Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder what has happened to my Son's school

989 replies

k2493 · 07/01/2024 11:09

Just posting for thoughts

Both my kids have gone through the same secondary school. When my daughter started, the school was lovely and new with around 750 kids.

Fast forward to 2024 and there is now 1500 kids and it's become like a dictatorship.

Due to the number of kids, the school has put lines either side of the hallway that they have to walk within otherwise they get detention.

Every hallway is a one way system.

The minute they arrive in school, they have to remove their coats or it's detention even with no heating in the middle of winter. The other day my son arrived back to school to find that there were long queues outside while they did two uniform checks at the door. By the time he got in, he was frozen. Immediately he got shouted at for still having his coat on even though he had just stepped in from the cold.

He then went around the corner and got shouted at again even though he tried to explain it's really difficult to be expected to stay warm, keep moving and remove your coat all at the same time. Nope. Threaten with detention again.

AIBU to wonder what has happened to our education system? I'm lucky in that my son is quite strong minded and just brushes it off but what about the kids who's mental health this is impacting? Surely we want our kids to remember school as being enjoyable for their education and friendships rather than for being shouted at every two minutes for not walking between lines or not taking their coats off the minute they arrive in school?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
11
UndertheCedartree · 10/01/2024 21:13

Extendedoctopustentacles · 10/01/2024 19:25

My DD is in Yr 11 in a relatively strict school - shirts tucked in, no coats in lessons, no phones out during the school day. She has not had one detention in her entire time at school. Most kids don't. It's not that hard to follow some basic ground rules and yet you'd think by some of the comments on here that there was some huge human rights infringement. We all have to adhere to rules at some points in our lives and it's no bad thing.

We're not talking about relatively strict schools. My DD's school is strict - she follows all the rules. Because like your school, I imagine they are sensible and have proportionate punishments. People are talking about the ultra harsh schools who have rules that aren't sensible and with punishments that aren't proportionate.

UndertheCedartree · 10/01/2024 21:09

Mumof3girks · 10/01/2024 18:56

My youngest was out of school for ages with mental health. Took ages to get her able to go back to school. Had her uniform check by the wellbeing teacher and it was fine. She went in and the head at the gate told her her uniform was wrong and she would have to change into lost property. Also tried to take her phone off her while she was still in the street outside. Was the last straw and I deregistered her again. Home education all the way.

Oh, that's awful. That's the kind of thing that would have crushed DD. At her school they have a simple uniform of shirt, trousers/skirt and jumper. And guess what? They all comply with uniform as it's not made difficult! I hope she is enjoying her home education.

UndertheCedartree · 10/01/2024 21:03

I mean these schools are taking over, yet all you hear is teachers saying how behaviour is getting worse.

UndertheCedartree · 10/01/2024 21:01

Extendedoctopustentacles · 10/01/2024 19:04

What's your metric to state that this makes behaviour worse?

Well, the fact so many teachers have come on to say how terrible the behaviour is at their school despite using these measures and then my experience as a teacher and a parent of these schools.

UndertheCedartree · 10/01/2024 20:59

Iwasafool · 10/01/2024 18:02

I must have missed it but I think it is a big part of it. I used to volunteer at a local primary and you could see the changes starting in year 6, I'm sure it was worse in year7.

What I'm refering to is specifically bad behaviour at school. A group of girls all really well behaved in Y6. 3 go to a nurturing school, 3 go to the non-nurturing school. The 3 at the nurturing school settle in well and continue to be well behaved. The other 3 don't settle, are unhappy at school and crying at home. They get more and more disillusioned as the weeks go by and after a while bad behaviour starts creeping in. I'm not even talking massive things. But for example taking selfies at school when phones should be switched off in their bags.

UndertheCedartree · 10/01/2024 20:53

twistyizzy · 10/01/2024 17:40

I'm sure the friendship groups they got into in the first few weeks had a lot to do with it and no-one knows whether the school had anything to do with it, whether you believe that or not is irrelevant.

Well, it's relevant to the discussion we're having, isn't it?

VegetablesFightingToReclaimTheAubergieneEmoji · 10/01/2024 20:25

Lorralorr · 10/01/2024 17:15

So my husband works in a super strict school like this. They do it for an absolutely zero tolerance approach to bad behaviour. Then kids are better behaved in classrooms too and this really benefits the kids with poor mental health/ ND who can’t deal with stuff being chucked around, shouting, teasing while they are trying to learn. He says it’s fantastic for behaviour and fantastic for staff - which leads to better retention, also good for kids. But not all kids respond well. Some love the rules some hate them!

There are some famous examples of zero tolerance schools in London which have really revolutionised prospects for kids in some of the most deprived areas - now others are starting to take note and institute similar ideas.

