Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder what has happened to my Son's school

989 replies

k2493 · 07/01/2024 11:09

Just posting for thoughts

Both my kids have gone through the same secondary school. When my daughter started, the school was lovely and new with around 750 kids.

Fast forward to 2024 and there is now 1500 kids and it's become like a dictatorship.

Due to the number of kids, the school has put lines either side of the hallway that they have to walk within otherwise they get detention.

Every hallway is a one way system.

The minute they arrive in school, they have to remove their coats or it's detention even with no heating in the middle of winter. The other day my son arrived back to school to find that there were long queues outside while they did two uniform checks at the door. By the time he got in, he was frozen. Immediately he got shouted at for still having his coat on even though he had just stepped in from the cold.

He then went around the corner and got shouted at again even though he tried to explain it's really difficult to be expected to stay warm, keep moving and remove your coat all at the same time. Nope. Threaten with detention again.

AIBU to wonder what has happened to our education system? I'm lucky in that my son is quite strong minded and just brushes it off but what about the kids who's mental health this is impacting? Surely we want our kids to remember school as being enjoyable for their education and friendships rather than for being shouted at every two minutes for not walking between lines or not taking their coats off the minute they arrive in school?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
11
UndertheCedartree · 09/01/2024 17:38

Natsku · 09/01/2024 14:57

That is really shit for the children. When I was in my first secondary school we could eat in our tutor rooms, the rooms had to be cleaned anyway (but we were responsible for emptying the bin) so not a reason to stop us eating there. In my second school there was plenty of room in the canteen and some teachers let you eat in their classrooms (though the deputy head cracked down on that at one point, locking the corridor doors, we actually got locked in which in hindsight was quite dangerous). Me and my friends often ate in the music practice rooms.

At Dd's school there is quite a large canteen to eat in and lots of outside seating areas too. But if raining/snowing then they can eat in their form rooms too so there is more indoor space to eat.

UndertheCedartree · 09/01/2024 17:34

TripleDaisySummer · 09/01/2024 14:39

No.

If it's really horrific weather they may open hall or sport hall or both - but it's really rare now and otherwise it's outside unless they can find a group occurring in lunchtime even library isn't allowed till Y11. The groups/activities can suddenly stop as well - they all stopped for a few week last term.

However at minute they are not allowed to eat inside building other than too small canteen at all and reason given to parents is it led to increased cleaning costs when this happened so blanket ban.

It may relax as year goes on - but has upset DD2 and many of her friends this last term.

That's such a shame they can't even go to the library. DD loves spending time in the library at break or lunch reading.

The thing is of course eating will cause cleaning to be needed but that doesn't mean they can just not provide enough space for lunch because it will need cleaning!

VegetablesFightingToReclaimTheAubergieneEmoji · 09/01/2024 17:34

Yes to the short lunch breaks. Mine don’t bother eating at school. They can’t get and eat lunch, packed lunches are stuffed in their bag all day so not favourable.
they come home ravenous and eat shit. None of that is favourable.

Verbena17 · 09/01/2024 17:29

Grammarnut · 09/01/2024 16:11

The environment you both describe works fine for nice middle class children from supportive homes who have access to lots of opportunities. It is useless in a school where many children live in unsupportive homes, are not fed breakfast, have families with no interest in education or reading etc. and set no boundaries on their children. In that situation, uniform, rules, detentions etc are the bulwark against chaos, as are exclusions, and these things allow the children who do want to work and progress, because the disruptive elements are removed.

‘Nice middle class children? 🤔
I didn’t say where my school or what the children were like.
Your reply was sweeping and judgemental.

I think there is always a way to engage the children you speak of above - perhaps it’s the one size fits all approach & not enough time and kindness by MATS & teaching staff today that creates barriers to learning for ANY child ….not only those who come from families who you seem to think cannot be bothered enough with their children.

If modern schools were more child focussed (and please don’t say they are because they’re not), I think the children you speak of would prove to be much more than just the background you say they’re coming from.

