Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder what has happened to my Son's school

989 replies

k2493 · 07/01/2024 11:09

Just posting for thoughts

Both my kids have gone through the same secondary school. When my daughter started, the school was lovely and new with around 750 kids.

Fast forward to 2024 and there is now 1500 kids and it's become like a dictatorship.

Due to the number of kids, the school has put lines either side of the hallway that they have to walk within otherwise they get detention.

Every hallway is a one way system.

The minute they arrive in school, they have to remove their coats or it's detention even with no heating in the middle of winter. The other day my son arrived back to school to find that there were long queues outside while they did two uniform checks at the door. By the time he got in, he was frozen. Immediately he got shouted at for still having his coat on even though he had just stepped in from the cold.

He then went around the corner and got shouted at again even though he tried to explain it's really difficult to be expected to stay warm, keep moving and remove your coat all at the same time. Nope. Threaten with detention again.

AIBU to wonder what has happened to our education system? I'm lucky in that my son is quite strong minded and just brushes it off but what about the kids who's mental health this is impacting? Surely we want our kids to remember school as being enjoyable for their education and friendships rather than for being shouted at every two minutes for not walking between lines or not taking their coats off the minute they arrive in school?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
11
UndertheCedartree · 11/01/2024 21:27

cornbeeflegs · 11/01/2024 17:41

Maybe that's a sixth form class, in which case they will be wearing 'business dress'?

Possible, although they look a little young.

UndertheCedartree · 11/01/2024 21:25

mathanxiety · 11/01/2024 17:15

press.princeton.edu/ideas/i-spent-a-year-and-a-half-at-a-no-excuses-charter-school-this-is-what-i-saw
The charter schools of the US are a far cry from those of the UK. Parents choose to send their students to charter schools in the US. They are not forced by residence in a catchment to send them.

And there are a great many recognized and acknowledged flaws in the approach.

The knee-jerk reactionary/ neo-con element of British society has hopped aboard a half digested idea from America and made it their own. For Black, Latinx, and PoC students they have substituted the British underclass.

www.kipp.org/news/a-letter-from-dave-levin-to-kipp-alumni/
A letter from Dave Levin, founder of KIPP schools, to alumni, apologising for the one size fits all approach, for the ways the rules hurt and dehumanised students and teachers alike, and contributed to the Us and Them (You) culture of broader society. In the American context, this translates primarily but not exclusively to anti-Blackness.

Above all, that apology contains a glimpse of the idea that the message such schools impart is that it is the students and their families/ culture that must be changed - because they are the problem, and they need the top-down imposition of a superior culture if they are to get anywhere in life. The broader inequalities and institutional biases of society remain unquestioned and untouched. If Margaret Thatcher ever had a wet dream, this is what it looked like.

In practice, what draconian rule schools allow is the unleashing of a comprehensive contempt for a wide swathe of the population, and a comprehensive dismissal of everything this cohort needs and offers.

I had a look and it seems that a 'charter school' is what we call an 'academy' and there are also trusts of multiple charter schools like our multi academy trusts. So it's the same kinds of schools using these methods. All I can say is I hope it doesn't move down to Primary here.

Redpeonies · 11/01/2024 21:16

SalmonWellington · 11/01/2024 20:47

Again - why does stricter discipline work better with kids from.rougher backgrounds?

I don't know if anyone has suggested that. It's more a correlation where wealthy areas have more resources, inside the school and inside the kids homes.

Kids deprived in various ways are more likely to live in deprived neighborhoods and the local schools have less resources to draw on, and that includes teachers who want to teach at those schools. The school may be short staffed or have less experienced staff, while teachers will often move on when they get another opportunity.

Kids who are disruptive can often be bounced out of other schools and are more likely to be at schools who have no choice as to which kids they accept.

Therefore it's a lot easier to be more relaxed with discipline when the schools and homes have more resources and you can expel children that cause problems.

Instability in the home has a big effect on a child's ability to learn and function. Of course instability in the home can be found across the class spectrum, but is more common in lower-income families. Again, children from higher income backgrounds are likely to have more resources to draw on, in and outside school to make up for some of this chaos.

https://bmcpublichealth.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s12889-020-08587-8

In a nutshell poorer kids are more likely to attend lower quality schools with higher student numbers and low teacher ratio. Therefore more structured discipline may be used, not because it's better for these kids, but because teachers are dealing with very different issues than teachers in other schools; such as a larger literal number of kids and a higher number getting no support or structure at home.

