporations - and even if owned by the 'enemy'

No land is 'not owned' though it might not be registered, it will still be owned - and to gain adverse possession you need to 'possess' the land, not just use it - so it might be that simply using it as a garden is not enough - e.g. fencing in open land is indicative of possessing the land (though not necessarily sufficient on its own...)

it is a veritable minefield - so I would be taking legal advice and not rushing in...

KingsleyBorder · 08/01/2024 10:57

AnxiousAn · 07/01/2024 16:58

The deeds don’t state anything about an entitlement to the footpath. Several of the neighbours have put up doors in their fences though so they can access the footpath directly from their garden.

Asked and answered @Zooeyzo .

Zooeyzo · 08/01/2024 10:55

Go back to the solicitor you used to buy the house and ask them to clarify the situation. There may be something on the deeds about access.

Cosywintertime · 08/01/2024 10:51

DeeLusional · 08/01/2024 10:15

If it's on her deeds and no one else has been granted the land by a court, she has EVERY right to it.

But it’s not on her deeds, she doesn’t even have right of way over it, she’s no more right to it than the neighbour. Likely less rights depending on how long he’s been using it.

ditalini · 08/01/2024 10:50

Just put a gate in your fence and start using it to access the path. If he's not had it long enough to claim adverse possession then this will stop the clock since he needs to demonstrate sole use.

I doubt he'll be bothered enough to make a fuss as he's not really using it and has no legal claim. if he has had use of it long enough then he can make an adverse possession claim and you're no worse off - of course if he fails to do it then it doesn't matter how long he's been using it since he'll no longer have sole use.

Once you've demonstrated access then you can start clearing the rubbish and use it as a garden. Eventually ask him if he wants the shed back or whether he'd like you to dispose of it for him. Finally put up a fence.

No different to what he did himself. No need for drama.

Christmaslights21 · 08/01/2024 10:41

The no access would bother me the most. Has he fenced this land in or can you just walk across it? I would have smelly old junk and bins at the bottom of my garden too!

ThreeAcross · 08/01/2024 10:30

it's on her deeds and no one else has been granted the land by a court, she has EVERY right to it

EVERYone knows that.

Obviously if it's on her deeds she has a right to it.

However...it isn't.

KingsleyBorder · 08/01/2024 10:22

AnxiousAn · 07/01/2024 16:55

@Whinge The deeds show that we don’t own it, and the neighbour has admitted they don’t own it either. All of the land was just disused and the neighbours have gradually, over the years, taken the bits at the back of their gardens. Neighbour 1 has taken the bit directly at the back of theirs and ours.

Sorry I thought that was clear? Nobody owns it…

@DeeLusional see this post re the deeds.

It’s a good idea to click “see all” on OP’s posts before commenting, though I think even the OP itself made it fairly clear that OP knew she had not purchased the land in question.

KingsleyBorder · 08/01/2024 10:19

DeeLusional · 08/01/2024 10:15

If it's on her deeds and no one else has been granted the land by a court, she has EVERY right to it.

But it’s not on her deeds. That is literally the whole point of her post.

DeeLusional · 08/01/2024 10:15

Chickpea17 · 07/01/2024 19:38

I don't understand why you think you have any right to this land, OP? It's nothing to do with you that the neighbour has fenced off this land years ago. You are only moved in 6 months ago so lost your opportunity to take part of the land.

If it's on her deeds and no one else has been granted the land by a court, she has EVERY right to it.

Sunflwer · 08/01/2024 09:52

As neither of you own it, if I wanted access to the footpath I'd just use that part to access the footpath. Otherwise I'd do nothing but put up better fences around my section.

KingsleyBorder · 08/01/2024 09:50

She doesn’t have a right of way in her deeds though @Runnerduck34 .

Runnerduck34 · 08/01/2024 09:47

I think there's some law that if you maintain unregistered land for x years you can claim it as yours.
However I would say to them that you need access to the footpath (which you have a right you in your deeds ) and would like to take over the piece of land at and of your garden like neighbouring houses- see what he says - he may be expecting it- especially if its just used for storage. You can offer to help with clearing/ fences etc

KingsleyBorder · 08/01/2024 09:43

Evanesy · 08/01/2024 09:36

You edited the post to add more as I commented.

The neighbour could apply for adverse possession and would be able to stop OP using that bit of land for access.