Verbena17 · 09/01/2024 17:17

dontbenastyhaveapasty · 09/01/2024 13:24

My son’s school is like this. It’s totally counter-productive and ridiculous.

We live in a rural area, there is only one secondary school for miles around and it serves the entire community. It’s always been a nice school with no major behaviour problems, no gangs, no knives. Intake predominantly working class, 80% of kids probably aspire to be mechanics/plumbers/farmers and 20% or so probably interested in university and a “professional” career.

Now it’s run by an academy trust and the head of “school improvement” is a Michaela School type. She marches around the school shouting at people, marches into lessons and orders kids to “reflection” (over the head of the class teacher) if she deems them to be sitting incorrectly or failing to have their eyes tracking the teacher in the correct manner. Reflection is an isolation room overseen by a member of staff who is ex-police. The children have to chant slogans in tutor time at the start of the day. Lunch is a 20min break with nowhere to sit down to eat. No fun is permitted at any time. Academic attainment in maths and English is the only thing that matters, and God help anyone not naturally academic, they are no longer wanted in the school.

What exactly is the point of it all? Even as the parent of a well behaved and naturally academic child, this kind of punitive culture is the opposite of what I want for my child. For the kids who are never going to get As or ever wear a suit to work, the whole thing is so alien it’s insanity. No wonder truancy and absence rates are through the roof.

It’s awful. MATS don't realise it’s the kiddos who don’t go to uni that will be training to do really important jobs - everybody needs plumbers, builders, electricians, cooks. Everything is about pushing to get super high academic grades when in reality, if there’s nobody left to do the ‘perceived as mundane jobs’, we’ll all be up shit creek without a paddle!

ThinkAboutItTomorrow · 09/01/2024 17:16

So excuses I've heard on this thread:

  1. Not having equipment disrupts lessons so is a big problem.

So the natural justice is the child has to manage without the equipment and catch up at home. If the ruler was needed to underline a heading they do it at home. That's proportionate. An hour after school detention isn't.
If the real issue is the child is being disruptive then punish that. Don't punish not having a ruler.

  1. Kids are all nightmares and parents are misguided in thinking theirs are angels.

If teachers were telling me my DD was a pain and disruptive or rude I would be 100% supportive of the teacher. But they aren't, they tell me she's a great kid / joy to teach / really conscientious/ got one of the highest attainment points scores. She gets multiple awards for hard work in maths and English, like weekly top of her class for trying hard etc. yet the rules are making her hate school and affecting her attendance.

This is a very privileged middle class area, in the top 10 in the Uk state school rankings, ofsted outstanding and yet parents are pulling their kids out because of the new behaviour policy.

It's a problem.

Pottedpalm · 09/01/2024 16:28

HelpIcantfindaname · 07/01/2024 11:25

In my DDs school coats must be taken off & put in bags before entering the building. They can't even carry coats inside. So they have to remove coats while they queue to go in. She carries so many books in her bag her coat doesn't fit in it. So she doesn't take one. That means she's wearing the same clothes on a freezing winters day as on a hot summer day. Luckily she gets dropped off & picked up most days so only has a 10min walk to the car park. But she has no coat for lunchtimes. Their dress code is crazy. Lots of detentions for boys with hair past their collars, girls with hair not tied back tightly enough. I agree with uniforms, but I think the coat rule is ridiculous. The staff are all dressed warmly. And there seems to be new rules each year.

It’s not a ‘ no coats’ rule though, it’s no coats inside. So.. take a big enough bag?
The staff are warmly dressed? Good for them. You know teachers in general have no say over these policies?

MrsMurphyIWish · 09/01/2024 16:22

A lot of the issues I see in school due to the sheer sizes of them. When I first started teaching in 2000 my largest class size (too set) was 25 and bottom set would be 15. My largest class size is now 34 and my bottom set is 30. We try to meet individual needs but with so many pupils, it is difficult.