The relationship between household chaos and child, parent, and family outcomes: a systematic scoping review - BMC Public Health

Background Household chaos, represented by the level of disorganisation or environmental confusion in the home, has been associated with a range of adverse child and family outcomes. This review aims to (1) identify how household chaos is measured, (2)...

https://bmcpublichealth.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s12889-020-08587-8

UndertheCedartree · 11/01/2024 21:09

Witchcraftandhokum · 11/01/2024 15:03

Schools are failing children because of successive governments washing their hands of education and handing schools over to businesses to run.

Please stop blaming the teachers.

Who's blaming teachers? Some people have questioned or commented on teachers roles but predominantly people are putting the blame on government/academies/SLT

pissedoffwithschool · 11/01/2024 21:05

cansu · 11/01/2024 20:54

Wildlife walker
I have absolutely no objection to this at all! I always say to my class at the start of the lesson please take off if your blazer if you need to. Personally I think the following is perfectly sensible
Kids wear the school uniform properly
They arrive on time
They are respectful and quiet when required
They bring the equipment needed
They stay in their seat and listen
They don't use their phones
They walk on one side of the corridor
They don't screech and shout in public spaces like corridors and loos
They complete sanctions given without a massive drama

Is this so radical??

So would you agree that my daughter's teacher was unreasonable?

UndertheCedartree · 11/01/2024 21:03

ThinkAboutItTomorrow · 11/01/2024 10:31

But sadly in my DDs school the shift to a draconian behaviour policy is being done 'for teachers' because of the recruitment challenges.

I can't believe most teachers much enjoy having to constantly dish out detentions for silly mistakes. I certainly can't imagine they are enjoying the push back from parents and having to run around and sort out issues when kids are given detentions in error (eg DD got one for not doing online homework when I'd seen her do it but it hadn't registered as completed on the system).

Or the meetings about attendance where they are having to reassure good well behaved kids that getting detention doesn't matter and they shouldn't worry about it, just to get them to not be so worried they are missing school.

It's crazy, isn't it? I mean what is the point of detentions if they don't matter. And I'm pretty sure they matter to the student who is missing their after school time.

Verbena17 · 11/01/2024 20:59

cansu · 11/01/2024 20:16

Teachers cannot increase the amount of money spent on support or pastoral staff. Many children with SEND require 1.1 support. There is no money to pay for TAs to support these children in most schools unless the student has 1.1 written into an EHCP. I can ask the senco five hundred times for help in my classroom for a student but they still can't give it. They do not have the money in the budget. I have minimal prep time and huge classes. Many children have needs that mean they need an adult alongside them to encourage, support and assist them. I cannot be that 1.1 as I have 29 others to teach and manage. Some of these will also have significant needs or may have behaviour or emotional difficulties. Then there are the kids who need to be challenged and then there are the quiet students who just get on who also need some of my time and attention. Verbena77 - I think you need to spend a week in a standard comp to get a flavour of what it is like.

I wasn’t meaning SEND issues /funding that cannot be quickly sorted by teaching staff.
I mean for staff to get together and decide on minimising the ridiculous petty rules, like no loo break, no blazers removed, detention for breathing talking etc.
I mean the stuff that can easily be dealt with by staff and passed up to the SLT.

UndertheCedartree · 11/01/2024 20:58

Extendedoctopustentacles · 10/01/2024 22:37

But your comments appear to suggest that this is common. I work in schools, I certainly don't see lots (any) of these "ultra harsh" ones. What I do see are lots of social media posts on our community groups lamenting the fact that "poor little Jonny" wasn't allowed to wear their hoodie to school or "my Tilly" suffers with anxiety, she shouldn't be made to take out her nose stud, despite the fact she got it last week and the uniform policy was sent out at the beginning of term clearly stating no nose studs unless clear.

It is common, you only have to read this thread to see that. Most of our local schools here have gone that way and I hear the same from teacher friends/parent friends in other parts of the country. And yeah, there are a few parents like that but the majority are not.

