Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder what has happened to my Son's school

989 replies

k2493 · 07/01/2024 11:09

Just posting for thoughts

Both my kids have gone through the same secondary school. When my daughter started, the school was lovely and new with around 750 kids.

Fast forward to 2024 and there is now 1500 kids and it's become like a dictatorship.

Due to the number of kids, the school has put lines either side of the hallway that they have to walk within otherwise they get detention.

Every hallway is a one way system.

The minute they arrive in school, they have to remove their coats or it's detention even with no heating in the middle of winter. The other day my son arrived back to school to find that there were long queues outside while they did two uniform checks at the door. By the time he got in, he was frozen. Immediately he got shouted at for still having his coat on even though he had just stepped in from the cold.

He then went around the corner and got shouted at again even though he tried to explain it's really difficult to be expected to stay warm, keep moving and remove your coat all at the same time. Nope. Threaten with detention again.

AIBU to wonder what has happened to our education system? I'm lucky in that my son is quite strong minded and just brushes it off but what about the kids who's mental health this is impacting? Surely we want our kids to remember school as being enjoyable for their education and friendships rather than for being shouted at every two minutes for not walking between lines or not taking their coats off the minute they arrive in school?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
11
Iwasafool · 10/01/2024 17:55

twistyizzy · 10/01/2024 17:40

I'm sure the friendship groups they got into in the first few weeks had a lot to do with it and no-one knows whether the school had anything to do with it, whether you believe that or not is irrelevant.

Well at their age I think raging hormones have probably got something to do with it.

twistyizzy · 10/01/2024 17:40

UndertheCedartree · 10/01/2024 17:07

I don't believe those DC just changed and their school had nothing to do with it. I've seen some of Dd's friends change and it is because of the schools they are at. The ones at Dd's school haven't changed atall.

I'm sure the friendship groups they got into in the first few weeks had a lot to do with it and no-one knows whether the school had anything to do with it, whether you believe that or not is irrelevant.

UndertheCedartree · 10/01/2024 17:33

dontbenastyhaveapasty · 10/01/2024 09:50

@Araminta1003 However, as a Londoner we are also sick and tired of having to pay for the rest of the “kind” country. Pushing ourselves and our kids in an over competitive way because parts of the rest of the country are financially unproductive. It is a toxic model for all.

Well, just stop then. Stop being so stressy and paranoid about grades, stop caring about how rich people are and valuing them solely on that basis. Start behaving like your local area is a community, chat to people in the street, take interest in the lives and well-being of children who are not yours. Volunteer to help in a youth club, take part in making meals for elderly people. You know, like us inhabitants of “kind but unproductive” parts of the country do. Community doesn’t happen by magic, it’s the result of people getting stuck in and getting their hands dirty.

I worked for a while in the London-influenced south-east. I moved home to the westcountry as soon as I had kids because the culture of “achievement” - ie chasing wealth at the expense of everything else - is awful and destructive. There is a lot more to life than how rich you are / how much your house is worth.

Also, please don’t get me started about blaming “the regions” for the structural economic inequality they suffer…..

But this is a massive thread derail. Apologies!

We're not all like that in the South East. Plenty of community in my city if you want to be part of it.

UndertheCedartree · 10/01/2024 17:30

ST10 · 10/01/2024 09:45

Unfortunately, I think it’s more a reflection of the state of our children and their behaviour rather than the school. These sorts of draconian measures seem to be commonplace in our state secondary schools and I think it’s desperate measures to try to keep behaviour under control. It’s very sad for the children who are well behaved as they also have to be treated this way. I know it seems bonkers but I’m a primary school teacher and experience the decline in behaviour every day, even amongst 5 year olds.

Well, it's not working is it? Unfortunately, it's making behaviour worse so I think we need desperate measures to put a halt to this fashion and get back to dealing with behaviour in a sensible manner.

Iwasafool · 10/01/2024 17:26

twistyizzy · 10/01/2024 16:32

No not all parents

And not all schools. I have one GS at a school local to me and it is very nurturing. My GS has dyslexia and struggled at primary but his secondary has been fantastic for him. He did well in GCSEs and is working hard at his A levels. His interests are well catered for.

