Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder what has happened to my Son's school

989 replies

k2493 · 07/01/2024 11:09

Just posting for thoughts

Both my kids have gone through the same secondary school. When my daughter started, the school was lovely and new with around 750 kids.

Fast forward to 2024 and there is now 1500 kids and it's become like a dictatorship.

Due to the number of kids, the school has put lines either side of the hallway that they have to walk within otherwise they get detention.

Every hallway is a one way system.

The minute they arrive in school, they have to remove their coats or it's detention even with no heating in the middle of winter. The other day my son arrived back to school to find that there were long queues outside while they did two uniform checks at the door. By the time he got in, he was frozen. Immediately he got shouted at for still having his coat on even though he had just stepped in from the cold.

He then went around the corner and got shouted at again even though he tried to explain it's really difficult to be expected to stay warm, keep moving and remove your coat all at the same time. Nope. Threaten with detention again.

AIBU to wonder what has happened to our education system? I'm lucky in that my son is quite strong minded and just brushes it off but what about the kids who's mental health this is impacting? Surely we want our kids to remember school as being enjoyable for their education and friendships rather than for being shouted at every two minutes for not walking between lines or not taking their coats off the minute they arrive in school?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
11
twistyizzy · 07/01/2024 18:12

Verbena17 · 07/01/2024 18:07

There’s a way around it - as their parent, write to school (so you have an evidence trail) and describe the unfairness and why your son won’t be doing detentions if they relate to ridiculous and unachievable pyramid-type discipline regimes!
Explain as you have here in very simple terms so they can read it and see how stupid it is!

Unless parents actually do something in high enough numbers, schools will be micromanaging and hyper-focussing on ridiculous behaviour issues that don’t exist, instead of actually teaching kids important things.

Thank goodness my kiddos have now both left the uk schooling system because it’s really not fit for purpose!

Parents are part of the problem though. They want schools to have rules until those rules apply to their precious DC and then they complain!
They don't want other kids disrupting lessons but then when their child is placed in isolation for constant disruptions they kick off.

Hotchocolate2023 · 07/01/2024 18:11

Sherrystrull · 07/01/2024 18:09

It allows the other children in the class to learn without disruption for a day.

You'd be surprised at what warrants a day in internal isolation. It more often than not is not disruptive behaviour.

Comedycook · 07/01/2024 18:09

Redpeonies · 07/01/2024 18:05

..."this is if they skip a detention or commit a serious infringement of the rules."

So what do you suggest for children who don't turn up for detention and commit a serious infringement of the rules?

What about all the children that are trying to learn and concentrate while kids are being disruptive and disobedient?

If a child is disruptive, I'd imagine the absolute worst thing for them is to be made to sit in silence for six hours. I'd suggest part of the problem is they're fizzing with energy and no outlet.

Poppytops88 · 07/01/2024 18:09

Comedycook · 07/01/2024 17:59

At my ds school they have isolation where they sit in silence in one room for the entire day...this is if they skip a detention or commit a serious infringement of the rules.

Now my view is this...we have abolished corporal punishment... thankfully. We don't want to see a return to that...but is what we have replaced it with any better. Ok we're not inflicting physical pain on the kids but sitting I silence in one room for six hours is surely like some sort of psychological torture. Why do we view physical chastisement as being so awful yet psychological chastisement as being fine?

Thing is in my dc school isolation isn't reserved for serious infringements. They get them for minor things such as not being behind the chair at the time of the bell for example, they have 5 mins to get from one lesson to another.

Sherrystrull · 07/01/2024 18:09

Comedycook · 07/01/2024 17:59

At my ds school they have isolation where they sit in silence in one room for the entire day...this is if they skip a detention or commit a serious infringement of the rules.

Now my view is this...we have abolished corporal punishment... thankfully. We don't want to see a return to that...but is what we have replaced it with any better. Ok we're not inflicting physical pain on the kids but sitting I silence in one room for six hours is surely like some sort of psychological torture. Why do we view physical chastisement as being so awful yet psychological chastisement as being fine?