My dd doesn’t get on well with it.
it completely crushed her to the point of depression and anxiety. She’s a really good kid who obsessively follows rules, she finds the zero tolerance panic inducing and won’t explain things for fear of being seen as being rude.
one size doesn’t fit all, whilst zero tolerance works for a some, some don’t care and some are utterly destroyed.

the school won’t recognise that it doesn’t work for the quiet, thoughtful ones. They just sit quietly worried about getting it wrong.

UndertheCedartree · 10/01/2024 20:16

Iwasafool · 10/01/2024 17:26

And not all schools. I have one GS at a school local to me and it is very nurturing. My GS has dyslexia and struggled at primary but his secondary has been fantastic for him. He did well in GCSEs and is working hard at his A levels. His interests are well catered for.

I've been singing the praises of my DD's nurturing secondary too. I had to fight hard to get her a place, though.

UndertheCedartree · 10/01/2024 20:12

Iwasafool · 10/01/2024 17:20

Really? I can't imagine anything worse than wondering if my child is going to be shot at school. On the news here yesterday about a ten year old shooting a ten year old and they said in the last 12 months 280 under tens shot dead in the US. Now that's horrific, having to wear a blazer when it's hot or follow a one way system hardly compares.

Of course the reality is not all UK schools are like that and not all US schools have shootings. I know which I'd prefer though, I definitely prefer my children alive.

I have to say I agree. I'd never want to send my DC to school somewhere you have to buy them a bag that doubles as a bullet proof vest 😥 Happy to have my 11yo in a lovely secondary school and my 16yo at a good college and I know they're safe! But, I digress.

UndertheCedartree · 10/01/2024 20:03

Lorralorr · 10/01/2024 17:15

So my husband works in a super strict school like this. They do it for an absolutely zero tolerance approach to bad behaviour. Then kids are better behaved in classrooms too and this really benefits the kids with poor mental health/ ND who can’t deal with stuff being chucked around, shouting, teasing while they are trying to learn. He says it’s fantastic for behaviour and fantastic for staff - which leads to better retention, also good for kids. But not all kids respond well. Some love the rules some hate them!

There are some famous examples of zero tolerance schools in London which have really revolutionised prospects for kids in some of the most deprived areas - now others are starting to take note and institute similar ideas.

It absolutely is not good for neurodiverse DC. My DD's school has no disruption in her classes and it really is good for ND kids because they don't put them under the stress of these extreme regimes.

UndertheCedartree · 10/01/2024 19:47

mathanxiety · 10/01/2024 15:00

It's a huge building, but it has had far more students in the past - during the baby boom years the same building held over 6,000 students, and class sizes for core subjects were huge. Students shared lockers back then.

The current student : teacher ratio is 15:1.

The lockers are situated along all the corridors, on all four floors. The PE lockers are in the PE section. There are miles of hallways. Back when the parent teacher meetings were in person, parents picked up printouts of maps when they entered the building, and there were helpful hall monitors giving directions.

Public schools are obliged to admit everyone living within the catchment (District) who registers, and to provide an appropriate education for all registered students.

Wow - 6000! Back in the day when I was at school we had cloakrooms and everyone had a peg and desks with open top lids in Y7-9 then lockers in Y10&11 and sixth form. We also had P.E lockers too. I looked round my old school when we were looking for a secondary school for DD and they don't have cloakrooms, desks or lockers anymore.

UndertheCedartree · 10/01/2024 19:38

mathanxiety · 10/01/2024 14:49

Where I am, children are expected to be able to write their first and last names fairly legibly and decode a few cvc words at age 5. They are expected to learn to count and associate numbers with quantities of objects. They are beginning to write their letters and numbers pointing the right way. They work on fine motor development - holding their pencils and art equipment properly, getting into and out of their outerwear and footwear, tying laces, and social-emotional skills - classroom tidyness, sharing classroom resources, paying attention during carpet time, practising their public speaking and listening skills, contributing to class discussions, dispute resolution, working in groups, and keeping track of their own personal belongings.

All children are a bit rough around the edges at age five. This is why schools in the US tend to focus on social and emotional foundations and physical readiness for learning and adapting to the communal environment in the early years, and only lean seriously into phonics and arithmetic when children are six and up.

To be fair the methods we are discussing have come from the US and I've seen videos of them being used in Primary schools there. So while your local schools sound great it's obviously not like that everywhere. Equally these schools haven't taken over everywhere in the UK either. There are still some really great schools.

UndertheCedartree · 10/01/2024 19:29

User79853257976 · 10/01/2024 12:27

I’m a secondary teacher, we don’t come down hard on Y7s at all. (This was in reply to someone but for some reason it’s appeared at the end of the thread).

Edited

I'm sure you don't speak for all schools. Some do come down hard on Y7s.

Extendedoctopustentacles · 10/01/2024 19:25

My DD is in Yr 11 in a relatively strict school - shirts tucked in, no coats in lessons, no phones out during the school day. She has not had one detention in her entire time at school. Most kids don't. It's not that hard to follow some basic ground rules and yet you'd think by some of the comments on here that there was some huge human rights infringement. We all have to adhere to rules at some points in our lives and it's no bad thing.

