Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder what has happened to my Son's school

989 replies

k2493 · 07/01/2024 11:09

Just posting for thoughts

Both my kids have gone through the same secondary school. When my daughter started, the school was lovely and new with around 750 kids.

Fast forward to 2024 and there is now 1500 kids and it's become like a dictatorship.

Due to the number of kids, the school has put lines either side of the hallway that they have to walk within otherwise they get detention.

Every hallway is a one way system.

The minute they arrive in school, they have to remove their coats or it's detention even with no heating in the middle of winter. The other day my son arrived back to school to find that there were long queues outside while they did two uniform checks at the door. By the time he got in, he was frozen. Immediately he got shouted at for still having his coat on even though he had just stepped in from the cold.

He then went around the corner and got shouted at again even though he tried to explain it's really difficult to be expected to stay warm, keep moving and remove your coat all at the same time. Nope. Threaten with detention again.

AIBU to wonder what has happened to our education system? I'm lucky in that my son is quite strong minded and just brushes it off but what about the kids who's mental health this is impacting? Surely we want our kids to remember school as being enjoyable for their education and friendships rather than for being shouted at every two minutes for not walking between lines or not taking their coats off the minute they arrive in school?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
11
Redpeonies · 11/01/2024 18:17

I know my nephew transferred to a state school that had fantastic A level results for 6th form only to find they were weeding out kids in the first year that weren't performing at the top level.

wildlifeWalker · 11/01/2024 18:14

@Redpeonies
I went to a comprehensive school with classes of about 30 pupils, 8 forms with very mixed backgrounds and abilities.

Although it was strict, we didn't get put in isolation for forgetting a ruler or not wearing the correct jumper.

We were allowed to take blazers off when it was too hot. We also had lockers to store our PE kit and books.

This was in the UK.

cornbeeflegs · 11/01/2024 17:41

wildlifeWalker · 11/01/2024 14:11

Saw this on X/Twitter this morning. Looks like one of the best state or grammar allows individual dress styles and they are allowed to take their jackets off!

Maybe that's a sixth form class, in which case they will be wearing 'business dress'?

mathanxiety · 11/01/2024 17:15

UndertheCedartree · 10/01/2024 19:38

To be fair the methods we are discussing have come from the US and I've seen videos of them being used in Primary schools there. So while your local schools sound great it's obviously not like that everywhere. Equally these schools haven't taken over everywhere in the UK either. There are still some really great schools.

press.princeton.edu/ideas/i-spent-a-year-and-a-half-at-a-no-excuses-charter-school-this-is-what-i-saw
The charter schools of the US are a far cry from those of the UK. Parents choose to send their students to charter schools in the US. They are not forced by residence in a catchment to send them.

And there are a great many recognized and acknowledged flaws in the approach.

The knee-jerk reactionary/ neo-con element of British society has hopped aboard a half digested idea from America and made it their own. For Black, Latinx, and PoC students they have substituted the British underclass.

www.kipp.org/news/a-letter-from-dave-levin-to-kipp-alumni/
A letter from Dave Levin, founder of KIPP schools, to alumni, apologising for the one size fits all approach, for the ways the rules hurt and dehumanised students and teachers alike, and contributed to the Us and Them (You) culture of broader society. In the American context, this translates primarily but not exclusively to anti-Blackness.

Above all, that apology contains a glimpse of the idea that the message such schools impart is that it is the students and their families/ culture that must be changed - because they are the problem, and they need the top-down imposition of a superior culture if they are to get anywhere in life. The broader inequalities and institutional biases of society remain unquestioned and untouched. If Margaret Thatcher ever had a wet dream, this is what it looked like.

In practice, what draconian rule schools allow is the unleashing of a comprehensive contempt for a wide swathe of the population, and a comprehensive dismissal of everything this cohort needs and offers.

SalmonWellington · 11/01/2024 16:40

The assumption in a lot of this is that more rules and stricter discipline help kids from.worse backgrounds behave better. There doesn't seem to be much evidence og this.

Redpeonies · 11/01/2024 16:07

wildlifeWalker · 11/01/2024 14:11

Saw this on X/Twitter this morning. Looks like one of the best state or grammar allows individual dress styles and they are allowed to take their jackets off!

Well again, top state and grammar schools usually have an intake of students with higher incomes and stable families with fewer social stresses. Families who can afford to deliberately move to the catchment areas of these schools for example.

