Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder what has happened to my Son's school

989 replies

k2493 · 07/01/2024 11:09

Just posting for thoughts

Both my kids have gone through the same secondary school. When my daughter started, the school was lovely and new with around 750 kids.

Fast forward to 2024 and there is now 1500 kids and it's become like a dictatorship.

Due to the number of kids, the school has put lines either side of the hallway that they have to walk within otherwise they get detention.

Every hallway is a one way system.

The minute they arrive in school, they have to remove their coats or it's detention even with no heating in the middle of winter. The other day my son arrived back to school to find that there were long queues outside while they did two uniform checks at the door. By the time he got in, he was frozen. Immediately he got shouted at for still having his coat on even though he had just stepped in from the cold.

He then went around the corner and got shouted at again even though he tried to explain it's really difficult to be expected to stay warm, keep moving and remove your coat all at the same time. Nope. Threaten with detention again.

AIBU to wonder what has happened to our education system? I'm lucky in that my son is quite strong minded and just brushes it off but what about the kids who's mental health this is impacting? Surely we want our kids to remember school as being enjoyable for their education and friendships rather than for being shouted at every two minutes for not walking between lines or not taking their coats off the minute they arrive in school?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
11
ScreamingBeans · 12/01/2024 13:33

PerspicaciaTick · 12/01/2024 13:25

A lot of schools now seem to assume that every pupil is disrespectful and disruptive so every interaction assumes the worst of the pupil.
Imagine being subject to senseless, continual collective punishment all day, every day regardless of how carefully you individually try and follow the arbitrary rules.

This is what I mean by schools are horrible. I'm just glad my kids are grown up and they can't do any more mental health damage to my youngest. It's taken her years to get back the self-confidence and self-esteem she had when she was 11.

PerspicaciaTick · 12/01/2024 13:25

A lot of schools now seem to assume that every pupil is disrespectful and disruptive so every interaction assumes the worst of the pupil.
Imagine being subject to senseless, continual collective punishment all day, every day regardless of how carefully you individually try and follow the arbitrary rules.

ThinkAboutItTomorrow · 12/01/2024 13:06

My take out from this thread is:

There is a behaviour challenge amongst kids. Schools will sit on a spectrum of how bad this is but it sounds as though all schools are experiencing worsening behaviour overall.

Some MATs and schools, and I would say from this thread, increasing numbers, are attempting to solve this with extremely stringent, zero tolerance, punishment heavy behaviour policies.

Many parents feel this is the wrong approach and it is negatively impacting children, especially those who are generally well behaved and want to be 'good'.

I've not seen any evidence of the success of stricter policies in creating better learning?

I feel there is a lack of root cause analysis of the problem. Isn't the poor behaviour a result of a) the impact of the pandemic on mental health and socialisation among kids b) the financial stresses in many homes that must surely impact kids c) an investment shortfall in schools meaning teachers and schools are trying to do more with less resources and are too thinly stretched to respond sensibly.

I really feel doubling down on more rules and punishment is the last thing we should be doing and will only be further damaging to a generation we have already failed.

Verbena17 · 12/01/2024 11:24

Thanks for calling me ‘dim’ @Sherrystrull 😊 That’ll be a lunch break detention.

I completely understand what you’re saying but I think you’re misunderstanding what I originally was saying. I was saying teachers are in a good position to make the small changes needed to reduce the red tape discipline that this whole post is on about.
Ive not said anything remotely arrogant or rude or bashing against teachers and I’m not saying how teachers should teach and how they should do their job - there are some absolutely brilliant teachers who are obviously hampered in what they do because of ridiculous rules set by government, MATS and SLTs.

I’m being positive; saying they can use advocacy for the children they teach- small changes in class, at lunchtimes and by reducing the crazy detentions for simple things that are not proportional to the ‘crime etc. And yes, I totally get how there isn’t much spare time to do anything other than plan and teach and also the additional burden of ofsted constraints but tell me what happens at staff meetings?

Is there not opportunity (at least monthly if not weekly) to put forward items for the agenda? A relative of mine certainly has that ability in primary staff meetings. Surely staff meetings aren’t just SLT talking and barking orders- isn’t it a 360 degree meeting where anyone can speak/bring ideas to the table?

In the same way midwives themselves (with parents) brought about better outcomes and changes for labouring mothers, surely there’s a way for teachers to be that bridge to better outcomes in schools - behavioural outcomes I mean, not academic.

wildlifeWalker · 12/01/2024 08:35

Needmorelego · 12/01/2024 06:51

@sashh my secondary was basically like my suggestion though. We were divided into 3 different buildings (originally separate schools but on the same campus). There were occasions we would have to go to one of the other buildings instead of our "own" - my building didn't have science or DT classrooms so we had to go across for those lessons. But 90% was in your own building with it's own teaching staff.
It was 3 forms per year (so approx 90 students) so didn't feel like a massive school.
However.....they scrapped that system and we were all mixed together. Now 9 forms per year (almost 300 students). Way more movement between the buildings (time consuming). And incredibly easy to become invisible now you were one of 300.