Verbena17 · 11/01/2024 20:54

Sherrystrull · 11/01/2024 19:59

Teachers aren't being passive. I cannot magically create SEND funding or get enough money to buy new pritt sticks or white board pens. I fight constantly with SLT for resources, the SENDcO for support and what does it achieve? Nothing. I also have a job to do without fighting for everything everyone needs. Even the basics would be nice.

@Verbena17, do you work as a teacher?

I don’t necessarily mean individually fight for it but as a body.
In staff meetings isn’t this sort of thing discussed?
I’m not a teacher but spent the entirety of my childrens’ school lives fighting to get them much needed support for different issues, including SEND issues.

cansu · 11/01/2024 20:54

Wildlife walker
I have absolutely no objection to this at all! I always say to my class at the start of the lesson please take off if your blazer if you need to. Personally I think the following is perfectly sensible
Kids wear the school uniform properly
They arrive on time
They are respectful and quiet when required
They bring the equipment needed
They stay in their seat and listen
They don't use their phones
They walk on one side of the corridor
They don't screech and shout in public spaces like corridors and loos
They complete sanctions given without a massive drama

Is this so radical??

UndertheCedartree · 11/01/2024 20:53

Extendedoctopustentacles · 10/01/2024 22:25

Taking over what exactly? Schools are there to educate. Quite often they can't because of the behaviour of "some" kids.

I mean more and more schools are following this fashion and the behaviour is getting worse not better. My DD's nurturing school on the other hand has a reputation for how well behaved the students are. As you say school is there to educate so let's do what we can to improve behaviour so learning can happen!

UndertheCedartree · 11/01/2024 20:50

Iwasafool · 10/01/2024 21:44

It was just his local comp, well the only one in the town so no choice but no fight to get him in. It has been wonderful for him.

That's really wonderful to hear ☺️

pissedoffwithschool · 11/01/2024 20:47

wildlifeWalker · 11/01/2024 20:28

Why exactly can pupils not take off their jumper or blazer if they are warm? I really don't get the reason for this. Not all people feel temperature in the same way.

You could just say at the beginning of the lesson they are allowed to which would prevent multiple students asking separately...

You would have thought.
When I was at school rules seemed much more reasonable. Most teachers turned a blind eye to us having our ties loose as long as they looked tidy, and we were allowed to have shirts untucked at lunchtimes as long as they got tidied again before lessons

SalmonWellington · 11/01/2024 20:47

Again - why does stricter discipline work better with kids from.rougher backgrounds?

greengreengrass25 · 11/01/2024 20:47

No yanbu she's in class and hot, what's wrong with loosening tie or taking off blazer or jumper. She's not being g disruptive. What is the big deal

She's not focusing on the lesson if she feels like this and has asked nicely

pissedoffwithschool · 11/01/2024 20:43

greengreengrass25 · 11/01/2024 20:29

@pissedoffwithschool

It's absolutely ridiculous

I would be furious as well

Have the students got no autonomy now

Thanks, not just me being precious then.
She's really upset because she likes to be a 'good girl', and takes it to heart if she gets told off.

greengreengrass25 · 11/01/2024 20:29

@pissedoffwithschool

It's absolutely ridiculous

I would be furious as well

Have the students got no autonomy now

wildlifeWalker · 11/01/2024 20:28

cansu · 11/01/2024 20:23

Agree also that it is much easier to have a relaxed approach with highly motivated, academic students. Comparing selective schools or schools in very leafy areas with more mixed comprehensives is pointless. They don't have the same clientele.

Why exactly can pupils not take off their jumper or blazer if they are warm? I really don't get the reason for this. Not all people feel temperature in the same way.

You could just say at the beginning of the lesson they are allowed to which would prevent multiple students asking separately...

cansu · 11/01/2024 20:23

Agree also that it is much easier to have a relaxed approach with highly motivated, academic students. Comparing selective schools or schools in very leafy areas with more mixed comprehensives is pointless. They don't have the same clientele.

cansu · 11/01/2024 20:16

Teachers cannot increase the amount of money spent on support or pastoral staff. Many children with SEND require 1.1 support. There is no money to pay for TAs to support these children in most schools unless the student has 1.1 written into an EHCP. I can ask the senco five hundred times for help in my classroom for a student but they still can't give it. They do not have the money in the budget. I have minimal prep time and huge classes. Many children have needs that mean they need an adult alongside them to encourage, support and assist them. I cannot be that 1.1 as I have 29 others to teach and manage. Some of these will also have significant needs or may have behaviour or emotional difficulties. Then there are the kids who need to be challenged and then there are the quiet students who just get on who also need some of my time and attention. Verbena77 - I think you need to spend a week in a standard comp to get a flavour of what it is like.