The environment also contributes to behaviour. My Victorian school was originally a 4 form entry, it’s now a 7 form entry. We can build extra blocks but we can’t widen the corridors or plumbing! Pupils can’t eat inside as we have a staggered timetable for each Key Stage. There is never any free space. My workroom was originally a locker room but we got rid of them 6 years ago for extra workspace or classrooms. We don’t have a Staffroom for instance, that’s now a classroom.

Children are unhappy and so are staff. Just so you know OP, I hate uniform. I am always the “bad guy” trying to enforce rules set by SLT who hide in their offices.

Grammarnut · 09/01/2024 16:11

Verbena17 · 09/01/2024 12:44

My school was exactly the same!
We respected almost every single teacher and they could have a bit of banter with us and we chatted about all sorts of interesting things, Friday afternoon quizzes if we worked hard during the week etc.

Now though there seems to be simply no time for anything other 100% full on slog and very little fun.

The environment you both describe works fine for nice middle class children from supportive homes who have access to lots of opportunities. It is useless in a school where many children live in unsupportive homes, are not fed breakfast, have families with no interest in education or reading etc. and set no boundaries on their children. In that situation, uniform, rules, detentions etc are the bulwark against chaos, as are exclusions, and these things allow the children who do want to work and progress, because the disruptive elements are removed.

Grammarnut · 09/01/2024 16:00

LarkspurLane · 07/01/2024 11:20

Mine have had to remove coats and have had a one way system for years. My kids have managed to avoid getting into trouble, they are fairly good boys.
However, this school year has been a nightmare, they are pulled up for every minor thing and this is unfortunately has led to them being unhappy at school and then getting into more trouble.
Whatever the school is doing to address behaviour might be working for the majority but not for my kids. I can't wait for them to leave.

What are 'minor things' though? Not having the correct equipment is not minor, it will disrupt the entire class whilst being sorted out and opens the gates to other students 'borrowing' equipment = bad discipline. Talking in the corridor, if against the rules, is not minor, either. And if the 'minor' things are let go then it is a sadly short step to the sort of disruption that can be caused by 'needing to go to the loo in classtime' - a nightmare - and disruption in both corridor and classroom. Not minor.

Grammarnut · 09/01/2024 15:56

Rycbar · 07/01/2024 11:25

A one way system is sensible in a school that size. The amount of injuries I had and saw from my days in high school from the crushes at the bottom of the stairs and in corridors was ridiculous! However everything else sounds a bit mental. Has behaviour got worse at the school since the numbers have grown? It sounds like the headteacher is trying to clamp down on it but probably going the wrong way about it!

Sounds like the right way. I hope they enforce bringing correct equipment in as well, and do not allow teachers to dish out pens/pencils to those who forget. Dishing out pencils to 'forgetful' students is a discipline problem, because the students doing this intend to cause a problem and it holds the whole class up. Every school I have ever worked in had a 'walk on the left' rule, good schools will also have a 'silence in the corridor' rule as well and enforce it. The OP's school does not sound especially oppressive but there must have been a discipline problem originally to have teachers on patrol telling students to take off their coats etc.

Natsku · 09/01/2024 14:57

That is really shit for the children. When I was in my first secondary school we could eat in our tutor rooms, the rooms had to be cleaned anyway (but we were responsible for emptying the bin) so not a reason to stop us eating there. In my second school there was plenty of room in the canteen and some teachers let you eat in their classrooms (though the deputy head cracked down on that at one point, locking the corridor doors, we actually got locked in which in hindsight was quite dangerous). Me and my friends often ate in the music practice rooms.

TripleDaisySummer · 09/01/2024 14:39

UndertheCedartree · 09/01/2024 14:26

So they can't even go in their form rooms if it's raining?

No.

If it's really horrific weather they may open hall or sport hall or both - but it's really rare now and otherwise it's outside unless they can find a group occurring in lunchtime even library isn't allowed till Y11. The groups/activities can suddenly stop as well - they all stopped for a few week last term.

