Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder what has happened to my Son's school

989 replies

k2493 · 07/01/2024 11:09

Just posting for thoughts

Both my kids have gone through the same secondary school. When my daughter started, the school was lovely and new with around 750 kids.

Fast forward to 2024 and there is now 1500 kids and it's become like a dictatorship.

Due to the number of kids, the school has put lines either side of the hallway that they have to walk within otherwise they get detention.

Every hallway is a one way system.

The minute they arrive in school, they have to remove their coats or it's detention even with no heating in the middle of winter. The other day my son arrived back to school to find that there were long queues outside while they did two uniform checks at the door. By the time he got in, he was frozen. Immediately he got shouted at for still having his coat on even though he had just stepped in from the cold.

He then went around the corner and got shouted at again even though he tried to explain it's really difficult to be expected to stay warm, keep moving and remove your coat all at the same time. Nope. Threaten with detention again.

AIBU to wonder what has happened to our education system? I'm lucky in that my son is quite strong minded and just brushes it off but what about the kids who's mental health this is impacting? Surely we want our kids to remember school as being enjoyable for their education and friendships rather than for being shouted at every two minutes for not walking between lines or not taking their coats off the minute they arrive in school?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
11
BananaSplitsss · 07/01/2024 22:34

Goatymum · 07/01/2024 11:57

Re the blue suit/tan shoes. I recently worked in a school and a member of SLT sprung to mind immediately! I didn’t know it was a ‘thing’.

Perhaps it was our school ? Wouldn’t surprise me.
The SLT are horrible. All blokes in navy suits and tan shoes swinging their dicks about.

Pricks the lot of them.

grafittiartist · 07/01/2024 22:33

Reasons might be:
Isolation room silent- has to be as it's got a group of poorly behaved kids all together in one room.
Detention for no equipment- I can't tell you how much of a lesson is lost to borrowing pencils- no responsibility for being ready.
One way system- so much safer.
Indoor coats off in classrooms - why have a uniform if it's covered with a jacket.

When you have huge numbers of pupils, rules have to be really pedantic and clear.

UndertheCedartree · 07/01/2024 22:30

twistyizzy · 07/01/2024 18:05

The problem is what is the alternative?
Schools don't have enough teaching staff yet alone pastoral staff. How would you deal with these kids without the staff to supervise more personal interactions?
Some of these kids shouldn't even be in mainstream school but there aren't enough specialist schools to take them so how do you suggest mainstream schools deal with them?
I agree with you FYI but just saying "it isn't acceptable" doesn't solve the problem.

Well, the points you raise are exactly what needs changing. We can't just shrug our shoulders and except schools being so underfunded and no SEN school places. But isolation doesn't need to be used as a punishment. It has only got to that in the schools that give an after school detention for forgetting a ruler or being hot so needing to take your jumper off. Then where do they go with a serious infringement? Stop pushing well- behaved Y7s into not caring anymore.

k2493 · 07/01/2024 22:25

Dogsandchocolaterule I'm sorry but your response is everything that is wrong with why so many are struggling with mental health and everything that is wrong with this country.

Read the many posts that say what possible implication does it have if they wear a coat to stay warm if they are still learning or have a different coloured hairband. There are far too many generalisations on here that so many kids misbehave and it's the parents fault.

I have friends who teach at private schools and the kids are worse than public schools so I'm sorry but I'm aughing about this.

For those taking knifes to school, I agree that this is a major concern but punishing kids for wearing coats is ridiculous.

I dread to think what the future looks like with so many Mental Health issues already identified.

Do you we really need to resort to isolations and detentions for stupid reasons because I'm sorry but in the scheme of things, they are stupid reasons.

Clearly you support a dictatorship. I don't. I think as said by many others there are other ways of making a system work, the system clearly isn't working and perhaps it's time to start looking. If something isn't working at work, it gets fixed or changed until it does so why aren't we giving our kids the same benefit if so many are struggling with the current system?

As for my son, how rude. He is really behaved at school verified by his teachers all the time and is a A stream student. What is not accepted is making life impossible for no reason. I would love to see how you would cope if it were you in that situation but as always there is always one who thinks they are better than everyone else.

OP posts:
UndertheCedartree · 07/01/2024 22:24

Redpeonies · 07/01/2024 18:05

..."this is if they skip a detention or commit a serious infringement of the rules."

So what do you suggest for children who don't turn up for detention and commit a serious infringement of the rules?

What about all the children that are trying to learn and concentrate while kids are being disruptive and disobedient?

Don't push the well behaved pupils to the point that detention means nothing and they just don't care anymore. These are not just generally disobedient and disruptive pupils. These are 11 yo kids who aren't coping.