You need to match like with like. It's unlikely for example, that top performing schools have double the amount of teenagers in the school building than it was designed to accommodate.

Again, selective schools such as grammars can cherry pick the highest performing most promising students, unlike an overcrowded comprehensive.

It's easier to have more relaxed discipline when you have a highly motivated student body in a school that's not crowded and with less children who are in poverty or suffering various kinds of social deprivation. Tight budgets may not stretch to provide all the pastoral services that a crowded school needs; while the intake from a more deprived area may have less social resources of highly motivated and economically wealthy parents.

Please use a true comparison.

mathanxiety · 11/01/2024 15:51

Iwasafool · 10/01/2024 17:23

So where do you think they are going wrong with the social emotional development? Students and ex students going into school and killing students/teachers and then frequently committing suicide hardly suggests what they are doing is working.

That's quite the cheap shot there.

Out of a population of about 350 million, how many have shot their fellow students?

Your comment is ridiculous.

Witchcraftandhokum · 11/01/2024 15:03

Schools are failing children because of successive governments washing their hands of education and handing schools over to businesses to run.

Please stop blaming the teachers.

wildlifeWalker · 11/01/2024 14:11

Saw this on X/Twitter this morning. Looks like one of the best state or grammar allows individual dress styles and they are allowed to take their jackets off!

To wonder what has happened to my Son's school
ThinkAboutItTomorrow · 11/01/2024 13:07

Araminta1003 · 11/01/2024 11:26

How are mass detentions for teachers? Someone has to staff those detentions? Is SLT staffing them?! For some kids “homework” club after school is a good idea. Are you all sure this is not what they are trying to achieve? Get the non compliant kids to do their work at school itself because they don’t have a quiet/safe place at home?

Sadly this isn't about getting kids to do homework. They are dolling out detentions for forgetting a ruler.

Weirdly they still have 3 strikes before a detention for behaviour issues. But forget your ruler or have your shirt undone and it's automatically an hour after school detention.

ThinkAboutItTomorrow · 11/01/2024 12:45

Sherrystrull · 11/01/2024 11:12

@ThinkAboutItTomorrow

So what do you mean by this?

But sadly in my DDs school the shift to a draconian behaviour policy is being done 'for teachers' because of the recruitment challenges.

They quoted 2 things in their rationale:

  1. 25% of parents didn't think behaviour was good or very good And
  2. teacher recruitment
Araminta1003 · 11/01/2024 11:26

How are mass detentions for teachers? Someone has to staff those detentions? Is SLT staffing them?! For some kids “homework” club after school is a good idea. Are you all sure this is not what they are trying to achieve? Get the non compliant kids to do their work at school itself because they don’t have a quiet/safe place at home?

Sherrystrull · 11/01/2024 11:12

@ThinkAboutItTomorrow

So what do you mean by this?

But sadly in my DDs school the shift to a draconian behaviour policy is being done 'for teachers' because of the recruitment challenges.

MeditatationMum · 11/01/2024 11:06

I went to school in the 80's. I used to get sent to the deputy head every morning where she would make me wipe my makeup off (I was a punk so makeup was a bit extreme) I used to persevere every day. I was eventually suspended.
We were allowed to wear coats though..

ThinkAboutItTomorrow · 11/01/2024 10:49

Sherrystrull · 11/01/2024 10:36

So the policy is to try and retain teachers? I'm assuming as without it behaviour is unmanageable?

No! There's little evidence behaviour was a problem. It was an ofsted outstanding school getting amazing exam results.

In a parent survey last year 75% of parents felt behaviour was good or very good. The school is using the 25% of parents who did not say this as the catalyst for the new policy, as well as teacher recruitment.

Yet the 80% of parents who expressed concern about the new policy in a recent survey are being ignored.

ThinkAboutItTomorrow · 11/01/2024 10:38

@Extendedoctopustentacles it may not yet be 'common' but I think this thread has highlighted a growing trend in schools toward over the top behaviour policy.

I don't take issue at people being told to follow the uniform guidelines. I don't agree that a breach is an instant jump to detention. Yes, told to take off the hoodie or nose ring. Yes, if they are caught again then detention is maybe more justified but I'm talking about kids getting automatic one hour after school detention for top button undone.

Sherrystrull · 11/01/2024 10:36

So the policy is to try and retain teachers? I'm assuming as without it behaviour is unmanageable?