However at minute they are not allowed to eat inside building other than too small canteen at all and reason given to parents is it led to increased cleaning costs when this happened so blanket ban.

It may relax as year goes on - but has upset DD2 and many of her friends this last term.

UndertheCedartree · 09/01/2024 14:28

BettyBakesCakes · 09/01/2024 14:08

One of Dd's friends wasn't allowed to take off her blazer when it was boiling in the first week of her secondary. She has ASD and sensory issues so being boiling hot was very distressing for her. She didn't want to go back in after that.

This is disability discrimination. And yet again shows why such policies are unacceptable.

This school honestly doesn't care about reasonable adjustments. It's our catchment school and when looking at schools for my DD I spoke to them and they were just not interested. And it's not even a big school!

UndertheCedartree · 09/01/2024 14:26

TripleDaisySummer · 09/01/2024 14:08

I agree, breaks are so important - as is having somewhere to sit down to eat! There are about 50 places to sit at a table, for around 1300 pupils. I’ve raised it with the school, who claim the pupils “prefer” to stand around outside and eat standing up! Or, in my son’s case, just eat a biscuit or snack and not his actual lunch - and I know of lots of children who basically don’t eat lunch at all.

We have same issue with no seats for eating - I've had to modify what I send DD2 in with - small easy to eat morsels.

For a time she managed by eating in clubs but due to cleaning they've stopped this - and no they have to eat before or after - but they know canteen isn't big enough yet provide no where else.

It's when it wet it upsets her most - there little shelter and they all fight for it - worse case it's standing up in rain eating.

They get 15 minutes mid morning and 1.30 30 minutes lunch break that clubs and revision classes are held in - many teachers used to turn blind eye to eating but SLT came down hard on that and do random inspections. I did used to wonder why last year DS and her were walking in - we're not far from school - and rushing to toilets and then basically eating their lunch. It's been even worse this last term ever more restrictions.

So they can't even go in their form rooms if it's raining?

UndertheCedartree · 09/01/2024 14:23

dontbenastyhaveapasty · 09/01/2024 13:56

@Natsku they get a 30min morning break, at 11:20, which many use for an early lunch break - the food servery is open both breaks. The second break is at 13:40.

I agree, breaks are so important - as is having somewhere to sit down to eat! There are about 50 places to sit at a table, for around 1300 pupils. I’ve raised it with the school, who claim the pupils “prefer” to stand around outside and eat standing up! Or, in my son’s case, just eat a biscuit or snack and not his actual lunch - and I know of lots of children who basically don’t eat lunch at all.

The illogical nature of the whole thing makes me even more frustrated - it is surely impossible to be unaware that hungry children do not learn well. The academy trust is obsessed with attainment, yet apparently incapable of any positive practical action that would boost it, such as ensuring every child can actually sit and eat a hot meal between 8:40 and 3:20…

And have every student been given a questionnaire asking if they prefer eating standing up or sitting down? How exactly are you meant to eat a proper meal standing up?

UndertheCedartree · 09/01/2024 14:19

Natsku · 09/01/2024 13:36

That sounds horrific @dontbenastyhaveapasty only 20 minute break for lunch? How much other breaks do they get? (lack of breaks I think is another contributing factor to poor behaviour - children and teenagers need regular breaks to let off steam, so they can manage to behave better in class. They get 15 minutes every 45 minutes here, or half an hour after a 1.5h lesson. I bet that's one of the factors that helps with behaviour here so less rules are needed)

Yes, that's a good point. My DD gets 20 minutes at break after her first 1hr 40 min lesson, then 1 hour for lunch after her second lesson. Then a final lesson before home time.

UndertheCedartree · 09/01/2024 14:16

dontbenastyhaveapasty · 09/01/2024 13:24

My son’s school is like this. It’s totally counter-productive and ridiculous.

