Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Neighbour has stolen garden (with pic)!

237 replies

AnxiousAn · 07/01/2024 15:47

Please see the image as it helps to explain this situation!

We moved into our house 6 months ago, so we are fairly new to the area. This is important as we are trying to be careful as to how we approach this.

Essentially, all of the terraced houses in our street used to back on to disused land. Over the years, all of the neighbours have claimed their ‘extra’ bit of garden by incorporating the disused land directly behind their garden. Behind the ‘extra gardens’ is a footpath.

Prior to us living here, there was an elderly owner, who as we understand from the other neighbours, didn’t claim his ‘extra’ bit as he has mobility issues. This means that Neighbour 1 has not only claimed their ‘extra’ bit, but also the bit behind our garden. Whilst we aren’t that bothered about having a bigger garden, it does mean we:

  • Have no access to the back of our house via the footpath.
  • Have Neighbour 1 regularly walking around that bit, directly at the back of our garden (fences are low).
  • It’s quite an eyesore as Neighbour 1 uses it for storage / rubbish bins / extra wood / compost. The fence they built some years ago when they claimed it is dilapidated and looks terrible. They also have a dilapidated, rotten shed on it, which they have said they don’t use but have no reason to get rid of.

Additionally, we are the only house down our road that doesn’t have the ‘extra’ bit, and the only people whose garden is now overlooked and boxed in. Neighbour 1 has admitted he doesn’t own the land and has never bothered purchasing it.

What would you do?

To reference the photo - the black lines are the original gardens and the green is the extra bits that have been claimed. N1 stands for Neighbour 1, Ours is our garden, N2 is the neighbour on our other side… (I’ve included our neighbour on the other side so you can see what everyone else has ‘claimed’.. apart from Neighbour 1). The grey is the foot path.

Neighbour has stolen garden (with pic)!
OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
6
SurelySmartie · 10/01/2024 09:21

As PPs suggest it’s definitely best to talk to neighbour first and see if you can come to an amicable agreement.

It depends on lots of factors. Is the land currently registered to anyone?
How long can neighbour prove they’ve had sole use of the bit behind yours?

Yes you could add that you don’t want to stir up trouble and risk everyone including your neighbour losing the extra land.

If it’s unregistered then someone has the right to make a claim after 12 years of evidenced sole use. It’s not an ‘old wives tale’. (It’s 10 years for registered land) https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/adverse-possession-of-1-unregistered-land-and-2-registered-land/practice-guide-5-adverse-possession-of-1-unregistered-and-2-registered-land-where-a-right-to-be-registered-was-acquired-before-13-october-2003

If there is an owner they can object. This might be the council.

Just because a piece of land isn’t registered it doesn’t necessarily mean it isn’t owned by someone.

If your neighbour doesn’t legally own it (as you say) and doesn’t have a potential legal claim then if the worst comes to the worst you could just attempt to take possession, by fencing it off yourself. But hopefully it won’t come to that.

Practice guide 5: adverse possession of (1) unregistered land and (2) registered land where a right to be registered was acquired before 13 October 2003

https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/adverse-possession-of-1-unregistered-land-and-2-registered-land/practice-guide-5-adverse-possession-of-1-unregistered-and-2-registered-land-where-a-right-to-be-registered-was-acquired-before-13-october-2003

Alwaysanotherwine · 10/01/2024 08:07

and op has literally stated that they have stolen the land over the years

putting fencing around land you don’t own is by definition stealing! i know- i’ve done it!

Alwaysanotherwine · 10/01/2024 08:02

originally all gardens stopped where op did

Alwaysanotherwine · 10/01/2024 08:01

look at the drawings

the original back gardens are where the black line is on op garden

the others have extended their back gardens out to include the green bits

where op has two black lines - one is for her fence - the other is the new fence all the neighbours have put in at the end once they’ve stolen the green bits

Cosywintertime · 09/01/2024 21:49

Alwaysanotherwine · 09/01/2024 18:31

to reckons posters, they have stolen it because they have extended their garden fences to include this extra land

they are not just storing some bins there! they have taken and refenced around it according to op sketch

if word gets back to the owners they’ll only have to look at their boundaries to see what they’ve done

having fenced it doesn’t make it theirs

we did exactly same thing before we legally bought the big at the back of our strip

originally we fenced it - did so for years but solicitor said it’s all old wives tales about gaining rights

What on earth are you talking about, 😂 look at the diagram again. No one has stolen anything.