It allows the other children in the class to learn without disruption for a day.

azteccandle · 07/01/2024 18:09

This is why a lot of parents (especially of ND children), are questioning whether sending their kids into that kind of environment every day is the best thing for them.
There are some excellent online school out there - yes, they cost £££ - but they are cheaper than going private and more suited to children that need flexibility.
I've been reading a few articles recently about how parents no longer respect the "contract" between parents and school, and how absences have increased significantly since covid. The contract works both ways. So many of our state schools are no longer fit for purpose - cramming thousands of kids into schools built for half the number and restricting budgets to the point where they can't even maintain the facilities means they need to be run more like prisons that educational institutions just to maintain order.

cansu · 07/01/2024 18:08

I think strict rules around almost all aspects of behaviour in schools has one principal cause - v challenging and disruptive behaviour largely supported or condoned by some parents. Schools now know that they cannot rely on some parents to manage their children or to work with schools and other services to manage them.

Schools are also picking up issues that other services used to offer support with
Police - too ovr stretched to deal with incidents outside school so school deal with them
Social care - inadequate parenting is not seen as a social care issue unless there is serious physical or sexual abuse.
Mental health - camhs not accepting cases or placing on long wait lists. Schools expected to support and offer counselling to children with mental health issues.
Send - huge rise in ND referrals and diagnoses. Schools in some areas being asked to start referrals taking this out of the hands of primary care. Lack of funds to support these children. Difficulty recruiting TAs due to poor pay and conditions.

TripleDaisySummer · 07/01/2024 18:08

Fitandfree · 07/01/2024 17:52

I'm amazed anyone wears a coat! It's very unusual at my son's school. No one wears a jumper either - the boys are still wearing short sleeved shirts and blazer. Rain, snow, or sunshine.

180 days of rain on average - and a lot very heavy.

I think they learn wet and cold is uncomfortable very quickly.

Verbena17 · 07/01/2024 18:07

There’s a way around it - as their parent, write to school (so you have an evidence trail) and describe the unfairness and why your son won’t be doing detentions if they relate to ridiculous and unachievable pyramid-type discipline regimes!
Explain as you have here in very simple terms so they can read it and see how stupid it is!

Unless parents actually do something in high enough numbers, schools will be micromanaging and hyper-focussing on ridiculous behaviour issues that don’t exist, instead of actually teaching kids important things.

Thank goodness my kiddos have now both left the uk schooling system because it’s really not fit for purpose!

fetchacloth · 07/01/2024 18:06

We had rules like this when I was at school in the 1970s.
In fact we had some really strict rules back then such as, no talking until spoken to, walking single file (no running allowed) in the corridors and to stand up when the headteacher entered the room. We certainly couldn't leave the classroom during lessons for loo visits or any other reason, we wouldn't dare ask.

Fast forward to now, schools are much more noisy, discipline is sometimes out of control and the school staff look constantly stressed trying to manage kids' behaviour. I can well understand why headteachers are imposing these measures.

Redpeonies · 07/01/2024 18:05

..."this is if they skip a detention or commit a serious infringement of the rules."

So what do you suggest for children who don't turn up for detention and commit a serious infringement of the rules?

What about all the children that are trying to learn and concentrate while kids are being disruptive and disobedient?

twistyizzy · 07/01/2024 18:05

Comedycook · 07/01/2024 17:59

At my ds school they have isolation where they sit in silence in one room for the entire day...this is if they skip a detention or commit a serious infringement of the rules.

Now my view is this...we have abolished corporal punishment... thankfully. We don't want to see a return to that...but is what we have replaced it with any better. Ok we're not inflicting physical pain on the kids but sitting I silence in one room for six hours is surely like some sort of psychological torture. Why do we view physical chastisement as being so awful yet psychological chastisement as being fine?