I think that's it's a great idea to separate a larger school into smaller more manageable blocks with shared special resources such as science.

I guess you would need more teachers though and that would eat into the 'profit' (fat cat salaries) made by academies.

Sherrystrull · 12/01/2024 07:09

@Verbena17

It's great you've been able to champion and work for your child. Many parents don't or can't.

You don't have the capacity to see past your own experience and realise that other parents don't do the same.

Of course you can comment on your experience but all of your comments of teachers need to do this, teachers don't do this and schools should do this whilst ignoring what teachers are telling you are insensitive and dim.

Why do you think you can comment on what goes on in schools when your only experience is short term volunteering and having your own dc?

It's a major issue in schools that many parents feel like you. I'd never be so arrogant to talk like that about any profession I've never worked in and would be receptive to the experiences of people doing the job.

Oh well, continue to drag down teachers, ignore the realities of the job they are telling you about and keep telling them what they should be doing. Just don't expect there to be any teachers left to listen.

Needmorelego · 12/01/2024 06:51

@sashh my secondary was basically like my suggestion though. We were divided into 3 different buildings (originally separate schools but on the same campus). There were occasions we would have to go to one of the other buildings instead of our "own" - my building didn't have science or DT classrooms so we had to go across for those lessons. But 90% was in your own building with it's own teaching staff.
It was 3 forms per year (so approx 90 students) so didn't feel like a massive school.
However.....they scrapped that system and we were all mixed together. Now 9 forms per year (almost 300 students). Way more movement between the buildings (time consuming). And incredibly easy to become invisible now you were one of 300.

twistyizzy · 12/01/2024 06:14

@Verbena17 if teachers had any say in changing things why do you think they are all leaving? People don't leave jobs where they have agency.
Primary is so different to secondary so it is like comparing apples and pears.
You have experience of primary but not of secondary.

sashh · 12/01/2024 04:27

Needmorelego · 09/01/2024 11:08

@UndertheCedartree big schools could divide up into schools within schools so they are smaller.
If a school is divided up into -say - school A, B and C it would be that A has all their lessons in Block/Section A, B in B, C in C etc. A pupils would have no lessons with B and C, B no lessons with A and C....you get the idea.
Sports facilities could be shared and some specialist subjects at GCSE level the groups could combine (for the 27 pupils that decide they want to do Latin 😂) but other than that it would be like 3 separate schools. Less overwhelming.

I like the idea but it wouldn't work, you would need to have science labs, art tooms, IT rooms etc in each 'school'.

The coats thing could be solved by having a school coat as part of the uniform. Wear the school coat and take it off when you get in or take your non uniform coat off outside.

To get round the problem of coats going missing you could use a tag like a microchip / airtag in the lining.

I've said a number of times PE kit should be designed so it can be worn as a summer uniform for the odd week it is 30+ in the UK.

My school (comp but run by nuns) had delusions of grandeur so we did have school coats and a seperate summer uniform to be worn from Easter until the September holidays (Lancashire, at the time the school holidays were similar to Scotland).

Verbena17 · 12/01/2024 00:26

Sherrystrull · 11/01/2024 23:51

I did read your post @Verbena17.

It's great you volunteered in school. However that doesn't make you able to make all the comments you have about teachers. Volunteers have a very minimal and rose tinted view of the job of a teacher just as a teacher lady in a hospital cannot imagine the role and responsibilities of a doctor.

I absolutely teach my class to be assertive and stand up for themselves.

Tell me then,

How do I get ten children in my class assessed for SEND when we can only afford 3 Ed psych visits for the entire school over a year?

How can I get the SENDcO to observe these children when they are covering multiple classes and showed under supporting the children we already have on the SEND register?

I'm tired of people blaming teachers for not standing up for themselves, not caring about the children in our care and not doing enough.

If there was better funding we could support these children more. However you bleating on about teachers not doing enough is insulting when you're battling a brick wall every day.

What are you doing to change things?

I was about to reply in full and then I re-read your extremely patronising and arsey comments about school volunteers and tea ladies in hospitals.

I don’t care what you do for your own class. As you’ve pointed out, I’m not a teacher so cannot possible imagine or comment. 😉
But magically, as a mum who spent hours pouring through the SEND Code of Practice, was able to get my child assessed and diagnosed for ASD, assessed by the county lead Ed Psych twice in 3 months at home (even though I was told they would never do assessments at home), got him an EHCP even when they refused to assess and then got him very the last place in a brand new special school.
The secret…..not involving his teachers or his school!

