Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder what has happened to my Son's school

989 replies

k2493 · 07/01/2024 11:09

Just posting for thoughts

Both my kids have gone through the same secondary school. When my daughter started, the school was lovely and new with around 750 kids.

Fast forward to 2024 and there is now 1500 kids and it's become like a dictatorship.

Due to the number of kids, the school has put lines either side of the hallway that they have to walk within otherwise they get detention.

Every hallway is a one way system.

The minute they arrive in school, they have to remove their coats or it's detention even with no heating in the middle of winter. The other day my son arrived back to school to find that there were long queues outside while they did two uniform checks at the door. By the time he got in, he was frozen. Immediately he got shouted at for still having his coat on even though he had just stepped in from the cold.

He then went around the corner and got shouted at again even though he tried to explain it's really difficult to be expected to stay warm, keep moving and remove your coat all at the same time. Nope. Threaten with detention again.

AIBU to wonder what has happened to our education system? I'm lucky in that my son is quite strong minded and just brushes it off but what about the kids who's mental health this is impacting? Surely we want our kids to remember school as being enjoyable for their education and friendships rather than for being shouted at every two minutes for not walking between lines or not taking their coats off the minute they arrive in school?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
11
mathanxiety · 10/01/2024 14:12

dontbenastyhaveapasty · 10/01/2024 08:17

What's being described here isn't about supporting education, it's about crowd control and uncivilised cohorts who from cradle to grave have lost contact with societal norms. This has resulted in an unkind and punitive environment for all which cannot possibly support learning.

This bit about “uncivilised cohorts”: it’s the same mindset that brought you “migrants are all bad”, “this country is going to the dogs” etc. It is bedded in unspoken very right-wing assumptions about people and society as a whole - particularly people who are working class or black, and it it TOTALLY UNTRUE!

Children today are NOT less civilised than in the 1970s or even the 1870s. Overall, we live in a safer and less violent society now than in the past. Over the years it had been demonstrated that treating children with civility, compassion and love results in better behaved, happier children who are more able to learn effectively.

The “unkind and punitive environment” you so rightly identify has been created by the academy leaders who spout this mad right-wing ideology - Kathryn Birbalsingh et al. It is the schools who have created this culture, it wasn’t there in society first - certainly not in most parts of the country.

The head of “school improvement” at my son’s school was formerly a senior member of staff at the Michaela school. Maybe the Michaela approach can work in a (very)small London school where there is huge choice in which school children can attend, and where maybe there are problems with gangs and knives. Maybe.

All I can say is that it is a total disaster when applied to schools in the rural westcountry, where a single school serves the entire population including all the kids with additional needs. And where society as a whole is broadly friendly, pleasant and kind. It’s like some bizarre Nazi experiment has taken over our schools in order to brutalise an entire generation and destroy our (currently kind and friendly) local culture.

This.

I'd love to see the evidence, the studies, the various pilots that were rolled out that back up the boot camp approach.

mathanxiety · 10/01/2024 14:05

dontbenastyhaveapasty · 10/01/2024 09:37

How can 1500 kids eat together in a canteen built for 500 kids?
You have completely unrealistic expectations of what a school can reasonably do.

I hear you that the schools have problems. But, they have lost sight of their responsibility to the well-being of the children in their care.

in the above example: if there are 1500 children who need to eat in a space that fits just 500, I would organise sittings - just exactly like many primary schools do. Not throw up my hand and say, “ oh well, the 1500 children in my care will just have to take their chances as to whether they get a meal or not. It’s not my problem if they don’t eat.”

There are three lunch sittings at my local US high school. Back in the 60s-80s when the school had over 6,000 students, they let senior year students go home/ off campus for lunch and had four sittings.

mathanxiety · 10/01/2024 14:03

@Iwasafool
Yes, it is.

But I'd take that risk over the shitshow that's being described here and called 'education'.

navigatingmy20s · 10/01/2024 13:45

Was the same for me at school nearly 15 years ago. If my children’s school is like this when they are older, you can bet i’ll be by the gate after school making a fuss and starting a petition 😂

VegetablesFightingToReclaimTheAubergieneEmoji · 10/01/2024 12:33

User79853257976 · 10/01/2024 12:27

I’m a secondary teacher, we don’t come down hard on Y7s at all. (This was in reply to someone but for some reason it’s appeared at the end of the thread).

Edited

My children’s do, any misdemeanour (no matter how tiny) is sanctioned, even just misunderstandings. i always put it down to not knowing the children so don’t know who is an issue and who just made a mistake.
End of year 7/ year 8 as they get to know the children they do slightly relax a little more.

VegetablesFightingToReclaimTheAubergieneEmoji · 10/01/2024 12:28

@MancLass76 i forgot to add the most important thing.
send them with an open mind. I know it’s hard, just because you know some have struggled with the rules etc doesn’t mean yours will.
if you talked to me, you’d get a bad review of my children’s secondary. Talk to a friend she cannot praise it enough as it has been great for hers, and it has been.

our primary was the same. Terribly regarded, but my children were beyond happy there.