ThinkAboutItTomorrow · 11/01/2024 10:31

Sherrystrull · 11/01/2024 10:00

Teachers don't get to make the policies, we don't choosing support for SEND children, we can barely choose what we teach. The capacity to teach children and individualise learning is becoming harder and harder to achieve. All teachers want idyllic classrooms with time to pastorally support every child but the curriculum in ram packed and classes are large. The government have screwed up schools with their lack of funding and by dragging down the teaching profession. I went into teaching to make a difference and to build relationships with children and families. I can't imagine many teachers will say differently. Sadly the inability to do this will contribute to me leaving after 20+ years.

But sadly in my DDs school the shift to a draconian behaviour policy is being done 'for teachers' because of the recruitment challenges.

I can't believe most teachers much enjoy having to constantly dish out detentions for silly mistakes. I certainly can't imagine they are enjoying the push back from parents and having to run around and sort out issues when kids are given detentions in error (eg DD got one for not doing online homework when I'd seen her do it but it hadn't registered as completed on the system).

Or the meetings about attendance where they are having to reassure good well behaved kids that getting detention doesn't matter and they shouldn't worry about it, just to get them to not be so worried they are missing school.

Sherrystrull · 11/01/2024 10:00

Teachers don't get to make the policies, we don't choosing support for SEND children, we can barely choose what we teach. The capacity to teach children and individualise learning is becoming harder and harder to achieve. All teachers want idyllic classrooms with time to pastorally support every child but the curriculum in ram packed and classes are large. The government have screwed up schools with their lack of funding and by dragging down the teaching profession. I went into teaching to make a difference and to build relationships with children and families. I can't imagine many teachers will say differently. Sadly the inability to do this will contribute to me leaving after 20+ years.

GnomeDePlume · 11/01/2024 06:48

Verbena17 · 11/01/2024 00:49

Sadistic I would say. Seems very worrying and strange to me that so many teachers across the country so not stand up for the children in situations like this. Like you say it is cruel and I don’t see how they don’t argue to the SLT against it and refuse to implement it.

Possibly because just as these rules can be used to manage out non compliant students they can also be used to manage out non compliant staff.

Verbena17 · 11/01/2024 00:49

UndertheCedartree · 10/01/2024 18:58

I have to say that is one of the rules that I find the cruelest and hardest to understand particularly as it affects those with sensory additional needs to a greater degree. It just seems so counter productive to make DC uncomfortable and then expect them to learn?

Sadistic I would say. Seems very worrying and strange to me that so many teachers across the country so not stand up for the children in situations like this. Like you say it is cruel and I don’t see how they don’t argue to the SLT against it and refuse to implement it.

Extendedoctopustentacles · 10/01/2024 22:37

UndertheCedartree · 10/01/2024 21:13

We're not talking about relatively strict schools. My DD's school is strict - she follows all the rules. Because like your school, I imagine they are sensible and have proportionate punishments. People are talking about the ultra harsh schools who have rules that aren't sensible and with punishments that aren't proportionate.

But your comments appear to suggest that this is common. I work in schools, I certainly don't see lots (any) of these "ultra harsh" ones. What I do see are lots of social media posts on our community groups lamenting the fact that "poor little Jonny" wasn't allowed to wear their hoodie to school or "my Tilly" suffers with anxiety, she shouldn't be made to take out her nose stud, despite the fact she got it last week and the uniform policy was sent out at the beginning of term clearly stating no nose studs unless clear.

Extendedoctopustentacles · 10/01/2024 22:25

UndertheCedartree · 10/01/2024 21:03

I mean these schools are taking over, yet all you hear is teachers saying how behaviour is getting worse.

Taking over what exactly? Schools are there to educate. Quite often they can't because of the behaviour of "some" kids.

Iwasafool · 10/01/2024 21:44

UndertheCedartree · 10/01/2024 20:16

I've been singing the praises of my DD's nurturing secondary too. I had to fight hard to get her a place, though.

It was just his local comp, well the only one in the town so no choice but no fight to get him in. It has been wonderful for him.

ichundich · 10/01/2024 21:31

madamepopov · 10/01/2024 11:03

I can't work out if you genuinely mean this or if you're being sarcastic?
I don't want my children to be blindly obedient to authority, I see no upside in that

It worked 'well' in Germany between 1933 and 1945.

Swipe left for the next trending thread