Sherrystrull · 11/01/2024 23:51

*tea lady

Sherrystrull · 11/01/2024 23:51

I did read your post @Verbena17.

It's great you volunteered in school. However that doesn't make you able to make all the comments you have about teachers. Volunteers have a very minimal and rose tinted view of the job of a teacher just as a teacher lady in a hospital cannot imagine the role and responsibilities of a doctor.

I absolutely teach my class to be assertive and stand up for themselves.

Tell me then,

How do I get ten children in my class assessed for SEND when we can only afford 3 Ed psych visits for the entire school over a year?

How can I get the SENDcO to observe these children when they are covering multiple classes and showed under supporting the children we already have on the SEND register?

I'm tired of people blaming teachers for not standing up for themselves, not caring about the children in our care and not doing enough.

If there was better funding we could support these children more. However you bleating on about teachers not doing enough is insulting when you're battling a brick wall every day.

What are you doing to change things?

Verbena17 · 11/01/2024 23:23

UndertheCedartree · 11/01/2024 22:08

I thought with uniform the government said schools should just have one branded item which most secondary schools don't seem to stick to atall!

At my Dd's school the main uniform only has one branded item - the jumper. But then you also have P.E kit with a branded top and hoodie so still ends up being expensive.

The secondary here has branded everything!
Blazer, tie, tartan skirt (extra cost for girls), PE rugby top, PE polo shirt, PE shorts, PE gym skort, PE long Gross socks.

Mega expensive and cheap polyester crap.

Verbena17 · 11/01/2024 23:19

Sherrystrull · 11/01/2024 21:53

@Verbena17

Then if you don't have time to volunteer and educate yourself on the issue, stop spouting information and opinions about teachers that you clearly know nothing about.

The government and Ofsted have clear agendas that schools have to follow if we want to do well in inspections. So yes, the government does make decisions like that. They certainly have much more clout than a class teacher or two getting together to stamp their feet. Honestly.

What’s sad is, you’re teaching our children to become independent and assertive young people….and yet from your reply, you seem to imply teachers have zero say themselves in anything and cannot make small changes. Kind of goes against the whole point of education.

If you had properly read my post, you’ll see I had volunteered in a school (for 2 yrs) and I’m now a parent cared and cannot therefore volunteer anymore. Just because someone isn’t a teacher, doesn’t mean they’re not up to understanding difficulties in teaching or schools. My child’s teachers didn’t understand autism but I don’t moan on and on that they all effed up his life.

cansu · 11/01/2024 22:23

UndertheCedartree
I think many people would be surprised about how much disruptive behaviour 'nurturing' schools tolerate and allow. If you have a child in a low set who is quiet and wants to get on then often the nurture means allowing students to disturb lessons day in, day out.

UndertheCedartree · 11/01/2024 22:08

Verbena17 · 11/01/2024 21:40

‘…big things like uniform’ aren’t decided by government 🤔
Uniform like taking your blazer off when you feel like it or not having your top button done up as long as you can’t see it etc. I mean they can deal with the niff naff and trivia that’s unnecessary.

And I did used to volunteer in a primary school and would love to help secondary kiddos now, but I’m a carer for my autistic DS so don’t have time.

I thought with uniform the government said schools should just have one branded item which most secondary schools don't seem to stick to atall!

At my Dd's school the main uniform only has one branded item - the jumper. But then you also have P.E kit with a branded top and hoodie so still ends up being expensive.

UndertheCedartree · 11/01/2024 22:04

Sherrystrull · 11/01/2024 21:32

@Verbena17

I advise you to volunteer in a school. You will then see that teachers as a body have limited capacity to change anything in school, especially big things like uniform. That gets decided by government, slt and governors.

I rarely see my teaching colleagues as I am in class all day every day teaching, marking, assessing and preparing.

She is a parent carer so not sure she'd be able, tbf.

UndertheCedartree · 11/01/2024 22:01

Redpeonies · 11/01/2024 21:16

I don't know if anyone has suggested that. It's more a correlation where wealthy areas have more resources, inside the school and inside the kids homes.

Kids deprived in various ways are more likely to live in deprived neighborhoods and the local schools have less resources to draw on, and that includes teachers who want to teach at those schools. The school may be short staffed or have less experienced staff, while teachers will often move on when they get another opportunity.

Kids who are disruptive can often be bounced out of other schools and are more likely to be at schools who have no choice as to which kids they accept.

Therefore it's a lot easier to be more relaxed with discipline when the schools and homes have more resources and you can expel children that cause problems.