The problem is what is the alternative?
Schools don't have enough teaching staff yet alone pastoral staff. How would you deal with these kids without the staff to supervise more personal interactions?
Some of these kids shouldn't even be in mainstream school but there aren't enough specialist schools to take them so how do you suggest mainstream schools deal with them?
I agree with you FYI but just saying "it isn't acceptable" doesn't solve the problem.

UndertheCedartree · 07/01/2024 18:04

ObliviousCoalmine · 07/01/2024 15:33

Of course they do?!

I've made a very specific of making sure I explain and justify why I am setting a boundary or making a rule to my child, regardless of the severity or how obvious the explanation is.

"Your curfew is X time because it is dark by then, the busses are less regular and if I'm late home from work I won't be able to come and get you if the bus doesn't turn up" not, "Be home by X because I said so, don't argue with it or you're not going out at all".

Absolutely no good comes from the "Because I said so approach, in parenting or teaching. It doesn't help them learn to rationalise decisions made by others, it doesn't help them to learn how to work out where their own boundaries are in their own lives. People expect their children to turn into well rounded adults but aren't furnishing them with the logical reasoning and critical thinking skills that they need, all "because they said so".

Completely agree. Some parents expect their DC to all of a sudden make good decisions when they've not spent time supporting them to make decisions!

Comedycook · 07/01/2024 17:59

At my ds school they have isolation where they sit in silence in one room for the entire day...this is if they skip a detention or commit a serious infringement of the rules.

Now my view is this...we have abolished corporal punishment... thankfully. We don't want to see a return to that...but is what we have replaced it with any better. Ok we're not inflicting physical pain on the kids but sitting I silence in one room for six hours is surely like some sort of psychological torture. Why do we view physical chastisement as being so awful yet psychological chastisement as being fine?

Hotchocolate2023 · 07/01/2024 17:55

IHaveAskedYouThriceNow · 07/01/2024 17:50

YANBU.
Local academy do this.
Dd had a breakdown a few years ago because of this approach with a new HT of said academy. 5/6 years on we’re seeing tentative signs of recovery.
Same academy trust has one of the worst track records for exclusions and managing out SN children.

If you treat children like criminals they’ll end up responding and behaving like criminals. It’s honestly like the whole system has lost sight of what children need!

Absolutely!

And as someone else said, detentions become meaningless. If you are going to get a detention for forgetting a pen or telling a teacher to fuck off, you may as well tell a teacher to fuck off. There is nothing proportionate about 2 hour detentions.

I was speaking to a parent friend last week, her DD's school has a 2 minute rules. The DD can't cope with the corridor (autistic) so would walk the long way round the building and arrive a minute or two after. School won't make any adjustment at all as an OT hasn't stated she has an issue with the hallway. She has been getting 2 hour detentions every single day and this is now moving to internal isolation with a threat to move to fixed term exclusions.

Fitandfree · 07/01/2024 17:52

I'm amazed anyone wears a coat! It's very unusual at my son's school. No one wears a jumper either - the boys are still wearing short sleeved shirts and blazer. Rain, snow, or sunshine.

AnneValentine · 07/01/2024 17:52

Whyyoulyingfor · 07/01/2024 17:45

Eh!? So you think it’s okay for a child to be sat with their hood up in class whilst learning? Would you go into a bank and expect the cashier to be doing that? Would you go to the GP and be happy for them to be doing that? It’s basic common courtesy and manners to be dressed and ready to learn (or work) in an appropriate way.

Perhaps you should question your own sanity and not teachers. You are just looking for something to pick fault with. Demonising teachers and schools in a nit picking pathetic way.

Would I think a GP wearing a coat was less able to do their job? Absolutely not. Schools are cold. Unless there is a health and safety risk that means it’s not appropriate I honestly couldn’t care less if the person is doing their job.

I work in a school as a side note and this is not something the vast majority of teaching or other staff would get remotely annoyed by. The few kids that do it are either cold or there is something else going on. They can’t use it as “f you” if you aren’t engaging in some warped power play.

Redpeonies · 07/01/2024 17:51

The whole country has lost sight of what children need and the schools reflect this.