Verbena17 · 10/01/2024 17:25

Lorralorr · 10/01/2024 17:15

So my husband works in a super strict school like this. They do it for an absolutely zero tolerance approach to bad behaviour. Then kids are better behaved in classrooms too and this really benefits the kids with poor mental health/ ND who can’t deal with stuff being chucked around, shouting, teasing while they are trying to learn. He says it’s fantastic for behaviour and fantastic for staff - which leads to better retention, also good for kids. But not all kids respond well. Some love the rules some hate them!

There are some famous examples of zero tolerance schools in London which have really revolutionised prospects for kids in some of the most deprived areas - now others are starting to take note and institute similar ideas.

Wouldn’t necessarily work for children who present with PDA - Pathological Demand Avoidance or demand avoidance type ASD.

There’s something having zero tolerance in the classroom, but all of the other regime type rules like no talking in corridors (as opposed to quiet voices in corridors) or not being able to use the loo as and when, take it too far.

Iwasafool · 10/01/2024 17:23

mathanxiety · 10/01/2024 14:49

Where I am, children are expected to be able to write their first and last names fairly legibly and decode a few cvc words at age 5. They are expected to learn to count and associate numbers with quantities of objects. They are beginning to write their letters and numbers pointing the right way. They work on fine motor development - holding their pencils and art equipment properly, getting into and out of their outerwear and footwear, tying laces, and social-emotional skills - classroom tidyness, sharing classroom resources, paying attention during carpet time, practising their public speaking and listening skills, contributing to class discussions, dispute resolution, working in groups, and keeping track of their own personal belongings.

All children are a bit rough around the edges at age five. This is why schools in the US tend to focus on social and emotional foundations and physical readiness for learning and adapting to the communal environment in the early years, and only lean seriously into phonics and arithmetic when children are six and up.

So where do you think they are going wrong with the social emotional development? Students and ex students going into school and killing students/teachers and then frequently committing suicide hardly suggests what they are doing is working.

UndertheCedartree · 10/01/2024 17:22

Araminta1003 · 10/01/2024 09:31

One of the things they need to do is bring in the architects as well and come up with buildings that are child friendly and happy places. Just like they used to do with council housing and light etc.

The burden cannot all be on schools. It is the NHS failing children that is even more to blame. Most of these children would also be happier if we had more youth clubs and safe spaces like that and mentors. It cannot just all be put on teachers/leaders in education.

I think this is another issue that schools are expected to do so many things that would have never been their remit in the past.

Iwasafool · 10/01/2024 17:20

mathanxiety · 10/01/2024 14:03

@Iwasafool
Yes, it is.

But I'd take that risk over the shitshow that's being described here and called 'education'.

Really? I can't imagine anything worse than wondering if my child is going to be shot at school. On the news here yesterday about a ten year old shooting a ten year old and they said in the last 12 months 280 under tens shot dead in the US. Now that's horrific, having to wear a blazer when it's hot or follow a one way system hardly compares.

Of course the reality is not all UK schools are like that and not all US schools have shootings. I know which I'd prefer though, I definitely prefer my children alive.

UndertheCedartree · 10/01/2024 17:19

twistyizzy · 10/01/2024 09:06

Teachers don't have time though. They don't have 1 x class of 30 kids like in primary, they have lots of classes of 30 so that's impossible.
The National Curriculum doesn't allow for arts and creativity and Ofsted doesn't judge on this.
How can 1500 kids eat together in a canteen built for 500 kids?
You have completely unrealistic expectations of what a school can reasonably do.
Add to that 3 x secondary schools in the near area are closed to RAAC and kids are being taught across different random portakabins across other different schools in the county so there isn't even a physical school 🙄.

I don't exactly know what subjects they teach at other secondary schools but my Dd's school specialises in the Arts. She does art and design, graphics, textiles, drama, dance and music - all chances for her to be creative which she really enjoys. She's definitely spending more time doing creative subjects than in Y6 as due to the SATs they focused mainly on English and Maths. There are also creative clubs she can go to at lunchtime as they have an hour so enough time for eating and clubs. Her school also does 'fun days' like they do in Primary which seems very unusual. But it's nice because it seems to inject some fun into the terms and the students seem to really enjoy them.