This matter does but cause any issues for OP - she’s simply seen other neighbours with an extended garden and wants it too. So if shes going to start causing issues, she needs to be prepared for any consequences.

Even if she doesn’t want to pursue the access, she should still build a new boundary. One of her complaints is that the existing fence is dilapidated and she has to look at the messy land. That is legally easy to solve.

if she were also able to get some access to the back path, all well and good, but it would not be the main driver for building a new fence.

I would query how useful the footpath access is anyway. If the entrance to the footpath still a way from a road then it’s no use for getting deliveries (eg of fence building materials!)
Dog walking and access by people in dirty boots I guess.
Might just be better to fence it off properly and forget about it.

WandaWonder · 08/01/2024 09:42

So who owns the green bit behind your black line?

If it is not you or N1? Then common?

But if common no one should use it to store stuff

And yes I have read it but can't get my head around it

Evanesy · 08/01/2024 09:36

KingsleyBorder · 08/01/2024 09:32

Nobody. I am just highlighting this as a compromise option that might solve her problem of having to look at the messy land.

You edited the post to add more as I commented.

The neighbour could apply for adverse possession and would be able to stop OP using that bit of land for access.

This matter does but cause any issues for OP - she’s simply seen other neighbours with an extended garden and wants it too. So if shes going to start causing issues, she needs to be prepared for any consequences.

Cosywintertime · 08/01/2024 09:35

KingsleyBorder · 08/01/2024 09:33

I’m not saying that anyone said she could NOT do what she wanted with her own land. I’m just pointing out that she can, as nobody else seems to have suggested this.

Not every comment has to be “aimed” at someone, for goodness sake.

Edited

Ok I think it’s the way it’s written, it looks like you’re disputing something. But yeah sure, she can build a fence.

KingsleyBorder · 08/01/2024 09:33

Cosywintertime · 08/01/2024 09:32

Don’t know who that’s aimed at, but of course she can do what she wishes on her own land, within permitted planning.

but she’s no more right to thr land behind her garden than you , me or the neighbour has,

I’m not saying that anyone said she could NOT do what she wanted with her own land. I’m just pointing out that she can, as nobody else seems to have suggested this.

Not every comment has to be “aimed” at someone, for goodness sake.

KingsleyBorder · 08/01/2024 09:32

Evanesy · 08/01/2024 09:31

Who said otherwise?

Nobody. I am just highlighting this as a compromise option that might solve her problem of having to look at the messy land.

Cosywintertime · 08/01/2024 09:32

KingsleyBorder · 08/01/2024 09:30

She absolutely does have the right to build a new fence at the end of her garden though. And if that fence happens to have a gate in it, who is going to stop her unless the actual owner of the land pops up?

Edited

Don’t know who that’s aimed at, but of course she can do what she wishes on her own land, within permitted planning.

but she’s no more right to thr land behind her garden than you , me or the neighbour has,

Evanesy · 08/01/2024 09:31

KingsleyBorder · 08/01/2024 09:30

She absolutely does have the right to build a new fence at the end of her garden though. And if that fence happens to have a gate in it, who is going to stop her unless the actual owner of the land pops up?

Edited

Who said otherwise?

KingsleyBorder · 08/01/2024 09:30

She absolutely does have the right to build a new fence at the end of her garden though. And if that fence happens to have a gate in it, who is going to stop her unless the actual owner of the land pops up?

Cosywintertime · 08/01/2024 09:29

This is all very extreme. He didn’t steal your garden. It’s not your garden and he didn’t steal anything, he simply uses some unused land behind your garden and has done for some considerable time.

you need to go and speak to him, historically there has been no issue with him using it, it was disused, you can ask him not to, as you wish to claim it, but you’ve no more right to it than he does, and that’s the key part.

you have no more right to it than him, so instructing solicitors is pointless. You simply need to fall on his good nature.

TempleOfBloom · 08/01/2024 09:24

If there is / was a right of way / access he can’t negate that even if he has managed adverse possession of the land.

It’s still land with a ROW over it.

I would start with that.

Evanesy · 08/01/2024 09:24

TheWorldisGoingMad · 08/01/2024 09:17

Perhaps they have taken away the OPs ability to access their garden from the rear.

Unless OP has a legal right to do so, and it would be in the deeds if that’s the case (which OP is refusing to answer which suggests no such right exists), then tough luck.

Swipe left for the next trending thread