Poppytops88 · 07/01/2024 17:51

Baircasolly · 07/01/2024 17:25

Ted Wragg by any chance?!

We aren't an academy yet but all the secondary schools around here tend to be joining Athena Academy and the rules are all very similar.

IHaveAskedYouThriceNow · 07/01/2024 17:50

YANBU.
Local academy do this.
Dd had a breakdown a few years ago because of this approach with a new HT of said academy. 5/6 years on we’re seeing tentative signs of recovery.
Same academy trust has one of the worst track records for exclusions and managing out SN children.

If you treat children like criminals they’ll end up responding and behaving like criminals. It’s honestly like the whole system has lost sight of what children need!

Redpeonies · 07/01/2024 17:48

Jollyoldfruit · 07/01/2024 17:22

I frequently think about going to school in the 70’s when our skirts were short and everyone including male teachers had long hair.
We were perfectly able to learn and progress regardless. All of these ridiculous rules are only affecting the pupils who naturally follow the rules, the others won’t give a fig.

The population has boomed since the 1970s. This school is a good example, it's managing twice the amount of kids than it was built for. Safety has probably become a much bigger issue, and the logistics of making sure they know where all the kids are.

In the 1970s, although the economy was difficult, socially the country was more stable. The parents of kids in the 1970s were born in the 30s, 40s and 50s, they had different societal expectations. People's fashions may have relaxed but most people were still being raised by their two biological parents and there was still a strong sense of community in most of the country. Kids played outside most of the time.
There were no distractions from the internet, phones, gaming, 24/7 porn all accessible to kids.

Now there are families who haven't had stability for 3 generations. Lots of blended families, ingrained problems, parents who have a very different attitude and level of respect toward teachers. Kids often don't have much extended family or people to turn to with problems.

Some of the most simple things in life in the 1970s can't be taken for granted anymore. Kids come to school with complex problems, many with no attention span and parents (wehther one or two) who have to work full-time. Teachers are expected to pick up the slack.
The result is many schools are overwhelmed, short staffed and underfunded and staff morale is low.

DyslexicPoster · 07/01/2024 17:47

Academies seem to the worst for this. My eldest was a good smart kid but utterly crushed at secondary. Left with great grades and utterly fucked MH.

He never wore a coat.

in contrast his brother is at a private SEN school where behaviour is by nature more funky. The teachers are chummy with the kids, my son told me he can’t even understand how kids can be depressed. Unfortunately his school is extremely unique. Finding the right school for the right kid is hard when all local schools sit under one academy chain. The son at Sen school still gets endless consequences but they do let creativity and uniqueness go.

Whyyoulyingfor · 07/01/2024 17:45

AnneValentine · 07/01/2024 16:18

Exactly! Or even just cold.

perhaps parents should consider why some teachers care.

Eh!? So you think it’s okay for a child to be sat with their hood up in class whilst learning? Would you go into a bank and expect the cashier to be doing that? Would you go to the GP and be happy for them to be doing that? It’s basic common courtesy and manners to be dressed and ready to learn (or work) in an appropriate way.

Perhaps you should question your own sanity and not teachers. You are just looking for something to pick fault with. Demonising teachers and schools in a nit picking pathetic way.

EveraGM · 07/01/2024 17:41

MissMelanieH · 07/01/2024 16:43

It's the trend in secondary schools at the moment, zero tolerance Michaela type discipline.
Meanwhile the trend in primary is a Dix-type nurture and attachment style ethos.
Which leads to a massive disconnect for pupils who are launched from one to another then excluded if they fail to cope.
Plus, all these detentions for wearing coats and dropping pencils. What is the consequence for really serious behaviour then because surely detentions lose all their power if over-used.

I agree to an extent, except even with the Paul Dix approach, primary PERM EX and suspensions has risen massively too.

High need pupils, breakdown at home, lack of support for families, lack of rules and expectations at home, screen time, poor language….a real mix of reasons.

Swipe left for the next trending thread