We live in a rural area, there is only one secondary school for miles around and it serves the entire community. It’s always been a nice school with no major behaviour problems, no gangs, no knives. Intake predominantly working class, 80% of kids probably aspire to be mechanics/plumbers/farmers and 20% or so probably interested in university and a “professional” career.

Now it’s run by an academy trust and the head of “school improvement” is a Michaela School type. She marches around the school shouting at people, marches into lessons and orders kids to “reflection” (over the head of the class teacher) if she deems them to be sitting incorrectly or failing to have their eyes tracking the teacher in the correct manner. Reflection is an isolation room overseen by a member of staff who is ex-police. The children have to chant slogans in tutor time at the start of the day. Lunch is a 20min break with nowhere to sit down to eat. No fun is permitted at any time. Academic attainment in maths and English is the only thing that matters, and God help anyone not naturally academic, they are no longer wanted in the school.

What exactly is the point of it all? Even as the parent of a well behaved and naturally academic child, this kind of punitive culture is the opposite of what I want for my child. For the kids who are never going to get As or ever wear a suit to work, the whole thing is so alien it’s insanity. No wonder truancy and absence rates are through the roof.

I just don't see how 20 minutes for lunch is a good thing? Again, it's just crowd control. I like DD to be able to have a full hour for lunch. To eat, socialise, go to clubs and have a proper break ready for the afternoon. It's just sad that schools/trusts/government don't see the value in that.

BettyBakesCakes · 09/01/2024 14:15

The blame lies at the door of government.

Absolutely agree with this.

As well as the insane rules, isolations for no real reason, lack of RAs, and all the other stuff mentioned in here, the whole education system needs an overhaul. Less focus on academic attainment by Ofsted and more on a well rounded curriculum with happy, attaining and attending students, more funding, more resources, more access to quick and consistent support for those who need it, less pressure on school staff. The whole system is a mess.

UndertheCedartree · 09/01/2024 14:10

AllMyGoodUserNamesAreAlreadyTaken · 09/01/2024 12:33

@UndertheCedartree yes these things should technically come under reasonable adjustments ...but the problem is there are 2000 students in DD's schools and I've no idea how many staff (but it's a lot)
Because of the standardised approach the staff now take, all students are treated as guilty from the off and once she's already been shouted at for not complying or being late, this increases her anxiety and she can't explain she has exceptions permission. She becomes mute when overwhelmed, anxious and then tries to flee. She's in fight or flight mode and can't even use her communication cards or permission slips to show staff.
I do realise with so many staff and so many pupils, it must be impossible for them to remember who has exemptions and for what & they do have my sympathy. I also realise that somehow DD (& young people like her) need to find effective ways of communication as this is preparation for life in the wider world but because her anxiety is so high as it is, this approach just makes her even more fearful and stressed. It's a catch 22.
She desperately wants to be home ed which ultimately we (& professionals) feel would further increase her withdrawing into herself and her sense of isolation too. There are no small secondary schools near us which she might cope better in. Her medical/physical health is poor and travelling each day to a school that's well over an hour away from home isn't an option as she is exhausted as is and frequently needs pain relief, blood sugars monitoring etc. She has 1:1 TA's for lessons but as she is cognitively typical, she doesn't want them with her at break times or in the corridors as she feels this marks her out even further as different to her peers.
We have under the guidance of health professionals now medicated her for anxiety but 6 weeks in, things are no better. She was up till midnight panicking last night and then up again at 2am. The taxi arrived 20 mins late this morning which sent her into meltdown and on the back foot from the off. So far I've had 4 phone calls from school and it's not even lunchtime. It's like watching my DD wither and shrivel into herself. I fully except this isn't schools fault by itself and my daughter has high levels of need but the fact that pupils are generally treated as a mass commodity just doesn't help.

Oh bless her. My DD would not being able to cope in that environment either. It is so frustrating now that often there is no choice of secondary school and you just have to put up with what you get even if it doesn't suit your DC atall.