User79853257976 · 10/01/2024 12:27

I’m a secondary teacher, we don’t come down hard on Y7s at all. (This was in reply to someone but for some reason it’s appeared at the end of the thread).

User79853257976 · 10/01/2024 12:26

I understand but the one way system will be for safety, as you say they school now has double the number of pupils. Behaviour in secondary is not good; those are some simple expectations to hopefully regain some control, although if the heating is broken there should be leeway. If they are sitting down and the lesson has started, their coats should be off. You wouldn’t sit in other indoor contexts with your coat on. If those things affect their mental health there might’ve other things going on.

VegetablesFightingToReclaimTheAubergieneEmoji · 10/01/2024 12:12

MancLass76 · 10/01/2024 11:22

I have a yr6 starting high school in September and some of the policies and practices are ridiculous. We’ve had the coat removing rule in our local high school for a while but the one way system was introduced this year and now my friend’s child has had weekly comments about being late to one particular class because the route is too long. This year they brought in someone to focus on behaviour and have started physically restraining YP at the first sign of any kind of frustration and are telling all kids not to struggle and submit. It’s shocking!

Christ. The phrase “submit” scares the shite out of me.
i am not naive enough to believe some children are violent, and violence in school cannot be tolerated under any circumstance. If that’s true and not wild teenage dramatics that’s terrible.

all I will say is prepare your child as much as you can, take any settling days you can. they will come down hard on year 7’s, so wait until the summer term at least before thinking of moving school. It does seem easier to move and catchment less of an issue if you move once they’ve started.

coffeeaddict77 · 10/01/2024 11:52

twistyizzy · 10/01/2024 11:41

@coffeeaddict77 because schools aren't workplaces. Most workplace aren't overcrowded with inadequate resources.
In most workplaces you don't risk being bullied or attacked in a toilet.
Schools have to keep the majority of students safe, that often means harsher rules to prevent the minority putting other students at risk of harm.
You can't compare workplaces with schools.
Workplaces don't consist of 1500 adolescents.

I don't think overheating students by making them keep their blazers on is keeping them safe and I don't think not letting students use the toilets in breaks is a good way of keeping them safe either. Obviously if there is evidence of attacks in toilets something has to be done (although I'm sure that there are other ways of preventing this rather than closing toilets altogether) but it seems they are being shut with the assumption this will happen rather than due to the fact it has happened.

twistyizzy · 10/01/2024 11:41

@coffeeaddict77 because schools aren't workplaces. Most workplace aren't overcrowded with inadequate resources.
In most workplaces you don't risk being bullied or attacked in a toilet.
Schools have to keep the majority of students safe, that often means harsher rules to prevent the minority putting other students at risk of harm.
You can't compare workplaces with schools.
Workplaces don't consist of 1500 adolescents.

coffeeaddict77 · 10/01/2024 11:32

twistyizzy · 10/01/2024 11:28

All the teachers I know have said they are leaving because of kids and/ parents (lack of parental support or being verbally attacked by parents). Out of a 50 min class they spend 20-30 mins doing behaviour control/forgotten homework etc etc etc.
5 good friends have left teaching in the last 2 years. 5 good teachers with 20 years' experience each. All replaced by cheaper, less experienced, newly qualified teachers.

Edited

It's no wonder the parents are unsupportive though if their child is being subjected to ridiculously harsh rules. In what workplace are you not allowed to take your jacket off if you are too hot or go to the toilet if you need to?

twistyizzy · 10/01/2024 11:28

Verbena17 · 10/01/2024 11:17

Probably not because of the kids but more the school mangers.

All the teachers I know have said they are leaving because of kids and/ parents (lack of parental support or being verbally attacked by parents). Out of a 50 min class they spend 20-30 mins doing behaviour control/forgotten homework etc etc etc.
5 good friends have left teaching in the last 2 years. 5 good teachers with 20 years' experience each. All replaced by cheaper, less experienced, newly qualified teachers.

peppermintcrisp · 10/01/2024 11:27

Probably not because of the kids but more the school managers

Yes sorry I didn't make this clear. A lot of teachers went to the last local LEA funded school.

One lovely peripatetic music teacher was openly vocal about how she hated the 'military camp' and what is was doing to the children. They as she predicted went on to cut all the music lessons and the wonderful orchestra. It is awful they only have ukelele lessons now.

GnomeDePlume · 10/01/2024 11:24

Verbena17 · 10/01/2024 11:17

Probably not because of the kids but more the school mangers.

Probably, I have no doubt that the highly prescriptive FIFO (fit in or fuck off) model is applied to teachers just as much as it is applied to students.

Very easy to use the rules to performance manage out any member of staff who doesn't comply. Not ensuring shirts are tucked in/ties straight can then be used as evidence of not maintaining classroom discipline.