Lorralorr · 10/01/2024 17:15

So my husband works in a super strict school like this. They do it for an absolutely zero tolerance approach to bad behaviour. Then kids are better behaved in classrooms too and this really benefits the kids with poor mental health/ ND who can’t deal with stuff being chucked around, shouting, teasing while they are trying to learn. He says it’s fantastic for behaviour and fantastic for staff - which leads to better retention, also good for kids. But not all kids respond well. Some love the rules some hate them!

There are some famous examples of zero tolerance schools in London which have really revolutionised prospects for kids in some of the most deprived areas - now others are starting to take note and institute similar ideas.

UndertheCedartree · 10/01/2024 17:07

twistyizzy · 10/01/2024 08:53

Of course we should deal with knife crime but that isn't up to the school to do, all they can do is mitigate it and the safety of the other kids and staff.
There are issues at primary but generally schools are smaller, teachers and parents have face to face relationship and there is less issues with mobile phones etc.
There was a massive change in personality in some of the kids DD went to primary with once they started secondary school ie the change in language and attitude was almost immediate. She doesnt go to school with the but sews them at the bus stop every morning and was on the Yr 6 Leavers group chat. She left the group after 4 weeks of Yr 7 because the language and bullying was horrendous. These kids 2 months earlier had been friends at primary. So there CAN be a change from primary to secondary.

I don't believe those DC just changed and their school had nothing to do with it. I've seen some of Dd's friends change and it is because of the schools they are at. The ones at Dd's school haven't changed atall.

twistyizzy · 10/01/2024 16:32

UndertheCedartree · 10/01/2024 16:30

Not all parents 😉

No not all parents

UndertheCedartree · 10/01/2024 16:30

twistyizzy · 10/01/2024 08:13

That is the most rational post of the thread!
It isn't just 1 thing, it is a combination of many things.
You are right in saying the focus has moved away from education. Education shoukd be about broadening the mind, being inquisitive and learning for the sake of learning. What we currently have in state education are exam factories. Parents buy into this though ie looking for the school that has the highest 7-9% rather than the school that offers the broadest curriculum and a supportive learning environment.

Not all parents 😉

UndertheCedartree · 10/01/2024 16:23

Kikisweb · 10/01/2024 06:56

My DS starts in September. He has high anxiety levels which are going to be made so much worse by modern secondary schools. He has a lot of problems with executive dysfunction so homework and having equipment is going to be a nightmare for him, and the punishments are going to trigger school refusal. I think most secondary schools take petty things to extremes and are creating the current extremely high rates of teen anxiety, self harm and suicide. The current system fails more children than it helps.

I'm sorry to hear that. My youngest ASD daughter has just gone into Y7 so we've been doing the transition and it is a steep learning curve. My advice would be to find out if they have a learning support centre or something like this as the LSAs come and get my DD every morning and I can pass on any worries she has and they support her with them. She can also go to the centre to do colouring and drawing before form time, at lunch and after school. They help them with homework too. She also finds the library a quiet place to go to at break and lunch to read and the librarian has been really kind to her and often helps her find where her next lesson is as getting lost is one of her fears. Every afternoon when we get home I check her planner for homework so I can help her stay on top of it. Then in the evening I help her lay out her uniform and get her bag ready for the next day.

UndertheCedartree · 10/01/2024 15:07

RosesAndHellebores · 10/01/2024 07:10

When I were a lass I got into the grammar school. Three form entry, 90 girls a year. Other local schools were 4 form entry. A couple of schools were rougher than others with poorer results, offering only cses. Compared to posts on here they were probably akin to finishing school. The rot set in, in about 1970, and it was the one size fits all comprehensive system that started it together with the Liberal left "anything goes" mentality.

What's being described here isn't about supporting education, it's about crowd control and uncivilised cohorts who from cradle to grave have lost contact with societal norms. This has resulted in an unkind and punitive environment for all which cannot possibly support learning.