UndertheCedartree · 10/01/2024 19:25

twistyizzy · 10/01/2024 11:41

@coffeeaddict77 because schools aren't workplaces. Most workplace aren't overcrowded with inadequate resources.
In most workplaces you don't risk being bullied or attacked in a toilet.
Schools have to keep the majority of students safe, that often means harsher rules to prevent the minority putting other students at risk of harm.
You can't compare workplaces with schools.
Workplaces don't consist of 1500 adolescents.

But we shouldn't just say oh it's fine because it's overcrowded. I mean what has overcrowding got to do with not being able to take your jumper off if you're hot? And going to the toilet is a human right and you can get ill by holding it in. Dd's school has expanded massively on a small site. They manage to let them go to the toilet. At her friend's smaller school they can't take blazers off or go to the toilet. Some good schools are able to make it work and the bad ones who can't cope should perhaps find out why.

UndertheCedartree · 10/01/2024 19:14

peppermintcrisp · 10/01/2024 11:27

Probably not because of the kids but more the school managers

Yes sorry I didn't make this clear. A lot of teachers went to the last local LEA funded school.

One lovely peripatetic music teacher was openly vocal about how she hated the 'military camp' and what is was doing to the children. They as she predicted went on to cut all the music lessons and the wonderful orchestra. It is awful they only have ukelele lessons now.

That's so sad.

UndertheCedartree · 10/01/2024 19:06

Iwasafool · 10/01/2024 11:19

The teachers I know who have left say it is the parents.

Unfortunately, parents get fed up of how their DC are being treated and there's no goodwill in the end.

Extendedoctopustentacles · 10/01/2024 19:04

UndertheCedartree · 10/01/2024 17:30

Well, it's not working is it? Unfortunately, it's making behaviour worse so I think we need desperate measures to put a halt to this fashion and get back to dealing with behaviour in a sensible manner.

What's your metric to state that this makes behaviour worse?

UndertheCedartree · 10/01/2024 19:01

GnomeDePlume · 10/01/2024 11:07

The teachers aren't given a choice. The focus on strict adherence to detailed rules are set possibly at the Academy Trust level or by SLT. Teaching staff are compelled to enforce these rules by SLT.

This creates an antagonistic atmosphere for teaching staff and students. I doubt either want or benefit from it. It gets in the way of teaching and learning.

Unfortunately highly prescriptive uniform, deferential silence etc etc all look good in brochures or when inspectors or prospective parents are in.

It also makes it easy to hide away anyone who doesn't suit the preferred optics.

This generation of students will include the parents and teachers of the future.

You reap what you sow.

Indeed

UndertheCedartree · 10/01/2024 18:58

colouringindoors · 10/01/2024 10:16

I have enormous sympathy for teaching staff. But I do believe some of these ''rules" can be counter productive. In the last heatwave students at my dcs school were not permitted to remove blazers between lessons, despite many obviously struggling with the heat.

I have to say that is one of the rules that I find the cruelest and hardest to understand particularly as it affects those with sensory additional needs to a greater degree. It just seems so counter productive to make DC uncomfortable and then expect them to learn?

Mumof3girks · 10/01/2024 18:56

My youngest was out of school for ages with mental health. Took ages to get her able to go back to school. Had her uniform check by the wellbeing teacher and it was fine. She went in and the head at the gate told her her uniform was wrong and she would have to change into lost property. Also tried to take her phone off her while she was still in the street outside. Was the last straw and I deregistered her again. Home education all the way.

UndertheCedartree · 10/01/2024 18:45

MammaEvz3 · 10/01/2024 10:04

My eldest is only 6 but thread's like this make me so concerned about when my children have to start secondary school. It sounds horrible these days! :(

There are still some lovely schools about! And hopefully maybe this fashion will have died a death by the time yours is at secondary.

GnomeDePlume · 10/01/2024 18:34

It will not help behaviour if flash point situations are created by having very prescriptive rules on trivia:

  • shirts tucked in, ties straight, the right colour socks & shoes
  • intolerance of normal human forgetfulness of bits of kit

If everything is punished by detentions and periods in isolation you are going to alienate students and their parents.

Remember that, for parents, detentions etc were for serious rule breaking. For the majority of parents having a child put in detention is initially very worrying. To then find out it was for something silly, the parent is not necessarily going to be supportive of the school.

Iwasafool · 10/01/2024 18:02

twistyizzy · 10/01/2024 17:59

@Iwasafool obviously and I've already said that in previous comments

I must have missed it but I think it is a big part of it. I used to volunteer at a local primary and you could see the changes starting in year 6, I'm sure it was worse in year7.

twistyizzy · 10/01/2024 17:59

@Iwasafool obviously and I've already said that in previous comments