BettyBakesCakes · 09/01/2024 14:08

One of Dd's friends wasn't allowed to take off her blazer when it was boiling in the first week of her secondary. She has ASD and sensory issues so being boiling hot was very distressing for her. She didn't want to go back in after that.

This is disability discrimination. And yet again shows why such policies are unacceptable.

TripleDaisySummer · 09/01/2024 14:08

I agree, breaks are so important - as is having somewhere to sit down to eat! There are about 50 places to sit at a table, for around 1300 pupils. I’ve raised it with the school, who claim the pupils “prefer” to stand around outside and eat standing up! Or, in my son’s case, just eat a biscuit or snack and not his actual lunch - and I know of lots of children who basically don’t eat lunch at all.

We have same issue with no seats for eating - I've had to modify what I send DD2 in with - small easy to eat morsels.

For a time she managed by eating in clubs but due to cleaning they've stopped this - and no they have to eat before or after - but they know canteen isn't big enough yet provide no where else.

It's when it wet it upsets her most - there little shelter and they all fight for it - worse case it's standing up in rain eating.

They get 15 minutes mid morning and 1.30 30 minutes lunch break that clubs and revision classes are held in - many teachers used to turn blind eye to eating but SLT came down hard on that and do random inspections. I did used to wonder why last year DS and her were walking in - we're not far from school - and rushing to toilets and then basically eating their lunch. It's been even worse this last term ever more restrictions.

UndertheCedartree · 09/01/2024 14:05

twistyizzy · 09/01/2024 12:05

@Poppytops88 exactly and then if Ofsted were in and saw that the school would get downgraded for Behaviour and Attitide.
A lot posters on here just haven't got a clue, including about how their own perfect DC behave in school!

A lot of us are teachers and recognise the problems!

UndertheCedartree · 09/01/2024 14:04

Poppytops88 · 09/01/2024 12:03

Went to collect something to reception today at 9.30 to collect something at my dc secondary. Two girls were just rocking up 45mins late, they just didn't care at all, no sorry just really rude, no alpologies, reason for lateness. The staff were kind but told them they were now to go straight to isolation. I could really see what they're up against. As I left some kids were just casually walking up the hill to school!

See, I think this shows how this extreme punishment of isolation for being late simply doesn't work.

At my Dd's school they get a break time detention for lateness and hardly any are late and all very polite and apologetic for being late.

If you aren't even going to get into a lesson but just go straight to isolation if late then you're not going to bother rushing to get in as soon as possible.

UndertheCedartree · 09/01/2024 14:00

MondieBee · 09/01/2024 11:48

I keep hearing behaviour is worse therefore secondary schools are having to come down harder, but I can't help wondering if some of the correlation is the other way.

If you introduce lots of arbitrary, nonsense rules and enforce them with lots of shouting and detentions, you're creating many more opportunities for rule breaking and therefore shouting and detentions, making it feel like behaviour is terrible. Therefore as a school you come down harder, making the original issue worse, and using the increased number of detentions as evidence that behaviour is worsening. This must create a ridiculous race to the bottom. It's clearly not working.

The navy suit, tan shoes description absolutely nails it.

I work with looked after children and don't get me started on the absolute lack of understanding of trauma and the expectations they place on teens who have moved placement 8 times in 2 years etc is ridiculous.

I blame schemes like teach first, I think many now senior staff did useless degrees, didn't know what to do with their lives, had inferiority complexes, ended up doing their one year teacher training and went into a job they didn't really enjoy. Very few are passionate educators, interested in child development and aware of adolescent brain development.

Combine a workforce that's got a high percentage of staff who don't really see teaching as a vocation with the endless funding cuts and the introduction of academies with the across the board rules (regardless of school demographic) and it's no surprise secondary education particularly is an utter shit show.

That's the thing. This trend has been around for a while and all I hear is behaviour is getting worse. So it's not working is it?