My DD has never had any type of detention. But if she was late for school (without exceptional reason) she would have a break time detention. Low level misbehaviour ' behaviour points', but she can also be rewarded with house points. Something more serious, a detention at lunchtime and for something really serious an after school detention. They have no need for isolation at her school. Disruption is almost nonexistent at her school and it has a reputation for being extremely well-behaved. With no need for a detention for being hot and taking your jumper off!

Gingerbee · 07/01/2024 22:19

cansu · 07/01/2024 18:08

I think strict rules around almost all aspects of behaviour in schools has one principal cause - v challenging and disruptive behaviour largely supported or condoned by some parents. Schools now know that they cannot rely on some parents to manage their children or to work with schools and other services to manage them.

Schools are also picking up issues that other services used to offer support with
Police - too ovr stretched to deal with incidents outside school so school deal with them
Social care - inadequate parenting is not seen as a social care issue unless there is serious physical or sexual abuse.
Mental health - camhs not accepting cases or placing on long wait lists. Schools expected to support and offer counselling to children with mental health issues.
Send - huge rise in ND referrals and diagnoses. Schools in some areas being asked to start referrals taking this out of the hands of primary care. Lack of funds to support these children. Difficulty recruiting TAs due to poor pay and conditions.

Very accurate

UndertheCedartree · 07/01/2024 22:16

And their behaviour is getting worse because they are giving up and just not caring anymore. All well behaved at Primary.

Gingerbee · 07/01/2024 22:16

HugoDarracott · 07/01/2024 11:19

Absolutely standard practice these days. I bet the senior staff are all ex PE teachers wearing navy suits and tan shoes.

Made me laugh out loud. So true

UndertheCedartree · 07/01/2024 22:15

Comedycook · 07/01/2024 17:59

At my ds school they have isolation where they sit in silence in one room for the entire day...this is if they skip a detention or commit a serious infringement of the rules.

Now my view is this...we have abolished corporal punishment... thankfully. We don't want to see a return to that...but is what we have replaced it with any better. Ok we're not inflicting physical pain on the kids but sitting I silence in one room for six hours is surely like some sort of psychological torture. Why do we view physical chastisement as being so awful yet psychological chastisement as being fine?

I agree. This is awful. And comes from detentions meaning nothing so they have to find harsher means. At my Dd's school, after school detention is for serious issues and so they don't have to resort to isolation. Her friend's at the schools like that are all struggling. It's heartbreaking. I regular have one of them bursting into tears when over at mine.

greengreengrass25 · 07/01/2024 22:13

Iwasafool · 07/01/2024 22:03

I used to work in a town where a senior school decided to do away with uniforms. Behaviour in the town became terrible, kids fighting, damaging plants and trees, all sorts. I spoke to a group who were pulling branches off a tree, I said I was going to ring the school to report their behaviour and they replied that I didn't know where they went to school as they didn't have uniforms.

I explained that there was only one senior school in the town so I knew perfectly well where they went to school. They were speechless. Didn't give me a high opinion of their intelligence but I did laugh at them.

Sometimes the non uniform is worse for those who aren't wearing the right designer items anyway

justasmalltownmum · 07/01/2024 22:06

Worked at a school almost identical to this.
The building is too small for that many kids. They have to make it one way to prevent them all barging into eachother.
The coat thing is just strange.
Uniform checks are expected - as a lot of kids started wearing trainers.

Iwasafool · 07/01/2024 22:03

I used to work in a town where a senior school decided to do away with uniforms. Behaviour in the town became terrible, kids fighting, damaging plants and trees, all sorts. I spoke to a group who were pulling branches off a tree, I said I was going to ring the school to report their behaviour and they replied that I didn't know where they went to school as they didn't have uniforms.

I explained that there was only one senior school in the town so I knew perfectly well where they went to school. They were speechless. Didn't give me a high opinion of their intelligence but I did laugh at them.

Wisenotboring · 07/01/2024 21:59

Massive schools with draconian measures as the only way to exert control on children. It's a race to the bottom. My child was totally traumatised in Y7.

enchantedsquirrelwood · 07/01/2024 21:58

Asking students to have only indoor clothes on when indoors, whatever next

But why does it matter? In what way does it "impact" teaching and learning?

Why create an environment where teachers are having to worry about this nonsense? Let the kids wear what they want if they are cold (or hot).

The one way system point is different and makes perfect sense (it could be replicated on pavements, too Grin )

CecilyP · 07/01/2024 21:49

Isolation is actually sitting in a classroom with a few other kids and a teacher doing your work quietly. You have breaks and can speak to the teacher if you need help. It is not exactly torture.

In many schools it is and it can be a useful resource for dealing with pupils being disruptive in class. In other schools it is exactly how the PP described.

UndertheCedartree · 07/01/2024 21:39

This reply has been deleted

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

Completely different around here. The schools that follow this approach are all the inadequate/requires improvement schools. The schools that do well are the ones that don't follow this. The bad schools seem to be clutching at straws, sadly.