Instability in the home has a big effect on a child's ability to learn and function. Of course instability in the home can be found across the class spectrum, but is more common in lower-income families. Again, children from higher income backgrounds are likely to have more resources to draw on, in and outside school to make up for some of this chaos.

https://bmcpublichealth.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s12889-020-08587-8

In a nutshell poorer kids are more likely to attend lower quality schools with higher student numbers and low teacher ratio. Therefore more structured discipline may be used, not because it's better for these kids, but because teachers are dealing with very different issues than teachers in other schools; such as a larger literal number of kids and a higher number getting no support or structure at home.

One of these schools which is our catchment school is actually quite small in terms of numbers of pupils. I don't think anyone wants to send their DC there but obviously many don't get a choice. The Primary school our DC went to actually had more pupils and an amazing pastoral care department. The secondary at one time was considered good but it seems to have a never ending succession of head teachers. I don't think anyone particularly wants to be there teachers or students.

Sherrystrull · 11/01/2024 21:53

@Verbena17

Then if you don't have time to volunteer and educate yourself on the issue, stop spouting information and opinions about teachers that you clearly know nothing about.

The government and Ofsted have clear agendas that schools have to follow if we want to do well in inspections. So yes, the government does make decisions like that. They certainly have much more clout than a class teacher or two getting together to stamp their feet. Honestly.

UndertheCedartree · 11/01/2024 21:51

pissedoffwithschool · 11/01/2024 21:05

So would you agree that my daughter's teacher was unreasonable?

Your DD was wearing uniform properly - she was just hot and wanted to take her jumper off. Ridiculously, she had to disrupt the lesson to ask if she could take it off and then the teacher prevented her. She then needed to loosen her tie - strictly speaking maybe not wearing uniform properly but better than feeling really ill and not being able to participate in the lesson. Your DD was completely reasonable.

UndertheCedartree · 11/01/2024 21:47

cansu · 11/01/2024 20:54

Wildlife walker
I have absolutely no objection to this at all! I always say to my class at the start of the lesson please take off if your blazer if you need to. Personally I think the following is perfectly sensible
Kids wear the school uniform properly
They arrive on time
They are respectful and quiet when required
They bring the equipment needed
They stay in their seat and listen
They don't use their phones
They walk on one side of the corridor
They don't screech and shout in public spaces like corridors and loos
They complete sanctions given without a massive drama

Is this so radical??

Not radical atall. Why do you ask?

UndertheCedartree · 11/01/2024 21:41

cansu · 11/01/2024 20:23

Agree also that it is much easier to have a relaxed approach with highly motivated, academic students. Comparing selective schools or schools in very leafy areas with more mixed comprehensives is pointless. They don't have the same clientele.

As mentioned my Dd's school is in a working class area. They are incredibly nurturing. It's possible.

Verbena17 · 11/01/2024 21:40

Sherrystrull · 11/01/2024 21:32

@Verbena17

I advise you to volunteer in a school. You will then see that teachers as a body have limited capacity to change anything in school, especially big things like uniform. That gets decided by government, slt and governors.

I rarely see my teaching colleagues as I am in class all day every day teaching, marking, assessing and preparing.

‘…big things like uniform’ aren’t decided by government 🤔
Uniform like taking your blazer off when you feel like it or not having your top button done up as long as you can’t see it etc. I mean they can deal with the niff naff and trivia that’s unnecessary.

And I did used to volunteer in a primary school and would love to help secondary kiddos now, but I’m a carer for my autistic DS so don’t have time.

UndertheCedartree · 11/01/2024 21:37

pissedoffwithschool · 11/01/2024 19:05

This!
My eldest is in Y8, and had just come home in tears because she got her first ever detention today. She was in her last lesson of the day, the room was really warm so about 10 minutes into the lesson she asked to take her jumper off. Teacher refused saying that it wasn't that warm. About 15 minutes later she asked again, again teacher refused saying that no-one else seemed to have a problem. She didn't dare to ask again so she did what I would consider to be the sensible thing and pulled her tie down and undid her collar. She remained like this for the rest of the lesson, and it wasn't until the end of the lesson that the teacher asked her to stay behind. Teacher wanted to know why she'd loosened her tie without permission, and accused her of being disruptive throughout the lesson. Issued her with a lunchtime detention for Monday.
I'm not saying that my daughter is an angel and the fact that she's a 'chatterbox' has been mentioned many times in parents' evenings, but she always gets her work done and knows the rules regarding general behaviour, uniform, etc.

I mean surely the way to be least disruptive is to just let someone who is too hot quietly take off their jumper?! And surely the teacher must know temperatures affect people differently. I'm sorry your DD was upset.

Sherrystrull · 11/01/2024 21:32

@Verbena17

I advise you to volunteer in a school. You will then see that teachers as a body have limited capacity to change anything in school, especially big things like uniform. That gets decided by government, slt and governors.

I rarely see my teaching colleagues as I am in class all day every day teaching, marking, assessing and preparing.