Alwaysanotherwine · 09/01/2024 18:31

to reckons posters, they have stolen it because they have extended their garden fences to include this extra land

they are not just storing some bins there! they have taken and refenced around it according to op sketch

if word gets back to the owners they’ll only have to look at their boundaries to see what they’ve done

having fenced it doesn’t make it theirs

we did exactly same thing before we legally bought the big at the back of our strip

originally we fenced it - did so for years but solicitor said it’s all old wives tales about gaining rights

Yesididntdothat · 09/01/2024 09:47
  • Have Neighbour 1 regularly walking around that bit, directly at the back of our garden (fences are low).
just noticing this bit from the Op, sounds like the neighbour does use that part of the garden so it's less likely he would want to give it back. A compost heap and bins are not rubbish you can offer to chuck away for him, as others have suggested. OP could sort out the low fence situation pretty easily herself surely, with a better fence!
FishTheRiver · 09/01/2024 09:38

@BambooFridge
Imagine an enormous company like say East Midlands Railways receiving correspondence saying

The people on Apple Tree Road in Huddersfield have extended their gardens on to a piece of land owned by you. They have put up fences and have looked after the former wasteland strip.

You really think they are going to leap up and start instructing their legal team?

That isn't far fetched idea at all. 🫤

BambooFridge · 09/01/2024 07:17

*OP tell neighbour you want the bit at the back and i guarantee they’ll give it you

The consequence of them not, are you telling the owner and them risking the entire row being taken back from them! Why would they do this?! They have no leg to stand on so have no choice but to give it to you.*

This is nuts.

You have absolutely no idea what the neighbour will do, what the landowner will do what the consequences of threatening the neighbour will be.

There are pieces of land like this all over the place. Owned by the local authority. Owned by railway companies. Owned by building companies.

Your plan is to say to this neighbour 'give me that land or I will tell on you'. Thus completely destroying the relationship with the neighbours.

Then, if he doesn't...to contact whoever owns it as you know for sure that they will say 'we can't have that' and start the process of get the land back from all of those people and returning it to wasteland.

In reality, the people who won it clearly don't care. It's definitely going to cost them money to get it back. And for what? To exact a revenge plan for someone they don't know.

Imagine an enormous company like say East Midlands Railways receiving correspondence saying

The people on Apple Tree Road in Huddersfield have extended their gardens on to a piece of land owned by you. They have put up fences and have looked after the former wasteland strip.

You really think they are going to leap up and start instructing their legal team?

Cosywintertime · 08/01/2024 23:11

Alwaysanotherwine · 08/01/2024 18:40

Why on earth are people suggesting a solicitor!!! this is the absolute one thing she cannot do!

The neighbours do not own the land

They have stolen it

Neither op, nor the neighbours are entitled to that land

A solicitor can’t do anything about the neighbour blocking her in at the back since it’s not on her deeds and we presume she had no right of access

OP can look into original owner but I imagine all that will do is alert them to the fact the row of neighbours have taken land

Why do this first OP? Think will guarantee you and all the rest losing that extra space

You are all making massive big deal about this.

OP tell neighbour you want the bit at the back and i guarantee they’ll give it you

The consequence of them not, are you telling the owner and them risking the entire row being taken back from them! Why would they do this?! They have no leg to stand on so have no choice but to give it to you.

you cannot go through solicitor for something you don’t own or isn’t on your deeds. You have mo right to it. Offering to buy it etc as first step is ridiculous

They are using it. They have not stolen it. And why would they stop using it so she can use it instead and incorporate it into her garden , just so she doesn’t tell on them? There is a huge chance the owners won’t care if the person uses it. It’s probably a nature strip or similar.

you seem to think being told on is such a fear making thing they’d just stop using it and let the op incorporate it .

personally I think if she asks politely they may say yes as all they do is store their bins there, but it’s crazy to suggest they would stop out of fear of being told on. The op doesn’t even know who owns it, and if she does, what’s she going to say, my neighbours put their bins on it?