MancLass76 · 10/01/2024 11:22

I have a yr6 starting high school in September and some of the policies and practices are ridiculous. We’ve had the coat removing rule in our local high school for a while but the one way system was introduced this year and now my friend’s child has had weekly comments about being late to one particular class because the route is too long. This year they brought in someone to focus on behaviour and have started physically restraining YP at the first sign of any kind of frustration and are telling all kids not to struggle and submit. It’s shocking!

Iwasafool · 10/01/2024 11:19

Verbena17 · 10/01/2024 11:17

Probably not because of the kids but more the school mangers.

The teachers I know who have left say it is the parents.

coffeeaddict77 · 10/01/2024 11:19

GnomeDePlume · 10/01/2024 11:07

The teachers aren't given a choice. The focus on strict adherence to detailed rules are set possibly at the Academy Trust level or by SLT. Teaching staff are compelled to enforce these rules by SLT.

This creates an antagonistic atmosphere for teaching staff and students. I doubt either want or benefit from it. It gets in the way of teaching and learning.

Unfortunately highly prescriptive uniform, deferential silence etc etc all look good in brochures or when inspectors or prospective parents are in.

It also makes it easy to hide away anyone who doesn't suit the preferred optics.

This generation of students will include the parents and teachers of the future.

You reap what you sow.

Yes, I am reminded a bit of Pink Floyd's "another brick in the wall". As a child in the 70s and early 80s, I remember finding it quite weird as teachers seemed generally quite nice by then but it looks like things are going backwards. Ultimately those children will be the unsupportive parents of the future as they will assume teachers are being unreasonable and always take the children's side.

Verbena17 · 10/01/2024 11:17

peppermintcrisp · 10/01/2024 11:16

All the great teachers leave unfortunately.

Probably not because of the kids but more the school mangers.

peppermintcrisp · 10/01/2024 11:16

All the great teachers leave unfortunately.

Verbena17 · 10/01/2024 11:16

GnomeDePlume · 10/01/2024 11:07

The teachers aren't given a choice. The focus on strict adherence to detailed rules are set possibly at the Academy Trust level or by SLT. Teaching staff are compelled to enforce these rules by SLT.

This creates an antagonistic atmosphere for teaching staff and students. I doubt either want or benefit from it. It gets in the way of teaching and learning.

Unfortunately highly prescriptive uniform, deferential silence etc etc all look good in brochures or when inspectors or prospective parents are in.

It also makes it easy to hide away anyone who doesn't suit the preferred optics.

This generation of students will include the parents and teachers of the future.

You reap what you sow.

It should be the teachers who advocate for the children. They should go to the SLT and higher and say they refuse to install cruel rules that have negative health implications. School bleat on about ‘healthy’ eating but then let the poor kids swelter or freeze because of bat shit crazy uniform rules!

Teachers are supposed to be their protectors (in loco parentis)…not prison wardens. Currently there isn’t much in loco parentis being seen other than literally being responsible for them during the long school day.

Araminta1003 · 10/01/2024 11:11

Army boot camp seems to be the model. Kids in flight and fright all day. Emerging with PTSD rather than resilience.

Verbena17 · 10/01/2024 11:09

madamepopov · 10/01/2024 11:03

I can't work out if you genuinely mean this or if you're being sarcastic?
I don't want my children to be blindly obedient to authority, I see no upside in that

Exactly! Teaching children to say yes no matter what is a safeguarding fail!
If they don’t feel they can question authority at times when they’re in danger/at risk, they will letting themself become a potential victim of abuse.

Being emotionally well equipped to say no is important for life but also for the things others have mentioned with regards to being able to remove blazers when they’re about to pass out in the heat.
They’re school children, not infantry guards who have chosen to be there.

GnomeDePlume · 10/01/2024 11:07

colouringindoors · 10/01/2024 10:16

I have enormous sympathy for teaching staff. But I do believe some of these ''rules" can be counter productive. In the last heatwave students at my dcs school were not permitted to remove blazers between lessons, despite many obviously struggling with the heat.

The teachers aren't given a choice. The focus on strict adherence to detailed rules are set possibly at the Academy Trust level or by SLT. Teaching staff are compelled to enforce these rules by SLT.

This creates an antagonistic atmosphere for teaching staff and students. I doubt either want or benefit from it. It gets in the way of teaching and learning.

Unfortunately highly prescriptive uniform, deferential silence etc etc all look good in brochures or when inspectors or prospective parents are in.

It also makes it easy to hide away anyone who doesn't suit the preferred optics.

This generation of students will include the parents and teachers of the future.

You reap what you sow.

madamepopov · 10/01/2024 11:03

Benibidibici · 07/01/2024 12:55

School rules just need to be justified.

No, they dont. Part of why they are there is to teach kids to simply be obedient.

I can't work out if you genuinely mean this or if you're being sarcastic?
I don't want my children to be blindly obedient to authority, I see no upside in that