It is not helped by the focus shifting from education to qualifications. An education should always be about more than paper quals, the value of which is becoming increasingly diluted.

I really agree with you about education vs. qualifications. This is another way that some DC are failed being made to take exams they have no hope of passing.

mathanxiety · 10/01/2024 15:00

UndertheCedartree · 10/01/2024 14:37

That's obviously a huge student population but would you say the schools are overcrowded? I assume not if there is room for everyone to have a locker?

It's a huge building, but it has had far more students in the past - during the baby boom years the same building held over 6,000 students, and class sizes for core subjects were huge. Students shared lockers back then.

The current student : teacher ratio is 15:1.

The lockers are situated along all the corridors, on all four floors. The PE lockers are in the PE section. There are miles of hallways. Back when the parent teacher meetings were in person, parents picked up printouts of maps when they entered the building, and there were helpful hall monitors giving directions.

Public schools are obliged to admit everyone living within the catchment (District) who registers, and to provide an appropriate education for all registered students.

Natsku · 10/01/2024 14:57

UndertheCedartree · 10/01/2024 14:34

It seems this overcrowding is the root of many problems.

Seems so. And that's a difficult (i.e. too expensive) problem to solve, so it won't get solved so instead more and more punitive rules and behaviour gets worse and worse. Depressing to think about.
I've got the opposite problem where I live, year groups are getting smaller and smaller so they're going to merge two schools from two towns. They're trying to figure out the best way to do it now, as neither of the schools is big enough (though I suspect it won't be on same level of overcrowding) but building a new school would cancel out the savings from merging the schools.

BettyBakesCakes · 10/01/2024 14:53

MancLass76 · 10/01/2024 11:22

I have a yr6 starting high school in September and some of the policies and practices are ridiculous. We’ve had the coat removing rule in our local high school for a while but the one way system was introduced this year and now my friend’s child has had weekly comments about being late to one particular class because the route is too long. This year they brought in someone to focus on behaviour and have started physically restraining YP at the first sign of any kind of frustration and are telling all kids not to struggle and submit. It’s shocking!

Schools can't just start restraining kids! I mean the law isn't great in that area but they can only use reasonable force where necessary and if there is a danger to the student, others or property.

mathanxiety · 10/01/2024 14:49

ST10 · 10/01/2024 09:45

Unfortunately, I think it’s more a reflection of the state of our children and their behaviour rather than the school. These sorts of draconian measures seem to be commonplace in our state secondary schools and I think it’s desperate measures to try to keep behaviour under control. It’s very sad for the children who are well behaved as they also have to be treated this way. I know it seems bonkers but I’m a primary school teacher and experience the decline in behaviour every day, even amongst 5 year olds.

Where I am, children are expected to be able to write their first and last names fairly legibly and decode a few cvc words at age 5. They are expected to learn to count and associate numbers with quantities of objects. They are beginning to write their letters and numbers pointing the right way. They work on fine motor development - holding their pencils and art equipment properly, getting into and out of their outerwear and footwear, tying laces, and social-emotional skills - classroom tidyness, sharing classroom resources, paying attention during carpet time, practising their public speaking and listening skills, contributing to class discussions, dispute resolution, working in groups, and keeping track of their own personal belongings.

All children are a bit rough around the edges at age five. This is why schools in the US tend to focus on social and emotional foundations and physical readiness for learning and adapting to the communal environment in the early years, and only lean seriously into phonics and arithmetic when children are six and up.

UndertheCedartree · 10/01/2024 14:43

Stressedmumoftwoteens · 10/01/2024 06:46

Try sending your child to a school where there is no uniform code, no rules and no discipline because that is what my child's school has become! Regularly my child has come home from school with ripped uniform or bruises where from where they have been pushed down the stairs because there is a mass bundle of kids rushing down the corridors. No one cares what time you turn up as long as it is vaguely right. Thank goodness my child is in year 11 and leaves soon.

That sounds very difficult for your DC.