Symphony830 · 08/01/2024 22:20

I have taken over a piece of land to the side of my work premises along with a neighbour. I did this after I’d exhausted all options as to who owned it via the Land Registry, the Local Authority, the business owners adjoining and the previous owner of my building.

Ive got a fire door leading out on to it that has been there in excess of 20yrs so due to the length of time passed I can legally acquire a right of access if some random person with a deed turned up evidencing it was their’s. My neighbour has similar rights to myself. We have agreed to share it. Have fenced it off so it’s for our exclusive use. That’s the important bit about acquiring a ‘possessory title’ over it in the future.

  1. Do your deeds make reference to any old Transfers? This is where you find rights of way/access; although they should have been noted on the registers.

  2. If you do an index map search covering the whole of the land grabbed by your neighbours it will uncover any legal owners (ie title numbers) *these are cheap to obtain.

  3. if you’re neighbour has been there in excess of 12yrs (or the person from whom he bought might have done a Statutory Declaration stating they’d used it X amount of years without objection when he bought). with that portion fenced off he could apply for a Possessory Title.

  4. The best outcome is that your neighbour can apply for the title so that you have the possibility of buying it from him.

Zooeyzo · 08/01/2024 21:44

OP if you do want to check with a solicitor on who actually owns it (I would want to know) ask for clarity from the conveyancer who you used to buy the house.
When I've had issues like this the sol normally doesn't charge anything.

GrannyAchingsShepherdsHut · 08/01/2024 20:10

You can use this map search to see if the land is registered and what the parcel number is to request the deeds.

https://www.landregistry-uk.com/map-search

But lots of land isn't registered, which doesn't mean no one owns it, just they've not registered it. Our house was registered for the first time when we bought it in 2020 and several of my neighbours are unregistered according to the map. They've lived here since the houses were built in the 70s.

What you do know for sure, is it isn't yours. Which is the important bit!

Land Registry UK - Map Search

The Map Search facility provides customers with the ability to view boundaries overlaid on Street maps and Aerial Photography, order copies of Title Registers and Title Plans for properties and land without a postal address and where the Title Number i...

https://www.landregistry-uk.com/map-search

Willyoujustbequiet · 08/01/2024 19:42

GabriellaMontez · 08/01/2024 19:05

presume

Rather than 'presume', I would want to clarify if there is/was a right of way or similar.

Even if there isn't a ROW ( a private ROW is actually called an easement) you can accrue one in several ways - by way of prescription, necessity etc.. all is not lost by any means if the deeds don't show one.

Willyoujustbequiet · 08/01/2024 19:30

OP your deeds show you don't own it but that doesn't mean someone else doesn't.

There has been been compulsory registration in England and Wales for over 30 years. You can do a search of the Index Map at the Land Registry and it should reveal the owner. You don't need a solicitor for this. You can print the form off online.

husbandmidlifecrisis · 08/01/2024 19:19

Awkward. Horrible that he’s using it as a rubbish dump! :(

Polis · 08/01/2024 19:15

Neither op, nor the neighbours are entitled to that land

The neighbour might be. A relative of mine lost some land that was actually on his deeds through adverse possession.

GabriellaMontez · 08/01/2024 19:05

Alwaysanotherwine · 08/01/2024 18:40

Why on earth are people suggesting a solicitor!!! this is the absolute one thing she cannot do!

The neighbours do not own the land

They have stolen it

Neither op, nor the neighbours are entitled to that land

A solicitor can’t do anything about the neighbour blocking her in at the back since it’s not on her deeds and we presume she had no right of access

OP can look into original owner but I imagine all that will do is alert them to the fact the row of neighbours have taken land

Why do this first OP? Think will guarantee you and all the rest losing that extra space

You are all making massive big deal about this.