Sherrystrull · 11/01/2024 19:59

Teachers aren't being passive. I cannot magically create SEND funding or get enough money to buy new pritt sticks or white board pens. I fight constantly with SLT for resources, the SENDcO for support and what does it achieve? Nothing. I also have a job to do without fighting for everything everyone needs. Even the basics would be nice.

@Verbena17, do you work as a teacher?

Verbena17 · 11/01/2024 19:22

Witchcraftandhokum · 11/01/2024 15:03

Schools are failing children because of successive governments washing their hands of education and handing schools over to businesses to run.

Please stop blaming the teachers.

But people are realising that many teachers are just staying passive and don’t advocate for the children.

So whilst you’re right, lots of teachers aren’t to blame for the decisions being made, they’re also not doing anything to fight them….when they can clearly see the nightmare they’re (the petty rules) causing.

pissedoffwithschool · 11/01/2024 19:05

ObliviousCoalmine · 07/01/2024 12:00

Our school is the same. My child has gone from never having any issues at primary and in year 7 to spending years 8 and 9 being pulled up for so many absolutely ridiculous things that it's lost all meaning and she couldn't really give a shit about what they're saying now.

Blowing up on all of the inconsequential shit like walking in single file and how straight a tie is makes a mockery of the whole thing. Detentions over socks make detentions over actual poor behaviour mean absolutely fuck all.

Grown adults writing seriously toned emails about "so and so has had three warnings about wearing their tie in the correct manner (straight, and it's a clip on..) and we will be forced to pursue this if they don't address this behaviour.

This hierarchical bullshit won't turn out well, and it's producing kids with complete contempt for the system.

This!
My eldest is in Y8, and had just come home in tears because she got her first ever detention today. She was in her last lesson of the day, the room was really warm so about 10 minutes into the lesson she asked to take her jumper off. Teacher refused saying that it wasn't that warm. About 15 minutes later she asked again, again teacher refused saying that no-one else seemed to have a problem. She didn't dare to ask again so she did what I would consider to be the sensible thing and pulled her tie down and undid her collar. She remained like this for the rest of the lesson, and it wasn't until the end of the lesson that the teacher asked her to stay behind. Teacher wanted to know why she'd loosened her tie without permission, and accused her of being disruptive throughout the lesson. Issued her with a lunchtime detention for Monday.
I'm not saying that my daughter is an angel and the fact that she's a 'chatterbox' has been mentioned many times in parents' evenings, but she always gets her work done and knows the rules regarding general behaviour, uniform, etc.

Redpeonies · 11/01/2024 18:30

@wildlifeWalker I understand this and I am not suggesting it is all schools, but a school with 1500 that was built for 750 often has to sacrifice the locker space for other essential things.

I also attended a comprehensive school in London. At Primary we had 30+ kids in our class.

What we experienced is not necessarily what current teachers are facing, such as huge overcrowding and serious underfunding for all the extra services and support that many students need. Or no room to put the extra services in.

I am not saying petty discipline measures work, but many schools are getting to a level of crowd control where they are trying to keep everyone safe and moving through the day. This is often with a significant number of kids who don't want to be there, or have various challenges which in previous decades would've had alternative help available in a number of forms that no longer exist (specialized schools, more social workers, more pastoral staff etc etc).

Teachers and school staff are spread extremely thin in some schools. There are many threads on MN of teachers desperate to get out of teaching, being signed off sick due to mental health and generally feeling exhausted and stressed out.

wildlifeWalker · 11/01/2024 18:18

Witchcraftandhokum · 11/01/2024 15:03

Schools are failing children because of successive governments washing their hands of education and handing schools over to businesses to run.

Please stop blaming the teachers.

I definitely think this is the problem.
Top salaries of CEOs of some of these schools is eye watering! Money that should be being used for education.

Swipe left for the next trending thread