UndertheCedartree · 10/01/2024 14:42

Poppytops88 · 10/01/2024 06:44

I watched 'The UKs Strictest School' on ITV yesterday. Its called Michaela Community School' in West London. Its a very deprived area and they get amazing results.
They think if you're really strict with the tiny things and zero tolerant then the big things won't happen. Some of it all very strange though and I can't see how the school could work for SEN children, I don't think they'd be accepting, I assume the parents of SEN children wouldn't consider the school.
Has anyone watched it or have any experiences of the school?

Those methods don't work for SEN children atall and due to most parents having no choice over school - they just have to go to their catchment school I would imagine there are lots of SEN kids not coping. You end up with lots of parents having to home educate.

NojudgementGem · 10/01/2024 14:39

My daughter recently started at a school which sounds very similar. This week she announced that she doesn’t think most of the teachers actually even like kids but rather that they became teachers because they get a power trip from shouting and putting them in detention. It makes me really sad, I want her to like her teachers, be inspired and motivated by them and instead she comes home telling me she hates school. She loved primary school and teachers always commented on her good behaviour. She now gets threatened with detention for dropping her pen or needing the toilet. What do you do?? I can’t help but agree with her that they are being OTT

UndertheCedartree · 10/01/2024 14:37

mathanxiety · 10/01/2024 03:30

That's nonsense.

I'm speaking from the perspective of a parent whose DCs went to a public high school in the US, a school with a very mixed student intake - a student body of 3,500+ from all sorts of ethnic backgrounds, income levels, cultural backgrounds, parents with wildly varying levels of aspiration and ambition and different experiences of school and school systems.

There were kids heading for Harvard and kids who wanted to be mechanics or hairdressers and all points in between. Many of the students were TESL students, from homes where Spanish or Polish or (lately) Ukrainian were the first languages. There were students whose ancestors came from the rural South whose experiences of segregation had an effect on how they viewed schools.

There were no uniforms, just a dress code.

There were lockers for every student, assigned on the first day of freshman year and kept for all four years, and PE lockers where students could keep their school issued PE shorts and Tshirts and leave their day clothes and bags while doing PE.

There was a five minute passing period between classes. Students could talk and use whatever side of the hallways they wished to use, getting around a building that is a city block long (1/8 of a mile) and four floors high.

Students could get a hall pass to use the bathroom during class. Hall passes were tracked.

Students were placed in academic tracks based on placement exams and performance in classes. They did not advance year by year with kids their age.

The library was specifically remodeled as a place where students could hang out, supervised.

Minor infractions of rules did not result in detentions or exclusions. A buildup of minor infractions resulted in a referral to a dean of discipline and a discussion of issues behind the behaviour, and problem solving. The school did not expel students and did not use detention as a constant response to chronic problems.

The school employed security guards to keep order in the hallways, cafeterias, and surrounds and to double as crossing guards/ direct traffic.

SEN were diagnosed and IEPs developed by SEN staff employed by the school. The school had a Special Ed section, plus a nursery for the babies and small children of staff and students, and farmed out kids who couldn't function in the mainstream school environment because of emotional or MH needs to specific alternative educational providers, with each student fully funded by the school, including school bus transport.

The school served breakfast and lunch in the cafeterias, with FSM students able to get a hearty meal at no cost twice a day, and reduced cost food available to hundreds more. During the covid shutdown the school distributed iPads and chrome books to all students and had free meals available for pickup to all registered for free school meals plus any other students whose families needed a weekly package of dry/ tinned pantry items - noodles, pasta, jars of sauce, dried fruit, instant porridge, etc.

Yes, all of that (and there was much, much more) costs money. If you think operating what amounts to a stressful boot camp masquerading as a school will accomplish what money and evidence-based approaches to discipline do, you need to examine what it is in your assumptions about your fellow Britons that makes you think that way.

That's obviously a huge student population but would you say the schools are overcrowded? I assume not if there is room for everyone to have a locker?

UndertheCedartree · 10/01/2024 14:34

Natsku · 10/01/2024 05:24

Wasn't against fire regulations when I was in school. Are classes just more crowded now perhaps?

It seems this overcrowding is the root of many problems.