OP tell neighbour you want the bit at the back and i guarantee they’ll give it you

The consequence of them not, are you telling the owner and them risking the entire row being taken back from them! Why would they do this?! They have no leg to stand on so have no choice but to give it to you.

you cannot go through solicitor for something you don’t own or isn’t on your deeds. You have mo right to it. Offering to buy it etc as first step is ridiculous

presume

Rather than 'presume', I would want to clarify if there is/was a right of way or similar.

EmmyA87 · 08/01/2024 18:52

My dad owns a house with this exact problem. He purchased the house long after N1 moved in so they’ve always had the extra bit of garden. It’s about an extra 20ft of garden so not a small bit by any means! They’ve installed a pool in there but were unsure if the land actually belongs to them or not. Everyone else’s gardens go back to the same length which includes this extra 20ft except my dad’s. We’re unsure if they took it when the house was vacant-auction property very dilapidated when bought!-but my dad has completely refurbished it so the extra 20ft would be nice! My advice would be as no one claims that bit of land would be to ask for the right of access and you’d actually like that little bit just like everyone else.

Alwaysanotherwine · 08/01/2024 18:40

Why on earth are people suggesting a solicitor!!! this is the absolute one thing she cannot do!

The neighbours do not own the land

They have stolen it

Neither op, nor the neighbours are entitled to that land

A solicitor can’t do anything about the neighbour blocking her in at the back since it’s not on her deeds and we presume she had no right of access

OP can look into original owner but I imagine all that will do is alert them to the fact the row of neighbours have taken land

Why do this first OP? Think will guarantee you and all the rest losing that extra space

You are all making massive big deal about this.

OP tell neighbour you want the bit at the back and i guarantee they’ll give it you

The consequence of them not, are you telling the owner and them risking the entire row being taken back from them! Why would they do this?! They have no leg to stand on so have no choice but to give it to you.

you cannot go through solicitor for something you don’t own or isn’t on your deeds. You have mo right to it. Offering to buy it etc as first step is ridiculous

StarlightLime · 08/01/2024 17:59

TheWorldisGoingMad · 08/01/2024 09:17

Perhaps they have taken away the OPs ability to access their garden from the rear.

Not everyone can access their land from the rear, it's not a standard right.

akkakk · 08/01/2024 12:52

Cosywintertime · 08/01/2024 12:35

True, but we need to remember, that it’s not her land he is using, it belongs elsewhere, so yes he may or may not be able to claim adverse possession, but she absolutely can’t and it is no more hers than mine.

i understand she titled it he had stolen her garden, but it’s not her garden, she’s no right to the land, any more than he does.

Absolutely right - but if she wants to do what she is suggesting then she should be checking the legal position first - and ultimately, the land will belong to someone - the whole concept of adverse possession is just a bit cheeky - the belief that somehow there is entitlement to something you don't own and haven't paid for...

Cosywintertime · 08/01/2024 12:35

akkakk · 08/01/2024 11:29

There is a lot of good sense on here, but also some inaccuracies - adverse possession is not simple - yes there is a basis now (since the law changed in 2002) of 10 years possession of registered land - but there are lots of different situations where it is not that easy - for example, crown foreshore is 60 years, crown lands or various ecclesiastical lands 30 years etc. Similarly, if the land has at any point in the last 10 years been in trust, then you can't apply for adverse possession - and that can happen if the owner has died (probate being a form of trust), or a business goes bust etc. There are different situations for land owned by foreign corporations - and even if owned by the 'enemy'

No land is 'not owned' though it might not be registered, it will still be owned - and to gain adverse possession you need to 'possess' the land, not just use it - so it might be that simply using it as a garden is not enough - e.g. fencing in open land is indicative of possessing the land (though not necessarily sufficient on its own...)

it is a veritable minefield - so I would be taking legal advice and not rushing in...

True, but we need to remember, that it’s not her land he is using, it belongs elsewhere, so yes he may or may not be able to claim adverse possession, but she absolutely can’t and it is no more hers than mine.

i understand she titled it he had stolen her garden, but it’s not her garden, she’s no right to the land, any more than he does.

PBandJ111 · 08/01/2024 12:08

Agree, get legal advice before talking to neighbour