ThinkAboutItTomorrow · 07/01/2024 21:34

LittleMG · 07/01/2024 21:05

I don’t think people realise how bad behaviour is in school and I think this is schools trying to address this.

I don't understand how giving after school detention for forgetting a ruler does this?

Taking firm action to manage poor behaviour is fair enough but terrifying good kids and punishing easy to make mistakes is just stupid & counter productive.

Dogsandchocolaterule · 07/01/2024 21:34

These threads make me laugh.

A one way system is sensible in a school otherwise crushes can happen.

Asking students to have only indoor clothes on when indoors, whatever next? Follow rules and be quiet? Goodness!

You all want students to have lovely learning environments, relaxed atmospheres, schools to be fun, but also turn on the schools if there is bullying, someone is injured in the corridors, students get detentions.

If you hate schools so much don't send them, homeschool them and do the amazingly great job yourself. It isn't the law to send them to school, you can always home educate.

If you want to send them to the school, support the teachers and follow the rules or remove them. Don't send them, get free childcare and moan when they instill their own rules.

OP your son sounds defiant and deserves a detention too.

UndertheCedartree · 07/01/2024 21:32

gerispringer · 07/01/2024 17:13

Poor diddums not being allowed to wear coats whenever they like. Yes it is disruptive when kids amble into lessons with coats on, hoods up like they are just going out for a winter walk. Lessons should be about learning, being prepared shouldn’t take 10-15 minutes off the lesson time. Oh - but it’s the teachers fault for not making the lesson “engaging “, hard to do that when kids are dressed for outdoors, fail to bring the books, equipment needed and generally don’t give a stuff. There should be no need for kids to be in outdoor wear indoors in a stuffy classroom. It’s almost never so cold you’d have to wear coats/ hats / gloves inside, if it was that cold they should be sent home. Yes the big coats are used as a cover for phone messaging, vape hiding and the rest.

Wouldn't some priority made for lockers help though so coats can be put away when DC arrive at school? Getting the coats right out of the way if they cause so many problems?

AnneValentine · 07/01/2024 21:29

Redpeonies · 07/01/2024 20:26

@AnneValentine well that's exactly why I invited you to share, it would be fantastic.

Share what? That an exclusionary approach helps no one? That rather than punishing kids look at the cause of the behaviour. What are they trying to tell you. It’s not rocket science. Teenager needs to wear their coat for a lesson. No problem. If they aren’t engaging in learning that’s a separate issue.

UndertheCedartree · 07/01/2024 21:28

Thegoodbadandugly · 07/01/2024 17:09

I guess it's very difficult these days, in the old days you stepped out of line you got the cane, you didn't dare misbehave and if you did get in trouble at school you also got it in the neck when you got home as well.

These days it's so incredibly difficult for schools to discipline children and also it's not just the children it's the parents, my little Jimmy is an angel he doesn't do any wrong when in actual fact little Jimmy is a right royal pain in the arse and nobody can learn because he's being so disruptive. It's a fine line. Unfortunately due to the few many have to suffer and it's sad.

Edited

In my day, the cane wasn't allowed. Teachers managed. The same way the teachers at my Dd's school manage. There is no disruption in her classes. Clearly, the Tories have wrecked education but the struggling schools all going down this strange path is clearly not helping by all the teachers saying they get hit, swore at etc. It's clearly not working. These schools need to look at the schools that are doing well and see what they are doing that is right.

wildlifeWalker · 07/01/2024 21:20

Comedycook · 07/01/2024 19:10

There's a secondary school near me that is known for being extremely easy going...it is very very over subscribed. My ds knows a couple of boys who go there and he says they're the only kids he knows who don't dread school on Monday morning

I'll bet their results are better too!
Is it still a state school?

UndertheCedartree · 07/01/2024 21:08

fullcirclearoundourstar · 07/01/2024 17:08

And yet we call them by their first names, have no school uniforms and my childrens head master was always dressed in ripped jeans and an old t-shirt.

I think this thread shows that many people might have more respect for schools if they were more like that!

Besides, plenty of people respect education and teachers. But I know many parents are finding their DC's schools harder to respect due to the rise in controlling rules such as not allowing hot DC to take their jumper off.

Redpeonies · 07/01/2024 21:05

Exactly @SequoiaTree it's always unfair to compare any kind of selective school (private, grammer, for the gifted) against one that cannot select.
Also size, location and pupil intake (i.e. income, class, family stability etc) should be comparable.

It's a no-brainer that a smaller school in a stable community with less social and economic problems, in a school district with a generous education budget, is likely to have very different issues than a school 3x as big with less resources.

It's essential to compare like with like.

LittleMG · 07/01/2024 21:05

I don’t think people realise how bad behaviour is in school and I think this is schools trying to address this.

Swipe left for the next trending thread